Critics Consensus

Gemini Man Is Visually Ambitious but Bland

Plus, The Addams Family plays it too safe, Parasite and Little Monsters are Certified Fresh, and guess Jexi's Tomatometer.

by | October 10, 2019 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got carbon-copied killers (Gemini Man, starring Will Smith and Will Smith), kooky kinfolk (The Addams Family, featuring the voices of Charlize Theron and Oscar Isaac), and stalker Siri (Jexi, starring Adam DeVine and Rose Byrne). What are the critics saying?


Gemini Man (2019) 26%

There are few stars left who can carry a film on charisma alone, and Will Smith is one of them. So what happens when you cast him in an action blockbuster opposite… himself? That’s what we find out this week in Gemini ManAng Lee‘s sci-fi thriller about an aging assassin (Smith) on the cusp of retirement who suddenly finds himself on the run from an agent hired by his old employers. Surprise — it’s actually a cloned, younger version of himself! If this all sounds a bit familiar, that’s because the film was originally conceived some 20 years ago, and in that time we’ve gotten movies like The IslandThe 6th DayTimecrimes, and Looper, many of which cover similar territory (especially Looper). Critics say that Gemini Man is helped by Smith’s presence in the lead role, as well as some of Lee’s intriguing directorial decisions, but the de-aging technology used to create the younger Will Smith dips a little too far into the uncanny valley, and despite some committed performances by the cast, the storytelling is rote and dated, packed with ineffective one-liners and groanworthy dialogue.


The Addams Family (2019) 43%

When cartoonist Charles Addams created The Addams Family back in 1938, there was no way he could have known that it would blossom into a multi-media franchise. His satirical take on the prototypical nuclear American family became a successful television series in the 1960s, spawning an animated series in the 1970s, a pair of cult classic films in the early 1990s, and yet another animated series shortly thereafter. And that doesn’t even cover the video games, the stage musical, and various other forms of entertainment based on the characters. This week, we get the latest iteration on the big screen in The Addams Family, an animated film that not only boasts a stacked voice cast that includes Charlize Theron, Oscar Isaac, Chloë Grace Moretz, Finn Wolfhard, Allison Janney, and Bette Midler (plus even more, but whew!), but also incorporates character designs directly inspired by Addams’ original cartoons. The story follows the kooky titular family as they flee yet another town that misunderstands them and settle into an abandoned asylum in New Jersey, only to butt heads with a home improvement reality show host whose goal is to homogenize the entire town. The Addamses have always stood for the power of individuality and represented the part of all of us that sometimes feels like an outsider, which is typically great fodder for a children’s film, but critics say The Addams Family mostly misses the mark. Not only does it drown viewers in its sweetness, its script is somehow both altogether predictable and disappointingly disjointed to feel like a single cohesive tale. It’s probably plenty engaging for toddlers, but it may be hit-or-miss for anyone older than that.


Jexi (2019) 14%

As long as we’re doing high-concept movies this week, we might as well talk about Jexi. Adam DeVine stars in this comedy about a phone-obsessed pop culture writer named Phil whose life begins to change for the better when some new A.I. software called “Jexi” (voiced by Rose Byrne) boosts his confidence and helps him make some smart decisions. The downside? As things start to look up for Phil, Jexi gets jealous and resorts to all kinds of shenanigans to keep him to herself. This is, in other words, something of a cross between Her and Fatal Attraction, and we’d love to be able to tell you what the critics thought, but the film wasn’t widely screened for critics. You know what that means: take a stab at what you think Jexi‘s Tomatometer will be in the comments!


Also Opening This Week In Limited Release

  • Parasite (Gisaengchung) (2019)Bong Joon-ho‘s Palme d’Or-winning mystery about a family of con artists whose scam on wealthy benefactors is jeopardized by an unexpected development, is Certified Fresh at 100%.
  • The Dead Center (2019) , a psychological thriller about a psychiatrist whose treatment of a catatonic patient unleashes something extra, is at 100%.
  • Fantastic Fungi (2019) , a documentary that dives into the world of mushrooms, is at 100%.
  • Little Monsters (2019) , starring Lupita Nyong’o in a horror-comedy about a teacher and slacker chaperone who attempt to protect their kindergarten class when their field trip devolves into a zombie apocalypse, is Certified Fresh at 84%.
  • The King (2019) , starring Timothée Chalamet and Joel Edgerton in David Michôd‘s historical drama about the ascension of King Henry V, is at 70%.
  • Mister America (2019) , starring Tim Heidecker in a political mockumentary about Heidecker’s campaign for District Attorney in San Bernardino, CA, is at 64%.
  • Mary (2019) , starring Gary Oldman and Emily Mortimer in a thriller about a family that embarks on a trip on a boat that may be cursed, is at 0%.

Like this? Subscribe to our newsletter and get more features, news, and guides in your inbox every week.

Tag Cloud

PBS FX Pop BBC ABC Family Heroines Western politics TBS quibi MSNBC scary movies spain VICE SDCC discovery kids Arrowverse anthology Chernobyl E! Marvel Esquire Mystery dragons Nickelodeon Tumblr GLAAD slashers reboot 20th Century Fox cinemax Ovation LGBT YouTube Premium cults NYCC cars CW Seed El Rey TV Land Avengers NBC Interview war Bravo sports toy story children's TV HBO Max Amazon Prime Thanksgiving crime Super Bowl DC Comics Schedule Apple TV Plus Superheroe Paramount Calendar documentary crime thriller Acorn TV Shudder The Arrangement OWN Paramount Network dogs CBS All Access Pop TV game of thrones Sci-Fi Watching Series spinoff aliens cancelled TV shows Disney crossover Marathons blockbuster game show FOX Endgame Rock Trailer CNN Brie Larson APB HBO Polls and Games YouTube book Biopics halloween GoT Quiz AMC Star Wars FXX Photos cancelled television DC Universe Academy Awards Song of Ice and Fire police drama theme song award winner TCA American Society of Cinematographers cooking Turner Classic Movies Kids & Family The Witch Star Trek Musical witnail Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Crunchyroll blaxploitation 007 Lionsgate binge Family TCA 2017 reviews teaser Horror Valentine's Day 21st Century Fox cops 24 frames Turner natural history psychological thriller OneApp Adult Swim 2015 robots Travel Channel Cannes Infographic Extras Shondaland Box Office Superheroes strong female leads The CW Elton John The Walking Dead screenings Starz Mary Poppins Returns dramedy Emmys Sneak Peek President TruTV 2018 Epix History TIFF biography jamie lee curtis LGBTQ Premiere Dates Baby Yoda tv talk Awards Tour Marvel Television social media true crime Reality IFC Films Disney+ Disney Plus Certified Fresh GIFs Disney Channel transformers stand-up comedy breaking bad comic Women's History Month YouTube Red Apple BBC America period drama Amazon Studios Ellie Kemper miniseries screen actors guild Trivia Tubi south america adaptation Cartoon Network sag awards ITV Creative Arts Emmys Pet Sematary Netflix Emmy Nominations Lifetime comiccon Marvel Studios Grammys dceu harry potter Sony Pictures hispanic ABC television E3 Disney streaming service spy thriller Comics on TV Tomatazos DGA DC streaming service space versus universal monsters Christmas See It Skip It movies Comic Book CMT Reality Competition Lucasfilm cartoon nature cancelled TV series supernatural zombie disaster franchise Spectrum Originals political drama romantic comedy Ghostbusters Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Lifetime Christmas movies TNT Black Mirror Red Carpet Set visit Comedy Central mockumentary Countdown USA Country Video Games Cosplay singing competition casting FX on Hulu richard e. Grant romance boxoffice psycho rotten movies we love Crackle WarnerMedia based on movie medical drama Columbia Pictures Disney Plus sequel Rocketman foreign Sundance Hallmark Christmas movies Mindy Kaling directors Mary Tyler Moore New York Comic Con RT History science fiction streaming Animation historical drama series ghosts 2016 werewolf serial killer 71st Emmy Awards Funimation spanish language elevated horror Election Opinion 2019 Film Festival Music Drama Film 2020 composers Netflix Christmas movies Syfy Black History Month Best and Worst what to watch Showtime Pride Month BET Sundance Now anime Spring TV The Purge MTV Year in Review TV Stephen King Mary poppins Mudbound Winter TV DirecTV zero dark thirty free movies First Reviews justice league revenge 2017 Discovery Channel Universal Captain marvel TCM Nominations WGN Food Network YA Fall TV talk show sitcom zombies animated Toys Martial Arts VH1 crime drama ESPN Winners vampires Apple TV+ National Geographic facebook dc Television Academy Pirates First Look Masterpiece cancelled Anna Paquin Freeform canceled TV shows Classic Film Spike Comedy Tarantino Action Sundance TV Britbox cats adventure Rocky hist docudrama A&E green book Podcast name the review Character Guide San Diego Comic-Con Vudu Awards A24 Musicals canceled Teen independent christmas movies Summer mutant batman spider-man video Fox News TLC Hulu Trophy Talk Pixar Binge Guide finale Holiday TCA Winter 2020 Logo USA Network SXSW joker Fantasy latino Hallmark movie diversity Nat Geo golden globes X-Men PaleyFest IFC MCU renewed TV shows CBS 45 thriller technology ratings doctor who Dark Horse Comics Rom-Com Peacock Walt Disney Pictures Warner Bros. festivals Amazon RT21 unscripted Amazon Prime Video Holidays Oscars travel indie Writers Guild of America comics SundanceTV TV renewals