James Schamus talks Taking Woodstock - RT Interview

by | November 13, 2009 | Comments

RT Interview: James Schamus on Taking Woodstock

James Schamus might be a workaholic. If it’s not enough that he’s the head of Focus Features — the independent imprint of Universal — he’s also an established producer and screenwriter best known for his collaborations with Ang Lee. This week sees the release of the pair’s latest, Taking Woodstock, a comedy about a family integral to the birth of the infamous Woodstock concert of 1969. And if that isn’t enough, he’s an associate professor of film at Columbia University and just delivered a politically-charged lecture to a rapt London Film Festival audience. While in town, he sat down with RT to talk about the release of Taking Woodstock, his work at Focus and his thoughts on the Tomatometer…

Taking Woodstock


We last spoke in Cannes where the movie got its world premiere. How has the journey been since then?

James Schamus: As you know, being from Rotten Tomatoes, the US release was probably disappointing. I have a suspicion about this. I don’t think the film is anti-American, but I do think it’s un-American in a way. I love America, I’m an unabashed American, but the hero is just kind-of hapless and lets things happen, and he has that 60s attitude of like, “Hey, let it be.” That’s the whole ethos of the movie, but it’s not the American way of doing things these days.

It ended up being more of an art house proposition in the States, and not as commercial as it has been in France and Asia and Germany. It’s more of a mainstream film out of America. I think there was some puzzlement with the American response because it just didn’t deliver the concert, which of course is the whole point of the movie. You can disagree or agree, which is fine, I don’t take umbrage ever at these kinds of discussions, but there was a refrain of, “If you’re going to make a movie about Woodstock you have to make a movie which shows the concert.” Actually, you don’t. You can really make a movie about this family three miles down the road, and what happens when a million people show up.

We were philosophical about the performance in the States and very happy with the performance elsewhere, but that’s my world at Focus. Because these things don’t cost so much to make we can take our knocks here and there and get our gravy somewhere else.

And every now and then you can have these big breakout hits…

JS: Yeah, I mean, look, I’m not in the hit business. It’s always great to have a runaway hit, but I’m in the singles and doubles business at Focus. I always say it’s not a Focus movie unless the vast majority of human beings don’t like it! We really make specialised films; I’m not a studio player. I don’t want to be a Hollywood studio, that’s the whole point. It is a trap, that the business instils in everybody — especially the specialised sector — this grow or die attitude. “You’ve got to have a big hit or it’s got to break a hundred or else you’re not…” I don’t know, I look at Focus and we seem to be making good money every year and that’s not our attitude. And I think Universal appreciates that, because that’s their job. We don’t want to mess with what they do.

After doing it for a while do you at least have an idea of how a film might play commercially?

JS: Oh, of course — when we made Brokeback, the gay cowboy movie, we knew it was going to be one of the biggest indie hits ever! No, you never have any idea how a movie will do, and that’s one of the great things about my job. You make the best movie you can, you work with the coolest people and you don’t worry too much about the box office except for making sure you have a game plan that gets you your money back. Maybe a little extra so you can send the cheque back to the corporate mothership so that they say, “Hey, good job guys, keep going.” And you keep your expectations modest but always keep the door open to success.

We’re not trying to make little movies that don’t make money. I’m always really excited when we have a big hit! I’m very happy, and I do everything I can to make that happen, but you can’t spend your whole life looking over your shoulder thinking, God, so and so just broke $100m, my next art movie better break that too. Some of the great surprises and joys of my business — films like Lost in Translation or Brokeback Mountain or Coraline — are movies where people who think they know this stuff would look at those movies and say, “I don’t think so.”

We wouldn’t see American films like those if not for companies like Focus.

JS: I think so and we’re really proud of the fact that we’re still doing it, but we just have to do it responsibly. There are lots of pressures in the business, a lot of our peer institutions have gone by the wayside, and I think the reason we’re still around — and God willing the reason we’ll still be doing it next year — is because we stretch ourselves aesthetically and try and make sure that our filmmakers know they have a wide berth, and we do all that responsibly.

Do you think it helps that you’re in charge of the business and also have an incredibly strong creative side? Not many other studio heads would be writing screenplays too…

JS: I think it hurts. I think I have to hold back. I’m really good, I think, at working on my stuff, but that’s my stuff. The Coen Brothers, that’s their stuff. What I have learned from day one is the value of me being there to support production, and actually I enjoy the marketing and distribution side of it to really bring my creativity and expertise to those jobs. When you’re working with great filmmakers, when they want advice or they have issues I’m not shy about sharing an opinion but my creativity is mine and theirs is theirs and I want to respect that.

I guess the joy of the job is in having that duality.

JS: Absolutely, and most importantly we’re still having fun. It’s tough times everywhere, but in the film business especially with erosion of DVD sales which cuts across from the biggest Hollywood productions down to ours, there are serious challenges we have to face. But if you’re not facing those challenges with a little bit of joy, what’s the point of showing up at work? I think that was part of the process of Woodstock for Ang was making a movie about something which isn’t treated that often in American movies — being happy. Happiness is not necessarily a very active state. It’s a place where you’re letting things happen to you and to the world. So it was great to go back into that sixties zone and really have that experience with the film.

What’s always been fascinating about Focus is that it’s a company working on independent projects within the Hollywood system.

JS: Yeah, we use the resources when we can and we operate in a system that gives us the birth and space to do that stuff, and certainly we navigate and leverage within that system to great advantage and effect. The system is still malleable enough to allow for those kinds of things to happen. It’s interesting on the outside of the studio system, when you go into the sites and places where the public at large is figuring out what they’re going to see.

Like Rotten Tomatoes, it poses very interesting challenges for us in particular since our best movies are probably the movies that aren’t for everybody. When you use this quantitative approach on the Tomatometer, it tells a very specific story that isn’t the story very often for movies like us. You guys are great because on the one hand it’s an incredible aggregation of thoughts and opinion, but on the other hand for specialised film — especially these days where critics are increasingly coming to a popular consensus approach to their work. They’re not articulating as boldly as an aggregate as they once did. We’re confronted with a very funny thing where our best movies get some of our worst ratings. How do you break through and say, “Hey guys, for you this is the one.”

I’ve always thought there’s a sweet spot in the middle of the Tomatometer — between about 45-55% – where it’s not a question of those movies being bad movies, but that’s where the ones that really divide people passionately wind up sitting. And some of them are my favourite movies. Films like The Fall or Antichrist are recent examples. I’ll always seek out a movie when I find it’s been scored between 45 and 55% precisely because I know I’m going to react to it very strongly.

JS: It’d be really fun to see how you can make that an exciting zone without it being the dead zone in the middle. Because I think you’re absolutely right, it really comes up again and again and you want the discussion, you want people to be getting the discussion going. Because the pop culture is at its most exciting when you bring in everybody and democratise it, everybody can have that voice. When it just becomes this number, suddenly it evacuates that possibility. It’ll be fun to see how that evolves.

I do think people misuse the site sometimes in the sense that they just go based on the score and not on the quotes. When you go to the quotes and then the full reviews, you absolutely get that sense that you don’t get from the score, particularly in the case of the 45-55s.

JS: That’s where I find myself constantly these days, as you know, so you’re articulating exactly what I’m doing with my business! It’s funny.

Taking Woodstock is out in the UK today.

Tag Cloud

zombies aliens mutant Lifetime Christmas movies YA Amazon Prime TV renewals spy thriller miniseries Marvel Studios Baby Yoda renewed TV shows BAFTA CMT Tubi 4/20 emmy awards FOX Nat Geo Disney Plus Shudder Schedule Video Games DC Comics streaming finale canceled TV shows Fall TV CW Seed PBS Endgame spider-man Stephen King Tomatazos BBC America Disney Channel Pride Month Amazon Studios hispanic game show Extras Pet Sematary franchise Creative Arts Emmys obituary documentaries Photos richard e. Grant LGBT APB anthology Trailer Mudbound E3 Valentine's Day strong female leads theme song IFC Films romance Reality singing competition Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Watching Series Comics on TV Hallmark halloween FX Classic Film comic NBC Hulu toy story indie Writers Guild of America MSNBC movie joker GIFs medical drama Paramount green book Hallmark Christmas movies video on demand Sony Pictures 2020 San Diego Comic-Con Biopics Summer VOD Disney children's TV Acorn TV TV Land casting stop motion Holidays versus nature Set visit USA Logo child's play Bravo screenings best Character Guide Film Festival Red Carpet Rocketman docudrama First Look Lifetime Adult Swim VICE Funimation christmas movies documentary name the review batman Premiere Dates BET Awards Television Academy serial killer facebook cinemax TCA Awards Christmas based on movie sports Musicals Spike cults crime drama TCA Epix Spring TV asian-american sequel Awards Tour Emmys free movies series GLAAD Kids & Family HBO Go CBS crossover E! Brie Larson dc indiana jones universal monsters Western game of thrones Sci-Fi historical drama justice league FX on Hulu romantic comedy WGN slashers ghosts Winter TV 2018 witnail adventure video Country The Walking Dead technology Apple police drama transformers golden globes news space Rock travel Family 2015 binge ITV Election superhero worst crime Toys period drama Calendar USA Network parents disaster 72 Emmy Awards VH1 films Countdown stand-up comedy TNT CBS All Access Arrowverse Winners Discovery Channel Disney+ Disney Plus Awards Ellie Kemper Opinion criterion biography YouTube Premium Women's History Month YouTube First Reviews Television Critics Association Rom-Com Musical Reality Competition cartoon RT History A24 Best and Worst 45 PlayStation harry potter Crackle Nickelodeon composers Sneak Peek Cosplay science fiction Amazon Prime Video Avengers The Arrangement NYCC a nightmare on elm street elevated horror SundanceTV talk show reboot tv talk politics TV National Geographic MTV Apple TV+ Chilling Adventures of Sabrina blaxploitation Showtime comics comedies anime History The Purge Masterpiece TBS dogs Lionsgate Film spanish language Sundance TV Horror Tumblr RT21 GoT MCU Columbia Pictures ABC Superheroe El Rey President Hear Us Out screen actors guild Mary Tyler Moore TLC HBO Max Marathons blockbuster Comedy Central 007 Mystery 2019 zombie WarnerMedia natural history Thanksgiving Super Bowl Comic Book movies festivals south america classics Peacock cops Animation supernatural PaleyFest spinoff sitcom Shondaland Drama Year in Review X-Men Mary poppins die hard Pop nbcuniversal Mary Poppins Returns DC Universe hist dramedy boxoffice Syfy TIFF ESPN TCA 2017 Black Mirror Teen Pirates Fantasy Spectrum Originals Starz CNN Britbox DirecTV diversity cancelled television HBO Black History Month 71st Emmy Awards crime thriller chucky Food Network Netflix comiccon true crime Pop TV award winner Elton John DGA Walt Disney Pictures Song of Ice and Fire concert Sundance 20th Century Fox what to watch OWN Anna Paquin adaptation werewolf Music cancelled TV shows Netflix Christmas movies Comedy Nominations Universal Warner Bros. OneApp dragons quibi Pixar vampires SDCC foreign psychological thriller directors Lucasfilm canceled discovery all-time YouTube Red critics Trophy Talk Martial Arts Amazon cats Dark Horse Comics reviews TCA Winter 2020 zero dark thirty SXSW A&E Vudu 24 frames mockumentary rotten movies we love Esquire jamie lee curtis Captain marvel Chernobyl The CW Grammys independent breaking bad Star Wars dark Heroines hollywood dceu war Cannes 2017 book stoner spain revenge social media television ratings Interview Rocky political drama laika BBC One Cartoon Network Trivia twilight Turner satire Star Trek Academy Awards Binge Guide 21st Century Fox doctor who Disney streaming service American Society of Cinematographers Quiz Holiday sag awards 2016 Tarantino Ghostbusters sequels Emmy Nominations animated The Witch robots DC streaming service AMC latino kids Marvel TruTV mission: impossible Oscars Podcast rotten Marvel Television cancelled TCM psycho New York Comic Con cars cancelled TV series Box Office BBC IFC See It Skip It Paramount Network Travel Channel unscripted Superheroes scary movies teaser Polls and Games Mindy Kaling Fox News thriller Ovation Certified Fresh fast and furious BET cooking LGBTQ FXX Sundance Now Crunchyroll Apple TV Plus Turner Classic Movies Freeform Infographic Action ABC Family