RT Interview: Gus van Sant and Dustin Lance Black on Milk

The director and writer tell RT about the journey to screen for the biopic.

by | January 22, 2009 | Comments

Gus van Sant and Dustin Lance Black - J. McCarthy/WireImage.com

Gus Van Sant and Dustin Lance Black look rather exhausted at this stage in their publicity whirlwind for Milk. The day RT sits down with them, the film has just received four BAFTA nominations, including one for Lance’s original script. The jetlag seems to be getting to them, but they perk up when they start talking about Harvey Milk and their very different journeys into this project.

Milk is an interesting companion piece to Rob Epstein‘s Oscar-winning documentary The Times of Harvey Milk, which is credited as a key reference.

Dustin Lance Black: It was an inspiration because of a speech that’s in it, and I heard that when I was in college. I’m from San Antonio, Texas, and Harvey says, “There’s a kid out there in San Antonio who’s going to hear my story and it’s going to give him hope.” And it’s true – it really did do that. I’d heard of Harvey about six years before that, from a theatre director who told me his story, and it was a revelation to me that there was such a thing as an out gay man, much less one who was elected to public office and celebrated. You don’t have that in Texas!

But it’s tough to do a comparison between the films. The thing I wanted to do in the script was get much more personal. The documentary doesn’t have most of the stories that I was drawn to. It doesn’t have Cleve Jones’ story, which is a father-son story, which I related to the most. And it doesn’t have Scott Smith and Harvey’s story. It doesn’t have Jack Lira. It doesn’t have any of the actual love stories. But it has the political framework, which is great. And the most transformative time in Harvey’s life was that political time, so obviously both Rob Epstein and I were drawn to that. I just thought it was an opportunity to get more into the personal stories – of what it was to be gay in that transformative time. In narrative I can take liberties and create that; in documentary maybe there wasn’t the material there to dive into those stories. To me it felt like there was more to be told.


How did you get in contact with the people from Harvey’s life?

DLB: It was a challenge. It was unfinanced, and there was no movie or book to base it on, because I didn’t have the rights to anything. But also it was a great opportunity, because I was forced to make those drives to San Francisco to meet all the real people. It started with Cleve Jones in 2004, because a friend introduced me to him and he started telling me the stories. He’s very candid, so he didn’t tell me the stories that would lionise Harvey or make him into a saint, but stories of a failed businessman who really messed up his relationships. And that humanised him in the kind of way that said to me, “Hey you can make a movie out of this!” Because if it’s just pure hagiography, who cares? You want to know that a real human being who’s kind of like you could achieve these things.

Next were Danny Nicoletta and Anne Kronenberg – meeting all of his allies – and then I moved on to meeting his political foes. It was difficult at first because these people had been told that a movie was going to be made for two decades, but it never happened. They’ve been sharing these stories, but they aren’t easy stories. It’s entertaining, beautiful and moving for us, but for them it’s incredibly painful. So once that dam broke and they did trust me enough to share, then a lot of people came out of the woodwork. I was just trying to build a history and get a sense of a man who I could never meet – and you can get that by talking to the people who he shaped, because they were so young back then.


Gus, you’ve been living with this project for quite a lot longer.

Gus van Sant: Well, I was involved in the other project, which was in 1992. Oliver Stone had attached himself to a project that producers Neil Meron and Craig Zaden had begun with Randy Shilts’ book The Mayor of Castro Street. It’s a pretty grand book – it’s a grand story and there’s a cast of lots of characters, with tens of thousands of people marching in the streets. It’s the birth of the “out” part of gay history, and at the centre is Harvey becoming a more out person, and his rallying cry to come out. And then Oliver joined on and it was like the jackpot: Oliver Stone, major Academy Award-winning films from Platoon to Wall Street. JFK was about to come out, and he was developing this script – it was edgy and hard-hitting and it was backed by $40 million from Warner Bros. And Robin Williams was going to play the role.

Then when JFK came out, Oliver decided he wasn’t going to do it. I don’t know what his other projects were – he might have had 10 other things in development at Ixtlan, his production company. So the studio was in an awkward place because they’d had one of the biggest guys. They did go to Ron Howard, because he told me, and Coppola, Spielberg – well, I would have if I was them. Then one day I was meeting with Rob Epstein socially – we’d met on the festival circuit in ’84 – and he told me Oliver had just dropped out of the film. I didn’t know there was a film – I didn’t even know there was a book! I’d seen Rob’s film about Harvey, and he was saying, “Oliver dropped out and they’re looking for a director – you should do it!” And when I told Warner Bros I might be interested in being considered, I was all of a sudden pushed in.

GVS: Oliver was a big supporter of my work, and I think that what was going on was that Oliver was looking at me as a compatriot, someone he respected as a director, whereas at Warner Bros, the executives and the producers, were looking at my demographic. I’d made Drugstore Cowboy, which made $5 million, and My Own Private Idaho, which made $15 million, which was pretty good, but I was a low-budget filmmaker. I hadn’t made a big-budget film, and in Hollywood there’s a sort of man and boys situation. You’re a man, you make $80 million movies! As if it’s harder to make an $80 million movie. Well, I guess businesswise it is because you have more executives to argue with.

DLB: Well, the meals are better!

GVS: Yeah! But making a $3 million film is a different business. So I lasted about one draft. I didn’t really have the support, not for any real reason, but my ideas were like, “This doesn’t look like a gay movie because they don’t look gay, they don’t kiss, nothing happens to signify that they are gay.” And I was met with, “You don’t understand why this is an important thing.” They just wanted me to do Oliver’s script, which was really asking the question: why did Dan White shoot these guys? That was really the theme. Harvey was the guy he shot, and he happened to be from the Castro, but Harvey wasn’t the central character – it was about the overall begging question, which is a big begging question. So that’s where I was.


Are the studio – and the public – more ready for a film like this now, with its more emotional approach?

GVS: Yeah I think there’s a lot of that. The media has gone through lots of things that make it a less foreign thing to have your lead character be gay. I think Ellen helped changed that.

DLB: I think society has opened, but we’re now in a post-Aids, gay rights era. We’re talking about rights again instead of survival. And so that’s starting to sound more like Harvey’s era. So it feels like it’s a part of the dialog of today. And in that way I think the public is ready to discuss this again.

How did you feel about the parallels between Prop 8 last November and 1978’s Prop 6?

GVS: There was no indication that was going to happen, at least not while we were shooting. And also, Barack Obama wasn’t the candidate, and Sarah Palin didn’t exist. All this stuff happened during our editing period: the world began to resemble some things in our movie. Obama, because he used the word “hope” so much, started to resemble Harvey and especially his hope speech. And Sarah Palin because she just looked like Anita Bryant.

DLB: And sounded like her! But there were clues when I started writing. Because it was 2004, so you had the re-election campaign of George W Bush and the Karl Rove strategy with the language of it sounding so much like Anita Bryant and the “save our children” campaign, bolstering their base through fuelling this fight between evangelicals and the gay community. We started hearing the same lines that I was looking at in my research!


You’re working together on a film of Tom Wolf’s 1968 book about Ken Kesey and the Merry Pranksters, The Electric Kool-Aid Acid Test. This subject is also getting the doc approach, and I know you’ve been in contact with Alex Gibney about his project.

GVS: He’s a lot further ahead with his film than we are. He’s incredible, and his filmmaking’s incredible. But Lance is writing our script, and I haven’t seen it.

DLB: Yeah, I’ve got to go now – I’ve got to get back to work! I have a draft, I just haven’t had a chance to work on it in like two weeks.

Have you taken the same approach as with Milk, interviewing the real people?

DLB: Yeah. You have to kind of act like there’s not a book, at least for a bit, and just discover the story yourself. But the book is wonderful, a great thing to guide you. When we finally get done with these press interviews for Milk, hopefully I can find two hours to read it head-to-toe with no break – to read it like it’s the movie. It’s that far along, but then we’ll see what Gus says.

Milk opens in UK on Friday and in Australia on 29th January. It’s out now in the US. Also on RT: Milk star James Franco chooses his five favourite films.

Tag Cloud

royal family adventure Summer Pop TV Columbia Pictures Discovery Channel richard e. Grant Universal Ghostbusters 21st Century Fox international Premiere Dates strong female leads Vudu theme song A&E MCU Set visit Black History Month Mary Tyler Moore RT21 WarnerMedia crime game show nbcuniversal Animation Spectrum Originals mockumentary Comic Book scorecard politics canceled Lionsgate President screen actors guild TLC green book dramedy slashers TNT Disney Plus BBC Tomatazos teaser spanish Stephen King movies spider-verse CW Seed a nightmare on elm street new zealand 90s batman remakes golden globes DC streaming service First Look rt labs critics edition casting BET Awards SundanceTV crime thriller GLAAD movie deadpool Shudder Cosplay Countdown Amazon VH1 OneApp toronto Rocketman heist movie Apple TV+ ghosts children's TV Syfy comic romance The Arrangement streaming Television Critics Association CBS All Access christmas movies cars FOX AMC Plus facebook TV Land Quiz hispanic renewed TV shows Holidays dark vs. streaming movies disaster Comics on TV Showtime new star wars movies Musical films kaiju Emmys The Purge HBO Go zombies HBO Max Britbox GoT Universal Pictures Amazon Prime Video sag awards nfl natural history Mindy Kaling Christmas indiana jones BBC America sequels Image Comics Apple TV Plus comics political drama 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards jurassic park travel TCA Awards mob dexter critic resources Pacific Islander women Broadway BET posters police drama indie based on movie monster movies kids NYCC football TCA 2017 Arrowverse screenings news Rock Sneak Peek Women's History Month Pride Month Election docuseries 20th Century Fox El Rey GIFs Mystery free movies japan biography cancelled Film Infographic black comedy Captain marvel ABC Family Martial Arts boxoffice young adult 2018 DGA italian Food Network joker Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Drama Reality Competition Avengers YouTube Premium Pop Hulu The Walking Dead spy thriller Hallmark crossover spain science fiction Legendary 99% Western cults Lucasfilm Sundance Now Musicals Logo Disney all-time Comic-Con@Home 2021 Mudbound Starz The Academy Television Academy APB Tubi 24 frames crime drama child's play Sci-Fi social media best PaleyFest action-comedy dogs FX on Hulu Endgame Year in Review National Geographic supernatural ViacomCBS Netflix Christmas movies thriller Toys tv talk PBS feel good YouTube vampires miniseries 71st Emmy Awards Nat Geo Reality festival Emmy Nominations Walt Disney Pictures Disney Channel superhero sitcom YA Interview canceled TV shows worst dc scene in color Paramount Network New York Comic Con Cannes TCA documentaries FXX chucky Alien Grammys adaptation BBC One laika hidden camera serial killer game of thrones black Nickelodeon mutant Marvel Studios medical drama universal monsters Warner Bros. Best and Worst spanish language blockbuster asian-american Superheroes nature Wes Anderson historical drama venice Crunchyroll series what to watch diversity LGBT Epix Hear Us Out documentary Teen Extras finale Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Spring TV Exclusive Video unscripted ABC Signature spinoff space Fox Searchlight scary movies harry potter ABC Winners criterion 2016 Oscars trailers Creative Arts Emmys dragons transformers Schedule psychological thriller Horror 2021 First Reviews Certified Fresh reviews BAFTA slasher DC Comics Turner Classic Movies Neflix 1990s Disney+ Disney Plus new york USA Network Ovation fresh award winner 45 versus 72 Emmy Awards australia TV LGBTQ Sony Pictures directors singing competition Holiday biopic halloween tv cancelled TV shows Video Games rom-coms PlayStation cancelled television 007 blaxploitation high school Valentine's Day Adult Swim Turner latino blockbusters Mary Poppins Returns Watching Series 2019 AMC Paramount Plus franchise mission: impossible Amazon Studios comic books aliens TBS stop motion hist revenge TCM witnail 2017 Elton John Binge Guide Acorn TV archives Netflix Red Carpet jamie lee curtis docudrama Polls and Games Tarantino Lifetime Christmas movies Travel Channel Opinion CNN Marvel Television war VICE period drama History A24 MSNBC IFC Masterpiece Heroines live action rotten movies we love TV movies Awards Black Mirror The Walt Disney Company MTV Trailer discovery Brie Larson worst movies TruTV 4/20 Trophy Talk robots kong saw Awards Tour book adaptation CBS Star Wars marvel cinematic universe 93rd Oscars superman San Diego Comic-Con Instagram Live USA concert popular gangster TV renewals adenture breaking bad justice league lord of the rings aapi composers james bond Freeform marvel comics basketball Baby Yoda dceu satire Crackle Country die hard twilight Marvel Biopics know your critic sequel Pet Sematary SDCC Dark Horse Comics true crime olympics south america japanese zombie anthology TV One comiccon NBA Disney streaming service cinemax SXSW fast and furious video on demand quibi Paramount Fantasy Calendar Tokyo Olympics American Society of Cinematographers Anna Paquin independent cops Podcast ID Apple animated hollywood elevated horror parents Tumblr king kong godzilla talk show Pirates psycho technology Pixar DC Universe Peacock Marathons golden globe awards Chernobyl 2020 cartoon HBO obituary YouTube Red boxing Kids & Family IMDb TV Rom-Com target Lifetime Thanksgiving ESPN romantic comedy critics dreamworks stand-up comedy Superheroe rotten Nominations Hallmark Christmas movies telelvision OWN cancelled TV series Shondaland video 73rd Emmy Awards pirates of the caribbean king arthur prank Star Trek Cartoon Network Box Office Fall TV E! book CMT NBC Character Guide TCA Winter 2020 Photos Ellie Kemper Super Bowl VOD art house genre binge debate zero dark thirty ratings Esquire Song of Ice and Fire Music Trivia cats E3 razzies werewolf See It Skip It stoner toy story WGN suspense Film Festival rt archives Family halloween Classic Film festivals hispanic heritage month mcc Action emmy awards foreign Fox News Mary poppins comic book movies sports Writers Guild of America scary doctor who X-Men Spike Bravo Comedy reboot Academy Awards The Witch name the review comedies ITV Rocky live event IFC Films The CW Winter TV television RT History legend Comedy Central 2015 anime classics comic book movie french DirecTV cooking Funimation sopranos Sundance TV Amazon Prime TIFF Sundance rt labs spider-man wonder woman FX