Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Eclipse Is Brighter Than New Moon

Plus, The Last Airbender is one of the year's worst-reviewed films.

by | July 2, 2010 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got brooding bloodsuckers (The Twilight Saga: Eclipse, starring Kristen Stewart and Robert Pattinson) and elemental excitement (The Last Airbender, starring Noah Ringer and Dev Patel). What do the critics have to say?


The Twilight Saga: Eclipse

Hey, Twihards — you’re probably going to see Eclipse anyway, so feel free to ignore the reviews. However, for the uninitiated who find themselves dragged to the theater, the critics say Eclipse is a big step up from New Moon — even if it still suffers from slack pacing and portentous dialogue. Kristen Stewart, Robert Pattinson, and Taylor Lautner are all back as the principals in every tween’s favorite supernatural love triangle; this time, all three are threatened by an army of newborn vampires assembled for the purpose of killing Bella to indirectly enact revenge upon the Cullens. The pundits say new director David Slade does well with the material, underscoring the emotional developments with some reasonably stirring action. However, they also note Eclipse is still too often a slog, with so-so acting, middling special effects, and lots of dead passages. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we run down Stewart’s best-reviewed films, as well as our Twilight character guide.)


The Last Airbender

Goodness, what happened to M. Night Shyamalan? In the decade since The Sixth Sense, his reputation as a wunderkind has taken a steep dive, one that won’t be revived with The Last Airbender, which critics are calling an incomprehensible, ugly mess. Based upon the popular Nickelodeon cartoon, Airbender tells the story of Aang (Noah Ringer), who utilizes his rare element-manipulation skills to bring peace to a war-torn fantasy world. The pundits say Airbender‘s baffling exposition and retrofitted 3-D effects make for a viewing experience that’s hopelessly muddled in both plot and visuals.

Also opening this week in limited release:

Tag Cloud

Red Carpet Tubi OWN name the review Rom-Com VICE Captain marvel Horror Amazon Studios Election space A&E BBC Turner Classic Movies Watching Series Comedy Central Animation crossover elevated horror cancelled FXX Extras latino Nominations Martial Arts Britbox Disney streaming service IFC serial killer Photos festivals Universal Nat Geo comic SDCC Spike thriller USA Network supernatural Reality Competition HBO Max Toys 2019 Pop ratings Stephen King mutant Western cults Holidays Spring TV Cannes animated TV Land crime batman LGBT Rocky APB Kids & Family WarnerMedia Lifetime Apple TV+ Trailer Lucasfilm Nickelodeon Adult Swim award winner harry potter tv talk IFC Films Mudbound SXSW A24 Trophy Talk YouTube Red Creative Arts Emmys Mystery Star Trek dragons crime thriller screen actors guild See It Skip It ESPN casting DC Comics Interview CNN Apple New York Comic Con green book sag awards Pixar CBS disaster blockbuster screenings Cosplay documentary El Rey Mindy Kaling talk show Dark Horse Comics AMC Turner Hallmark toy story Anna Paquin Binge Guide Comic Book Disney+ Disney Plus Vudu technology Heroines free movies TIFF dogs President revenge spain Sundance Marvel Television hist aliens The Walking Dead National Geographic Epix Mary Tyler Moore First Reviews Calendar slashers ghosts MTV Logo Endgame discovery Tomatazos psycho medical drama 2018 Music transformers Sundance TV Ovation Reality Baby Yoda dramedy social media dceu Disney Classic Film video travel based on movie hispanic Family zombie Women's History Month composers BBC America political drama science fiction Starz Valentine's Day Trivia sitcom Sony Pictures Holiday zero dark thirty comiccon Sundance Now FOX politics Fantasy Shondaland PaleyFest TCA Tarantino what to watch BET Tumblr renewed TV shows GoT Comedy facebook directors Amazon Prime Quiz halloween doctor who FX theme song TCM ABC Netflix Christmas movies Food Network Writers Guild of America series Television Academy cancelled TV shows Chilling Adventures of Sabrina TCA Winter 2020 spanish language strong female leads singing competition Emmys 2020 TV renewals 2017 breaking bad christmas movies war TV Star Wars Masterpiece game of thrones Rocketman historical drama finale cooking Paramount Network HBO MCU Rock YA zombies Disney Channel Apple TV Plus Comics on TV Teen ABC Family movies Brie Larson Acorn TV Syfy Film MSNBC Superheroe Crunchyroll sports sequel television independent ITV RT21 Black Mirror book teaser Pet Sematary Superheroes canceled 71st Emmy Awards Winter TV docudrama cinemax Showtime PBS NBC Elton John DC Universe boxoffice E! south america Thanksgiving romance 2015 Disney Plus Premiere Dates cancelled television Winners Warner Bros. YouTube Premium GIFs Fox News Musicals Pirates versus period drama dc The CW Lionsgate joker DirecTV Fall TV cartoon spinoff SundanceTV Netflix cats Amazon Prime Video Pride Month Academy Awards Marathons golden globes mockumentary Hulu 24 frames Action canceled TV shows game show robots TruTV CBS All Access Awards Christmas Box Office Crackle Podcast children's TV OneApp Discovery Channel true crime Amazon Lifetime Christmas movies NYCC Chernobyl Ellie Kemper Drama anime miniseries 21st Century Fox Sneak Peek stand-up comedy RT History Freeform justice league TNT X-Men Grammys TBS quibi 45 2016 streaming Super Bowl WGN witnail anthology cops American Society of Cinematographers spider-man Hallmark Christmas movies richard e. Grant reboot Musical Peacock jamie lee curtis USA YouTube blaxploitation San Diego Comic-Con Esquire biography Video Games First Look movie Countdown diversity The Witch 007 Oscars unscripted The Arrangement The Purge Marvel Studios cars vampires Character Guide Summer 20th Century Fox Sci-Fi Best and Worst Song of Ice and Fire Cartoon Network romantic comedy Spectrum Originals VH1 TLC Year in Review Opinion Schedule binge LGBTQ Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt comics indie adventure Walt Disney Pictures Columbia Pictures psychological thriller Film Festival crime drama DGA Country Bravo Marvel Ghostbusters natural history Biopics Polls and Games E3 nature police drama kids GLAAD DC streaming service cancelled TV series foreign Emmy Nominations Set visit Certified Fresh spy thriller Arrowverse Paramount adaptation Mary poppins CW Seed Shudder Avengers rotten movies we love werewolf CMT Mary Poppins Returns Awards Tour History Infographic TCA 2017