Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Robin Hood Isn't A Merry Time

Plus, Letters to Juliet gets returned to sender, and Just Wright isn't, ahem, just right.

by | May 14, 2010 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got serious swashbuckling (Robin Hood, starring Russell Crowe and Cate Blanchet), amour in Verona (Letters to Juliet, starring Amanda Seyfried and Chris Egan),and roundball romance (Just Wright, starring Common and Queen Latifah). What do the critics have to say?


Robin Hood

Robin Hood is a merry man, right? Doesn’t he rob from the rich and give to the poor? Well, not in Ridley Scott’s Robin Hood, and the film suffers from its deviation from the legend, despite its impressive visuals and strong performances. Russell Crowe stars as the titular hero, returning to Sherwood Forrest from the Crusades reluctantly deciding that England needs some cleaning up. To that end, he teams with a motley bunch that will become the Merry Men, as well as the recently widowed Lady Marion (Cate Blanchet); swordplay and archery ensues. The pundits say that although Robin Hood is handsomely produced and well-acted, it’s way too downbeat and lacks the sense of fun that made previous big-screen retellings so memorable and exhilarating. (Check out our feature, Legendary Heroes on Film, as well as this week’s Total Recall, in which we count Russell Crowe’s best-reviewed films.)


Letters to Juliet

Romeo once wondered, “Is love a tender thing? It is too rough, too rude, too boisterous; and it pricks like thorn.” Not in Letters to Juliet, which critics say is too safe, too predictable, and too sticky sweet. Amanda Seyfried stars as a young woman on vacation in Verona with her dispassionate fiancé — and finds that many love-minded people have written “Dear Abby”-esque letters to Shakespeare’s heroine. She responds to one elderly writer of a long-lost missive — and soon finds herself in the company of a nice young man. The pundits say Letters to Juliet has a refreshingly earnest romantic charm, but it suffers from limp dialogue and an utter lack of surprises.


Just Wright

Sometimes a movie can generate tons of goodwill despite its hackneyed premise. The critics say Just Wright is such a film, one that benefits from its likeable leads but is ultimately undone by its sheer predictability. Common stars as a pro hoopster who’s just suffered a potentially career ending injury. He turns to a physical therapist (Queen Latifah) for help, but soon the pair are falling for one another. Will love carry the day? Unfortunately, Just Wright takes an intriguing premise and strong performances and undercuts them with a strict adherence to formula.

Also opening this week in limited release:

  • Beetle Queen Conquers Tokyo, a documentary about obsessive Japanese bug lovers, is at 92 percent.

  • Ken Loach’s Looking for Eric, a comedy about a postal worker who takes unconventional measures to win back his love, is at 87 percent.
  • Daddy Longlegs, a dramedy about the strange things that happen when a single dad takes a trip with his sons, is at 80 percent.

  • Barking Water, a drama about a final road trip for an aging couple, is at 60 percent.

  • The Living Wake, starring Jesse Eisenberg in a black comedy about a dying eccentric making plans for his going-away party, is at 40 percent.

  • Princess Kaiulani, starring Q’Orianka Kilcher and Barry Pepper in the real-life tale of a young woman who fought for the rights of indigenous Hawaiians, is at 29 percent.

Tag Cloud

American Society of Cinematographers canceled TV renewals Crunchyroll Musicals Red Carpet talk show Marvel Food Network RT21 AMC harry potter renewed TV shows YA The Arrangement TIFF war YouTube Premium cancelled TV shows Disney streaming service sports kids boxoffice Sundance Now History 2016 Martial Arts spinoff sequel Drama batman Apple TV+ Christmas supernatural Polls and Games Turner romantic comedy robots Emmys Tomatazos Pop 45 Adult Swim Comics on TV Marvel Studios Kids & Family Interview Writers Guild of America Toys Superheroe Bravo Character Guide werewolf San Diego Comic-Con Captain marvel toy story CBS All Access 21st Century Fox CNN Trophy Talk Thanksgiving Mystery Stephen King zombie historical drama blockbuster Sci-Fi travel hispanic Emmy Nominations Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Tumblr quibi Comedy Central spanish language Television Academy Epix richard e. Grant Holidays The Walking Dead Apple Star Wars serial killer dc Arrowverse PaleyFest dragons Brie Larson Pirates Women's History Month Classic Film Disney christmas movies biography 2017 revenge theme song ghosts miniseries Nickelodeon Disney Plus Tarantino PBS Amazon Awards Walt Disney Pictures movies Winter TV zero dark thirty DGA First Look TCA 2017 BET Election jamie lee curtis ratings transformers See It Skip It Summer Premiere Dates Pet Sematary Paramount Awards Tour joker GoT free movies APB medical drama Winners Spike golden globes X-Men Set visit Reality Competition Ovation cancelled television USA Network dceu TCA aliens Countdown CW Seed crime drama 71st Emmy Awards mockumentary cooking tv talk SXSW CBS casting IFC Films Oscars cartoon spider-man Horror YouTube 2018 Watching Series ESPN LGBT psychological thriller 20th Century Fox versus teaser Superheroes Dark Horse Comics Mudbound Lionsgate Certified Fresh HBO Mindy Kaling nature Masterpiece Shudder New York Comic Con book 2020 USA slashers vampires Schedule canceled TV shows Syfy Universal social media latino cinemax diversity Trailer Star Trek finale Hallmark Ghostbusters Calendar natural history WarnerMedia Netflix witnail MCU period drama science fiction Disney+ Disney Plus Crackle Sneak Peek Vudu Cannes comics Acorn TV Lifetime Christmas movies Showtime screenings Netflix Christmas movies cults psycho Paramount Network Turner Classic Movies Western National Geographic Anna Paquin Fox News Cartoon Network ABC Family docudrama children's TV YouTube Red technology SundanceTV Warner Bros. Nat Geo 24 frames anime Esquire elevated horror adventure Super Bowl dramedy Comedy comiccon police drama Marvel Television zombies Starz halloween Apple TV Plus Comic Book anthology Hallmark Christmas movies based on movie festivals Freeform independent mutant television MSNBC cancelled TV series Action Spring TV FXX GIFs award winner Ellie Kemper binge Fall TV justice league animated Quiz NBC Sundance FOX spain cops political drama Fantasy crossover Heroines Film Festival 2015 DC streaming service LGBTQ ITV BBC America Best and Worst NYCC E3 HBO Max Infographic spy thriller sitcom true crime Hulu Columbia Pictures composers ABC space politics Mary Poppins Returns Year in Review Podcast Spectrum Originals E! TCM MTV Elton John cars comic Shondaland hist 2019 Grammys Pride Month Peacock Binge Guide Rock indie VH1 Photos Lifetime Disney Channel stand-up comedy Rocky Box Office Song of Ice and Fire Rom-Com streaming OWN discovery Musical Chilling Adventures of Sabrina TruTV Film The CW Animation DC Universe adaptation First Reviews A&E DC Comics SDCC GLAAD DirecTV blaxploitation Chernobyl game show Britbox Marathons VICE President TV Land Teen The Purge El Rey facebook Creative Arts Emmys FX Logo RT History A24 Holiday green book crime thriller Black Mirror Cosplay Biopics disaster game of thrones Amazon Prime Music Sony Pictures CMT TV romance cats IFC Nominations Mary poppins Video Games singing competition 007 Reality BBC Lucasfilm thriller WGN breaking bad Pixar Country Trivia Valentine's Day Mary Tyler Moore crime TLC Amazon Prime Video strong female leads what to watch rotten movies we love south america unscripted TBS TNT Family cancelled Opinion Extras foreign video series The Witch Rocketman doctor who