Critics Consensus

Gemini Man Is Visually Ambitious but Bland

Plus, The Addams Family plays it too safe, Parasite and Little Monsters are Certified Fresh, and guess Jexi's Tomatometer.

by | October 10, 2019 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got carbon-copied killers (Gemini Man, starring Will Smith and Will Smith), kooky kinfolk (The Addams Family, featuring the voices of Charlize Theron and Oscar Isaac), and stalker Siri (Jexi, starring Adam DeVine and Rose Byrne). What are the critics saying?


Gemini Man (2019) 26%

There are few stars left who can carry a film on charisma alone, and Will Smith is one of them. So what happens when you cast him in an action blockbuster opposite… himself? That’s what we find out this week in Gemini ManAng Lee‘s sci-fi thriller about an aging assassin (Smith) on the cusp of retirement who suddenly finds himself on the run from an agent hired by his old employers. Surprise — it’s actually a cloned, younger version of himself! If this all sounds a bit familiar, that’s because the film was originally conceived some 20 years ago, and in that time we’ve gotten movies like The IslandThe 6th DayTimecrimes, and Looper, many of which cover similar territory (especially Looper). Critics say that Gemini Man is helped by Smith’s presence in the lead role, as well as some of Lee’s intriguing directorial decisions, but the de-aging technology used to create the younger Will Smith dips a little too far into the uncanny valley, and despite some committed performances by the cast, the storytelling is rote and dated, packed with ineffective one-liners and groanworthy dialogue.


The Addams Family (2019) 43%

When cartoonist Charles Addams created The Addams Family back in 1938, there was no way he could have known that it would blossom into a multi-media franchise. His satirical take on the prototypical nuclear American family became a successful television series in the 1960s, spawning an animated series in the 1970s, a pair of cult classic films in the early 1990s, and yet another animated series shortly thereafter. And that doesn’t even cover the video games, the stage musical, and various other forms of entertainment based on the characters. This week, we get the latest iteration on the big screen in The Addams Family, an animated film that not only boasts a stacked voice cast that includes Charlize Theron, Oscar Isaac, Chloë Grace Moretz, Finn Wolfhard, Allison Janney, and Bette Midler (plus even more, but whew!), but also incorporates character designs directly inspired by Addams’ original cartoons. The story follows the kooky titular family as they flee yet another town that misunderstands them and settle into an abandoned asylum in New Jersey, only to butt heads with a home improvement reality show host whose goal is to homogenize the entire town. The Addamses have always stood for the power of individuality and represented the part of all of us that sometimes feels like an outsider, which is typically great fodder for a children’s film, but critics say The Addams Family mostly misses the mark. Not only does it drown viewers in its sweetness, its script is somehow both altogether predictable and disappointingly disjointed to feel like a single cohesive tale. It’s probably plenty engaging for toddlers, but it may be hit-or-miss for anyone older than that.


Jexi (2019) 11%

As long as we’re doing high-concept movies this week, we might as well talk about Jexi. Adam DeVine stars in this comedy about a phone-obsessed pop culture writer named Phil whose life begins to change for the better when some new A.I. software called “Jexi” (voiced by Rose Byrne) boosts his confidence and helps him make some smart decisions. The downside? As things start to look up for Phil, Jexi gets jealous and resorts to all kinds of shenanigans to keep him to herself. This is, in other words, something of a cross between Her and Fatal Attraction, and we’d love to be able to tell you what the critics thought, but the film wasn’t widely screened for critics. You know what that means: take a stab at what you think Jexi‘s Tomatometer will be in the comments!


Also Opening This Week In Limited Release

  • Parasite (Gisaengchung) (2019)Bong Joon-ho‘s Palme d’Or-winning mystery about a family of con artists whose scam on wealthy benefactors is jeopardized by an unexpected development, is Certified Fresh at 100%.
  • The Dead Center (2019) , a psychological thriller about a psychiatrist whose treatment of a catatonic patient unleashes something extra, is at 100%.
  • Fantastic Fungi (2019) , a documentary that dives into the world of mushrooms, is at 100%.
  • Little Monsters (2019) , starring Lupita Nyong’o in a horror-comedy about a teacher and slacker chaperone who attempt to protect their kindergarten class when their field trip devolves into a zombie apocalypse, is Certified Fresh at 84%.
  • The King (2019) , starring Timothée Chalamet and Joel Edgerton in David Michôd‘s historical drama about the ascension of King Henry V, is at 70%.
  • Mister America (2019) , starring Tim Heidecker in a political mockumentary about Heidecker’s campaign for District Attorney in San Bernardino, CA, is at 64%.
  • Mary (2019) , starring Gary Oldman and Emily Mortimer in a thriller about a family that embarks on a trip on a boat that may be cursed, is at 0%.

Like this? Subscribe to our newsletter and get more features, news, and guides in your inbox every week.

Tag Cloud

game of thrones TCA Mary Tyler Moore Heroines comics 21st Century Fox Hallmark Christmas movies Animation GIFs Set visit The Purge See It Skip It CNN serial killer tv talk Amazon YA SXSW Nominations Awards Marathons SundanceTV south america LGBT Watching Series sports E! CBS quibi Marvel Studios dceu RT21 joker Lifetime Arrowverse PaleyFest Rock Tumblr Superheroes vampires Comedy Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt space Pixar Interview Mindy Kaling 2018 Martial Arts Showtime TCA 2017 Reality Competition festivals MCU war free movies Star Wars Adult Swim CMT what to watch Marvel rotten movies we love Oscars cooking Dark Horse Comics travel Mystery Certified Fresh San Diego Comic-Con First Look Teen ESPN CBS All Access TV crime thriller mockumentary cults Nat Geo Film Festival TIFF Epix YouTube Spike ABC Tomatazos Pet Sematary Polls and Games Star Trek Western blaxploitation Year in Review Red Carpet crossover APB cars cancelled television DirecTV Anna Paquin Disney streaming service Esquire breaking bad Character Guide Cannes doctor who based on movie Vudu cancelled TV series Nickelodeon Ghostbusters TV Land unscripted crime YouTube Premium spy thriller diversity foreign nature Amazon Prime NYCC anime ABC Family WarnerMedia Walt Disney Pictures Starz facebook hist Amazon Prime Video Pride Month Premiere Dates Chilling Adventures of Sabrina X-Men versus Awards Tour DC Comics Holiday spain zero dark thirty National Geographic Syfy cops Opinion Sundance Now batman zombie dramedy justice league 45 Trailer YouTube Red cartoon Reality talk show Women's History Month Disney technology Lucasfilm Crackle Columbia Pictures Disney+ Disney Plus thriller Christmas hispanic Kids & Family Shudder Acorn TV History Warner Bros. Summer children's TV Logo dragons true crime Film Winter TV psychological thriller Black Mirror Cosplay Creative Arts Emmys VH1 Action Valentine's Day composers Comics on TV Britbox ghosts teaser zombies game show canceled TV shows ratings USA MSNBC Fantasy Netflix police drama psycho Extras christmas movies El Rey Photos CW Seed book Ovation streaming renewed TV shows theme song TruTV Ellie Kemper Country toy story RT History Video Games Rocketman Lifetime Christmas movies Paramount Network Calendar binge Sundance Brie Larson TV renewals Television Academy TNT Musical PBS Holidays Family Quiz award winner Binge Guide Apple Mudbound Food Network cinemax TBS cancelled Hallmark ITV Biopics OWN Hulu IFC Films halloween spider-man AMC screenings Sci-Fi Mary poppins TLC The Arrangement Musicals elevated horror Crunchyroll Sony Pictures Toys boxoffice BBC Cartoon Network Stephen King 2015 robots Apple TV Plus Rocky Captain marvel President Freeform animated Trivia A24 Disney Plus science fiction HBO Max comiccon slashers SDCC Horror Emmy Nominations canceled Bravo Comic Book Spring TV Apple TV+ The Walking Dead DGA IFC stand-up comedy crime drama werewolf finale 2019 DC streaming service New York Comic Con 2020 Disney Channel historical drama Trophy Talk Song of Ice and Fire Fall TV cats Elton John VICE period drama cancelled TV shows discovery BET supernatural Rom-Com 2016 independent Emmys FX medical drama FXX Fox News singing competition BBC America latino sequel Countdown The CW American Society of Cinematographers Podcast strong female leads Netflix Christmas movies MTV Pop Writers Guild of America Sneak Peek DC Universe sitcom 71st Emmy Awards spanish language 20th Century Fox Thanksgiving political drama harry potter Grammys Paramount movies comic disaster social media 2017 Box Office 24 frames WGN Mary Poppins Returns The Witch GoT Tarantino Super Bowl Infographic Drama Spectrum Originals golden globes LGBTQ 007 witnail Comedy Central romance Chernobyl HBO series Winners Superheroe Election Pirates politics USA Network Lionsgate mutant Turner Classic Movies Schedule docudrama casting biography Turner Marvel Television jamie lee curtis miniseries Best and Worst indie adventure Shondaland spinoff revenge Music kids romantic comedy A&E blockbuster natural history television richard e. Grant aliens adaptation transformers video TCM Masterpiece Universal NBC E3 anthology FOX First Reviews GLAAD dc Peacock green book Classic Film