Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Eclipse Is Brighter Than New Moon

Plus, The Last Airbender is one of the year's worst-reviewed films.

by | July 2, 2010 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got brooding bloodsuckers (The Twilight Saga: Eclipse, starring Kristen Stewart and Robert Pattinson) and elemental excitement (The Last Airbender, starring Noah Ringer and Dev Patel). What do the critics have to say?


The Twilight Saga: Eclipse

Hey, Twihards — you’re probably going to see Eclipse anyway, so feel free to ignore the reviews. However, for the uninitiated who find themselves dragged to the theater, the critics say Eclipse is a big step up from New Moon — even if it still suffers from slack pacing and portentous dialogue. Kristen Stewart, Robert Pattinson, and Taylor Lautner are all back as the principals in every tween’s favorite supernatural love triangle; this time, all three are threatened by an army of newborn vampires assembled for the purpose of killing Bella to indirectly enact revenge upon the Cullens. The pundits say new director David Slade does well with the material, underscoring the emotional developments with some reasonably stirring action. However, they also note Eclipse is still too often a slog, with so-so acting, middling special effects, and lots of dead passages. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we run down Stewart’s best-reviewed films, as well as our Twilight character guide.)


The Last Airbender

Goodness, what happened to M. Night Shyamalan? In the decade since The Sixth Sense, his reputation as a wunderkind has taken a steep dive, one that won’t be revived with The Last Airbender, which critics are calling an incomprehensible, ugly mess. Based upon the popular Nickelodeon cartoon, Airbender tells the story of Aang (Noah Ringer), who utilizes his rare element-manipulation skills to bring peace to a war-torn fantasy world. The pundits say Airbender‘s baffling exposition and retrofitted 3-D effects make for a viewing experience that’s hopelessly muddled in both plot and visuals.

Also opening this week in limited release:

Tag Cloud

scene in color film series Creative Arts Emmys slasher game of thrones Pop TV 4/20 Anna Paquin new star wars movies Winter TV movie ITV Universal Pictures Freeform Emmy Nominations Comedy Central spy thriller Best Actor witnail San Diego Comic-Con HBO women mob cinemax kids crime criterion BBC America IFC classics broadcast FXX TLC TCA Awards critics video on demand Tumblr Paramount BBC harry potter Lucasfilm Native boxing Ghostbusters Paramount Network APB TCA 2017 New York Comic Con Comics on TV Kids & Family DirecTV doctor who Amazon Prime anime Disney Channel a nightmare on elm street Reality Legendary 71st Emmy Awards Indigenous independent nfl target scene in color Ellie Kemper Arrowverse A24 halloween tv Acorn TV Christmas werewolf BBC One vs. WarnerMedia royal family disaster ID strong female leads CBS laika Television Critics Association facebook BAFTA Nominations Cannes superhero Pacific Islander Grammys Quiz live event DC Comics Elton John SXSW Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Mary Tyler Moore razzies cats TBS Mindy Kaling 2018 comic book movie Martial Arts Stephen King Summer TCA Alien ABC Signature Geeked Week festivals leaderboard Neflix SXSW 2022 Prime Video Marvel Star Trek DGA Wes Anderson PaleyFest concert jurassic park zero dark thirty dragons Apple TV+ Tags: Comedy feel good Food Network VH1 TruTV marvel comics hispanic heritage month all-time Ovation RT History dramedy USA Exclusive Video spider-verse obituary Disney President theme song Horror venice name the review zombie MCU Music Discovery Channel Reality Competition basketball book adaptation blaxploitation christmas movies Red Carpet Syfy debate Superheroe rotten movies we love 99% ABC trophy Oscar dexter mockumentary mcc thriller HBO Go target biography TV movies 21st Century Fox Opinion fresh animated heist movie Bravo National Geographic Musicals parents medical drama rom-coms blockbusters Universal NBC diversity 2017 game show Funimation aliens ABC Family Hallmark Christmas movies toronto archives popular YouTube Shondaland Musical Action ghosts scene in color series cancelled television The Arrangement 94th Oscars Showtime screenings South by Southwest Film Festival Esquire political drama suspense ViacomCBS rt archives psychological thriller new zealand australia science fiction based on movie Endgame hidden camera action-comedy Netflix Christmas movies FX jamie lee curtis Disney+ Disney Plus Animation OneApp war History Western quibi monster movies Baby Yoda Spring TV FOX spanish language casting IMDb TV toy story Film sitcom crime thriller crime drama VOD blockbuster cults YA Cosplay ratings Pride Month LGBTQ psycho high school NBA CMT cancelled TV series Polls and Games Rocky Character Guide scorecard universal monsters crossover Netflix Comic Book adventure marvel cinematic universe Photos asian-american king kong adaptation screen actors guild french directors dceu green book The CW Hallmark 45 GoT DC Universe spinoff Countdown renewed TV shows Lifetime Best and Worst canceled Star Wars Celebration streaming movies Sundance Turner rt labs critics edition james bond Rock art house fast and furious DC streaming service Set visit sopranos Sony robots E! Family Broadway Academy Awards vampires olympics what to watch space 79th Golden Globes Awards Epix Paramount Plus social media CNN remakes know your critic CW Seed Sneak Peek Disney streaming service The Witch police drama gangster twilight festival transformers Holiday Sony Pictures award winner children's TV Instagram Live trailers emmy awards 90s Apple TV Plus Travel Channel indie Nat Geo 2015 king arthur Captain marvel Awards Tour posters south america Emmys justice league Podcast Paramount Pictures Starz 72 Emmy Awards TV One 2019 genre The Academy Warner Bros. TCA Winter 2020 Fargo comiccon OWN deadpool 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards italian stand-up comedy lord of the rings biopic 24 frames The Walt Disney Company ESPN Trailer nbcuniversal worst Hulu singing competition serial killer 1990s 73rd Emmy Awards joker japan VICE A&E SundanceTV reviews PlayStation Amazon Studios SDCC teaser Rocketman Thanksgiving obi wan Fox News Heroines 20th Century Fox 93rd Oscars First Reviews discovery sag awards stoner dreamworks Country Hear Us Out Disney Plus prank richard e. Grant 2016 young adult hist Mudbound dark Pet Sematary American Society of Cinematographers Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Image Comics sports supernatural First Look Sundance TV pirates of the caribbean dogs Brie Larson TV Land X-Men true crime kong Crackle franchise best Marvel Studios Extras cartoon scene in color technology free movies Spectrum Originals comic mission: impossible rt labs scary summer preview movies cooking USA Network natural history BET scary movies MTV YouTube Premium documentary Trophy Talk WGN Awards LGBT Amazon cars rotten wonder woman Nickelodeon CBS All Access FX on Hulu zombies See It Skip It IFC Films golden globes tv talk spider-man versus telelvision superman historical drama El Rey new york GLAAD Watching Series Super Bowl Pirates child's play Chernobyl book Toys Columbia Pictures Rom-Com comic book movies Comic-Con@Home 2021 summer TV preview stop motion Masterpiece Drama comedies unscripted japanese MGM indiana jones TIFF Superheroes finale batman docudrama Turner Classic Movies documentaries Crunchyroll Black History Month sequel golden globe awards cancelled TV shows AMC Plus worst movies 007 spanish anthology Hollywood Foreign Press Association YouTube Red 2021 comics miniseries Trivia dc NYCC Focus Features TV renewals streamig Apple adenture Marathons Mary poppins Tokyo Olympics Marvel Television Star Wars docuseries HFPA breaking bad Interview boxoffice Black Mirror Amazon Prime Video Holidays Walt Disney Pictures cancelled die hard Video Games Tarantino Dark Horse Comics Lionsgate live action GIFs binge TNT Spike Fall TV Adult Swim RT21 Comedy The Walking Dead talk show Mystery news cops E3 international Election chucky halloween films Best Actress series spain Calendar mutant elevated horror 2020 Tubi Classic Film summer TV Box Office godzilla sequels hollywood Vudu composers hispanic football The Purge HBO Max Fox Searchlight critic resources Pop Sci-Fi canceled TV shows Tomatazos aapi Writers Guild of America Valentine's Day romance Britbox satire BET Awards Television Academy PBS interviews Teen TCM Winners romantic comedy Avengers video MSNBC Fantasy Sundance Now slashers saw Song of Ice and Fire Best Picture black Shudder Peacock Cartoon Network Mary Poppins Returns Biopics reboot Schedule television travel politics nature Premiere Dates comic books revenge Logo Infographic Film Festival latino Pixar Best Director Certified Fresh Oscars streaming TV period drama Binge Guide legend AMC Lifetime Christmas movies black comedy foreign Year in Review kaiju Women's History Month