Critics Consensus

Critical Consensus: "Hoax" Shines; Force Is With "ATHF"; "Disturbia" Mixed; "Pathfinder," "Stranger" Not Perfect; "Redline," Slow Burn" Not Screened

by | April 12, 2007 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got snoops ("Disturbia," starring Shia LaBeouf), temps ("Perfect Stranger," starring Halle Berry and Bruce Willis), Mooninites ("Aqua Teen Hunger Force Colon Movie Film for Theaters"), and frauds ("The Hoax," starring Richard Gere). What do the critics have to say?

With a plot involving a bored house-arrested teenager, binoculars, and a neighbor who may be a murderer, it’s hard not to imagine "Disturbia" as "Rear Window" for the YouTube generation. Shia LaBeouf plays the James Stewart role as a kid trying to figure out whether he’s witnessing the work of a serial killer — or if it’s just his imagination. Though critics say "Disturbia" rips off Hitchcock, some still praise the film’s tense atmospherics; others call it too predictable, with the exception of one problematic twist late in the game. However, most agree that star Shia LaBeouf is evolving into an engaging screen presence. At 56 percent on the Tomatometer, keep your expectations in check and "Disturbia" may be worth a peep.

"Hey, look, it’s like YouTubing with The Rockettes."

Frankly, we’re getting a little worried about Halle Berry. Ever since she took home the Oscar for "Monster’s Ball," she hasn’t been able to steer clear of mediocre movies. The latest example: "Perfect Stranger," a twisty whodunit that is unlikely to redeem her in the eyes of the scribes. Berry stars as an investigative reporter looking into the murder of a friend; signs seem to point to a powerful, sketchy ad exec (played by Bruce Willis), so she goes undercover as a temp in his firm. There’s nothing wrong with sexy potboilers, but the critics say "Perfect Stranger" is way too convoluted and filled with lame red herrings to work. At 16 percent on the Tomatometer, you may want to avoid this "Stranger."

"Now why wouldn’t they book my flight to Mypos?"

Another month, another swords-and-decapitations-filled epic. "Pathfinder" stars Karl Urban as Ghost, an orphaned Viking boy raised by Native Americans, destined to fight off his ancestors when they come back to pillage pre-Columbus America. Despite a few rousing action sequences, critics are finding lots to take issue with in "Pathfinder" including a non-existent plot, silly dialogue, a sophomoric obsession with gory violence, and even the cinematography, which bathes everything in a washed-out blue. This "Pathfinder" is lost in the woods with a 33 percent Tomatometer.

Forget the Vikings, pneumonia’s going to kill this guy.

If you’re a fan of Adult Swim’s "Aqua Teen Hunger Force," critics say you’ll probably dig its big screen adaptation, "Aqua Teen Hunger Force Colon Movie Film for Theaters." If you’re not initiated into the world of those wacky anthropomorphic fast food items Meatwad, Frylock, and Master Shake, however, you’re likely to be left cold. Absurdist antics are the order of the day as our heroes seek out a piece of antiquated gym equipment called the Insanoflex. Long story short, critics say if you’re up for wacky non-sequiturs and are untroubled by such pesky cinematic conventions as narrative, "ATHFCMFFT" is as tasty as a Happy Meal. If not, politely ignore the film’s 68 percent Tomatometer.

This movie would’ve been better if it starred Mel Gibson. And Master Blaster.

When it comes to literary scandal, James Frey and Stephen Glass ain’t got nothing on Clifford Irving, whose phony "autobiography" of reclusive billionaire Howard Hughes was a sensation — until Hughes emerged to dispute it. Irving appeared as himself in Orson Welles’ endlessly inventive final film "F for Fake," and now Lasse Hallström has made "The Hoax," a fictional account of the affair that critics say features Richard Gere’s best performance in years. The pundits say Hallström’s direction is deft enough to make the film work as a comedy, a thriller, and an empathetic character study to boot. At 85 percent, this "Hoax" is no joke. In fact, it’s Certified Fresh.

After sunrise, but before blanket turndown service.

Add two more flicks to ever-growing list of movies hidden from critics. "Redline," starring Angus MacFadyen and Eddie Griffin, is set in the world of illegal drag racing, while "Slow Burn" stars Ray Liotta and LL Cool J in a complex murder mystery. Guess those Tomatometers, kids.

"I dare you to make fun of the pompadour."

Also opening this week in limited release: "Red Road," a tense, Hitchcockian meditation on grief, is at 88 percent; the documentary "Jack Smith and the Destruction of Atlantis," about the underground artist, is at 88 percent; "Year of the Dog," a Sundance-approved comedy about the love of man’s best friend starring Molly Shannon, is at 86 percent; the Slamdance-accepted "Rock the Bells," a doc about efforts to stage a Wu-Tang reunion, is at 86 percent; "Private Fears in Public Places," a melodrama about relationships by legendary French director Alain Resnais, is at 82 percent; "Everything’s Gone Green," the tale of a slacker written by Gen-X writer Douglas Coupland, is at 67 percent; and "Lonely Hearts," a noir starring John Travolta, Salma Hayek, and Jared Leto, is at 43 percent.

This one’s strictly for the dogs.

Recent Halle Berry Movies:
57% — X-Men: The Last Stand (2006)
62% — Robots (2005)
9% — Catwoman (2004)
87% — X2: X-Men United (2003)
15% — Gothika (2003)

Recent Richard Gere Movies:
41% — Bee Season (2005)
48% — Shall We Dance? (2004)
86% — Chicago (2002)
47% — Unfaithful (2002)
52% — The Mothman Prophecies (2002)

Tag Cloud

child's play Musicals canceled TV shows E3 Country YA festivals true crime 007 Dark Horse Comics docuseries spanish Sony Pictures 45 E! Rock comics romance mcc Spectrum Originals cats anime worst movies Black Mirror comiccon Disney Plus Shondaland adaptation zero dark thirty technology The Arrangement elevated horror NBC mockumentary golden globes CW Seed CNN heist movie Britbox a nightmare on elm street chucky Christmas wonder woman mob revenge golden globe awards cops period drama Wes Anderson 79th Golden Globes Awards Sci-Fi TV critic resources miniseries singing competition FX on Hulu new star wars movies Marathons Marvel Television kaiju festival National Geographic thriller spider-man Holiday james bond marvel cinematic universe 90s christmas movies Valentine's Day TCM Cannes witnail Ovation 20th Century Fox Fantasy Logo Image Comics Hulu Reality Tags: Comedy social media MCU Drama book adaptation MTV movies casting Kids & Family toy story Starz The Walking Dead biography feel good international quibi historical drama sequel Esquire Summer kong batman live event scary movies Travel Channel Heroines Lifetime Christmas movies Shudder genre disaster hidden camera Writers Guild of America El Rey telelvision Chernobyl Trophy Talk robots critics Academy Awards scary high school TCA 2017 deadpool award winner transformers History DC Comics The Academy all-time stoner Amazon Prime Trivia Paramount Network venice San Diego Comic-Con Rocketman See It Skip It Comedy crossover slasher mission: impossible Apple TV Plus Infographic ABC Family slashers canceled indie indiana jones Holidays Winter TV Acorn TV anthology Martial Arts Set visit 2020 TLC films psycho latino Super Bowl TNT Oscars BAFTA SundanceTV Walt Disney Pictures Creative Arts Emmys kids IFC blockbuster Calendar Podcast art house Video Games psychological thriller Exclusive Video Best and Worst Arrowverse Freeform X-Men sports 2015 Schedule New York Comic Con 2016 1990s superman HFPA comic books Anna Paquin natural history ITV Rom-Com Hear Us Out A&E OneApp TCA Awards free movies hispanic heritage month Amazon sag awards TBS olympics new zealand Cosplay children's TV Netflix Columbia Pictures BET Awards crime thriller satire Binge Guide south america Quiz WGN Star Trek cars screenings blaxploitation ID lord of the rings Fall TV USA Network Hallmark Christmas movies young adult black comedy versus Comedy Central Mary poppins posters Endgame animated CBS Black History Month USA comic book movie Certified Fresh trophy Discovery Channel Election dramedy Rocky streaming movies know your critic scene in color Paramount Apple TV+ YouTube Red live action royal family foreign Awards Tour MSNBC Film Festival Countdown President police drama basketball biopic unscripted twilight Sundance crime ratings YouTube 2018 WarnerMedia dogs Vudu name the review discovery series Premiere Dates video boxing halloween tv strong female leads Photos romantic comedy Pride Month Comic-Con@Home 2021 fresh Captain marvel Comic Book BBC Crunchyroll Lifetime Mary Tyler Moore Baby Yoda 24 frames 71st Emmy Awards DirecTV TV Land superhero cancelled TV shows PlayStation harry potter 21st Century Fox Elton John criterion Apple First Reviews pirates of the caribbean RT History classics Sundance TV HBO Max TV One sequels Mindy Kaling Fargo spy thriller what to watch Thanksgiving Pacific Islander football PBS GoT travel serial killer Red Carpet Opinion Syfy documentary Disney Channel 2019 Character Guide screen actors guild Nominations Awards based on movie Warner Bros. Nat Geo blockbusters Avengers archives Grammys Western VICE ViacomCBS Women's History Month IMDb TV Instagram Live war Fox News Polls and Games concert Pet Sematary boxoffice Box Office First Look FX jamie lee curtis Ghostbusters renewed TV shows Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt news documentaries fast and furious dc breaking bad diversity Mystery ESPN Animation Brie Larson TCA game show 99% 2021 saw 2017 best popular Film Horror FXX science fiction rotten movies we love Winners movie parents Cartoon Network dragons richard e. Grant medical drama BBC America rt labs Hollywood Foreign Press Association book HBO universal monsters talk show Emmy Nominations directors Sundance Now spider-verse cooking Superheroes Prime Video AMC Plus GLAAD PaleyFest joker composers cancelled TV series mutant binge 4/20 game of thrones Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Tokyo Olympics scorecard Music Marvel Studios cinemax stand-up comedy trailers The CW dreamworks teaser women cancelled adenture Tomatazos Turner Classic Movies Extras Spike rom-coms green book SDCC Nickelodeon rt labs critics edition action-comedy spanish language video on demand OWN emmy awards APB Sneak Peek Year in Review Neflix 72 Emmy Awards french Superheroe dark aapi ABC Signature Adult Swim Crackle comic facebook Lionsgate zombies DGA justice league Pop TV zombie razzies king kong crime drama target stop motion halloween Comics on TV Reality Competition space ghosts Star Wars Peacock A24 Universal Pictures sitcom television streaming Paramount Plus toronto dceu rt archives Alien Legendary IFC Films LGBT DC streaming service NYCC American Society of Cinematographers Lucasfilm Disney+ Disney Plus asian-american Broadway 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards obituary Pop Song of Ice and Fire cancelled television hist godzilla Tumblr japan laika debate Interview Masterpiece Funimation vs. italian Mary Poppins Returns finale die hard legend ABC Television Critics Association nbcuniversal political drama Universal The Walt Disney Company sopranos Tarantino The Purge Fox Searchlight DC Universe YouTube Premium NBA marvel comics FOX HBO Go nature Bravo new york remakes RT21 suspense BET spain docudrama werewolf worst spinoff VH1 Emmys LGBTQ Trailer TIFF vampires SXSW Turner nfl Mudbound 73rd Emmy Awards politics japanese franchise cults Family Epix aliens The Witch TV movies australia 93rd Oscars Tubi gangster theme song Food Network CMT Marvel hollywood AMC jurassic park rotten doctor who Television Academy Hallmark leaderboard Showtime Disney Disney streaming service TruTV independent VOD comedies TCA Winter 2020 black king arthur Teen Amazon Prime Video cartoon TV renewals Pixar Watching Series Stephen King Classic Film supernatural reviews tv talk Musical dexter Ellie Kemper Amazon Studios BBC One comic book movies CBS All Access monster movies GIFs prank Toys Spring TV Netflix Christmas movies hispanic Pirates Biopics reboot adventure Action