Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Dumb and Dumber To Has Too Few Laughs

Plus, Beyond the Lights is melodrama done right, and The Newsroom and The Comeback are Certified Fresh

by | November 13, 2014 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got foolhardy travelers (Dumb and Dumber To, starring Jim Carrey and Jeff Daniels) and a lovelorn pop star (Beyond the Lights, starring Gugu Mbatha-Raw and Nate Parker). What do the critics have to say?

Dumb and Dumber To


Twenty years ago, Dumb and Dumber solidified Jim Carrey’s reign as the king of lowbrow comedy, and established directors Bobby and Peter Farrelly as the maestros of heartfelt gross-out humor. Unfortunately, critics say that while Harry and Lloyd can still generate an occasional dumb laugh, Dumb and Dumber To is more crass than funny, and too content to recycle laughs from its superior predecessor. This time out, Harry (Jeff Daniels) needs a kidney transplant, so he recruits Lloyd (Carrey) for a road trip to find a young woman that might be his daughter in the hope that she’s cool with donating a kidney). The pundits say Dumb and Dumber To gets a lot of mileage out of the charisma of its stars, but it simply lacks the heart and freshness of the original. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we count down Daniels’ best-reviewed films.)

Beyond the Lights


“Melodramatic” has become something of a dirty word these days, but there’s nothing wrong with a little melodrama if it’s done well. Take Beyond the Lights, for example: critics say there’s nothing original about this romantic drama, but thanks to sharp direction from Gugu Mbatha-Raw and Gina Prince-Bythewood and an attractive, likeable cast, it’s a top-notch crowd-pleaser. Gugu Mbatha-Raw stars as a rising pop star who’s rapidly becoming disenchanted with fame. She falls hard for Kaz (Nate Parker), an off-duty police officer, after he helps her out of a jam. Will true love conquer all? The pundits say Beyond the Lights is so well-executed that it mostly transcends its cliches, and it ends up having a thing or two to say about the toll that fame takes on women. (Watch our interviews with Mbatha-Raw and Parker here.)

Certified Fresh on TV:

With an energetic new arc and deeper character development, The Newsroom (Certified Fresh at 82 percent) finds itself rejuvenated in its third season — even if it still occasionally serves as a soapbox for creator Aaron Sorkin.

Substantially similar to its predecessor in all the best ways, critics say this new season of The Comeback (Certified Fresh at 83 percent) thrives on Lisa Kudrow’s starring performance as Valerie Cherish.

Also opening this week in limited release:

  • Foxcatcher, starring Channing Tatum and Steve Carell in a drama about an Olympic wrestling hopeful who falls under the influence of a questionable patron, is Certified Fresh at 93 percent.
  • Thou Wast Mild and Lovely, a drama about wild passions on a Kentucky farm, is at 83 percent.
  • Bad Turn Worse, a drama about a trio of Texas teens whose going-away celebration is financed by stolen cash, is at 82 percent.
  • The Homesman, starring Tommy Lee Jones and Hilary Swank in a Western about a former schoolteacher who recruits a man with a past to help her establish a sanctuary for troubled women, is at 78 percent.
  • Starry Eyes, a sci-fi horror film about an actress who is unwittingly enlisted by a sinister organization, is at 78 percent.
  • Jon Stewart‘s Rosewater, starring Gael García Bernal in a based-on-true-events drama about a Newsweek reporter accused of espionage while on assignment in Iran, is at 73 percent.
  • Miss Meadows, starring Katie Holmes in a drama about an elementary school teacher who moonlights as a vigilante, is at 50 percent.
  • Wolves, an action/horror hybrid about a teen werewolf who discovers an unsettled community of wolf-people, is at 33 percent.

Tag Cloud

Kids & Family cartoon A&E Esquire San Diego Comic-Con DirecTV travel Pet Sematary Vudu ghosts transformers richard e. Grant Dark Horse Comics sequels war child's play SDCC Freeform Sneak Peek scary movies Academy Awards emmy awards TV renewals psychological thriller Star Wars TV Land comic Martial Arts Set visit criterion vampires critics National Geographic films CBS All Access politics versus Sundance TV science fiction Disney+ Disney Plus revenge elevated horror Comics on TV Sundance Now BBC One social media natural history Chilling Adventures of Sabrina OneApp stop motion doctor who Premiere Dates dark Stephen King TLC Valentine's Day crime Character Guide President Tubi cancelled television Tomatazos Awards Winners cancelled TV series binge quibi Mudbound spy thriller romance screenings Rocketman spider-man spanish language Binge Guide name the review tv talk movies Heroines 2018 Pixar IFC comedies Cosplay Classic Film Opinion stand-up comedy Emmy Nominations adventure TCA Country CW Seed Lionsgate dceu Summer video TCA Winter 2020 Fall TV Reality YouTube Red Christmas Superheroes Fox Searchlight satire japanese spinoff green book Marvel Television composers Amazon Prime TCA Awards thriller The Walking Dead discovery theme song Schedule biography FX First Reviews Crackle Sci-Fi best 2016 screen actors guild award winner American Society of Cinematographers football DC Universe YouTube Marvel Nickelodeon BET First Look anime Showtime Sony Pictures scorecard Superheroe sitcom Hear Us Out historical drama Spring TV canceled TV shows Funimation facebook stoner VOD Starz TIFF WGN 2020 Lifetime Christmas movies french Election Black History Month E! laika christmas movies nbcuniversal sag awards Polls and Games spain Spectrum Originals NBC 4/20 Grammys robots singing competition Comedy Central mutant Lucasfilm streaming dragons docudrama dramedy anthology fast and furious USA Network Rom-Com justice league Writers Guild of America nfl foreign History Endgame all-time kids independent Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Syfy comics E3 Rocky Adult Swim Apple Infographic Song of Ice and Fire reviews Cartoon Network book TV Netflix sequel children's TV Toys true crime mission: impossible Marathons ITV Fox News GoT crime drama Turner psycho Epix YA Bravo free movies Nat Geo Mary poppins FX on Hulu dc Video Games LGBTQ hispanic Music ABC Family canceled CMT Western Fantasy harry potter breaking bad HBO Max NYCC Warner Bros. Emmys BBC America Film Creative Arts Emmys PlayStation Family A24 Apple TV Plus Hallmark superhero jamie lee curtis festival BET Awards romantic comedy reboot Watching Series Avengers archives Shondaland medical drama Britbox teaser BAFTA Disney Channel venice Acorn TV festivals sports police drama The Academy 24 frames Television Academy toronto ESPN Mystery latino Tumblr Musicals TruTV worst movies Pirates spanish halloween 2015 TNT nature Crunchyroll golden globes serial killer remakes Best and Worst franchise Paramount universal monsters 2017 HBO Go PaleyFest VICE Television Critics Association cults X-Men Countdown The Purge Awards Tour Lifetime indiana jones Super Bowl LGBT slashers The Arrangement Photos Pop TV RT History obituary Black Mirror Women's History Month Captain marvel crime thriller period drama directors New York Comic Con USA die hard Quiz Comic Book blaxploitation SundanceTV Turner Classic Movies TCM Trivia Year in Review FXX PBS Chernobyl Pride Month Cannes BBC Disney television toy story witnail DC streaming service based on movie SXSW Mindy Kaling mockumentary disaster documentary CNN MCU Amazon Studios space Trailer game show Paramount Network cars dogs The Witch Interview rotten MSNBC Arrowverse a nightmare on elm street Film Festival Thanksgiving Netflix Christmas movies Brie Larson cops DC Comics Extras Winter TV Comedy Action Elton John Universal 2019 asian-american batman video on demand Trophy Talk FOX hist casting 71st Emmy Awards TCA 2017 ABC APB Rock unscripted miniseries worst Star Trek Disney streaming service Spike DGA series Amazon Prime Video zombies boxoffice south america El Rey documentaries 21st Century Fox OWN Oscars Box Office Sundance what to watch Peacock classics WarnerMedia Calendar comiccon Pop movie The CW Musical Holiday Ovation cooking Holidays Tarantino adaptation halloween tv talk show chucky Mary Poppins Returns Red Carpet 45 Logo Discovery Channel zero dark thirty Ghostbusters Shudder concert cancelled renewed TV shows 20th Century Fox rotten movies we love Anna Paquin news Marvel Studios Apple TV+ Podcast diversity blockbuster AMC GIFs joker Disney Plus Food Network YouTube Premium VH1 Drama Amazon Biopics See It Skip It cats cancelled TV shows Columbia Pictures Hulu GLAAD Walt Disney Pictures Certified Fresh australia Masterpiece hollywood crossover 007 Teen RT21 TBS indie aliens animated Animation Travel Channel italian Baby Yoda MTV ratings technology supernatural Mary Tyler Moore 72 Emmy Awards HBO twilight Ellie Kemper game of thrones finale IFC Films Horror cinemax werewolf CBS Hallmark Christmas movies Reality Competition political drama zombie strong female leads parents Nominations