Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Conan the Barbarian is a Bloody Mess

Plus, Fright Night scares up some laughs and chills, but Spy Kids and One Day strike out.

by | August 19, 2011 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a heroic strongman (Conan the Barbarian, starring Jason Momoa and Rachel Nichols), pint-sized agents (Spy Kids: All the Time in the World in 4D, starring Jessica Alba and Joel McHale), scary neighbors (Fright Night, starring Anton Yelchin and Colin Farrell), and part-time lovers (One Day, starring Anne Hathaway and Jim Sturgess). What do the critics have to say?

Conan the Barbarian


The 1982 Conan the Barbarian became a seminal entry in the sword-and-sorcery subgenre, maiking Arnold Schwarzenegger a star in the process. And although critics say Jason Momoa does his best with the title role, this new Conan the Barbarian eschews pulpy swashbuckling for non-stop action, and the result is a numbing barrage of blood, guts, and noise. The titular warrior is out for vengeance against the warlord who killed his family. On the trail of his foe, he encounters the beautiful Tamara (Rachel Nichols), and together, they leave a mountain of dead bodies strewn about the countryside. The pundits say Conan the Barbarian has a decent look and some thrills, but it’s mostly just a brutal, hyperactively-edited gore-fest that barely pauses to develop the characters or the plot. (Check out co-star Rose McGowan’s Five Favorite Films here.)

Spy Kids: All the Time in the World in 4D


Throughout his career, director Robert Rodriguez has led a seemingly incongruous double life: when he’s not making stylistically bold neo-grindhouse films, he’s helming impish adventure tales for the kiddies. Unfortunately, critics say the fourth installment of his venerable Spy Kids franchise, All the Time in the World in 4D, is tired, juvenile stuff that isn’t improved by gimmicky 3D and scratch ‘n’ sniff cards. Jessica Alba stars as retired spy who’s lured back into action when a maniacal super villain threatens the free world. She’s joined in her mission by some newly recruited spy kids. The pundits say Spy Kids 4 is almost entirely bereft of the charm and excitement of the series’ first two entries, with mediocre special effects and an overabundance of sophomoric humor. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we count down Rodriguez’s best-reviewed movies.)

Fright Night


On paper, a remake of Fright Night sounds like an opportunistic attempt to cash in on the current vampire craze — especially since the original, a minor genre classic that deftly (and self-referentially) mixed laughs and scares, still holds up pretty well. However, critics say this new Fright Night is surprisingly effective, thanks to some terrific performances and a solid script that captures — and occasionally expands upon — what worked the first time around. Anton Yelchin stars as Charley, a too-cool-for-school teen who notices that something’s not quite right about Jerry (Colin Farrell), the guy who moved in next door. As it turns out, Jerry’s a vampire who’s preying on the neighborhood, and it’s up to Charley to stop him. The pundits say that while Fright Night doesn’t always match the mischievous appeal of its source material, the script is sharp and clever, and the cast — particularly Farrell, who oozes sly menace — is uniformly excellent.

One Day


The premise of One Day is undeniably intriguing: it’s a romantic dramedy featuring two mismatched would-be lovers whose tentative relationship stretches for decades. Unfortunately, critics say the execution is a bit off; we’re never quite convinced our heroes are meant to be together, and the annual check-in conceit alluded to in the title seems contrived after a while. Anne Hathaway and Jim Sturgess are the couple, who meet at the end of college and are attracted to one another despite class and personality differences. Every subsequent June 15, we get glimpses of their lives, loves, and careers, as the pair maintains a friendship that might someday become something more. The pundits say One Day deserves credit for attempting to upend the traditional structure of the movie romance, and the stars’ repartee is fitfully amusing, but the characters are too ill-defined to make much of an impression.

Also opening this week in limited release:

  • Summer Pasture, a documentary about the harsh lives of Tibetan nomads, is at 100 percent.
  • The Last Circus, a dramedy about a clown whose life is upended by the rise of Fascism in Spain, is at 92 percent.
  • The Hedgehog, a drama about a morose 12-year-old who befriends the grumpy concierge in her apartment building, is at 83 percent.
  • Mozart’s Sister, a historical drama about the great composer’s talented older sibling, is at 80 percent.
  • Griff the Invisible, a comedy/romance about a shy working stiff who moonlights as a superhero, is at 78 percent.
  • Atrocious, a lo-fi horror film about a family that films its investigation into a terrifying urban legend, is at 67 percent.
  • The Journals Of Musan, a drama about a North Korean defector awkwardly adjusting to his new life in South Korea, is at 60 percent.
  • John Sayles‘s Amigo, a drama about a village torn apart by the Philippine-American War, is at 59 percent.
  • 5 Days Of War, starring Rupert Friend and Emmanuelle Chriqui in a drama about an American reporter caught in the crossfire of the 2008 Georgian conflict with Russia, is at 55 percent.
  • A Horrible Way to Die, an indie thriller about an escaped serial killer who’s looking for his ex-girlfriend, is at 40 percent.
  • Flypaper, starring Patrick Dempsey and Ashley Judd in a crime comedy about a would-be bank robber who develops a bond with a teller, is at 22 percent.
  • Programming The Nation?, a documentary about subliminal messages in politics and advertising, is at 14 percent.

Tag Cloud

Podcast Stephen King Winners docuseries Cartoon Network Film Festival documentary Martial Arts prank slasher Bravo Columbia Pictures biopic Universal Pictures Trophy Talk Lucasfilm video Trailer spider-verse Elton John Schedule festival new york stoner Drama Grammys 2015 Showtime SXSW 2022 WarnerMedia cats Infographic book DC Universe Heroines Turner Classic Movies Star Trek medical drama deadpool cancelled TV series Tubi halloween tv trailers Rocketman Discovery Channel finale travel blockbuster Women's History Month comiccon Super Bowl NYCC teaser Lifetime 2016 Biopics VH1 rotten streaming BBC America blockbusters Certified Fresh TCA Awards debate Disney Best Actor superhero CW Seed Nickelodeon Logo joker remakes American Society of Cinematographers art house thriller Mary Tyler Moore elevated horror Toys Shondaland vs. Christmas Holiday Amazon Prime Video Fall TV indie comic book movie child's play Academy Awards Best and Worst Teen diversity target TruTV popular jurassic park President nbcuniversal obi wan war The CW TBS BBC One Comedy Central Anna Paquin suspense casting mission: impossible PaleyFest Cannes scary movies Amazon venice Instagram Live sag awards Action stop motion TV Land news renewed TV shows series Mystery australia classics dexter witnail Binge Guide binge 90s 45 TCA heist movie History cults Trivia game of thrones cars docudrama Film Hear Us Out chucky Avengers crossover police drama Reality fast and furious The Purge Shudder E! revenge natural history green book 2019 Pop TV Paramount Black Mirror period drama 1990s halloween zero dark thirty Marvel MGM spanish language black YouTube Red adenture fresh Rom-Com wonder woman Nat Geo romance The Witch mockumentary Pet Sematary nature Cosplay romantic comedy Polls and Games laika 2021 women Syfy Box Office monster movies Brie Larson Kids & Family DGA Animation Tags: Comedy cancelled TV shows political drama Sundance Now new zealand USA Network dreamworks Tokyo Olympics posters TV One dceu Musical Baby Yoda AMC latino TCA 2017 versus Extras Video Games leaderboard Pop ABC Signature anthology ID FX Disney Channel sequel Country HBO Netflix Christmas movies hollywood Best Director christmas movies cancelled 2017 E3 Fox News Television Academy streamig screen actors guild South by Southwest Film Festival ESPN south america Fox Searchlight 21st Century Fox ratings dogs Fantasy king kong zombies SundanceTV Legendary HBO Max Crunchyroll Marvel Television See It Skip It YouTube Food Network CBS foreign Premiere Dates Neflix zombie Ellie Kemper award winner Apple rt labs critics edition streaming movies Disney+ Disney Plus CMT dragons true crime Television Critics Association Pirates NBA Holidays MSNBC Pacific Islander reviews 24 frames Tumblr Character Guide tv talk A&E talk show marvel cinematic universe 007 Mindy Kaling ABC Lifetime Christmas movies WGN all-time FOX hispanic heritage month OneApp TIFF rt labs BET Awards television satire twilight kaiju Creative Arts Emmys die hard crime thriller Hallmark telelvision Apple TV Plus Alien Musicals sequels young adult Sci-Fi BBC singing competition mcc Winter TV reboot First Reviews TCM franchise james bond movie king arthur Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Fargo Wes Anderson international Superheroes Comic Book RT21 El Rey critics legend Year in Review scorecard Watching Series 2020 comic books Best Picture based on movie japanese lord of the rings Apple TV+ comics VOD archives ViacomCBS YA Best Actress TV movies Amazon Prime X-Men comedies DC Comics pirates of the caribbean Captain marvel worst movies Calendar IMDb TV olympics trophy Opinion live action strong female leads Marvel Studios Ghostbusters The Arrangement BET 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Oscar crime The Walt Disney Company Exclusive Video concert aapi a nightmare on elm street films documentaries Peacock kids Oscars Star Wars stand-up comedy Pride Month sitcom TV renewals black comedy 73rd Emmy Awards golden globes BAFTA SDCC mutant independent dc godzilla CBS All Access 4/20 Amazon Studios superman rotten movies we love Britbox Hollywood Foreign Press Association 2018 Emmy Nominations Ovation Reality Competition boxing Warner Bros. royal family gangster canceled Sneak Peek hispanic comic game show Sundance TV Rocky SXSW Music AMC Plus boxoffice Turner Hallmark Christmas movies Election japan TV Song of Ice and Fire Dark Horse Comics Travel Channel universal monsters PBS sopranos emmy awards marvel comics richard e. Grant MCU 94th Oscars IFC doctor who HBO Go ABC Family GoT biography festivals composers feel good Classic Film high school Funimation nfl cops scene in color live event discovery space supernatural dark serial killer new star wars movies Comic-Con@Home 2021 Horror italian quibi FX on Hulu FXX Universal batman politics Lionsgate Red Carpet unscripted DC streaming service Quiz saw 79th Golden Globes Awards football 20th Century Fox TCA Winter 2020 cancelled television Walt Disney Pictures Spike name the review comic book movies Mary poppins slashers The Walking Dead canceled TV shows New York Comic Con Arrowverse book adaptation Black History Month Image Comics Sony Pictures harry potter Countdown VICE Vudu criterion Tomatazos Epix Paramount Plus Sundance Acorn TV breaking bad spider-man razzies Comedy kong cartoon Comics on TV asian-american Interview 93rd Oscars anime aliens National Geographic scary movies Hulu Awards Tour PlayStation directors screenings DirecTV YouTube Premium hist Family werewolf Rock Spectrum Originals adventure Tarantino robots TLC miniseries NBC worst Valentine's Day Crackle best free movies A24 RT History disaster genre french Nominations Chernobyl transformers 99% animated CNN Broadway Marathons Spring TV IFC Films Freeform facebook USA GIFs know your critic action-comedy Masterpiece HFPA Disney Plus APB Pixar video on demand Netflix spy thriller hidden camera technology obituary Set visit social media Adult Swim mob Summer what to watch science fiction psycho Superheroe Writers Guild of America Starz parents 72 Emmy Awards Paramount Network ghosts rom-coms Disney streaming service toy story Emmys TNT historical drama dramedy Western cooking Endgame children's TV Prime Video ITV critic resources LGBTQ golden globe awards cinemax Awards indiana jones sports vampires First Look crime drama toronto Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Photos OWN spinoff The Academy Esquire theme song LGBT blaxploitation psychological thriller Mary Poppins Returns San Diego Comic-Con 71st Emmy Awards justice league GLAAD basketball jamie lee curtis spain Mudbound Thanksgiving rt archives MTV adaptation spanish