Rotten Tomatoes Predicts the Oscars 2018

by | March 1, 2018 | Comments

The 90th Academy Awards ceremony, which will take place on Sunday, March 4, promises to be an interesting one, featuring a mix of high profile films like Christopher Nolan’s Dunkirk and Guillermo del Toro’s The Shape of Water and smaller surprise hits like Jordan Peele’s Get Out and Greta Gerwig’s Lady Bird, among others. It’s always a tricky proposition to try and guess who’s going to win, but we here at Rotten Tomatoes have crunched the numbers, weighed the intangibles, and held lively discussions to determine who we think will come out on top. Read on for our full list of Oscar predictions, and let us know if you feel differently about any of them. Then, you can also pop over to our audience poll to see what fellow movie fans think will win, and you can even download your own RT Oscar ballot to keep score on the big night!

Best Picture: Three Billboards Outside Ebbing, Missouri (2017) 91%

(Photo by Merrick Morton /Fox Searchlight Pictures)

A couple of months ago, we would have told you that the Best Picture category was still too close to call. Suddenly, though, Martin McDonagh’s pitch black comedy picked up a lot of steam, winning top honors at the Golden Globes and the BAFTAs, while stars Frances McDormand and Sam Rockwell earned accolade after accolade along the way. With all of that in mind, we think Three Billboards will likely prevail over its competition.

Best Director: Guillermo del ToroThe Shape of Water (2017) 92%

(Photo by Kerry Hayes /Fox Searchlight Pictures)

It took deep passion and a lifelong obsession and empathy for movie monsters to make a love story like this work. And with Martin McDonagh not nominated in this category, here’s a fine opportunity to award a Best Director statue to del Toro over his Best Picture loss.

Best Actor: Gary OldmanDarkest Hour (2017) 84%

(Photo by Jack English/Focus Features)

Industry favorite Oldman completely transformed into British Prime Minister Winston Churchill for his role in Darkest Hour. Previously nominated in the same category for 2011’s Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy, he fully inhabits the stooped, gruff Churchill, who struggles with a decision that will literally determine the fate of England and the rest of Europe, perhaps even the world: whether to negotiate with Adolf Hitler or continue the fight — each at a terrible price.

Best Actress: Frances McDormandThree Billboards Outside Ebbing, Missouri (2017) 91%

(Photo by Fox Searchlight Pictures)

Got enough money to buy three billboards in Times Square, New York? Then bet it all on McDormand, the prohibitive favorite. She took out the SAG. She took out the Golden Globe (in the drama category). She took out the Oscar back in 1997 for Fargo. And she delivers a fierce performance in the most serious, emotionally draining role of the bunch. Only two questions remain: Will there be enough space on that stacked mantle for her 2018 trophy? And just how awesome will her speech be.

Best Supporting Actor: Sam RockwellThree Billboards Outside Ebbing, Missouri (2017) 91%

(Photo by Merrick Morton/Fox Searchlight Pictures)

No matter where you stand on the character — the small-town cop’s journey from repugnant racist to near-hero has riled some viewers — there’s no doubting the impact of Rockwell’s performance. Any thought that Willem Dafoe would prove a neck-and-neck rival has long been buried under a pile of Golden Globes, SAGS, and BAFTAs all bearing the Moon star’s name.

Best Supporting Actress: Allison Janney, I, Tonya (2017) 90%

(Photo by 30West)

Best Supporting Actress is truly Janney’s to lose. She’s been dominating the awards circuit for her portrayal as Tonya Harding’s loveless, abusive, bird-shouldered mother in a role that was literally written for her.

Best Original Screenplay: Get Out (2017) 98%

(Photo by Universal Pictures)

Get Out has proven it has steam. Jordan Peele’s hit has won most of the major awards in this category, and as rumors swirl that older academy voters aren’t even considering it for Best Picture, this seems like a (well deserved) consolation prize.

Best Adapted Screenplay: Call Me by Your Name (2017) 94%

(Photo by Sony Pictures Classics)

The year’s big kids are playing in the Original Screenplay category (where Three Billboards, Get Out, and Lady Bird will duke it out) leaving James Ivory with a fairly clear path to victory for his much-lauded take on André Aciman’s novel. It will be the 89-year-old’s first Oscar victory — ever. Ivory received directing nods for Merchant-Ivory classics The Remains of the Day, Howards End, and A Room with a View, but he never won, and this is his first nomination for writing.

Best Animated Feature: Coco (2017) 97%

(Photo by Walt Disney Studios)

This one is easy. You’d be pretty hard-pressed to find someone who doesn’t like Coco.

Best Foreign Language Film: The Square (2017) 85%

(Photo by Magnolia Pictures)

The Square may have the lowest Tomatometer score of any of the nominees in the category (still a not-too-shabby 82%), and some of the smart money is on the dazzling A Fantastic Woman, but hear us out. The Square has earned multiple Film Critics groups awards, contains one of 2017’s most memorable scenes, was seen by a decent thwack of people (it made almost $1.5 million during its theatrical run) and co-stars a couple of Americans with whom Academy members are familiar. We’re calling an upset.

Best Documentary Feature: Faces Places (2017) 99%

(Photo by Cohen Media Group)

With its investigation into Russian sports doping, Icarus is a heavy hitter in this category, as is Last Man in Aleppo, a look at recovery missions in war-torn Syria. Our favorite, though, is Faces Places, the charming collaboration between French New Wave godmother Agnès Varda and photographer/artist JR that weaves a rich tapestry of fading working-class life in the French countryside. Also, we’d love to see a repeat of Varda’s acceptance dance moves from the Governors Awards.

Best Cinematography: Blade Runner 2049 (2017) 88%

(Photo by Stephen Vaughan/Warner Bros.)

We’re predicting a lot of “it’s time” prizes, and there’s nothing more timeist than Roger Deakins’ previous 13 nominations without a single win. Though there’s a lot of CGI in Blade Runner 2049, think about Jared Leto’s wooden sanctuary with reflective water or Harrison Ford’s Vegas stronghold as the intimate areas blessed with Deakins’ trademark splash of hue and color.

Best Film Editing: Dunkirk (2017) 92%

(Photo by Warner Bros.)

While Baby Driver certainly makes splashy use of editing, we think Christopher Nolan’s war epic will take the crown simply because its entire narrative structure absolutely hinges on its ability to transition between concurrent storylines seamlessly. Nolan is no stranger to creative storytelling devices, and his considerable skill has never been employed more poignantly than here.

Best Production Design: Blade Runner 2049 (2017) 88%

(Photo by Warner Bros.)

Bigger is better this year. This is a movie where every room and location had to be imagined to exist 32 years in the future, but from the vantage point of a dystopian 1981. The sets feel lived-in with bleak purpose and history, the city skylines rising mystic and ominous.

Best Costume Design: Phantom Thread (2017) 91%

(Photo by Focus Features)

The film, starring Daniel Day-Lewis as a renowned dressmaker in 1950s London, has fashion at its very core. Costume designer Mark Bridges, who previously won an Oscar for his work on 2011’s The Artist and was also nominated for 2014 drama Inherent Vice, here evokes the most glamorous work of fashion icon, 35-time Oscar nominee, and eight-time winner Edith Head.

Best Original Score: The Shape of Water (2017) 92%

(Photo by Fox Searchlight Pictures)

A great musical score can often go unnoticed because it blends so seamlessly into its film, and there are certainly a couple of nominees in this category this might apply to. That said, Alexandre Desplat’s enchanting music, magical with a hint of a sinister streak, goes a long way in making The Shape of Water feel like the quietly haunting fairy tale that it is.

Best Original Song: “This Is Me” – The Greatest Showman (2017) 56%

(Photo by Niko Tavernise/20th Century Fox Film Corp.)

We love “Remember Me” and “Mystery of Love” just as much as the next person with even a modicum of taste. But we aren’t arguing with your mom’s Spotify play count.

Best Visual Effects: Blade Runner 2049 (2017) 88%

(Photo by Warner Bros.)

With the series frequently and purposely bereft of emotion, a lot of watching Blade Runner is simply luxuriating in its world. The visual effects take us there, and make something as simple as a three-way sex scene with an android, an imprinted human, and a bounty hunter a thing of beauty.

Best Makeup & Hairstyling: Darkest Hour (2017) 84%

(Photo by Jack English/Focus Features)

Darkest Hour impressed for its thorough and seamless transformation of its lead, Gary Oldman, into British Prime Minister Winston Churchill. This is the third nomination for Kazuhiro Tsuji and first for David Malinowski and Lucy Sibbick.

Best Sound Mixing: Dunkirk (2017) 92%

(Photo by Melinda Sue Gordon/Warner Bros.)

Some will be quick to point out Baby Driver‘s clever use of gunfire and windshield wipers to keep time with the action onscreen, but Dunkirk relies so heavily on sound to immerse audiences in the thick of battle that we find it difficult to imagine it will be beat. Plus, war movies traditionally do very well in the sound categories, and we’re expecting that to be the case here.

Best Sound Editing: Dunkirk (2017) 92%

(Photo by Melinda Sue Gordon/Warner Bros.)

Having said all that about sound mixing, it’s worth noting that Dunkirk‘s supervising sound editor, Richard King, went to great lengths to create the aural experience of the film. How great, you ask? He interviewed actual veterans to gain insight into what they heard on the battlefield. He researched and rebuilt from scratch one of the famous German dive-bombing sirens — which don’t exist anywhere any more — to capture its signature wail. This all may not be immediately apparent, but the overall effect of King’s work is a rich soundscape that plays a huge part in the film.

Best Short Film (Animated): Dear Basketball (2017) 69%

(Photo by ShortsTV)

Look, we’re not saying Dear Basketball is the best entry in this category — the handmade wonder Negative Space seems to be the favorite in terms of cinematic quality. That said, you probably shouldn’t underestimate the sheer number of nostalgic Lakers fans in the academy.

Best Short Film (Live Action): DeKalb Elementary (2017) 92%

(Photo by ShortsTV)

Riveting, tense, and powerfully acted, DeKalb Elementary would be a good bet to win this category in any year. However, in the midst of a national debate about gun violence, the film — based upon a real-life school shooting incident — is an absolute lock.

Best Documentary (Short Subject): Heroin(e) (2017) 100%

A hopeful film about a heartbreaking subject, Heroin(e) is the tale of three strong women fighting the scourge of opioid abuse in Huntington, WV. It’s also on Netflix, which means it’s readily available for Academy voters to watch.

Tag Cloud

Creative Arts Emmys historical drama game of thrones stand-up comedy royal family Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt NBC Trophy Talk Walt Disney Pictures scary 79th Golden Globes Awards Bravo Reality Competition A24 OWN Legendary Holiday indiana jones sequel Esquire hispanic Pop TV screenings Neflix telelvision godzilla NBA streamig comics Character Guide Universal Paramount aapi docudrama elevated horror hollywood ITV rt archives king kong Mary Tyler Moore Fargo new york GIFs Winners high school Heroines game show posters CNN Amazon Prime 99% Musicals BBC America japan SXSW VICE dogs Musical joker asian-american TV movies movies Hollywood Foreign Press Association 2021 satire blockbusters basketball TBS Elton John directors Western LGBTQ crime thriller cartoon Trivia versus Pacific Islander SDCC zombies Cannes fast and furious Alien suspense Rocketman comedies TCA Awards cancelled TV series 90s Britbox halloween tv disaster international remakes Fall TV biography documentaries ratings dragons unscripted A&E Food Network TV renewals ghosts Tags: Comedy mcc The Arrangement festivals dexter robots DC Universe Crunchyroll Comedy Central Biopics Best and Worst ESPN Universal Pictures Hulu Amazon Studios jamie lee curtis Grammys RT History boxing Marvel Studios Superheroes slashers Hallmark Christmas movies singing competition latino TCM Fox Searchlight richard e. Grant Dark Horse Comics Tubi Schedule chucky cancelled television Superheroe 94th Oscars Paramount Network rotten movies we love 007 Mary poppins news Pet Sematary Sundance TV scary movies Shudder supernatural Anna Paquin psychological thriller finale dc Fantasy Sci-Fi The Walt Disney Company spanish language scorecard worst zero dark thirty IFC renewed TV shows screen actors guild hidden camera cats reboot Turner theme song a nightmare on elm street TV Peacock YouTube Red witnail ID live event PaleyFest period drama zombie anthology The Academy streaming HFPA anime VOD football talk show TCA Disney Plus FOX diversity spain Starz cinemax Lifetime quibi HBO Go italian TNT stoner discovery Logo harry potter Comic Book films spider-man sitcom Interview war Lifetime Christmas movies Song of Ice and Fire DC streaming service CW Seed Netflix Christmas movies ABC Valentine's Day concert broadcast romance Black Mirror The Witch Binge Guide CBS All Access aliens Reality ABC Family razzies kids Endgame Emmy Nominations Vudu Arrowverse Captain marvel 21st Century Fox Focus Features Mindy Kaling transformers Chernobyl name the review mission: impossible FXX Travel Channel Baby Yoda Infographic archives venice BET comic book movie Prime Video mockumentary MGM Stephen King adventure Marvel Best Actress toy story mutant blockbuster Christmas gangster Countdown summer preview facebook Star Wars blaxploitation Turner Classic Movies See It Skip It interviews Family Exclusive Video Ovation sports rom-coms natural history what to watch Rom-Com heist movie Mary Poppins Returns social media Disney streaming service TCA Winter 2020 Extras Crackle 2020 golden globe awards Tarantino APB pirates of the caribbean comic books mob kaiju Comedy Paramount Pictures Disney leaderboard hispanic heritage month wonder woman batman canceled FX black comedy critic resources Nat Geo rt labs critics edition AMC new star wars movies SundanceTV PBS romantic comedy Adult Swim Sony Pictures boxoffice Sneak Peek doctor who summer TV preview Oscars king arthur WarnerMedia women IMDb TV Tomatazos USA The Walking Dead comiccon YouTube Premium Awards spinoff scene in color rt labs nfl Writers Guild of America toronto Spectrum Originals feel good Lucasfilm 2016 BET Awards parents Polls and Games japanese Showtime Super Bowl Video Games legend San Diego Comic-Con South by Southwest Film Festival Best Picture Apple TV Plus Avengers 2017 GLAAD Hallmark 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Holidays sopranos festival Music WGN VH1 Red Carpet Horror GoT IFC Films jurassic park TCA 2017 criterion live action ABC Signature Academy Awards marvel cinematic universe Winter TV nature political drama 2018 christmas movies Hear Us Out art house MSNBC BAFTA vs. 72 Emmy Awards SXSW 2022 spider-verse Year in Review Ghostbusters Ellie Kemper Watching Series dreamworks Premiere Dates E! Certified Fresh award winner The Purge medical drama technology streaming movies TruTV Brie Larson biopic Oscar know your critic 2019 dramedy movie Sundance Now Best Actor independent action-comedy Cartoon Network Marvel Television comic book movies Martial Arts First Reviews cancelled cancelled TV shows Cosplay YA james bond binge debate hist 2015 Amazon Prime Video teaser prank YouTube composers superhero Lionsgate TV One adaptation Netflix ViacomCBS based on movie HBO Max Drama Rock 1990s HBO sequels book adaptation Calendar Instagram Live TLC BBC One Women's History Month Set visit Syfy australia indie New York Comic Con Opinion revenge Discovery Channel cults crime drama franchise genre cops X-Men Mystery saw Election golden globes all-time Mudbound series rotten Acorn TV Comic-Con@Home 2021 E3 children's TV Broadway President classics Columbia Pictures Nominations cars south america Amazon breaking bad Country worst movies LGBT canceled TV shows Emmys Box Office olympics Quiz book adenture Pixar The CW Television Critics Association Marathons obi wan Fox News BBC 24 frames USA Network child's play foreign popular stop motion Pop Film superman science fiction spy thriller miniseries 4/20 CMT die hard Toys MTV vampires free movies lord of the rings Thanksgiving DGA Comics on TV documentary best trailers french First Look spanish Rocky Awards Tour 45 kong Star Trek Trailer Summer 73rd Emmy Awards reviews Pride Month Nickelodeon 93rd Oscars National Geographic deadpool target docuseries twilight video Paramount Plus casting Chilling Adventures of Sabrina 71st Emmy Awards werewolf Best Director thriller police drama cooking obituary Black History Month psycho El Rey strong female leads CBS NYCC Photos dark dceu Kids & Family Spring TV Television Academy DC Comics green book serial killer Apple TV+ politics DirecTV TV Land Disney+ Disney Plus OneApp Sundance MCU Pirates universal monsters Shondaland summer TV marvel comics Funimation Wes Anderson critics black young adult slasher tv talk sag awards trophy FX on Hulu laika television space AMC Plus TIFF PlayStation new zealand Image Comics Classic Film Disney Channel Tokyo Olympics Freeform monster movies crossover Warner Bros. emmy awards RT21 Spike Tumblr Film Festival travel video on demand justice league Podcast halloween Action Apple nbcuniversal true crime Teen animated comic crime History Animation 20th Century Fox American Society of Cinematographers Epix fresh Masterpiece