Critics Consensus

Critical Consensus: "Knocked Up" Is A Knockout; "Mr. Brooks," "Gracie" Less So

by | May 31, 2007 | Comments

This week at the movies we’ve got matters of life ("Knocked Up," starring Katherine Heigl and Seth Rogen), death ("Mr. Brooks," starring Kevin Costner and Demi Moore), and soccer ("Gracie," starring Elisabeth Shue). What do the critics have to say?

When director Judd Apatow titles a movie, you always know what to expect. Like, what else could something called "The 40-Year-Old-Virgin" possibly have been about? And Apatow’s newest flick, "Knocked Up," is just as bluntly advertised: a perpetually stoned schlub (Seth Rogen) impregnates a woman way out of his league (Katherine Heigl) after a one-night stand, putting the kibosh on his arrested development. But, like "Virgin," "Knocked" has a sweetness and depth that extends well beyong most comedies; critics call it a hilarious, poignant, and refreshing look at the rigors of courtship and child-rearing, with a sometimes raunchy, always witty script that is ably acted and directed. At 88 percent on the Tomatometer, "Knocked Up" isn’t just Certified Fresh, it even tops "Virgin"’s 82 percent.


In "Mr. Brooks," Kevin Costner plays a successful businessman and loving father with a big secret: he’s a serial killer on the down low. It’s an admittedly intriguing setup, and critics say "Mr. Brooks" gives its talented cast, which includes Demi Moore, William Hurt, and Dane Cook (!) a chance to take on some meaty roles, as well as providing audiences with some amusing, smarter-than-average plot twists and thrills. Unfortunately, the pundits also note that "Mr. Brooks" is overstuffed with said twists, making for a film that becomes more preposterous as it goes along. "Mr. Brooks" currently stands at 53 percent on the Tomatometer.

"They call me Mister Brooks!"

"Gracie" is the latest in a long line of inspirational sports movies that feature a dogged protagonist overcoming prejudice and family trauma. The film, a fictional treatment of star Elisabeth Shue’s high school sports career, tells the story of a 15-year-old (Carly Schroeder) who wants to play soccer at a time when there isn’t a girls’ squad at her school. Couple the sexism Gracie faces with the tragic death of her brother, and you’ve got the stuff that sports movies are made of, right? Well, critics say that "Gracie" can be rousing and touching in spots, but it’s ultimately undone by its predictable story arc and a lack of nuance. At 42 percent on the Tomatometer, "Gracie" is something of a draw.

Apparently trying out an interesting new soccer maneuver.

Also opening this week in limited release: "The Trials of Darryl Hunt," a doc about a man falsely accused of murder, is at 100 percent; "Radiant City," a visually expressive doc about suburban sprawl, is at 91 percent; "Crazy Love," a doc about a remarkably dysfunctional relationship, is at 87 percent; "Day Watch," the second installation in Timur Bekmambetov’s vampire trilogy, is at 73 percent; "Pierrepoint – The Last Hangman," which tells the tale of a conflicted executioner, is at 73 percent; and the indie rom-com "I’m Reed Fish" is at 67 percent.

"I can’t help it if I think the last season of ‘Gilmore Girls’ sucked."

Recent Kevin Costner Movies:
38% — The Guardian (2006)
18% — Rumor Has It… (2005)
74% — The Upside of Anger (2005)
78% — Open Range (2003)
7% — Dragonfly (2002)

Tag Cloud

72 Emmy Awards WGN Food Network Binge Guide Disney+ Disney Plus Holiday Starz YA book adaptation Year in Review dc WarnerMedia Vudu talk show boxing Brie Larson E3 Esquire ViacomCBS christmas movies Tarantino rotten movies we love vs. Sci-Fi Martial Arts miniseries dragons Netflix Christmas movies period drama batman zombie Neflix 93rd Oscars laika spanish language quibi video on demand basketball canceled prank sports hidden camera comic book movie fast and furious game show Paramount Plus Mary Poppins Returns Amazon Studios historical drama HBO Pacific Islander Amazon Peacock natural history science fiction BET Awards Turner Crunchyroll Acorn TV TCA Winter 2020 Winter TV Classic Film festival cancelled cancelled television Red Carpet Pixar IMDb TV The Purge Fox News sag awards parents emmy awards stand-up comedy Universal Pictures breaking bad jurassic park Pop TV Spike Prime Video heist movie biography legend Fantasy Quiz Set visit foreign President Hallmark Christmas movies TV renewals ABC Signature BET Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Mindy Kaling name the review kids Marvel A&E NBC Country venice American Society of Cinematographers television art house Hulu blaxploitation Endgame Star Wars Marvel Television kaiju reviews dogs psycho cancelled TV series Nominations royal family die hard Reality Superheroes black best Lucasfilm MSNBC singing competition social media archives Animation NBA Netflix new york Creative Arts Emmys facebook south america HBO Max FXX Musical Disney 1990s Baby Yoda YouTube scorecard police drama boxoffice Drama thriller TV Land indiana jones know your critic Photos ghosts Mary Tyler Moore NYCC Awards Tour CBS All Access sequels Cosplay Crackle TV Alien dark target First Reviews Comic Book concert Amazon Prime Video Infographic AMC screenings feel good crossover Bravo blockbusters Disney Plus Amazon Prime USA ratings Britbox The Witch Elton John golden globes Black Mirror Action 24 frames comic books serial killer Superheroe Fox Searchlight Disney Channel critics reboot Captain marvel asian-american Ghostbusters Song of Ice and Fire dceu Epix scary LGBTQ spider-man Sundance Now Columbia Pictures sitcom streaming movies Television Academy Pirates rt archives TLC Marvel Studios Masterpiece Broadway 71st Emmy Awards Heroines australia Best and Worst marvel comics vampires kong Stephen King lord of the rings Instagram Live justice league Hollywood Foreign Press Association Musicals 2018 anime Cartoon Network comedies CBS USA Network Kids & Family Oscars renewed TV shows PBS SDCC cinemax spanish technology theme song toy story Tomatazos TIFF Nat Geo The Academy Rocketman Travel Channel dramedy slashers black comedy italian A24 Calendar VOD Film hist IFC CW Seed cops football The Walking Dead Shondaland leaderboard spinoff disaster james bond Election anthology Logo CNN Comedy Central stop motion politics Polls and Games wonder woman debate Marathons Universal all-time women IFC Films BBC One Anna Paquin adaptation sopranos true crime Podcast LGBT docudrama 007 binge book supernatural Television Critics Association OWN Apple Winners saw Christmas Mary poppins godzilla animated RT History First Look 79th Golden Globes Awards ABC Family new zealand genre king arthur DGA aapi popular festivals The Arrangement Character Guide FOX Disney streaming service trophy BBC America Apple TV Plus Western Interview Avengers BAFTA indie hispanic heritage month Hear Us Out hollywood elevated horror Sundance TV Fall TV pirates of the caribbean telelvision RT21 Valentine's Day Emmys Comedy marvel cinematic universe children's TV Box Office Star Trek rotten toronto Lifetime Christmas movies crime series nbcuniversal dexter remakes Tubi TCA 2017 Comics on TV TV One witnail Rocky Paramount Network Exclusive Video FX superman movies war Trivia SXSW Biopics YouTube Premium twilight 20th Century Fox psychological thriller cartoon crime thriller Academy Awards slasher Schedule award winner Lifetime werewolf independent spider-verse stoner blockbuster AMC Plus screen actors guild Sneak Peek Teen Shudder hispanic comic cooking Opinion Summer adenture Legendary japan cats scary movies Mudbound X-Men Dark Horse Comics deadpool Pride Month nfl medical drama zombies mob OneApp golden globe awards Pet Sematary Thanksgiving news franchise docuseries travel suspense Music cars Arrowverse jamie lee curtis Rom-Com comics Ovation new star wars movies Premiere Dates San Diego Comic-Con king kong mockumentary 2021 live action scene in color The Walt Disney Company chucky Countdown FX on Hulu discovery Sundance casting Paramount Family Fargo tv talk Cannes diversity critic resources Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt New York Comic Con films sequel revenge based on movie cancelled TV shows high school Freeform Discovery Channel Film Festival biopic crime drama ESPN 4/20 a nightmare on elm street international action-comedy Image Comics VH1 National Geographic rt labs critics edition spy thriller GIFs halloween 2019 TCA Awards Walt Disney Pictures 2015 See It Skip It classics aliens movie Super Bowl french documentary Extras teaser Apple TV+ Adult Swim Funimation what to watch TNT obituary Toys harry potter Certified Fresh dreamworks 45 MTV mission: impossible fresh olympics E! DC streaming service game of thrones richard e. Grant nature 73rd Emmy Awards space Tags: Comedy political drama video GoT criterion 21st Century Fox rom-coms BBC doctor who PlayStation APB 2020 robots TCM History versus TBS TV movies adventure SundanceTV Watching Series comiccon monster movies Horror Turner Classic Movies live event Reality Competition Tokyo Olympics Mystery unscripted free movies Women's History Month universal monsters romance DirecTV ID Emmy Nominations documentaries DC Universe rt labs Writers Guild of America directors Syfy Sony Pictures Tumblr Trailer Chernobyl CMT razzies Comic-Con@Home 2021 Holidays GLAAD 2016 gangster ABC trailers 99% Spectrum Originals child's play Spring TV latino Nickelodeon HBO Go El Rey posters young adult Wes Anderson Grammys Ellie Kemper cults 2017 japanese composers 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards streaming joker TruTV DC Comics Awards halloween tv mutant canceled TV shows finale Rock zero dark thirty Warner Bros. comic book movies VICE ITV The CW Trophy Talk transformers satire YouTube Red green book Hallmark HFPA superhero TCA romantic comedy mcc worst movies Showtime Black History Month spain Video Games MCU Lionsgate worst strong female leads PaleyFest 90s Pop