Critics Consensus

Critical Consensus: "Vendetta" Hits, "Man" Misses

by | March 16, 2006 | Comments

This week’s wide releases highlight a rarely-tread path in modern cinema, as both pics feature two of America’s sweethearts — every geek’s fave, Natalie Portman, and cute little Amanda Bynes — enduring two very different boyish makeovers, with two very different results. Will "Vendetta" live up to the hype? Can a girly "Man" make teens swoon for Shakespeare? The scribes will tell us!

Ah, the hype. "V for Vendetta," arguably the year’s first event movie, has been generating the loudest buzz for months — and critics say it’s justified. Produced by the Wachowski brothers (masters of the Matrices), and starring Natalie Portman and a fully masked Hugo Weaving, "Vendetta" tells the story of a near-future dystopia, where a lone freedom fighter named V (Weaving) plots a series of revolutionary bombings to bring down a shady, secretly policed government. Along the way, V recruits young, frightened Evey (Portman), shaves her head, and turns her into a proper young revolutionary. The scribes say this political thriller is high on politics as well as thrills, with a few stunning set pieces augmenting an austere, yet stylish, mise-en-scene; however, the incendiary tone of its politics — which have been labeled terrorist-like by some — is more than a bit difficult for some to stomach in this post-9/11 day and age. Nevertheless, "V for Vendetta" is enjoying Fresh status with a 68% score on the Tomatometer, and the critical mass urges at least one thought-provoking viewing.

Faring worse at the hands of the critics, "She’s The Man" is a teen-oriented take on Shakespeare’s gender-bender "Twelfth Night," from two of the writers of a better Bard treatment, "10 Things I Hate About You." TV teen queen Amanda Bynes stars as Viola, a prep school tomboy who decides to impersonate her twin brother Sebastian in order to play on his soccer team. Donning a short wig and boy’s clothing, Viola infiltrates Illyria Prep, but soon falls for her dreamy roommate, who’s crushing on a pretty blonde, who has the hots for the undercover Viola; hilarity and sexual confusion ensue. Unfortunately, the scribes say this comedy of errors is just that, with an erratic comic timing, unbelievable plotlines, and too-broad jokes that make you feel embarrassed for Bynes — the actress, not her character. At 50% on the Tomatometer, "She’s" not quite "The Man."

Recent Big-Screen Graphic Novel Adaptations
38% — Art School Confidential (2006)
87% — A History of Violence (2005)
78% — Sin City (2005)
18% — The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen (2003)
95% — American Splendor (2003)
83% — Road to Perdition (2002)
92% — Ghost World (2001)
56% — From Hell (2001)

Tag Cloud

dc harry potter Comedy Central E! FXX Best and Worst period drama Musicals Action travel 2017 psycho Syfy El Rey CMT Ellie Kemper Certified Fresh A&E 24 frames Comedy Tomatazos Hulu 45 cats dceu crime thriller CBS Pirates ESPN Pop Tumblr Set visit Red Carpet IFC TNT Trivia thriller science fiction talk show VH1 Nickelodeon DirecTV boxoffice serial killer BBC cooking Rom-Com Spring TV war Box Office Year in Review USA Countdown Nominations composers Warner Bros. Esquire MTV Writers Guild of America biography American Society of Cinematographers Dark Horse Comics based on movie Sci-Fi BBC America ABC Lionsgate Opinion Marathons Netflix Fox News Disney Channel sitcom singing competition TCA 2017 Super Bowl AMC vampires GLAAD YA TV Land PBS HBO DC Comics Grammys Rock Western police drama Trailer Valentine's Day Fantasy 2016 historical drama Starz justice league The Arrangement Sneak Peek Infographic adventure cops Reality Competition Fall TV Musical Extras Winter TV crime 21st Century Fox 2015 medical drama Amazon Martial Arts SDCC binge Photos Adult Swim The CW TBS SundanceTV TruTV crime drama technology supernatural Logo Holidays Rocky Schedule Toys BET 007 Polls and Games political drama what to watch social media Marvel NYCC Crackle First Look Masterpiece comiccon Freeform Country dramedy PaleyFest cinemax Biopics Summer GoT Mystery Star Trek Calendar politics Bravo Premiere Dates Reality Mindy Kaling Star Wars Interview Kids & Family TCM WGN sports GIFs Awards APB Animation Oscars Nat Geo Watching Series romance docudrama Comic Book Cartoon Network diversity CNN aliens FX ABC Family DC Universe FOX Mary Tyler Moore Winners Emmys Superheroes Video Games History ITV CBS All Access OWN Election Sundance Music TCA Drama Food Network Disney Horror Podcast Lifetime NBC TV RT History discovery Cosplay TLC Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt transformers E3 President MSNBC VICE Thanksgiving LGBTQ Paramount Teen Showtime zombie TIFF Ghostbusters Character Guide Universal X-Men