Critics Consensus

Critical Consensus: "Black Dahlia" Wilts; "Gridiron Gang" Fumbles; "Last Kiss" Just Like the First; "Everyone's Hero" Not

by | September 14, 2006 | Comments

This week at the movies, we have De Palma‘s latest thriller ("The Black Dahlia"), Zach Braff whining about growing up ("The Last Kiss"), The Rock teaching young criminals about the reformative nature of football ("Gridiron Gang"), and the late Christopher Reeve‘s brainchild ("Everyone’s Hero"). What do the critics have to say?

Everyone is dressed to kill (Hilary Swank as a femme fatale!) in Brian De Palma‘s latest thriller "The Black Dahlia," but the movie is decidedly coming up snake eyes for critics. While his movie captures the tawdry atmosphere of the ’40s, the story is so convoluted and, in retrospect, so flimsy, the phrase "looks great, less filling" comes to mind. That several of the lead characters are miscast doesn’t help, either. Critics agree De Palma has overreached in his ambitious adaptation of James Ellroy’s novel, as "The Black Dahlia" currently sits at 44% on the Tomatometer.

The makings of a love triangle. Eckhart, Johansson, and Hartnett in "Black Dahlia."

Growing up is hard to do, but do they have to make yet another movie about it? That’s what critics are asking with "The Last Kiss," the English language remake of the Italian movie "L’Ultimo Bacio." Starring Zach Braff ("Garden State"), the movie follows four buddies in their late twenties at various stages of their lives. While the dialogue is particularly strong, courtesy of Oscar winner Paul Haggis ("Crash"), the movie brings nothing particularly new to its premise that hasn’t been done before, and better, in other movies such as Barry Levinson’s "Diner." "The Last Kiss" has a Tomatometer of 45%.

"Gridiron Gang" is one of those inspirational tales about triumphing over adversity that you’ve probably seen a million times, except this one stars former wrestler The Rock as the probation officer who reforms young criminals through football. The movie is as clichéd as you might expect, and most of the critics say the sappy nature of this tale, compounded by predictability, makes "Gridiron" (39% Tomatometer rating) a fumble.

Remember the Titans! The Gridiron gang after a victory.

"Everyone’s Hero," the animated tale directed partially by the late Christopher Reeve, has its heart in the right place, but critics say this bland cartoon won’t appeal to anyone besides tiny tots. It sits at 38% on the Tomatometer.

In Guess the Tomatometer for "The Covenant" last week, ‘havoc_012’ hit the bull’s-eye with a guess of 3%.

Recent De Palma Directed Movies:
49% — Femme Fatale (2002)
24% — Mission to Mars (2002)
33% — Snake Eyes (1998)
67% — Mission:Impossible (1996)

Recent The Rock Movies:
29% — Be Cool (2005)
19% — Doom (2005)
25% — Walking Tall (2004)
69% — The Rundown (2003)

Tag Cloud

Thanksgiving Masterpiece OWN Quiz finale Pirates Lifetime Mystery El Rey Columbia Pictures USA Network Crackle aliens Women's History Month 24 frames Cartoon Network Stephen King theme song DC streaming service biography GoT 2016 Mindy Kaling RT History Lionsgate game show Fox News Black Mirror Universal festivals Reality Competition TV Land Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt green book TCA Ghostbusters Certified Fresh Freeform CMT Grammys WGN disaster SundanceTV crime drama Sci-Fi politics IFC Films Pop The Arrangement Winter TV Amazon nature anime richard e. Grant crossover adaptation true crime Ellie Kemper Rom-Com Epix harry potter Comedy Animation Premiere Dates Bravo Nickelodeon PaleyFest Amazon Prime Hulu HBO CNN The Witch Starz Rocketman Paramount Network Toys Paramount serial killer what to watch Awards Music IFC comic Valentine's Day Christmas Spike miniseries Countdown sitcom Disney TCM GLAAD TCA 2017 DirecTV Star Wars Esquire thriller historical drama Trivia composers cooking Emmys strong female leads LGBTQ adventure 20th Century Fox cults BBC 2015 Cosplay Schedule Marvel Drama Winners A&E teaser Creative Arts Emmys Adult Swim Brie Larson Comic Book Star Trek GIFs sports Food Network Calendar period drama Kids & Family Fantasy Biopics APB war spy thriller Horror Shudder mutant 2017 Super Bowl Photos Video Games MSNBC award winner Dark Horse Comics Mary poppins dramedy Oscars Sony Pictures zero dark thirty unscripted social media YouTube Red Trailer CBS 2019 Marathons Martial Arts Pixar Infographic comiccon science fiction Summer DC Universe Election Musicals Extras Set visit sequel 2018 Trophy Talk SDCC medical drama Polls and Games dragons Syfy hist facebook Ovation TBS DGA Sundance Superheroe Rocky Film Festival MCU transformers political drama ABC VH1 CBS All Access Podcast animated Netflix dceu Superheroes Pet Sematary President Britbox 21st Century Fox Warner Bros. Captain marvel blaxploitation Shondaland Best and Worst spider-man Song of Ice and Fire justice league Elton John diversity American Society of Cinematographers based on movie TruTV 007 golden globes X-Men spinoff TV Comedy Central TIFF singing competition VICE Heroines See It Skip It FX vampires YA Box Office Mary Poppins Returns toy story ABC Family natural history The CW Nominations NBC FXX cinemax Action Mudbound TNT Acorn TV First Look Anna Paquin dc doctor who Interview DC Comics Sundance Now Rock Red Carpet crime ESPN Showtime USA boxoffice Chernobyl Walt Disney Pictures Musical discovery Teen cats Character Guide romance talk show ITV Sneak Peek Watching Series Tarantino Tumblr YouTube Premium MTV casting travel police drama mockumentary zombie robots New York Comic Con San Diego Comic-Con jamie lee curtis AMC Year in Review BBC America Logo RT21 E! Cannes Writers Guild of America Western cops psycho Mary Tyler Moore Tomatazos anthology BET space supernatural NYCC E3 witnail CW Seed Nat Geo FOX Opinion Awards Tour Disney Channel zombies Apple ratings Holidays SXSW Pride Month Country 45 elevated horror Vudu crime thriller psychological thriller Fall TV Chilling Adventures of Sabrina LGBT Spectrum Originals streaming technology National Geographic docudrama History binge TLC Reality television Spring TV Comics on TV Lucasfilm PBS