Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Cowboys and Aliens is All Mixed Up

Plus, The Smurfs has critics feeling blue, and Crazy, Stupid, Love is sharp and funny.

by | July 29, 2011 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got bronco-busters and extraterrestrials (Cowboys and Aliens, starring Daniel Craig and Harrison Ford), little blue people (The Smurfs, starring Neil Patrick Harris and Katy Perry), and modern romance (Crazy, Stupid, Love, starring Steve Carell and Ryan Gosling). What do the critics have to say?

Cowboys and Aliens


What is Cowboys and Aliens? Is it a Western? A sci-fi thriller? An homage? A parody? Well, say critics, it’s all those things and more, though it’s not quite as seamless – or as fun – as one might have hoped, given the talents involved (and the B-movie promise of its undeniably awesome title). Daniel Craig stars as a mysterious man with no memory of his past who stumbles into a rough-and-tumble town called Absolution, where he’s treated with disdain by a tyrannical lawman (Harrison Ford). However, when hostile space invaders blast away at the community, they turn to the stranger for help. Critics say what could have been a giddy, action-packed romp is bogged down by serious tonal problems; though Cowboys and Aliens has a top-notch cast and moments of genre-bending fun, we’re never sure how seriously to take the action onscreen, and the result is an odd hybrid that never fully takes flight. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we count down Craig’s best-reviewed films, as well as our gallery of movie genre mashups.)

The Smurfs


Many a Gen-Xer has a soft spot for the Smurfs, those diminutive blue folks who enlivened our youthful Saturday mornings. Unfortunately, not all is smurfy in Smurfland; critics say the live action/ CGI hybrid The Smurfs is pretty thin stuff, an unfunny, less-than-thrilling family film with plenty of crass innuendo but almost no magic. Neil Patrick Harris stars as a New York workaholic who must help the Smurfs get back to their village – they’ve been chased out by their archenemy Gargamel, and they must navigate the Big Apple in the meantime. The pundits say The Smurfs feels like a nostalgic cash-grab, with a generic plot and little of the charm that made these elfin creatures appealing to begin with.

Crazy, Stupid, Love


When it comes to romantic comedies, sometimes great acting can give shape to uneven material. Critics say that’s largely the case with Crazy, Stupid, Love, a fitfully rewarding effort enlivened by its star power. Steve Carell stars as a newly divorced middle-aged guy who hasn’t been on a date in years and has almost no way with the ladies. He ends up tagging along with a good-looking younger playboy (Ryan Gosling) and learning a thing or two about contemporary amour. The pundits say Crazy, Stupid, Love too often resorts to sitcommy scenarios, though it’s also insightful, funny, and occasionally quite touching, thanks to a cast that also includes Emma Stone and Julianne Moore.

Also opening this week in limited release:

  • The Interrupters, a documentary about a group of “violence interrupters” who attempt to combat urban violence in Chicago, is at 100 percent.
  • The Guard, starring Brendan Gleeson and Don Cheadle in a dramedy about a gruff Irish policeman who teams with an incredulous FBI agent on a drug investigation, is at 93 percent (Check out our interview with Gleeson here).
  • Attack the Block, an action/comedy about a group of inner city London kids who defend the city against an alien invasion, is Certified Fresh at 91 percent.
  • The Future, directed by and starring Miranda July in the tale of an unmarried couple whose maturity is tested after adopting a stray cat, is at 91 percent.
  • Point Blank, a French thriller about a nurse who finds himself caught in the crossfire of rival gangsters as he attempts to save his kidnapped wife and child, is at 88 percent.
  • Sleep Furiously, a lyrical documentary about life in a Welsh farming community, is at 79 percent.
  • Good Neighbors, starring Scott Speedman and Jay Baruchel in a thriller about the residents of an apartment building who become fascinated with a series of local murders, is at 65 percent.
  • The Devil’s Double, starring Dominic Cooper in a dual role as Saddam Hussein’s hard-partying son Uday and as his reluctant body double, is at 61 percent.

Tag Cloud

2018 Marvel TCA 2017 singing competition TCA YouTube Red Horror Adult Swim Rock WGN Box Office Toys FOX Lifetime Fox News Nat Geo docudrama Schedule Fall TV Heroines TIFF Pirates Trivia sequel ABC Family Comic Book politics Fantasy Super Bowl Writers Guild of America PBS DC streaming service GoT Amazon Prime Teen USA Network Grammys Chernobyl 2015 Quiz ABC Awards Tour DGA Western cinemax E! crime Chilling Adventures of Sabrina dragons Spike teaser Shondaland BBC Tomatazos Country Disney Channel Polls and Games television dramedy Ellie Kemper natural history based on movie CW Seed Winners Lucasfilm San Diego Comic-Con Superheroe BET medical drama A&E IFC casting crossover Showtime anthology GLAAD supernatural Set visit Nickelodeon El Rey Anna Paquin composers IFC Films historical drama Emmys game show CBS period drama Opinion Mystery spy thriller Mindy Kaling comiccon diversity TLC DC Universe Red Carpet Pet Sematary TruTV Rocky cats Brie Larson Countdown RT History Trailer National Geographic transformers cults Sundance richard e. Grant streaming Tumblr Vudu 21st Century Fox Apple CMT Epix romance Cosplay DC Comics MCU VICE police drama Pride Month festivals Comedy Central vampires blaxploitation boxoffice hist Lionsgate zombie mutant discovery adventure Masterpiece Sneak Peek Bravo justice league psycho The Arrangement Cannes See It Skip It 2017 theme song MSNBC Warner Bros. Musical Calendar Summer Superheroes ratings mockumentary X-Men 20th Century Fox award winner Starz Captain marvel SundanceTV Sundance Now Watching Series Extras Musicals Comics on TV Shudder Sony Pictures Mary Poppins Returns OWN ESPN Star Trek CNN Creative Arts Emmys Character Guide Freeform MTV Election FX Winter TV Infographic doctor who Drama TV NYCC President YA Rom-Com Mary poppins Tarantino Music Kids & Family Crackle travel First Look SDCC crime thriller Thanksgiving Paramount Christmas cooking Pop robots science fiction History animated Women's History Month Amazon binge talk show aliens TNT Acorn TV finale AMC DirecTV Ovation SXSW FXX psychological thriller Year in Review American Society of Cinematographers Disney spinoff strong female leads harry potter Columbia Pictures Mary Tyler Moore LGBTQ Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Interview Cartoon Network USA GIFs cops Syfy BBC America Walt Disney Pictures Universal TBS Trophy Talk Action 007 facebook Photos serial killer Holidays Food Network technology biography E3 Certified Fresh VH1 nature Spectrum Originals Netflix space YouTube Premium RT21 Esquire 2016 45 Premiere Dates Comedy PaleyFest war Reality Rocketman Pixar Biopics ITV TV Land Black Mirror thriller 2019 true crime APB sitcom comic disaster golden globes what to watch 24 frames Spring TV Martial Arts dceu CBS All Access TCM Mudbound zero dark thirty political drama Hulu adaptation jamie lee curtis LGBT Song of Ice and Fire Animation miniseries Britbox social media Valentine's Day The Witch spider-man dc witnail elevated horror green book toy story Nominations Ghostbusters Reality Competition Sci-Fi HBO anime crime drama Dark Horse Comics Best and Worst Film Festival New York Comic Con Video Games Marathons Oscars sports Stephen King Logo Awards Star Wars zombies Paramount Network The CW Podcast Elton John unscripted NBC