RT Editors Predict the Academy Award Winners

Find our picks for every category at this year's Oscars!

by | March 5, 2010 | Comments


Oscar Poll

Is there anyone on the planet that doesn’t claim to know who will win big on Oscar night? Still, despite the clutter of prediction and prognostication, we at RT got together to gather up our collective two cents. After five arduous hours of shouting, bitter recriminations, and a near-fatal knife fight that could only be settled by hugging it out over a bowl of Lucky Charms, we settled on our picks. If you don’t like ’em, don’t get mad – tell us what you think! Cast a ballot with your picks, or print our snazzy Oscar ballot out to follow along on Oscar Night.

In addition, you can watch the Oscars with RT on the big night! Our Editor-in-Chief Matt Atchity will be tweeting live from the Oscar ceremony, so don’t forget to follow us on Twitter. Plus, check out our Awards Tour page, where you’ll be able to use your Facebook account to discuss the proceedings with RT editors and other RTers. Immediately following the show, we’ll be updating our Best of the Best Pictures feature in order to place the winner in its rightful historical context.

Without further ado, here are our predictions for the 2010 Academy Awards!


Best Picture

Although Oscar watchers say The Hurt Locker and Avatar are neck-and-neck for Best Picture, we’ll give the nod to Kathryn Bigelow’s tense Iraq war drama for a number of reasons. Chiefly, though Avatar‘s technical wizardry is not in question, a number of folks have been less than enamored with its plot and dialogue; contrast that with the near-universal critical praise for The Hurt Locker. Secondly, James Cameron didn’t enamor himself to many with his “king of the world” speech when he won for Titanic in 1997. And it’s noteworthy that the biggest voting bloc in the Academy is comprised of actors, those sensitive souls that may feel vaguely threatened by the technical advancements of Avatar. In addition, the decision to expand the number of nominees from five to 10 this year seems to effectively limit the possibility of any dark horse candidates swooping in for the victory. Given all those factors, we think The Hurt Locker will pull out the win on Sunday night.


Avatar


Avatar

82%


An Education


An Education

94%


The Hurt Locker


The Hurt Locker

98%


Inglourious Basterds


Inglourious Basterds

88%


The Blind Side


The Blind Side

70%


District 9


District 9

90%


Precious


Precious

91%


A Serious Man


A Serious Man

87%


Up


Up

98%


Up in the Air


Up in the Air

90%


Achievement in Directing

In the history of the Academy Awards, only four women have ever been nominated for Best Director: Lina Wertmuller (Seven Beauties, 1976), Jane Campion (The Piano, 1993), and Sofia Coppola (Lost in Translation, 2003), and now Bigelow. It seems probable to us that Academy voters, aware of the opportunity to make history, will give the award to Bigelow, who’d be worthy of the honor regardless of gender.


Avatar


Avatar
(James Cameron)


82%


The Hurt Locker


The Hurt Locker
(Kathryn Bigelow)


98%


Inglourious Basterds


Inglourious Basterds
(Quentin Tarantino)


88%


Up In The Air


Up In The Air
(Jason Reitman)


90%


Precious


Precious
(Lee Daniels)


91%


Performance by an Actor in a Leading Role

Way out west there was this fella… fella I wanna tell ya about. Fella by the name of Jeff Bridges. There was a lot about Bridges that didn’t make a whole lot of sense — most notably, the fact that he’d been nominated for four Oscars and never won a single one. Sometimes there’s a man… I won’t say a hero, ’cause, what’s a hero? But sometimes, there’s a man. And I’m talkin’ about Jeff Bridges here. Sometimes, there’s a man, well, he’s the man for his time and place — and given his remarkable body of work, including a great performance in Crazy Heart — Jeff Bridges will get his moment in the sun this year. The Dude will abide.

Jeff Bridges

Jeff Bridges


Crazy Heart

94%

George Clooney


George Clooney


Up in the Air

90%

Colin Firth

Colin Firth


A Single Man

83%

Morgan Freeman


Morgan Freeman


Invictus

77%

Jeremy Renner

Jeremy Renner


The Hurt Locker

98%


Performance by an Actress in a Leading Role

Remember in 1997 when Karl Malone won the NBA MVP award mostly because people were tired of voting for Michael Jordan? We see a similar situation this year — even though Meryl Streep won nearly universal praise for her performance in Julia & Julia, we see Sandra Bullock taking home the Oscar — she’s an audience favorite who tweaked her onscreen persona in a box office hit, which should be enough to put her over the top.

Sandra Bullock


Sandra Bullock


The Blind Side

70%

Helen Mirren

Helen Mirren


The Last Station

64%

Carey Mulligan


Carey Mulligan


An Education

94%

Gabourey Sidibe


Gabourey Sidibe


Precious

91%

Meryl Streep

Meryl Streep


Julie & Julia

75%

Performance by an Actor in a Supporting Role

In Inglourious Basterds, Waltz took gleeful malevolence to new heights, relishing every syllable of sinister dialogue Tarantino provided him. It’s a delicious performance – one of the most villainous in recent memory – and Waltz’s coronation in this category seems like a foregone conclusion.

Matt Damon

Matt Damon


Invictus

77%

Woody Harrelson

Woody Harrelson


The Messenger

90%

Christopher Plummer

Christopher Plummer


The Last Station

64%

Stanley Tucci


Stanley Tucci


The Lovely Bones

40%

Christoph Waltz


Christoph Waltz


Inglourious Basterds

88%


Performance by an Actress in a Supporting Role

The Academy loves a dramatic makeover, and Mo’Nique certainly fits the bill. In Precious, playing one of the worst movie moms since Joan Crawford in Mommie Dearest, the funnywoman-cum-talk show hostess has been showered with honors this awards season, and we think she’s a lock for the Oscar.

Penelope Cruz

Penelope Cruz


Nine

37%

Vera Farmiga

Vera Farmiga


Up in the Air

90%

Anna Kendrick


Anna Kendrick


Up in the Air

90%

Mo’Nique


Mo'Nique


Precious

91%


Maggie Gyllenhaal


Maggie Gyllenhaal


Crazy Heart

92%


Best Original Screenplay

Even if the trend has been bucked in the last couple years, the writing categories tend to be where the Academy throws a bone to the innovative left-of-center oddities and highbrow fare that voters don’t feel comfortable enough to honor with the Best Picture Oscar (notable examples include Citizen Kane in 1941, Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind in 2004, and Juno in 2007). Quentin Tarantino should be familiar with the drill by now; Pulp Fiction may have influenced a generation of indie types, but its lone Oscar was for its script. We think QT will take his second Oscar this year, as Basterds is too inventive to ignore, and too wild not to take the top prize.


The Messenger


The Messenger


90%


The Hurt Locker


The Hurt Locker


98%


Inglourious Basterds


Inglourious Basterds


88%


Up


Up

98%


A Serious Man


A Serious Man


87%


Best Adapted Screenplay

What happened to Up in the Air? Upon its release in December, awards prognosticators deemed a favorite to win Best Picture and at least several acting awards. Its Oscar stock may have dropped precipitously since then, but we think the Academy will still recognize Up in the Air for its smart, literate script.


District 9


District 9


90%


An Education


An Education


95%


In the Loop


In the Loop


93%


Precious


Precious

91%


Up in the Air


Up in the Air


90%

Animated Feature Film

Didn’t the Academy already tip its hand in this category? By nominating Up for Best Picture — and none of the other nominees in the running for Best Animated Feature — doesn’t it logically follow that it’s the best of the bunch? Even though some voters may have Pixar fatigue, it seems unlikely that anything could top Up, which already took home the Golden Globe for animation.


Coraline


Coraline


94%


Fantastic Mr. Fox


Fantastic Mr. Fox


92%


The Princess and the Frog


The Princess and the Frog


83%


Secret of Kells


Secret of Kells

100%


Up


Up


98%


Achievement in Art Direction

Avatar looks pretty.


Avatar


Avatar

82%


The Imaginarium of Dr. Parnassus


The Imaginarium of Dr. Parnassus

66%


Nine


Nine

37%


Sherlock Holmes


Sherlock Holmes

69%


The Young Victoria


The Young Victoria

75%


Achievement in Cinematography

When your movie captures a dreamscape as potent and vivid as Pandora, you’re probably getting an award.


Avatar


Avatar

82%


The Hurt Locker


The Hurt Locker

98%


Inglourious Basterds


Inglourious Basterds

88%


Harry Potter and the Half Blood Prince


Harry Potter and the Half Blood Prince

83%


The White Ribbon


The White Ribbon

83%


Achievement in Costume Design

When in doubt, go with the period piece. When three period pieces are involved, go with the one that seemed to get the most praise for its look.


Bright Star


Bright Star

83%


Coco Before Chanel


Coco Before Chanel

64%


Nine


Nine

37%


The Imaginarium of Doctor Parnassus


The Imaginarium of Doctor Parnassus

66%


The Young Victoria


The Young Victoria

75%


Achievement in Film Editing

Our usual inclination in this category is to select the movie with the most noticeable cuts – the movie with the flashiest display of the editor’s craft. With that in mind, we’re going with Inglourious, since it maintains a palpable, unnerving level of tension while utilizing virtually every visual idea in Tarantino’s arsenal.


Avatar


Avatar

82%


The Hurt Locker


The Hurt Locker

98%


Inglourious Basterds


Inglourious Basterds

88%


District 9


District 9

90%


Precious


Precious

91%


Original Song

A movie about a down-on-his-luck country singer had better have a killer soundtrack. Fortunately Crazy Heart‘s collection of tracks mixes twangy classics and rock-solid originals – especially Ryan Bingham’s gritty, tear-stained The Weary Kind.


Princess and the Frog


“Almost There”

83%


Princess and the Frog


“Down in New Orleans”

83%


Paris 36


“Loin de Pename”

59%


Nine


“Take it All”

37%


Crazy Heart


“The Weary Kind”

92%



Original Score

With the exception of Buck Sanders, who’s co-nominated with Marco Beltrami, everyone up for the Best Original Score has been previously nominated at least twice. We think Michael Giacchino is going to win, not least because of the fact that the part of Up that’s always mentioned is that wordless montage at the beginning – those heart-wrenching three minutes that tell the tale of Carl’s marriage, punctuated by Giacchino’s poignant, three-hanky music.


Avatar


James Horner

82%


Fantastic Mr. Fox


Alexandre Desplat


92%


The Hurt Locker


Marco Beltrami & Buck Sanders

98%


Sherlock Holmes


Hans Zimmer

69%


Up


Michael Giacchino

98%


Achievement in Visual Effects

Duh.


Avatar


Avatar

82%


District 9


District 9

90%


Star Trek


Star Trek

94%


Achievement in Sound Editing

To compensate for not winning Best Picture, the Academy will bestow the technical awards on them tall blue folks.


Avatar


Avatar

82%


The Hurt Locker


The Hurt Locker

98%


Inglourious Basterds


Inglourious Basterds

88%


Star Trek


Star Trek

94%


Up


Up

98%


Achievement in Sound Mixing

(See “Achievement in Sound Editing.”)


Avatar


Avatar

82%


The Hurt Locker


The Hurt Locker

98%


Inglourious Basterds


Inglourious Basterds

88%


Star Trek


Star Trek

94%


Transformers 2


Transformers: Revenge of the Fallen

20%


Achievement in Makeup

Let’s get down to brass tacks: any time you have the opportunity to reward a movie for making a girl with green skin look attractive, you’ve got to do it.


Il Divo (92%)


Star Trek (94%)


The Young Victoria (75%)


Documentary Feature

According to right wing pundits, Hollywood is aggressively insular in its bleeding-heart liberalism. We at RT would like to table that argument – indefinitely, if possible – but they might have a point in one respect: the Best Documentary category. Man on Wire excepted, recent winners have tended to focus on ecological and/or foreign policy debacles. By that logic, we’re picking the save-the-whales thriller The Cove.


Burma VJ (96%)


The Cove (96%)


Food, Inc. (97%)


The Most Dangerous Man in America (100%)


Which Way Home (100%)


Foreign Language Film

This category has been hard to pick in recent years, with several wild cards (Departures in 2008, The Lives of Others in 2006) triumphing over movies that earned some measure of box office success (Waltz with Bashir and Pan’s Labyrinth, respectively). The Golden Globes aren’t much of a predictor, either – the last time a movie swept both awards was in 2004, with The Sea Inside. And although Michael Haneke (Cache, Funny Games) has become something of a divisive figure in international cinema (his films have been alternately embraced and decried for their ambiguity and brutality), few question his craftsmanship and integrity. We think he’ll join the ranks of Fellini, Bergman, and Kurosawa with a win in this category.


Ajami (96%)


El Secreto de Sus Ojos (100%)


The Milk of Sorrow (86%)


The White Ribbon (86%)


Un Prophete (98%)


Documentary Short

When it comes to short docs, the voters tend to favor entries that focus on the timely and the poignant. Given the domestic automobile industry’s woes, this seems like a safe choice.

China’s Unnatural Disaster

The Last Campaign of Governor Booth Gardner

The Last Truck: Closing of a GM Plant

Music by Prudence

Rabbit a la Berlin


Animated Short Film

Nick Park is nominated in this category with a new Wallace and Grommit short, A Matter of Loaf and Death. Case closed, right? Not so fast. Our choice is the action-packed, deliriously satirical Logorama. It’s as anti-corporate as a year’s subscription to Adbusters, but manages to delight nonetheless with its handmade look, which utilizes some of big business’ best-known trademarks and mascots as sentient beings.

French Roast

Granny O’Grimm’s Sleeping Beauty

The Lady and the Reaper

Logorama

A Matter of Loaf and Death


Live Action Short Film

Filmed in Ukraine near Chernobyl, Juanita Wilson’s haunting, mysterious The Door already won big at the Irish Film and Television Awards. And that’s all we got, though Internet Oscar swamis say this category is in the bag – and if it’s on the Internet, it has to be true.

The Door

Instead of Abracadabra

Kavi

Miracle Fish

The New Tenants


Come back and watch the Oscars with RT this Sunday, March 7 starting at 4:00PM Pacific/7:00PM Eastern for live coverage of the 82nd Annual Academy Awards! With your trusty Oscar ballot in hand, we’ll be covering the show via Twitter and Facebook on our Awards Tour headquarters with all the latest winners and pictures live from the show!