Total Recall

Total Recall: Winona Ryder's Best Movies

We count down the best-reviewed work of the Dilemma star.

by | January 14, 2011 | Comments

Winona Ryder

Winona Ryder was one of the more prolific film stars of the late 1980s and early 1990s, appearing in almost 20 movies over the space of a decade and working with some of the industry’s most respected actors and directors along the way. Her pace has slowed in recent years, but with roles in Black Swan and this weekend’s The Dilemma, Winona’s pulling double duty at the box office — which, naturally, got us thinking about the many highlights of an eclectic filmography that includes teen comedies, period dramas, and plenty in between. How do your favorites stack up against the critics’? It’s time to find out!


10. Night on Earth

A series of loosely interconnected vignettes from writer/director Jim Jarmusch, 1991’s Night on Earth gave Ryder a chance to move away from teenage roles by casting her in the film’s opening segment, as a driver who develops an unexpected connection with a Hollywood executive (Gena Rowlands) while ferrying her from the airport. While Night didn’t offer Ryder as much screen time as some of her other films, it offered a glimpse at the more experimental fare she’d dabble in later (such as Richard Linklater’s A Scanner Darkly), and impressed critics like Roger Ebert, who wrote, “At the end, we have learned no great lessons and arrived at no thrilling conclusions, but we have shared the community of the night, when people are unbuttoned and vulnerable — more ready to speak about what’s really on their minds.”


9. The Crucible

With a screenplay adapted by Arthur Miller from his own play, director Nicholas Hytner (The Madness of King George) at the helm, and a cast that included Ryder, Daniel-Day Lewis, Paul Scofield, and Joan Allen, The Crucible looked like the can’t-miss art house hit of 1996. Things didn’t quite work out that way — it barely made back half of its budget — but even if it wasn’t a commercial success, the big-screen version of Miller’s allegorical account of the McCarthy witch hunts, set against the backdrop of one teenage girl’s hysterical accusation during the Salem trials, its stars earned critical praise for their work. “There’s an awful, piercing truth in the performances of Daniel Day-Lewis, Winona Ryder, Joan Allen and Paul Scofield as members of a community destroyed by guilt, paranoia and betrayal,” wrote Edward Guthmann of the San Francisco Chronicle.


8. Mermaids

It takes a special kind of screen presence to keep from being steamrolled by Cher at her scene-stealing best, and that goes double for any movie where she gets to play a “free spirit” — but even though it was Cher’s name getting first billing above the title, Winona Ryder walked away with Mermaids, adding genuine pathos to what could have been a decidedly unmemorable melodrama about the struggles of a 15-year-old girl (Ryder) to find herself in the shadow of her aggressively independent single mother (Cher). “Having made something of a specialty of woe-is-me, adolescent angst, Ryder finds a deeper level here,” observed Hal Hinson of the Washington Post, identifying it as “a level of comedy with something genuinely painful mixed in.”


7. Beetlejuice

You’ve seen a lot of movies about people hiring exorcists to get rid of ghosts. But what if ghosts could hire someone to get rid of people? That was the novel idea behind Beetlejuice, the gleefully unhinged Gothic comedy that cemented Tim Burton’s bankability, gave Ryder an early breakthrough after her supporting role in Lucas, and simply let Michael Keaton run wild as a demented “bio-exorcist” summoned by recently deceased newlyweds (Geena Davis and Alec Baldwin) to repel the family that has moved into their home. Calling it “Tim Burton’s freshest work, and perhaps the purest embodiment of his funky world view,” Rob Vaux of Flipside Movie Emporium noted, “Count the number of people whose careers were made here; that’s no fluke.”


6. The Age of Innocence

A year after scoring a leading role for Francis Ford Coppola in Dracula, Ryder went to work for another great American director — and earned an Academy Award nomination along the way — in Martin Scorsese’s The Age of Innocence. Adapted from Edith Wharton’s 1920 novel, Innocence gave Ryder the chance to hone her dramatic chops with a tremendous cast, including Daniel Day-Lewis and Michelle Pfeiffer, and gave fans of tightly corseted love stories a reason to bring their hankies to the theater. “When the movie was over,” sighed an appreciative Steve Rhodes, “I could hardly move.”


5. Bram Stoker’s Dracula

Ryder joined her fondness for period pictures with her affinity for gothic-tinged characters in Bram Stoker’s Dracula, Francis Ford Coppola’s beautifully filmed, proudly overblown take on the classic vampire legend. Surrounded by a marquee-worthy cast that included Gary Oldman, Keanu Reeves, and Anthony Hopkins, Ryder held her own; their performances helped scare up a $215 million gross that restored some of the fading lustre to Coppola’s career. “Coppola never stops putting on his own showboat performance,” wrote Rob Gonsalves of eFilmCritic, adding, “His Dracula isn’t like anything else around.”


4. Black Swan

For those of us who remember Ryder’s days as a fresh-faced ingenue who racked up teenaged roles in the 1980s and 1990s — and who was playing love-interest roles, a la her part in Mr. Deeds, in the early aughts — it came as something of a shock to see her appear as Natalie Portman’s discarded predecessor in Black Swan. (Sure, she also played Spock’s mom in the Star Trek reboot, but that was a blink-and-you-missed-it bit part.) But if she was graduating to a new generation of characters, Ryder remained as attracted to challenging, high-quality scripts as ever, and although Portman and Mila Kunis were unquestionably the stars of this Darren Aronofsky drama, Swan still gave Ryder an opportunity to be part of one of the best-reviewed films of 2010. “This is, no doubt about it, a tour de force,” wrote David Edelstein of New York Magazine, calling it “a work that fully lives up to its director’s ambitions.


3. Little Women

For many books, one film adaptation is more than enough — but not Louisa May Alcott’s Little Women, the 19th century classic that took its fifth trip before the cameras in 1994. Given the parade of Women that came first — including George Cukor’s classic take on the book — director Gillian Armstrong had her work cut out for her. Fortunately, she also had a solid screenplay by Robin Swicord (Memoirs of a Geisha), as well as a terrific cast that included Susan Sarandon, Claire Danes, Kirsten Dunst, and — as the headstrong Jo — Winona Ryder. Acknowledging prior adaptations, Janet Maslin of the New York Times wrote, “Ladies, get out your hand-hemmed handkerchiefs for the loveliest Little Women ever on screen.”


2. Edward Scissorhands

1990 was a pretty good year for Ryder — while Welcome Home, Roxy Carmichael didn’t do so well with audiences or critics, it was also the year she released Mermaids and a little flick called Edward Scissorhands. Playing to Ryder’s gift for playing soulful, doe-eyed teens with an outsider streak, Scissorhands reunited her with Beetlejuice director Tim Burton and gave her a chance to co-star with then-boyfriend Johnny Depp — and it was also a hit at the box office, as well as with scribes like Rolling Stone’s Peter Travers, who wrote, “Burton’s richly entertaining update of the Frankenstein story is the year’s most comic, romantic and haunting film fantasy.”


1. Heathers

You knew we were going to end up here. It was roundly ignored during its theatrical run, but Heathers is now regarded as one of the best teen comedies — heck, best comedies — of the 1980s. Starring Ryder as a disgruntled member of her high school’s popular clique and Christian Slater as the homicidal drifter looking for a little help purging the cool kids, Heathers gave its two young leads a burst of counter-culture cachet while impressing critics like Todd McCarthy of Variety, who called it “A super-smart black comedy about high school politics” while noting that it “showcases a host of promising young talents.” Sequels and adaptations have been rumored for years, but Heathers is just fine the way it is — here’s hoping Hollywood leaves well enough alone.

In case you were wondering, here are Ryder’s top 10 movies according RT users’ scores:

1. Night on Earth — 91%

2. Edward Scissorhands — 88%

3. Black Swan — 88%

4. Girl, Interrupted — 83%

5. Heathers — 82%

6. Bram Stoker’s Dracula — 79%

7. Little Women — 79%

8. Reality Bites — 74%

9. The Age of Innocence — 73%

10. The House of the Spirits — 73%

Take a look through Ryder’s complete filmography, as well as the rest of our Total Recall archives. And don’t forget to check out the reviews for The Dilemma.

Finally, here’s Ryder in one of her finest performances, playing Debbie Gibson:

Tag Cloud

E3 italian slashers basketball golden globe awards dreamworks Polls and Games sopranos Chernobyl Freeform laika Premiere Dates Television Critics Association GLAAD IMDb TV Western genre Action slasher classics emmy awards Apple young adult Discovery Channel obi wan cartoon remakes CBS jurassic park screenings thriller indie wonder woman HBO Max 2020 See It Skip It TCA Winter 2020 razzies Awards BBC zero dark thirty SDCC social media strong female leads scene in color film series Trailer concert ABC new zealand christmas movies Television Academy book adaptation japan Bravo adaptation E! Neflix vampires hispanic BET Awards Creative Arts Emmys critic resources Biopics game show Marvel Television video on demand The Academy Universal political drama Musicals Endgame asian-american TV renewals leaderboard comic book movie Native latino 72 Emmy Awards space supernatural Winter TV mockumentary rotten ITV disaster crime thriller Anna Paquin cancelled TV shows Nat Geo crime tv talk History Disney streaming service Classic Film OWN Superheroe live event Rock MCU halloween tv HFPA binge movie Walt Disney Pictures french scene in color series comedies renewed TV shows 2018 gangster talk show TV movies adenture MTV spinoff witnail free movies TCA 2017 transformers joker werewolf a nightmare on elm street finale deadpool Opinion Best Picture royal family nfl Fantasy olympics VICE mutant mob Broadway die hard target scene in color stoner Oscar YouTube Paramount Network james bond A&E Marathons Summer trailers doctor who ID Animation TCM Family USA green book ABC Family cats 45 First Look Tags: Comedy Women's History Month spider-man Vudu Comic-Con@Home 2021 Epix DirecTV YA comic book movies news Pacific Islander debate Warner Bros. MSNBC streaming movies TV all-time boxing TruTV National Geographic 24 frames universal monsters Heroines Marvel Studios Grammys CBS All Access GIFs 4/20 RT History Universal Pictures crime drama Ovation Marvel Comics on TV composers anime Watching Series Adult Swim TV Land popular Cartoon Network Music Rocky FOX Set visit ratings American Society of Cinematographers DC Comics comic Podcast WGN summer preview Oscars Sundance BBC One Columbia Pictures independent mission: impossible Disney Plus international Hallmark New York Comic Con 71st Emmy Awards TCA Awards canceled TV shows parents Amazon Prime BET Masterpiece nbcuniversal scene in color Turner Classic Movies Thanksgiving spain Tumblr TIFF docuseries 93rd Oscars discovery foreign prank 94th Oscars Mary poppins sitcom anthology facebook Netflix Christmas movies summer TV The Arrangement book Instagram Live PBS Character Guide GoT football 20th Century Fox Toys streamig zombies A24 Spike Mary Poppins Returns Indigenous critics Trophy Talk Fall TV Cosplay unscripted Sony Exclusive Video kids child's play Comedy Amazon Prime Video Film Festival heist movie psycho spanish language zombie X-Men scary black video CNN HBO Binge Guide ViacomCBS festival high school BBC America Box Office biography Apple TV+ richard e. Grant Lifetime Christmas movies CW Seed new york Certified Fresh new star wars movies IFC Films halloween Valentine's Day Pet Sematary worst movies TV One NBA dc VOD rotten movies we love dramedy sequel rt archives Emmys 2017 romance know your critic spider-verse ESPN PlayStation San Diego Comic-Con children's TV versus dark Teen diversity cults teaser venice kong romantic comedy toronto Best Actress Starz hispanic heritage month screen actors guild Kids & Family Shudder godzilla live action 007 79th Golden Globes Awards TBS franchise marvel comics Showtime indiana jones Amazon Studios art house nature DC Universe 99% cinemax Star Wars Celebration period drama medical drama Schedule 2021 what to watch directors Paramount Plus war Spring TV VH1 Film satire quibi blockbuster Emmy Nominations Legendary rt labs First Reviews cops Alien NYCC Amazon science fiction Sneak Peek Best and Worst theme song Mary Tyler Moore 2016 Avengers Reality Competition Funimation 1990s Photos Brie Larson 2015 DC streaming service Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt marvel cinematic universe casting Black Mirror Hollywood Foreign Press Association Lucasfilm natural history Sundance TV TLC Holidays sequels trophy Travel Channel Esquire Ellie Kemper scorecard comics LGBT WarnerMedia historical drama IFC stand-up comedy telelvision Hulu obituary police drama SundanceTV Holiday Countdown scary movies serial killer CMT Stephen King Apple TV Plus chucky spanish Paramount Pictures Horror Rocketman superhero Musical YouTube Red legend Acorn TV Britbox USA Network Song of Ice and Fire Disney travel 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards ABC Signature best king kong The Walt Disney Company Sci-Fi Tomatazos documentaries Reality TCA Sundance Now Syfy robots Food Network true crime Quiz worst Elton John aliens Christmas Election Mudbound Comedy Central Rom-Com Tokyo Olympics Fox News Crunchyroll boxoffice jamie lee curtis cancelled suspense Paramount movies psychological thriller SXSW south america elevated horror Focus Features Tarantino HBO Go harry potter Red Carpet Mindy Kaling stop motion Writers Guild of America AMC cars APB Tubi Ghostbusters Nickelodeon MGM Superheroes australia Fargo crossover fast and furious rt labs critics edition spy thriller Logo blockbusters 2019 cancelled TV series Country Netflix sports Image Comics comiccon Best Actor SXSW 2022 technology The Walking Dead toy story target Pop fresh Baby Yoda Chilling Adventures of Sabrina AMC Plus based on movie Trivia animated vs. Winners FX on Hulu Disney+ Disney Plus Geeked Week television award winner Pixar FX streaming LGBTQ lord of the rings Martial Arts Best Director kaiju miniseries dceu YouTube Premium broadcast Turner blaxploitation films Drama Lifetime twilight politics 73rd Emmy Awards Super Bowl archives Disney Channel posters adventure ghosts black comedy cancelled television RT21 saw canceled OneApp cooking El Rey batman Captain marvel rom-coms South by Southwest Film Festival breaking bad The CW interviews revenge criterion Black History Month documentary monster movies reviews Lionsgate mcc dexter 21st Century Fox superman feel good king arthur Hear Us Out justice league Star Wars Interview Crackle Video Games dogs dragons Academy Awards Wes Anderson Infographic series golden globes Pirates singing competition pirates of the caribbean women comic books DGA biopic 90s summer TV preview TNT Spectrum Originals PaleyFest Peacock Year in Review Star Trek FXX BAFTA action-comedy hist Calendar The Witch hollywood Comic Book NBC Awards Tour sag awards Extras Pop TV reboot japanese The Purge game of thrones Arrowverse Fox Searchlight Mystery name the review hidden camera Cannes docudrama Sony Pictures Shondaland festivals Nominations President aapi Dark Horse Comics Hallmark Christmas movies Prime Video Pride Month