Hear Us Out

Hear Us Out: The Haunting of Hill House Episode 6 Might Be This Year's Best Horror Movie

Mike Flanagan's adaptation of Shirley Jackson's novel proves that skeletons in the closet can be just as scary as malevolent demons, psychotic killers, and rampaging aliens.

by | October 18, 2018 | Comments

Two 2018 films, Certified Fresh titles A Quiet Place and Hereditary, proved that there’s a lot more to a great theatrical horror experience than just a collection of jump scares — though jump scares will always have their place. And those titles were just the beginning of the year’s successful feature film horror offerings; The Nun scored at the box office (if not on the Tomatometer), and this Friday’s release Halloween was just Certified Fresh and is expected to cross $100 million at the domestic box office easily, putting it in the top 10 highest grossing horror films ever.

Small-screen horror entertainment, however, has experienced mixed levels of success recently, which is proved out in the season-to-season Tomatometer score fluctuations of TV horror staples like The Walking Dead and American Horror Story and the cancellation of a gem like Fox’s massively underappreciated The Exorcist sequel series.

On the top end: Stranger Things.

It’s perhaps no coincidence that the latest exceptional horror offering comes from the same distributor, Netflix. Mike Flanagan’s The Haunting of Hill House, a small-screen adaptation of Shirley Jackson’s classic novel, has captured the chill-seeking fancy of the streaming-TV masses and collected enough critical approval to be Certified Fresh at an impressive 90% on the Tomatometer with 49 reviews.

Spoiler alert: This article contains details about episode 6 of The Haunting of Hill House. Stop here if you have not watched the episode.

The series, which began streaming earlier in October, follows the five Crain siblings during two different eras — as kids growing up in America’s most famous haunted house (before it was famous), and as adults when their past trauma just won’t stay buried. The show accomplishes a fine balance between cinematic restraint and slow-burn terror while exploring the interconnected experiences of the disconnected family.

And its sixth episode, “Two Storms,” is, arguably — go on, argue in the comments — the best horror entertainment to hit any screen in 2018.

The Haunting of Hill House (Netflix)
(Photo by Steve Dietl/Netflix)

Yes, it’s bold to compare a 54-minute TV episode to two breakout theatrical hits — but hear us out.

With A Quiet Place, the John Krasinski–directed alien-invasion piece works best when the story is stripped of its audio, putting the audience in the position of the Abbott family’s deaf daughter as she and her parents are stalked by a mostly unseen foe. Taking away one of the five senses elevates the story, adding a great sense of urgency to the tense survivalist tale.

Flanagan triumphs with a volume game over A Quiet Place, dispersing the terrifyingly present horror in The Haunting of Hill House across a wider group and a larger time frame — there is simply more terror to go around.

Hereditary hews closer to the themes of The Haunting of Hill House, as both the movie and the series explore the toll that grief can take on each member of a struggling family unit. At one point in “Two Storms,” Steven (Michiel Huisman), the eldest brother — inadvertently? — connects the film and series in considering what he sees as his father Hugh’s (Timothy Hutton) possible mental illness. Hearing him utter the word “hereditary” in this context almost feels like a shoutout to Ari Aster’s feature film hit. But the big mysterious gimmick that Hereditary relies on ends up being revealed as something much more bonkers than a simple mental-illness story line.

Hereditary and The Haunting of Hill House work best when they explore the various ways a shared trauma can effect its lead characters. But what makes the Netflix series, most specifically its sixth episode, work just as well or even better than that film is its laser-sharp focus on the Crain family — and the emotional rawness that comes with it.

Steve Dietl/Netflix
(Photo by Steve Dietl/Netflix)

The combination of detailed world-building by Flanagan (Oculus, Gerald’s Game) and the work of the talented ensemble cast — which includes the likes of Huisman, Hutton, Carla Gugino, Henry Thomas, Elizabeth Reaser, Oliver Jackson-Cohen, Victoria Pedretti, and Kate Siegel as the elder members of the Crain family, and epic performances by the young talent playing their younger versions — comes together perfectly here in a way that has led to many to compare Flanagan’s adaptation to a spooky version of NBC’s hit drama This Is Us.

The Haunting of Hill House should certainly be categorized as horror, but the first half of the series spends a huge chunk of its time focusing on the Crain family dynamic. Standalone episodes dive deeper into each character’s life, from Luke’s (Jackson-Cohen) battle with addiction to young Nell’s run-ins with a shadowy figure known simply as “The Bent-Neck Lady.”

Cycling back and forth from the present to the past, exploring how the tragedy of death can forever change lives, the show ends up opening itself up to comparisons to other shows like HBO’s landmark drama Six Feet Under — but, you know, with ghosts. Those comparisons become background noise once the greatness of episode 6 comes into focus.

Taking place in just two locations — Shirley’s (Reaser) funeral parlor in the present, and Hill House in the past — the stories that unfold in “Two Storms” are presented as two sides to the same tragic coin. On one hand, the episode works as a dysfunctional family reunion — bringing each character together to mourn the untimely tragic death of the family’s youngest sister, Nell (Pedretti). On the other, the story brings every little bit of trauma out from hiding. Like the ghosts that have stayed hidden throughout the backdrop of the series up until this point, the deep-seated issues of the Crain family finally step out of the shadows and into the light, showing us all that the scariest parts of any ghost story are the secrets we keep.

It’s that simple notion that works as the strongest theme throughout the show’s run. And as episode 6 shows, it’s when these literal and symbolic ghosts come to light that the skin-crawling terror becomes way more tactile than we ever thought possible.

The first attention-grabbing detail of the episode comes in its first few minutes: the funeral parlor’s color palate. Various shades of grays and blues give the room a cold, unwelcoming feel, perfect for the events that end up playing out. Then, once each member of the Crain family steps into the room wearing their own shades of blues and grays, it’s clear the set dressing has more symbolism than previously thought.

Steve Dietl/Netflix
(Photo by Steve Dietl/Netflix)

That point is further driven home once we see young Nell, who died an unfortunate death upon returning to Hill House, dressed head-to-toe in bold red inside her open coffin. Much like Hill House’s red room door, Nell stands out and is now similarly inaccessible, having been swallowed into the room and ultimately to her death. It seems that even in death, Nell was just as mysterious to her family as she was in life.

Of course, once the family reunites under this roof, the drama ignites. Secrets, lies, addictions, resentment — they all join together in a flurry. And as spacious as the set seems to feel, the combination of excellent camera work and top-notch acting brings the audience even closer to the action in the most unexpected of ways.

One of the most impactful scenes in the episode happens in the story’s first half: an ultra-long shot inside the funeral home follows different characters through the length of the set, exploring multiple angles and story developments, without cutting. As the conflict plays out on screen during that 18-minute period, the horror show bleeds into the realm of intimate stage play. The movement of the camera matches each character’s struggles with grief and as the heartstrings get violently plucked, the cinematography twists in circles around everyone, suddenly becoming its own important character. With all the ghosts hiding in the tapestry of the show, what’s to say that our own perspective of the events doesn’t play a part?

Steve Dietl/Netflix
(Photo by Steve Dietl/Netflix)

But Mike Flanagan doesn’t give us the typical fly-on-the-wall stylings of a cinéma vérité flick. Instead, we’re brought into the drama, closer and closer, to the point where it almost feels like the camera is the storm in question — with the Crain family stuck right in its chaotic eye.

And just as the viewers think they have their bearings, some seamless editing shifts the show’s timelines altogether, throwing the characters and audience alike back into the past, into a storm of a different kind. With a crashing chandelier and the shattering of windows, “Two Storms” foreshadows Olivia’s (Gugino) murderous psychosis, while young Nell physically briefly disappears from reality altogether. Both in the funeral parlor and Hill House, episode 6 successfully drives home the point that trauma has no expiration date and locking this monster behind a door, in a box, or down in the basement is just one more questionable life choice that will eventually resurface in need of a reckoning.

Great news for horror fans: Flanagan is next writing and directing one of the most anticipated feature films of 2020, Doctor Sleep, based on Stephen King’s novel of the same name, which is a sequel to The Shining. The film follows a grown-up Danny Torrance, still psychic and as messed-up as ever. It stars Ewan McGregor.

The Haunting of Hill House is now streaming on Netflix.

Adjusted Score: 99.493%
Critics Consensus: The Haunting of Hill House is an effective ghost story whose steadily mounting anticipation is just as satisfying as its chilling payoff.
Synopsis: The Haunting of Hill House is a modern reimagining of Shirley Jackson's legendary novel of the same name, about five... [More]

Tag Cloud

singing competition Hallmark Avengers Epix nature Photos Universal Classic Film Marvel Video Games free movies MCU DirecTV sports Disney streaming service batman Marvel Television Film supernatural police drama historical drama Certified Fresh IFC Films CBS All Access 2018 blaxploitation See It Skip It Netflix finale thriller Holidays miniseries psychological thriller CNN name the review Dark Horse Comics composers GIFs The Walking Dead LGBTQ Walt Disney Pictures FXX television Apple TV Plus Emmy Nominations ghosts Comics on TV Ghostbusters Holiday First Reviews latino aliens Calendar President cops strong female leads Year in Review Netflix Christmas movies doctor who joker Pirates Reality Competition NYCC video screenings zombie game of thrones binge slashers Women's History Month Lionsgate technology cults Nickelodeon MSNBC Fantasy BBC America Chernobyl Family romance dramedy anime Britbox E! spy thriller Drama TLC Mary Poppins Returns Shudder green book what to watch Podcast sitcom Apple crime drama comic Turner Classic Movies FX cancelled television Emmys Amazon Prime Video social media streaming 21st Century Fox The Witch Stephen King Animation Sci-Fi Teen boxoffice VH1 2016 Action rotten movies we love political drama anthology CW Seed comiccon YA Kids & Family Cartoon Network canceled TV shows Captain marvel Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt serial killer Ovation ABC Family unscripted blockbuster breaking bad science fiction Box Office LGBT 20th Century Fox hispanic Trivia USA APB SundanceTV Extras DC streaming service Biopics Paramount Trailer Black Mirror Mary poppins Best and Worst Heroines Character Guide Star Wars documentary Red Carpet adventure USA Network Endgame zero dark thirty Spring TV YouTube Premium Reality mockumentary TV Land directors Quiz 2017 Television Academy casting DC Comics justice league Sundance TV Showtime 2020 Anna Paquin Apple TV+ Starz TV dragons Christmas First Look RT21 Binge Guide Comedy Central jamie lee curtis Baby Yoda Hallmark Christmas movies spider-man A&E Music FOX politics Toys VICE Acorn TV halloween south america ITV biography Disney Pride Month ESPN Cosplay Pixar sequel golden globes Nominations 007 Country San Diego Comic-Con comics Valentine's Day Horror WarnerMedia war TCA 2017 Countdown History Mystery DGA Academy Awards Lifetime Christmas movies Crackle BET natural history Disney Plus Winners Trophy Talk IFC foreign Rocky Lifetime Amazon Prime Summer Sneak Peek game show Peacock Syfy X-Men based on movie Fox News Rock TruTV El Rey Chilling Adventures of Sabrina E3 Cannes Spectrum Originals richard e. Grant quibi Amazon adaptation witnail canceled renewed TV shows Infographic Awards Writers Guild of America dc crossover Paramount Network travel medical drama Mary Tyler Moore cartoon MTV versus Elton John Rocketman Warner Bros. facebook Martial Arts Musical Musicals Bravo revenge Western book Disney+ Disney Plus theme song RT History cooking Superheroe WGN ABC YouTube Red Nat Geo The Arrangement teaser The Purge Winter TV SDCC sag awards 2015 zombies cars Hulu TBS hist Grammys Oscars Star Trek Spike Tubi Rom-Com Vudu Tumblr Awards Tour Comedy christmas movies cancelled TV shows Film Festival indie period drama mutant movies CBS Interview PaleyFest NBC true crime A24 Set visit Discovery Channel TIFF AMC Comic Book Sundance 24 frames space TV renewals PBS Song of Ice and Fire ratings BBC Thanksgiving Mudbound Opinion discovery spain diversity Arrowverse Tomatazos Brie Larson stand-up comedy Food Network GoT cancelled Lucasfilm children's TV 2019 Mindy Kaling Premiere Dates Watching Series independent Creative Arts Emmys Columbia Pictures Pop Sundance Now cancelled TV series Crunchyroll American Society of Cinematographers TCM kids TCA HBO Esquire HBO Max romantic comedy OneApp Election The CW TCA Winter 2020 festivals New York Comic Con Pet Sematary disaster psycho Polls and Games Super Bowl series Sony Pictures Freeform animated tv talk spanish language crime reboot National Geographic screen actors guild crime thriller Fall TV Logo CMT 45 Turner YouTube DC Universe award winner talk show OWN harry potter transformers cinemax Disney Channel Schedule Superheroes Adult Swim SXSW Shondaland Marvel Studios elevated horror Masterpiece Ellie Kemper docudrama Marathons Tarantino spinoff 71st Emmy Awards robots cats toy story dceu GLAAD TNT werewolf vampires