Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Eclipse Is Brighter Than New Moon

Plus, The Last Airbender is one of the year's worst-reviewed films.

by | July 2, 2010 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got brooding bloodsuckers (The Twilight Saga: Eclipse, starring Kristen Stewart and Robert Pattinson) and elemental excitement (The Last Airbender, starring Noah Ringer and Dev Patel). What do the critics have to say?


The Twilight Saga: Eclipse

Hey, Twihards — you’re probably going to see Eclipse anyway, so feel free to ignore the reviews. However, for the uninitiated who find themselves dragged to the theater, the critics say Eclipse is a big step up from New Moon — even if it still suffers from slack pacing and portentous dialogue. Kristen Stewart, Robert Pattinson, and Taylor Lautner are all back as the principals in every tween’s favorite supernatural love triangle; this time, all three are threatened by an army of newborn vampires assembled for the purpose of killing Bella to indirectly enact revenge upon the Cullens. The pundits say new director David Slade does well with the material, underscoring the emotional developments with some reasonably stirring action. However, they also note Eclipse is still too often a slog, with so-so acting, middling special effects, and lots of dead passages. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we run down Stewart’s best-reviewed films, as well as our Twilight character guide.)


The Last Airbender

Goodness, what happened to M. Night Shyamalan? In the decade since The Sixth Sense, his reputation as a wunderkind has taken a steep dive, one that won’t be revived with The Last Airbender, which critics are calling an incomprehensible, ugly mess. Based upon the popular Nickelodeon cartoon, Airbender tells the story of Aang (Noah Ringer), who utilizes his rare element-manipulation skills to bring peace to a war-torn fantasy world. The pundits say Airbender‘s baffling exposition and retrofitted 3-D effects make for a viewing experience that’s hopelessly muddled in both plot and visuals.

Also opening this week in limited release:

Tag Cloud

TCM binge dceu ghosts romantic comedy Spectrum Originals game show richard e. Grant Sci-Fi Pop TV Sneak Peek sag awards spanish police drama Lifetime Christmas movies mission: impossible anthology Crunchyroll kids President cults james bond Sundance Now BAFTA stoner TBS Walt Disney Pictures football Superheroes independent theme song animated Tomatazos OWN Hallmark Christmas movies Writers Guild of America Columbia Pictures LGBTQ die hard dragons Sony Pictures stop motion canceled TV shows Nickelodeon ID Avengers werewolf Logo nature VH1 New York Comic Con Black Mirror FX on Hulu scary movies FOX FXX Extras Esquire TCA Fall TV Musical Dark Horse Comics Western streaming cancelled emmy awards Disney toronto Best and Worst scorecard Country best Television Critics Association aliens based on movie historical drama witnail Black History Month Alien Netflix Christmas movies RT21 black vampires classics TNT Holiday cars miniseries Peacock Showtime Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt rotten comedies psychological thriller Winter TV HBO NYCC Elton John mockumentary breaking bad Reality Star Trek reboot Calendar child's play TV Land Super Bowl Comic Book Nat Geo transformers Music BBC America Star Wars Podcast 72 Emmy Awards TCA Winter 2020 24 frames Tarantino series quibi technology cancelled television worst movies television franchise Grammys spain WGN DGA Interview Rom-Com Fantasy dogs biography Women's History Month talk show Box Office sequel Superheroe political drama BBC Brie Larson science fiction Amazon Studios free movies obituary archives MCU Amazon Ellie Kemper deadpool Winners HBO Max directors Stephen King Nominations Endgame Action Cartoon Network universal monsters war nbcuniversal The Academy disaster Ovation Disney Channel Mindy Kaling Disney streaming service indie criterion french Spring TV Countdown justice league cancelled TV series TV E! robots Teen revenge Pride Month Christmas spy thriller joker concert Netflix movie PlayStation zombies Academy Awards Premiere Dates Hulu Mudbound GoT children's TV Shondaland VICE Song of Ice and Fire YA Warner Bros. Arrowverse Martial Arts Tubi strong female leads A24 spanish language Awards docudrama critics Comedy Central Britbox Animation Certified Fresh name the review all-time Tumblr Chilling Adventures of Sabrina true crime WarnerMedia Polls and Games YouTube Red First Reviews Anna Paquin Comics on TV Biopics Spike news 99% Schedule medical drama Adult Swim what to watch HBO Go dark YouTube Premium Vudu Trophy Talk versus SundanceTV romance indiana jones comic American Society of Cinematographers Rocky Summer Pixar Mystery The CW 2018 Thanksgiving FX 2015 Family GLAAD superhero Cosplay sitcom ABC Amazon Prime SDCC BET Captain marvel screen actors guild Ghostbusters festival Marvel Discovery Channel twilight remakes MSNBC Kids & Family Television Academy cops Epix Toys Funimation Marvel Studios spider-man TCA 2017 dramedy book Opinion Infographic composers politics sequels crime thriller italian Emmys rt archives Bravo 2016 Emmy Nominations satire reviews Amazon Prime Video slashers thriller Valentine's Day OneApp christmas movies Classic Film a nightmare on elm street Creative Arts Emmys 71st Emmy Awards serial killer Crackle TLC CBS All Access Food Network movies Cannes IFC Films CMT Starz Photos south america TruTV rotten movies we love Sundance TV renewed TV shows APB PBS video dc Lucasfilm comic books halloween tv award winner BBC One Quiz diversity mutant El Rey Drama Pirates PaleyFest GIFs stand-up comedy laika Lifetime Syfy documentaries Watching Series Character Guide adventure adaptation The Witch Hallmark Binge Guide toy story USA Network green book ratings NBC spinoff tv talk cats VOD halloween X-Men First Look cinemax nfl documentary crossover sports natural history The Arrangement Year in Review ABC Family venice blaxploitation Film DC streaming service Masterpiece cartoon Reality Competition Disney+ Disney Plus TIFF psycho Universal Musicals screenings IFC Apple TV Plus San Diego Comic-Con unscripted comics ITV Freeform zombie game of thrones festivals video on demand AMC Rocketman golden globes canceled finale See It Skip It zero dark thirty LGBT japanese CNN Paramount USA discovery Shudder Fox Searchlight History DC Universe A&E fresh Set visit crime films RT History Lionsgate teaser Turner Mary poppins National Geographic 45 elevated horror Paramount Network Video Games cooking boxoffice facebook blockbuster fast and furious doctor who MTV E3 comiccon Acorn TV Holidays YouTube harry potter space period drama Marathons SXSW CBS Rock hist Fox News 4/20 cancelled TV shows Pet Sematary australia worst DC Comics Travel Channel DirecTV 2020 Election anime TCA Awards Trivia batman Horror 21st Century Fox 20th Century Fox travel Trailer parents BET Awards hollywood Apple asian-american latino supernatural Hear Us Out foreign Mary Poppins Returns Red Carpet The Purge social media Pop CW Seed Oscars 007 Sundance Heroines chucky Comedy Awards Tour Apple TV+ boxing crime drama jamie lee curtis singing competition hispanic Film Festival 2017 Disney Plus TV renewals The Walking Dead Turner Classic Movies casting Baby Yoda 2019 ESPN Chernobyl Marvel Television Mary Tyler Moore