Critics Consensus

Sully Is Certified Fresh

Plus, The Wild Life is adrift on an island of mediocrity, and Atlanta and Better Things are also Certified Fresh.

by | September 8, 2016 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a heroic pilot (Sully, starring Tom Hanks and Laura Linney), a famed castaway (The Wild Life, with voice performances by David Howard and Yuri Lowenthal), a sinister surrogate (When the Bough Breaks, starring Morris Chestnut and Regina Hall), and a ghost-infested domicile (The Disappointments Room, starring Kate Beckinsale and Michael Landes). What do the critics have to say?


Sully (2016) 85%

Tom Hanks excels at playing decent fellows, and Clint Eastwood has more than proven his ability to make compelling cinema out of stories about simple guys rising to difficult situations. All of which is to say that on paper, this weekend’s Sully — about the heroic efforts of real-life US Airways pilot Chesley “Sully” Sullenberger to save a plane full of people by landing his crippled craft in the Hudson River — looks like a complete slam dunk. Critics say the end result more or less lives up to those lofty expectations, although not quite to the extent its pedigree might suggest; instead, reviews describe a straightforward drama that runs more toward the “solidly entertaining” end of the spectrum than the ranks of surefire Oscar contenders. If Eastwood and Hanks have both made better movies, that certainly isn’t to say Sully doesn’t soar often enough in its own right — or that it isn’t well worth a trip to your local cineplex.


The Wild Life (2016) 17%

The story of Robinson Crusoe has been adapted for film plenty of times, and given unusual twists ranging from telling the tale with a female castaway (1954’s Miss Robin Crusoe) to transplanting the action to Mars (1964’s Robinson Crusoe on Mars). Now, that long list yet adds yet another entry with The Wild Life, a 3D animated effort offering the classic story from the perspective of the animals living on the island where Crusoe shipwrecks. It isn’t a terrible idea, but critics say this is one case where far too much has been lost in translation; overbearing and unfunny, the end result has little to offer any filmgoer who isn’t a very young child or a parent desperate for a 90-minute reprieve. If you find yourself outside either of those demographics this weekend, feel free to find other viewing options.


When the Bough Breaks (2016) 13%

Domestic interlopers have been used as the catalyst for cinematic thrills on numerous occasions, and this weekend’s When the Bough Breaks — starring Morris Chestnut and Regina Hall as a couple whose bliss is threatened by an unbalanced surrogate played by Jaz Sinclair — might deliver its share. Unfortunately, it wasn’t screened for critics, so we have no way of knowing yet… and you know what that means: it’s time for you to guess the Tomatometer!


The Disappointments Room (2016) 0%

Also arriving without the benefit of early reviews is The Disappointments Room, a thriller from Eagle Eye and Disturbia director D.J. Caruso. Starring Kate Beckinsale and Mel Raido as a couple whose new home comes with a secret (and potentially lethal) room, it could give us the first terrifying haunted house of the fall film season — or it could be a rickety dud. Which will it be? Guess that Tomatometer!


What’s Hot on TV

Atlanta: Season 1 (2016) 97%

Atlanta offers a unique vehicle for star and series creator Donald Glover‘s eccentric brand of humor — as well as a number of timely, trenchant observations.


Better Things: Season 1 (2016) 95%

Pamela Aldon‘s Better Things abstains from traditional sitcom sendups and forges a path all its own – in this bawdy, often hilarious and bittersweet ode to the daily highs and lows of being a single mother.


Queen Sugar: Season 1 (2016) 93%

With an authenticity of culture and place and strong performances throughout, Queen Sugar rises above melodrama in this alluring, unhurried and powerful portrait of a fractious black American family.


One Mississippi: Season 1 (2015) 93%

One Mississippi proves an honest vehicle for its moving dramatic narrative, observational comedy, and the genuine acting skills of its lead, Tig Notaro.


Also Opening This Week In Limited Release

  • Cameraperson (2016) , a documentary honoring the career of cinematographer Kristen Johnson, is at 100 percent.
  • One More Time With Feeling (2016) , a behind-the-scenes look at the making of Nick Cave‘s tragedy-fueled new album, is at 100 percent.
  • As I Open My Eyes (À peine j'ouvre les yeux) (2016) , about the Arab Spring’s impact on one Tunisian family, is at 100 percent.
  • Demon (2016) , about a Polish wedding threatened by supernatural events, is at 90 percent.
  • Author: The JT LeRoy Story (2016) , a documentary about an infamous literary hoax, is at 89 percent.
  • Other People (2016) , starring Molly Shannon and Jesse Plemons in a seriocomic look at the illness-mandated reunion between a mother and son, is at 86 percent.
  • Kicks (2016) , about a teen’s quest to retrieve his stolen sneakers from a local delinquent, is at 79 percent.
  • London Road (2016) , offering a unique documentary/musical approach to the true story of a rash of U.K. murders, is at 74 percent.
  • First-time director Meg Ryan‘s Ithaca (2016) , which traces the aftermath of a young man’s decision to fight in World War II, is at nine percent.

Tag Cloud

Star Trek Musical Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt werewolf Cosplay Rocky movie kids series X-Men Mary Poppins Returns comic Star Wars versus disaster New York Comic Con Rom-Com Mary Tyler Moore halloween Sundance Now romance Spike HBO Max period drama Shondaland ITV psycho 24 frames renewed TV shows Year in Review comiccon TCA Marvel Studios The CW Lionsgate 2019 directors cops ratings sag awards Pop Binge Guide game show Animation hist First Reviews space blockbuster Winners Oscars Discovery Channel diversity OWN SundanceTV spider-man Mystery Sony Pictures Polls and Games independent dogs Heroines Academy Awards President sports APB robots Lifetime Christmas movies Writers Guild of America Disney Channel Chernobyl El Rey Country NBC IFC Infographic 2018 YA Holiday finale hispanic CMT PBS Adult Swim medical drama Election docudrama Black Mirror cults Extras crime drama Marvel USA Apple TV+ The Walking Dead reboot Comic Book Kids & Family CBS Box Office Arrowverse Tomatazos MCU book politics Disney+ Disney Plus ESPN Nominations cancelled science fiction YouTube Red slashers MTV cats Columbia Pictures cancelled television National Geographic VICE Ellie Kemper Hallmark Christmas movies Sneak Peek Shudder name the review Tarantino spanish language Amazon Prime TNT Rocketman singing competition Brie Larson Cannes Reality Competition Character Guide Calendar Walt Disney Pictures television First Look ghosts CBS All Access political drama dragons 2017 Trailer Dark Horse Comics RT21 Awards Tour what to watch biography Disney streaming service sequel Emmys Crackle adaptation Marathons Interview A24 dc WGN joker Sci-Fi Anna Paquin social media History Premiere Dates boxoffice 45 TCA Winter 2020 NYCC quibi war mockumentary Epix Video Games Masterpiece toy story The Witch spinoff harry potter TV Land Superheroe zero dark thirty talk show Action AMC miniseries Classic Film elevated horror Winter TV video historical drama Pirates Lifetime natural history latino transformers The Purge Starz BBC OneApp YouTube Premium Pride Month jamie lee curtis supernatural Best and Worst tv talk Emmy Nominations Trophy Talk anime cartoon witnail Horror crossover strong female leads E! MSNBC WarnerMedia Tubi movies serial killer Acorn TV Song of Ice and Fire Universal GLAAD spain Apple TV Plus Awards Mary poppins casting Pixar HBO facebook zombie cancelled TV series free movies indie Turner Classic Movies Cartoon Network Crunchyroll Showtime Family Logo GIFs Britbox award winner Super Bowl FXX Western blaxploitation VH1 foreign SDCC Tumblr Amazon Prime Video dceu Drama canceled mutant TV zombies rotten movies we love Nickelodeon cars TLC Syfy Fall TV See It Skip It Hulu Reality Disney DirecTV Podcast Red Carpet sitcom Avengers The Arrangement Mindy Kaling BET Creative Arts Emmys Esquire unscripted dramedy Freeform Teen Schedule screen actors guild teaser CNN Captain marvel discovery 20th Century Fox Trivia binge comics revenge Certified Fresh game of thrones Turner vampires Hallmark E3 children's TV Marvel Television thriller ABC spy thriller Elton John anthology doctor who Christmas crime thriller Food Network RT History Summer LGBTQ Film Festival TruTV Bravo Fantasy Countdown composers Baby Yoda Spring TV YouTube justice league technology Toys Ovation Women's History Month screenings DC Comics stand-up comedy Amazon Studios Stephen King American Society of Cinematographers Set visit Lucasfilm canceled TV shows USA Network 71st Emmy Awards christmas movies Holidays cancelled TV shows TBS police drama breaking bad based on movie Music Rock SXSW DGA Nat Geo south america TCA 2017 Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Superheroes Endgame theme song Peacock cooking Ghostbusters TCM travel Fox News IFC Films Comics on TV psychological thriller Paramount Netflix FOX Television Academy Grammys Apple 2020 Netflix Christmas movies Warner Bros. Pet Sematary batman Musicals DC Universe adventure TIFF DC streaming service romantic comedy aliens cinemax GoT LGBT Comedy Amazon ABC Family 2016 green book Biopics TV renewals CW Seed Watching Series nature festivals Paramount Network true crime Spectrum Originals Photos Comedy Central 21st Century Fox Valentine's Day BBC America Sundance A&E Mudbound PaleyFest Sundance TV Vudu 2015 Disney Plus richard e. Grant 007 animated Film Thanksgiving golden globes FX Opinion streaming Martial Arts Quiz San Diego Comic-Con documentary crime