Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Playing for Keeps Misses the Mark

Plus, Hyde Park on Hudson is a little too soapy.

by | December 7, 2012 | Comments

This week at the movies brings only one new release: Playing for Keeps, a romantic comedy starring Gerard Butler, Jessica Biel, and Uma Thurman. What do the critics have to say?

Playing for Keeps


Some bad movies are aggressive in their awfulness, while others are simply uninspired or clichéd. Critics say Playing for Keeps falls into the latter category, squandering an attractive cast on a script that offers plenty of jarring tonal shifts but no surprises. Gerard Butler stars as a washed-up soccer pro who decides that coaching his kid’s soccer team will help make up for all the time he’s been out of his son’s life. However, the other players’ moms immediately take a shine to the hunky new coach, and complications ensue. The pundits say Playing for Keeps is slavishly devoted to the romantic comedy playbook without exuding much personality of its own, and at times it’s surprisingly sexist. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we count down Butler’s best-reviewed movies.)

Also opening this week in limited release:

Tag Cloud

Teen adventure President Pixar vampires concert parents El Rey Thanksgiving TCA Awards Cannes First Look rotten movies we love quibi Lucasfilm Biopics docuseries 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Sneak Peek National Geographic Disney+ Disney Plus X-Men Stephen King nfl Comedy Central spanish asian-american green book NYCC FOX french justice league news Ghostbusters james bond TruTV A&E worst movies Marathons Cartoon Network doctor who LGBT Dark Horse Comics Shondaland Esquire black golden globe awards dramedy cancelled child's play Lionsgate Fox Searchlight children's TV jurassic park Marvel Television cars Western cancelled TV series Broadway godzilla YouTube Red dark Showtime Musicals Year in Review The Arrangement finale USA Network Ovation superman Writers Guild of America LGBTQ Spectrum Originals Captain marvel Christmas Hear Us Out 99% DC streaming service laika SDCC Red Carpet supernatural DirecTV prank hidden camera Spike Lifetime obituary Television Critics Association FX on Hulu unscripted ABC Family medical drama true crime See It Skip It Bravo Food Network remakes politics classics women hispanic stand-up comedy scorecard historical drama Trophy Talk movies game show Reality 2018 revenge Exclusive Video comic sitcom E! boxing Legendary Amazon Studios thriller HBO Max psycho Drama space binge hollywood kaiju scary movies hist political drama Sony Pictures Star Trek Universal Countdown what to watch crossover Marvel Studios CBS Country Watching Series VICE OneApp BBC One Superheroes RT21 2020 Election mutant reboot Ellie Kemper Adult Swim dceu Film Festival mission: impossible Nominations The CW australia all-time romantic comedy die hard 4/20 Nickelodeon GIFs 24 frames criterion foreign Emmy Nominations DC Universe Netflix Christmas movies Columbia Pictures Film Logo MCU 72 Emmy Awards miniseries CBS All Access mockumentary popular chucky Box Office kong cats Creative Arts Emmys emmy awards ViacomCBS streaming Oscars spain archives MTV cartoon Women's History Month Rock ESPN christmas movies NBC biography Pop TV Black History Month anthology halloween A24 The Walking Dead Pet Sematary rom-coms Sundance TV ratings name the review Best and Worst fresh based on movie documentary cooking free movies Masterpiece Rocky AMC pirates of the caribbean composers japanese sequels FX universal monsters slashers Reality Competition festival theme song zombies Animation Brie Larson Cosplay Mudbound Amazon PaleyFest Disney streaming service Syfy CMT New York Comic Con Pirates TCA Heroines Polls and Games SXSW Spring TV crime drama Comics on TV transformers latino Fall TV Tumblr TV renewals halloween tv Crackle king kong Mystery Starz animated talk show video VH1 serial killer festivals Action blockbuster films war Holidays DC Comics Mary Poppins Returns Pop south america facebook sequel toronto Superheroe Turner Classic Movies Pride Month Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt police drama Toys BBC America crime reviews Peacock Vudu Alien Black Mirror The Academy Classic Film Horror Schedule stoner The Walt Disney Company American Society of Cinematographers crime thriller Star Wars batman adaptation fast and furious Mary poppins twilight jamie lee curtis Set visit boxoffice diversity romance Sundance Now football Fantasy ID spanish language Paramount Elton John 2019 Shudder HBO Go 20th Century Fox Disney Channel YouTube Premium technology Arrowverse TCM dc History PlayStation TV Land movie FXX BBC Quiz ghosts discovery travel Infographic PBS Emmys satire YA Nat Geo period drama directors razzies Certified Fresh TIFF TLC Interview Apple TV+ 007 TCA 2017 Opinion Warner Bros. kids dogs Premiere Dates Britbox strong female leads Tomatazos Awards Podcast Amazon Prime Family Comedy Video Games joker Song of Ice and Fire game of thrones Photos TV casting tv talk Tarantino Walt Disney Pictures canceled blaxploitation Sundance Musical comiccon Calendar nature Music Hallmark Marvel Character Guide YouTube 2017 rotten comic books Amazon Prime Video rt archives cinemax cancelled TV shows BET Awards Rom-Com science fiction 45 Super Bowl werewolf versus Acorn TV Freeform golden globes sports BAFTA worst anime Hallmark Christmas movies Avengers ABC natural history MSNBC critics harry potter TV One cancelled television Lifetime Christmas movies Hulu Academy Awards Binge Guide TBS dragons canceled TV shows The Purge Discovery Channel Holiday Summer cops Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Grammys Winter TV Paramount Network superhero 21st Century Fox indiana jones zombie deadpool blockbusters cults renewed TV shows telelvision 2015 ABC Signature breaking bad nbcuniversal VOD spinoff spider-man Television Academy OWN Kids & Family San Diego Comic-Con GLAAD 2016 comedies Paramount Plus documentaries zero dark thirty RT History BET robots best CNN Winners monster movies TCA Winter 2020 SundanceTV Apple TV Plus Disney sag awards Endgame psychological thriller screen actors guild Awards Tour USA Martial Arts a nightmare on elm street award winner Turner series trailers indie Funimation Tubi teaser Chernobyl richard e. Grant GoT italian Sci-Fi toy story stop motion HBO WGN DGA Valentine's Day elevated horror 2021 spy thriller comics Travel Channel Mary Tyler Moore The Witch singing competition TNT Trivia independent WarnerMedia Anna Paquin Crunchyroll 71st Emmy Awards ITV television book screenings Netflix E3 social media First Reviews APB Comic Book CW Seed Fox News franchise docudrama video on demand witnail Rocketman Epix Apple venice Extras IFC Films Baby Yoda Trailer aliens disaster Mindy Kaling Disney Plus IFC