Critics Consensus

Now You See Me 2 Is all Smoke and Mirrors

Plus, Warcraft is a disappointing fantasy, and The Conjuring 2 is a spooky sequel.

by Jeff Giles | June 9, 2016

This week at the movies, we’ve got rogue magicians (Now You See Me 2, starring Jesse Eisenberg and Mark Ruffalo), a Horde of Orcs (Warcraft, starring Ben Foster and Paula Patton), and paranormal investigators (The Conjuring 2, starring Vera Farmiga and Patrick Wilson). What do the critics have to say?

Now You See Me 2 (2016)

34%

Now You See Me didn’t exactly inspire critical adulation when it arrived in theaters in 2013, but it made a lot of money — so now we have Now You See Me 2, which reunites most of the original’s showy cast while adding a few new faces for another magical heist filled with twists, turns, and double-crosses. The problem, according to most critics, is the same one that dogged the original — namely, that the movie is more interested in giving the appearance of a busy caper than actually making sense. If it’s a talented onscreen assemblage you’re after, Now You See Me 2 offers this weekend’s biggest bang for your buck, but for genuine cinematic magic, the pundits suggest looking elsewhere.

Warcraft (2016)

29%

It isn’t often that the critical establishment even bothers to feign interest in a video game adaptation — but then, most video game adaptations don’t have Warcraft‘s pedigree. With director Duncan Jones at the helm, this fantasy saga threatened to deliver more than just another exercise in franchise-building; alas, instead of offering filmgoers an experience as enchanting as its source material, critics say the Warcraft movie is a hollow shell of CGI eye candy with a narrative void at its center. Although Jones gets credit for assembling an impressive visual spectacle, his efforts aren’t enough to compensate for subpar acting, dense mythology, and a plodding plot — and in the end, Warcraft is one more in a long line of game-to-film journeys ending with a critical walk of shame.

The Conjuring 2 (2016)

80%

Director James Wan gave horror enthusiasts a Certified Fresh surprise with 2013’s The Conjuring, which used chilling restraint to tell a terrifically creepy tale drawn from the archives of real-life paranormal investigators Ed and Lorraine Warren. More than $300 million later, Wan is back — along with stars Patrick Wilson and Vera Farmiga — to offer another dramatization of the Warrens’ ghostbusting exploits. Although most critics can’t help but point out that this stuff isn’t quite as scary the second time around, they’re also quick to admit that Wan remains a deft genre filmmaker, and while The Conjuring 2 is subject to the laws of diminishing returns suggested by its title, it’s still got its share of suitably nasty scares.

What’s New on TV

Outcast: Season 1

80%

A cut above average summer fare, Outcast provides the genuine chills one should — but often can’t — expect from television horror.

Maya & Marty: Season 1

38%

Maya & Marty is a safer, weekday version of Saturday Night Live with little to recommend it other than Maya Rudolph and Martin Short‘s admittedly considerable charms.

Feed the Beast: Season 1

23%

Feed the Beast‘s visual appeal isn’t enough to make up for predictable plotting, convoluted dialogue and unlikable characters.

Also Opening This Week In Limited Release

King Jack (2015) 94% , a coming-of-age drama about a troubled young teen tasked with looking after his visiting cousin, is at 100 percent.
Tikkun (2015) 95% , a drama about an Orthodox religious schoolar whose life changes dramatically after he survives a near-death experience, is at 100 percent.
De Palma (2015) 95% , a documentary portrait of the auteur behind Scarface and Mission: Impossible, is at 95 percent.
Last Cab to Darwin (2015) 88% , a drama about a terminally ill man who drives accross Australia to a place where he can die on his own terms, is at 88 percent.
Therapy for a Vampire (2014) 63% , a horror/comedy in which a bored bloodsucker becomes a patient of Sigmund Freud, is at 86 percent.
From Afar (2015) 79% , a drama about a lonely older man who befriends the teenaged leader of a criminal gang, is at 74 percent.
Len and Company (2015) 70% , starring Rhys Ifans and Juno Temple in a comedy about a reclusive musician who’s shaken from complacency when he’s visited by his estranged son, is at 67 percent.
Diary of a Chambermaid (2015) 66% , starring Léa Seydoux in a period drama about a domestic worker and the difficulties she has with both her employers and a fellow servant, is at 64 percent.
Another (2014) 29% , a supernatural thriller about a young woman who discovers terrifying things about her own history, is at 50 percent.
, starring Colin Firth and Jude Law in a biopic of influential book editor Max Perkins, is at 46 percent.
Careful What You Wish For (2015) 17% , starring Nick Jonas and Isabel Lucas in a noirish thriller about a young man who engages in a steamy and dangerous affair with a married woman, is at 27 percent.
Puerto Ricans in Paris (2015) 30% , starring Luis Guzman and Edgar Garcia in a crime caper about a pair of NYC detectives on the hunt for a stolen purse in the City of Light, is at 17 percent.