Critics Consensus

Fantasy Island, Underwater, and The Rhythm Section Hit Digital Release This Week

As more people self-quarantine at home, we run down the most notable films hitting VOD and early digital release.

by | April 16, 2020 | Comments

As more and more people are compelled to practice social distancing and encouraged to stay home, as movie theaters temporarily shutter their doors, and as studios continue to pull their scheduled 2020 films off the release calendar, we’ve decided to reformat this weekly Critics Consensus column to focus on titles that are newly available on the home entertainment market. With that in mind, our list of digital new releases this week includes a trio of thrillers – one about an insidious vacation destination, one about deep-sea terror, and one about a fledgling vigilante on the warpath. See below for the full list.


Blumhouse's Fantasy Island (2020) 8%

The late 1970s/early 1980s TV series Fantasy Island always had something of a Twilight Zone-esque feel to it, what with people living out their deepest, wildest fantasies “for a price,” so it didn’t seem entirely unreasonable for the good people over at Blumhouse to take that premise and mine it for horror thrills. In this big screen adaptation, Michael Peña plays Mr. Roarke, the titular island’s mysterious proprietor and host, who welcomes a group of young visitors and sets about introducing them to the wish-fulfillment scenarios that will inevitably go sideways and force them to fight for their lives. Unfortunately, despite a premise with some potential, Fantasy Island was savaged by critics, who called it thinly plotted, populated by generic characters, and overly reliant on the most predictable horror movie cliches, en route to a 7% on the Tomatometer. That said, it did make a decent chunk of change at the box office, so don’t be surprised if Blumhouse decides it’s worth another visit.

Available now on: FandangoNOWAmazonGoogle PlayiTunesVudu


Underwater (2020) 47%

If something about Underwater feels familiar, that may be because it wears its influences on its very wet sleeve. Taking its cues from isolation-based horror classics like Alien and The Thing, this thriller centers on the crew of a deep-sea research and drilling vessel that is hit hard by an earthquake, forcing them to flee for the refuge of another underwater station a mile away. At the same time, the crew become aware that they are being hunted by creatures of unknown origin. Critics were split on Underwater, with some calling it stylish and well-acted enough to serve as a satisfactory diversion, while others called it too blatantly and blandly derivative to leave a lasting impression. This one made just below what Fantasy Island did at the box office, but it also cost a lot more to make, so even if Underwater got better reviews, don’t expect it to be the beginning of a new franchise.

Available now on: FandangoNOW, AmazonGoogle PlayiTunesVudu


The Rhythm Section (2020) 29%

You might be thinking to yourself, “Gee, the new movies available on digital this week aren’t particularly good,” and you’d be right, at least judging from the Tomatometer scores. But it’s also understandable, considering these are all January and February releases – i.e. historically not the most optimal time to find quality cinema playing at your local theaters. With that in mind, it shouldn’t be surprising that yet another female vigilante/super-spy action-thriller failed to generate much excitement for critics, even if it was based on a novel, produced by the people behind the James Bond movies, and starred a committed Blake Lively. The story follows an Oxford-educated woman whose life has crumbled after her family was killed in a plane crash. When she’s approached with information that the crash wasn’t an accident, she embarks on a journey that finds her training to become an assassin and plotting her revenge. It’s a familiar template that’s been utilized, in one way or another, several times before, both in much better movies and in much worse ones. It’s not likely this will go down as one of the more memorable efforts, unfortunately.

Available now on: FandangoNOWAmazonGoogle PlayiTunesVudu


Thumbnail image by Columbia Pictures

Tag Cloud

Britbox TNT cancelled television ID A&E franchise kids spider-man animated scary movies Pirates stand-up comedy dogs Western laika zombie streaming slasher Paramount Network BAFTA Tumblr Winter TV Certified Fresh rt labs Fox Searchlight Comedy kaiju Crunchyroll Mary Tyler Moore Watching Series criterion Comedy Central Film period drama Pop SDCC basketball Hallmark Christmas movies genre HBO Max Dark Horse Comics suspense Fantasy police drama action-comedy Trailer MTV BET cinemax El Rey Rocky japanese Mudbound Netflix Christmas movies emmy awards robots technology aliens Pixar book E3 tv talk news Amazon Studios 21st Century Fox diversity Best and Worst GIFs italian Video Games First Reviews documentary facebook GLAAD AMC child's play canceled Esquire Family Nominations Comic-Con@Home 2021 IFC Films Rom-Com Biopics Tubi Disney+ Disney Plus mcc LGBT CNN adventure Nat Geo godzilla asian-american Exclusive Video SundanceTV Writers Guild of America Lucasfilm blockbusters strong female leads name the review art house worst high school Legendary docudrama Food Network joker 90s popular king kong LGBTQ adaptation A24 YouTube PaleyFest Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Ellie Kemper prank Rocketman Sundance TV TruTV USA vampires indie quibi films latino The Purge Trivia TBS Teen Baby Yoda ABC Signature Women's History Month Disney Channel The CW Cannes christmas movies ViacomCBS Music trailers TCA Winter 2020 TCM Podcast binge Emmy Nominations scorecard Polls and Games BBC One singing competition 007 comic book movies FX on Hulu OneApp crime drama Cartoon Network classics President Valentine's Day Image Comics australia Apple OWN biography nature Spectrum Originals Nickelodeon superhero Amazon Prime Video The Walt Disney Company television Sony Pictures science fiction spy thriller international game show Marvel Television Extras breaking bad MSNBC 2019 lord of the rings Winners AMC Plus Comic Book Reality travel fast and furious Infographic Pet Sematary dceu elevated horror Television Academy VOD docuseries werewolf true crime CMT Hear Us Out YA women hidden camera new york 2016 Universal canceled TV shows The Academy directors award winner Summer finale unscripted sopranos cats Avengers Black History Month reboot romantic comedy Epix telelvision political drama mutant Reality Competition politics medical drama spanish razzies WarnerMedia Tokyo Olympics Emmys die hard ghosts olympics dragons marvel comics transformers History Marvel 2015 halloween tv disaster The Witch stoner Lifetime Christmas movies Instagram Live know your critic sag awards cartoon Mary Poppins Returns aapi twilight E! Turner Classic Movies based on movie Hallmark PBS teaser Superheroes Starz chucky Awards Tour Funimation Freeform Kids & Family Drama boxing Musicals Ghostbusters Pacific Islander BET Awards independent Spring TV Premiere Dates heist movie comics black comedy rom-coms 2020 TCA Awards spinoff festivals Holiday Peacock miniseries Film Festival wonder woman posters social media obituary TV DGA SXSW natural history cults cancelled TV shows cancelled TV series YouTube Premium spanish language Endgame crime thriller cancelled screen actors guild vs. Broadway Trophy Talk toronto Sundance Masterpiece book adaptation DC Universe game of thrones dexter nfl stop motion The Walking Dead DC Comics Apple TV Plus Shondaland NYCC San Diego Comic-Con Logo RT History hispanic DirecTV spain Ovation sitcom Hulu PlayStation 45 Martial Arts Wes Anderson reviews Oscars cars black football Walt Disney Pictures Turner hispanic heritage month legend best Arrowverse cooking cops Anna Paquin richard e. Grant Shudder CW Seed Netflix remakes revenge TV movies Horror movie Character Guide 72 Emmy Awards 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards crossover king arthur Red Carpet zombies golden globe awards universal monsters zero dark thirty anime rotten Cosplay Song of Ice and Fire blaxploitation First Look james bond ratings NBC TLC comic war Black Mirror Pop TV dramedy Tarantino Grammys FXX Holidays Christmas sports Marvel Studios Year in Review critics Binge Guide documentaries comiccon Musical Showtime See It Skip It blockbuster jamie lee curtis RT21 2021 live event rt labs critics edition Opinion National Geographic mockumentary Calendar Fall TV 24 frames Travel Channel Amazon Prime BBC America new zealand 71st Emmy Awards critic resources Mindy Kaling Mary poppins biopic 1990s Fox News Sundance Now deadpool Star Wars hist comedies children's TV streaming movies scary new star wars movies witnail mission: impossible crime supernatural Rock Apple TV+ casting Discovery Channel mob Creative Arts Emmys screenings Action royal family ABC Family jurassic park psychological thriller slashers sequels X-Men Toys dark ESPN Box Office nbcuniversal Lifetime japan rt archives festival comic books DC streaming service indiana jones USA Network 4/20 Countdown Universal Pictures Set visit Country Stephen King BBC TCA 2017 video versus WGN saw a nightmare on elm street renewed TV shows Mystery free movies Star Trek Lionsgate series justice league adenture VH1 thriller Super Bowl Paramount hollywood TV One American Society of Cinematographers Spike TV Land batman Bravo pirates of the caribbean 2018 french spider-verse Sneak Peek Amazon target Quiz toy story harry potter psycho Classic Film venice rotten movies we love 73rd Emmy Awards GoT parents Animation Television Critics Association fresh Superheroe CBS All Access Brie Larson New York Comic Con Neflix MCU serial killer halloween Acorn TV space satire Crackle video on demand TV renewals romance Disney Plus young adult ABC what to watch The Arrangement Captain marvel comic book movie debate Schedule doctor who YouTube Red Paramount Plus Interview Warner Bros. theme song movies historical drama Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt feel good worst movies HBO HBO Go 99% boxoffice live action IMDb TV NBA Disney superman 93rd Oscars Disney streaming service Tomatazos IFC sequel Vudu Awards green book Chernobyl TIFF Election Alien kong ITV Comics on TV FX Thanksgiving golden globes monster movies VICE scene in color APB archives Sci-Fi Syfy anthology foreign marvel cinematic universe TCA Marathons Elton John Pride Month south america FOX Adult Swim gangster Columbia Pictures Photos dreamworks discovery dc CBS 20th Century Fox Academy Awards composers Heroines concert 2017 all-time talk show