Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Race to Witch Mountain Doesn't Cast A Spell

Plus, Last House on the Left falls short of the original, and Miss March is largely laugh-free.

by | March 12, 2009 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a supernatural quest (Race to Witch Mountain, starring Dwayne “The Rock” Johnson and AnnaSophia Robb), a vengeance thriller ( Last House on the Left, starring Sara Paxton and Garret Dillahunt), and playmate pratfalls (Miss March starring Zach Cregger and Trevor Moore). What do the critics have to say?


Race to Witch Mountain

Race to Witch Mountain finds Disney attempting to resurrect a franchise that delivered some sizable hits for the studio in the 1970s. However, critics say the reboot is only sporadically successful, despite the best efforts of a talented cast. Dwayne “The Rock” Johnson stars as an ex-con cabbie who picks up two teens with supernatural powers; together, they attempt to elude government officials and ominous forces. The pundits say the cast is just fine, especially the Rock, who mixes toughness and good humor with panache. But the rest of the film is alternately too noisy and not exciting enough to maintain interest throughout. (Check out star Carla Gugino‘s five favorite films, and our rundown of the finest live-action Disney films.)


The Last House on the Left

Wes Craven‘s original The Last House on the Left was a horror movie touchstone, a film so violent in its time that even its poster had to reassure audience members that it was only a movie. Critics say the remake (which Craven produced) is stylishly crafted and effective in spots, but it misses the spirit of the original by miles, lacking Craven’s bleak artistry and his sense of social commentary. Sara Paxton stars as a young woman who is brutally attacked by a prison escapee and his flunkies. She flees to the supposed safety of her house, but when her parents discover that they’re harboring the very thugs who attacked their daughter, they exact their own brand of revenge. The pundits say the film is better-made than most, but it’s ultimately pretty generic, substituting the dark subtleties of Craven’s landmark film with oodles of gratuitous gore.


Miss March

Unless your taste runs toward the bottom-of-the-barrel lowest common denominator, the critics say you may want to scratch Miss March off your calendar. The film stars Zach Cregger (who also directed with co-star Trevor Moore, both part of the the Whitest Kids U’ Know comedy troupe) as a young man who awakens from a coma to discover his once-chaste high school significant other is now a Playboy centerfold. The pundits say Miss March is crass, unfunny, and poorly made, a gross-out comedy with little beyond scene-stealer Craig Robinson to recommend it.

Also opening this week in limited release:

Tag Cloud

TLC SXSW aliens comiccon DC streaming service Best and Worst Marvel Mindy Kaling Musical Epix sitcom Action E3 RT21 DC Comics New York Comic Con SDCC Pet Sematary IFC zombies Fall TV Winter TV crime zombie Comic Book Netflix Freeform zero dark thirty FXX DirecTV disaster Columbia Pictures CNN spy thriller Music Dark Horse Comics mockumentary dragons travel MCU WGN Emmy Nominations singing competition facebook USA Character Guide Nat Geo DGA Acorn TV Rom-Com period drama Podcast Pride Month based on movie blaxploitation Video Games Horror MSNBC Musicals TNT Shudder Superheroe Sci-Fi Chilling Adventures of Sabrina medical drama Drama psychological thriller CW Seed sequel 21st Century Fox cooking DC Universe PBS Showtime Cannes Mary poppins Masterpiece YA LGBTQ justice league Comedy TCA 2017 Rocketman Schedule BET anime San Diego Comic-Con unscripted docudrama Photos Country Writers Guild of America vampires Starz strong female leads Apple diversity PaleyFest Ovation crime drama BBC America biography YouTube Premium true crime OWN TCM sports romance VH1 teaser toy story Interview Trailer Reality Competition 24 frames Creative Arts Emmys BBC Tomatazos TV Lifetime YouTube Red 2019 El Rey 45 LGBT Disney Channel cinemax Sundance Food Network Brie Larson NBC award winner Spectrum Originals Valentine's Day APB Tumblr Trophy Talk Syfy Emmys TCA cops Oscars Awards talk show 20th Century Fox discovery TruTV Certified Fresh USA Network Polls and Games television Rocky crossover CMT Bravo Reality Cosplay ESPN GLAAD Opinion ITV Adult Swim dramedy what to watch Spring TV dceu Pop Anna Paquin Super Bowl Tarantino Comedy Central Mystery 2018 political drama Countdown Disney politics FX Paramount Red Carpet golden globes theme song casting Year in Review Quiz doctor who Logo AMC The Witch Walt Disney Pictures TIFF Grammys harry potter Awards Tour Britbox mutant serial killer nature composers Crackle Box Office cats Vudu transformers green book SundanceTV Shondaland Pirates X-Men Cartoon Network hist Premiere Dates Lionsgate Kids & Family binge Film Festival natural history 007 TBS Heroines animated Comics on TV Sundance Now Rock Star Wars boxoffice Elton John psycho Set visit CBS All Access The CW Holidays robots Trivia Spike Lucasfilm CBS First Look HBO The Arrangement Thanksgiving Sony Pictures Election Summer Warner Bros. streaming Mudbound American Society of Cinematographers Paramount Network Winners Western NYCC Hulu Ellie Kemper ABC space Calendar elevated horror Mary Poppins Returns Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt adaptation 2017 technology RT History police drama cults war comic Martial Arts History game show social media E! richard e. Grant President jamie lee curtis Women's History Month dc Stephen King Universal WarnerMedia Captain marvel IFC Films witnail Toys historical drama Amazon Prime spider-man Superheroes Ghostbusters festivals spinoff GoT Watching Series Song of Ice and Fire Infographic Mary Tyler Moore Fox News 2016 See It Skip It ratings Pixar Black Mirror adventure GIFs ABC Family science fiction Amazon Extras Chernobyl HBO Max FOX National Geographic 2015 miniseries Esquire Nickelodeon Biopics Animation Nominations Teen Marathons Fantasy Sneak Peek Star Trek MTV crime thriller A&E finale anthology VICE TV Land Christmas supernatural thriller