Major Awards Need to Stop Ignoring Incredible Horror Performances

Lupita Nyong'o's twin turn in Us is being called Oscar-worthy – so were these 15 killer performances that the Academy and others didn't deem to be winners.

by | March 25, 2019 | Comments


In 2018, Jordan Peele’s Get Out jolted the Oscars status quo by earning nominations for four awards, including a Best Actor nod for Daniel Kaluuya. It’s not totally uncommon for prestige to pluck a horror performance from the dirt and see it as the radiant flower it is: Ruth Gordon won an Oscar for her eerie turn in Rosemary’s Baby; Bette Davis got a nod for her freaky What Ever Happened to Baby Jane? role; and Jodie Foster, Natalie Portman, and Kathy Bates all took home Oscars for Silence of the Lambs, Black Swan, and Misery, respectively. But even when a horror performance is honored, a whole lot of people twist themselves into knots trying to say a film wasn’t actually horror — Kaluuya was nominated for a Golden Globe in the Musical or Comedy category.

Ever since the premiere of Peele’s sophomore feature Us at SXSW, Lupita Nyong’o’s stunning performance as Adelaide and Red — two distinctly different but complementary versions of the same character — has been earning her high praise. Not since Jeremy Irons’ turn in David Cronenberg’s Dead Ringers has an actor in a horror film rendered such a complex psychological study of the self through twinning. Nyong’o’s transformation is physical and visceral and — pretty clearly — the caliber for awards consideration. So Peele kindly settled any debate before it began by tweeting: “Us is a horror movie.”

In honor of all the actors who’ve toiled away in horror, either to be forgotten or snubbed, here are 13 horror performances we’ve adored – but which the major awards ignored.

Essie Davis in The Babadook (2014) 98%

(Photo by ©IFC Midnight)

Before Jennifer Kent’s The Babadook premiered in 2014, Essie Davis was best known in America for her roles in The Matrix films and her portrayal of master sleuth Phryne Fisher in Miss Fisher’s Murder Mysteries (check it out on Netflix – it’s a lot of fun). But grieving single mother Amelia was an opportunity for Davis to shine as a complex, terrifying anti-heroine haunted by a ghoulish children’s book character, and the death of her husband. Davis was so committed to the role that she lost her voice for three days after performing a wrenching 11-second scream on set. She told the Guardian, “It didn’t matter if I looked like s–t and felt like s–t every day, because that’s what it needed.” Her face — often in closeup — is puffy, with wild eyes darting in response to every creak in the house. Amelia is creepy and dangerous, and yet Davis imbues her with a sensitivity that makes her circumstance relatable and that much more horrifying.

Toni Collette in Hereditary (2018) 89%

When we look back on the scariest mothers of movie history, Toni Collette’s performance as Annie will likely hover around the number-one spot for a long while. Annie is unabashedly selfish with her time and art, quite different from so many of the doting mothers on film who give up their lives for their children. She both has pain and inflicts pain — indicative of the generational trauma of their family — which means she can’t really be boiled down into Good or Bad. Collette slams her whole body and being into this character for a riveting, histrionic performance that lays waste to restraint. Annie’s grief, laughter, and anger show themselves on the screen with Shakesperian levels of gravity and calculated artifice, and no one will soon forget the horrific contortions of Collette’s face as she wails in mourning for the dead. Also, against all odds, Collette somehow finds little slices of humor and humility in Annie. Miraculous. (Miraculous, too, that she was snubbed last awards season.)

James McAvoy in Split (2016) 77%

How many completely different characters does a guy gotta play in the same movie to get any awards talk? In Split, McAvoy embodies 23 separate personalities, ranging from a literal beast who can crawl up walls to a prim, post-menopausal woman in heels and pearls named Patricia. McAvoy said his favorite character of the bunch was actually a 9-year-old boy named Hedwig, who’s got a slight speech impediment and a whole lot of saliva when he talks. In that role, McAvoy chewed up the scenery, shoulders slumped like a bored child, bouncing off the walls with the energy of a kid who’s seen way too many shoot-’em-up movies. McAvoy’s greatest craft trick, however, was in finding the silliness amid the horror, keeping the tension taut throughout those laugh lines, and then searching his way back to a more tender performance as Kevin Wendell Crumb, a broken man lost in his many identities.

Nicolas Cage in Mandy (2018) 90%


(Photo by © RLJE Films)

It’s no secret that Nicolas Cage is known for throwing himself deeply into his roles, creating a kind of fun dance of them, seeing how far he can take the character with spontaneous emotional outbursts. Too many filmmakers simply rely on that Cage-iness when they cast him in their movies, but director Panos Cosmatos offered the actor real motivation with the character of devoted and then heartbroken Red Miller, whose quiet, sensitive side embraces his love, Mandy, with all his heart, before she is brutally ripped from him. Despite Cage’s character having to smelt his own battle axe, Cage himself is actually appropriately restrained and then only unhinged in rare moments when the narrative calls for it, but every emotion is grounded in grief and then wild and painful revenge. Cage co-star Andrea Riseborough as Mandy deserves more than a mention here, as well, having delivered an equally stellar performance that ranges from philosophical monologues to maniacal laughter.

Betty Gabriel in Get Out (2017) 98%

Betty Gabriel was filming a low-budget action movie called Beyond Skyline when co-star Frank Grillo recommended her for a role in Blumhouse’s The Purge: Election Year. Word had it that Jordan Peele was going to direct his debut feature and was looking to fill out a couple of roles. Gabriel showed up, and the rest is history. As housekeeper Georgina, Gabriel locates the heart of this supporting character — both the woman she was and the new woman who’s inhabiting her body. In one pivotal scene, her voice quakes as she says, “No. No-no-no-no-no-no,” her eyes — filled with tears — at odds with the smile on her face, as though she’s a dummy puppet and either part is being manipulated by a different puppeteer. This chasm in Georgina’s personality becomes her central tension and the source of so many skin-crawling scenes, with the underlying message that the scariest thing is not knowing yourself.

Gong Yoo in Train to Busan (2016) 94%

Yeon Sang-ho’s ultra-violent zombie action film earned a place in America’s hearts, not just because of its thrilling and bloody chase sequences, but because it’s really the story about a father’s sacrifice for his child. Gong Yoo plays Seok-woo, a busy, divorced dad whose young daughter has asked him to take her to be with her mother in Busan. Before he even gets on the fateful train with the girl, he already feels like a failure, unable to properly show love. Gong Yoo’s performance of this sad dad finding his way grounds an otherwise flighty narrative. Even in busy action sequences populated by hundreds of zombified extras, Yoo exudes a kind of nervous strength focused singularly on the survival of his daughter. Sang-ho also includes another dad in the film, Sang-hwa, played by Ma Dong-seok, who offers an extremely complementary performance to Yoo’s, displaying a kind of earnest courage, which Yoo feeds off of for the transformation of his character.

Tony Todd in Candyman (1992) 78%


(Photo by ©TriStar Pictures)

Who can make you jump out of your skin and also yearn for his fateful embrace? The candyman can! Tony Todd’s presence in this frightfully ridiculous story rises above the material. The convoluted urban fairy tale features Todd as its boogeyman, called from his grave when his name is said in the mirror three times. Todd said he was immediately taken with the role, despite some misgivings around race in the story, simply because the imagery of gore in the city was something he hadn’t seen before. In 2015, he told IGN: “I’ve always wanted to find my own personal Phantom of the Opera.” That desire is evident in Todd’s melodrama and theatricality. He embodies and flaunts the grotesque, a mythically imposing figure with sweeping grand gestures that become impossibly romantic — even though the Candyman’s got a rib cage of bees! Todd’s resonant voice, wide smile, and mesmerizing eyes add up to one tempting, unforgettable villain.

Jeff Goldblum in The Fly (1986) 93%

The Fly

(Photo by 20th Century Fox Film Corp.)

It’s galling that, at first, the studio couldn’t see Jeff Goldblum as Seth Brundle, the brilliant scientist destroyed by his own teleportation creation. But perhaps they didn’t know that Goldblum would work out like a madman and drink coffee every waking minute of his days to embody the maniac his character would become — the Brundlefly. Cronenberg knew. As Brundle, Goldblum’s natural charisma perfectly matches Geena Davis’ Veronica, a journalist who’s come out to a stranger’s apartment to check out his weird machines. Veronica’s inquisitiveness puzzle-pieces together with Brundle’s excitement, and the two settle into a lovely, if short-lived, romance. Where Goldblum shines is when he transforms into a wild man capable of snapping off a strongman’s arm in a bar. In one scene, the actor ad-libbed an entire caffeine-fueled, buzzy monologue about philosophy and science while Davis played off his energy as the straight-man. Even under pounds of goopy makeup, Goldblum makes his Brundlefly a sympathetic monster of circumstance.

Sissy Spacek and Piper Laurie in Carrie (1976) 93%

Director Brian De Palma was adamant that Carrie’s telekinetic outbursts were simply about teenaged angst, but young actor Sissy Spacek latched onto the idea that Carrie was “really about a young girl who is an artist who just wants to be normal,” and that the girl dreamed of expressing herself through poetry one day, but her fascist mother took it away from her. Spacek’s mythology of her character was so deep that De Palma at times just let her run off with the role, while he focused on specific shots. Her mannerisms equally evoke an innocent naïf and an all-powerful goddess, and her performance is matched only by that of Piper Laurie, who didn’t at first understand what would be required of her from the script, until she read it with the eyes of Lady Macbeth. The result of Laurie’s work is an unrivaled whites-of-her-eyes performance of Biblical intensity, glimmers of it present in Toni Collette’s Annie of Hereditary.

Mia Farrow in Rosemary's Baby (1968) 96%

Though Ruth Gordon was honored by the Academy Awards for her part as the nosy neighbor attempting to lure Rosemary into an orgy with the devil, Mia Farrow sadly was not, despite the arc of her emotions anchoring this nightmarish tale. Director Roman Polanski himself said he didn’t really have to direct her. He trusted her to come to these emotions herself, and he didn’t pre-plan or storyboard any shots, instead watching how Farrow approached the scene and setting up around that. Rosemary transforms from shy, childlike cheerleader wife to pregnant paranoid prisoner of a cult. The way she moves between gullibility and strength becomes so relatable, while the gaslighting becomes more and more absurd — an accurate, if frightening, portraiture of a woman at the whims of her man and the devil he’s made a deal with. Her performance is so affecting that the calm and resolute demeanor she strikes when she’s made peace with her destiny is both surprising and inevitable.

Isabelle Adjani in Possession (1981) 88%


(Photo by Courtesy the Everett Collection)

Three words: Subway tunnel scene. Andrzej Zulawski’s tale of an unearthly sex monster who’s taken hold of a Berlin housewife turns into high art because of Isabelle Adjani’s dedication to self-annihilation over the course of the film. Here, she plays Anna, one half of a marriage that’s suddenly imploding in hysteria and intrigue. Anna’s husband, played by an impeccable Sam Neill, attempts to search out where and with whom she’s been spending her time. When she is in the house, she’s erratic, cutting herself and her husband with an electric knife, eyes possessed. But in that tunnel scene is where the audience gets the full indication of how much Anna’s body is not her own, as Adjani flagellates herself with a milk carton, ramming her tiny frame into the tile walls, bathing in the spilled milk as though she’s communing with a higher, violent spirit. She barks and gasps with laughter until her body erupts with blood and green goop, and, holy wow, is it unnerving.

Linda Blair in The Exorcist (1973) 84%

Linda Blair earned an Oscar nomination for her role as possessed little Reagan, thank God, but lost out to another young actor, Tatum O’Neil, in the Supporting Actress category. Famously, writer William Blatty blasted George Cukor for leading a campaign to denigrate horror films as undeserving of an Academy Award, but Blair’s performance lives on, award or not. As the lovable Reagan (pre-possession), she gleams with innocence and precociousness, which makes that moment when she stands with blank eyes, cursing her mother’s fancy guests and urinating on the carpet, so shocking. The emotional flexibility it takes for a child to then be strapped to a bed, globbed with green makeup, hurling incredible insults at adults, is otherworldly, not to mention the physicality required of her to constantly thrash on the bed and yank at the straps on her wrists and ankles. Oh, lord, and then there’s the crucifix… We’ll just say it’s a tour de force performance most adult actors wouldn’t have the maturity to do, let alone a child.

Jack Nicholson/Shelley Duvall in  The Shining (1980) 85%

Jack Nicholson and Shelley Duvall as Jack and Wendy Torrance are two sides of a terrifying coin. Jack is all action, while Wendy is reaction, their push and pull and friction grinding this film into brutal horror. One gets the sense that Nicholson was born to play his role of a sadistic alcoholic narcissist who blames his wife and children for his writerly failures, even though they’ve uprooted their lives to fulfill his dream of finally getting some free time to work on that novel. Nicholson is wild-eyed and untethered, some of his greatest lines (“Here’s Johnny!”) resulting from a multitude of takes meant to wear the actors down into lunacy. Duvall embodies pure, unadulterated fear, lip quivering, earth quaking beneath her. Nicholson’s performance lives on for its horror only because Duvall can deliver the uncertainty and panic, her arms limply but dutifully swinging a baseball bat at an approaching monster Wendy always knew lurked beneath.

Tag Cloud

aapi spider-verse rotten HBO Masterpiece nbcuniversal Travel Channel christmas movies superhero science fiction Brie Larson mission: impossible obi wan Video Games Tags: Comedy YouTube Premium Calendar South by Southwest Film Festival Binge Guide HBO Go Mary poppins CNN historical drama TV war Action mob First Look GLAAD Mystery Sundance El Rey biography tv talk award winner Fox Searchlight Academy Awards Mudbound Discovery Channel 2015 TCM Musical facebook Spring TV sopranos video on demand Hallmark Christmas movies Family high school Paramount Plus asian-american zombies RT21 italian a nightmare on elm street Sundance TV YA screen actors guild Mary Poppins Returns FOX south america comic book movie news Musicals Best Director die hard new star wars movies Women's History Month binge Comic Book ViacomCBS royal family Sundance Now Food Network hollywood Holidays PBS Horror rt labs anthology dramedy renewed TV shows action-comedy films free movies TCA comic Hulu Toys halloween IFC Films trophy fresh Image Comics Legendary slashers Disney streaming service ABC Signature sag awards Drama indie supernatural docuseries ABC french 99% dc justice league cancelled TV series Reality The Arrangement robots 2018 E3 dreamworks legend emmy awards X-Men live action Comedy Central wonder woman telelvision Lifetime Christmas movies Shondaland Tokyo Olympics comiccon travel BBC One Trailer TCA 2017 Netflix See It Skip It Shudder sequel Tomatazos hidden camera richard e. Grant The Walt Disney Company TLC adventure OWN IFC VICE BAFTA YouTube Red television latino DGA criterion Television Critics Association Rocky Podcast universal monsters 21st Century Fox Baby Yoda BET Awards Apple Syfy FX on Hulu FXX black elevated horror video zombie spanish TV Land period drama Ovation archives Awards cats festival biopic indiana jones canceled TV shows king kong Certified Fresh stop motion Countdown posters President PlayStation APB medical drama New York Comic Con cinemax independent BET thriller Valentine's Day unscripted Britbox Peacock Spectrum Originals technology RT History based on movie finale MSNBC Oscar Thanksgiving dexter joker Alien 93rd Oscars Disney CBS Amazon USA razzies crime thriller Trophy Talk MTV trailers AMC Plus blaxploitation marvel comics DC Comics toronto Tumblr streaming movies 4/20 Emmy Nominations young adult MGM adaptation psychological thriller genre toy story Trivia twilight theme song harry potter Best Picture Warner Bros. Best and Worst lord of the rings superman Turner critic resources women DC streaming service Disney Plus book Set visit WGN child's play Dark Horse Comics Marathons Photos cancelled japanese cooking Box Office venice Apple TV+ classics spider-man halloween tv Animation Lionsgate stoner scary movies Prime Video talk show Pet Sematary movies batman summer preview Reality Competition mutant Super Bowl 2019 psycho suspense Quiz Kids & Family adenture Fantasy Schedule Mary Tyler Moore spain Nickelodeon witnail Adult Swim parents Comics on TV streamig critics Walt Disney Pictures DirecTV foreign transformers game show Infographic PaleyFest jurassic park 73rd Emmy Awards IMDb TV rotten movies we love romance 2017 Oscars basketball LGBT worst movies Pop TV Winter TV monster movies 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards anime remakes summer TV preview streaming Star Wars Comedy Lifetime jamie lee curtis singing competition Grammys Martial Arts vampires Premiere Dates comic books SXSW 2022 mcc E! Sci-Fi docudrama Broadway Nat Geo Emmys blockbuster Biopics cartoon spanish language disaster Hallmark Hear Us Out boxoffice Disney Channel 2020 vs. 007 sports 1990s Pride Month Holiday worst composers Cosplay debate FX Country SundanceTV Spike American Society of Cinematographers Neflix godzilla Elton John Anna Paquin international hispanic heritage month Winners Logo game of thrones CMT Avengers romantic comedy NYCC cults 45 nfl 2021 GoT TBS concert Television Academy scary reviews TV renewals Rom-Com Acorn TV First Reviews what to watch Marvel dceu 24 frames The Walking Dead reboot pirates of the caribbean screenings new zealand golden globe awards 20th Century Fox A24 police drama king arthur rt labs critics edition Arrowverse boxing werewolf Character Guide ESPN crime drama Creative Arts Emmys rom-coms cars zero dark thirty stand-up comedy Film Festival Song of Ice and Fire Superheroes scorecard japan ITV LGBTQ Lucasfilm TIFF Interview cops Best Actress crossover festivals golden globes olympics dogs 79th Golden Globes Awards Columbia Pictures Best Actor Exclusive Video USA Network black comedy saw sitcom Fargo franchise summer TV movie discovery true crime 72 Emmy Awards laika green book spinoff ghosts breaking bad Fox News art house Stephen King Freeform Nominations DC Universe San Diego Comic-Con Chilling Adventures of Sabrina BBC America BBC Marvel Television Star Trek australia leaderboard slasher NBC ID Teen Bravo dark know your critic Epix hispanic serial killer dragons Amazon Prime Video james bond live event OneApp directors all-time satire Rocketman social media crime Crackle Disney+ Disney Plus Extras TNT revenge The CW Election children's TV chucky comics Sneak Peek Wes Anderson cancelled TV shows History kaiju Pixar gangster TCA Awards The Witch doctor who Comic-Con@Home 2021 Ghostbusters cancelled television Film CBS All Access kong casting new york documentary Red Carpet Instagram Live politics Mindy Kaling MCU VH1 Netflix Christmas movies Christmas GIFs Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt SXSW 90s NBA CW Seed aliens quibi Writers Guild of America series Classic Film Showtime feel good YouTube versus Marvel Studios heist movie deadpool ABC Family Universal Pictures Apple TV Plus popular Paramount HBO Max best diversity Turner Classic Movies book adaptation Starz Cannes Pirates football comic book movies Black History Month Amazon Studios Cartoon Network 2016 obituary mockumentary blockbusters Music kids documentaries Funimation Endgame Opinion TV One Year in Review name the review political drama TruTV Fall TV strong female leads Hollywood Foreign Press Association Western Universal TCA Winter 2020 target natural history WarnerMedia Ellie Kemper nature National Geographic Black Mirror scene in color Vudu SDCC Paramount Network HFPA Esquire Pop Heroines hist AMC miniseries Summer Chernobyl rt archives comedies Sony Pictures canceled animated VOD spy thriller 94th Oscars sequels Captain marvel ratings Tarantino teaser Awards Tour The Academy fast and furious TV movies Amazon Prime Crunchyroll marvel cinematic universe Pacific Islander Rock The Purge prank Polls and Games space Tubi 71st Emmy Awards Watching Series Superheroe A&E