Critics Consensus

Fantasy Island, Underwater, and The Rhythm Section Hit Digital Release This Week

As more people self-quarantine at home, we run down the most notable films hitting VOD and early digital release.

by | April 16, 2020 | Comments

As more and more people are compelled to practice social distancing and encouraged to stay home, as movie theaters temporarily shutter their doors, and as studios continue to pull their scheduled 2020 films off the release calendar, we’ve decided to reformat this weekly Critics Consensus column to focus on titles that are newly available on the home entertainment market. With that in mind, our list of digital new releases this week includes a trio of thrillers – one about an insidious vacation destination, one about deep-sea terror, and one about a fledgling vigilante on the warpath. See below for the full list.


Blumhouse's Fantasy Island (2020) 8%

The late 1970s/early 1980s TV series Fantasy Island always had something of a Twilight Zone-esque feel to it, what with people living out their deepest, wildest fantasies “for a price,” so it didn’t seem entirely unreasonable for the good people over at Blumhouse to take that premise and mine it for horror thrills. In this big screen adaptation, Michael Peña plays Mr. Roarke, the titular island’s mysterious proprietor and host, who welcomes a group of young visitors and sets about introducing them to the wish-fulfillment scenarios that will inevitably go sideways and force them to fight for their lives. Unfortunately, despite a premise with some potential, Fantasy Island was savaged by critics, who called it thinly plotted, populated by generic characters, and overly reliant on the most predictable horror movie cliches, en route to a 7% on the Tomatometer. That said, it did make a decent chunk of change at the box office, so don’t be surprised if Blumhouse decides it’s worth another visit.

Available now on: FandangoNOWAmazonGoogle PlayiTunesVudu


Underwater (2020) 47%

If something about Underwater feels familiar, that may be because it wears its influences on its very wet sleeve. Taking its cues from isolation-based horror classics like Alien and The Thing, this thriller centers on the crew of a deep-sea research and drilling vessel that is hit hard by an earthquake, forcing them to flee for the refuge of another underwater station a mile away. At the same time, the crew become aware that they are being hunted by creatures of unknown origin. Critics were split on Underwater, with some calling it stylish and well-acted enough to serve as a satisfactory diversion, while others called it too blatantly and blandly derivative to leave a lasting impression. This one made just below what Fantasy Island did at the box office, but it also cost a lot more to make, so even if Underwater got better reviews, don’t expect it to be the beginning of a new franchise.

Available now on: FandangoNOW, AmazonGoogle PlayiTunesVudu


The Rhythm Section (2020) 29%

You might be thinking to yourself, “Gee, the new movies available on digital this week aren’t particularly good,” and you’d be right, at least judging from the Tomatometer scores. But it’s also understandable, considering these are all January and February releases – i.e. historically not the most optimal time to find quality cinema playing at your local theaters. With that in mind, it shouldn’t be surprising that yet another female vigilante/super-spy action-thriller failed to generate much excitement for critics, even if it was based on a novel, produced by the people behind the James Bond movies, and starred a committed Blake Lively. The story follows an Oxford-educated woman whose life has crumbled after her family was killed in a plane crash. When she’s approached with information that the crash wasn’t an accident, she embarks on a journey that finds her training to become an assassin and plotting her revenge. It’s a familiar template that’s been utilized, in one way or another, several times before, both in much better movies and in much worse ones. It’s not likely this will go down as one of the more memorable efforts, unfortunately.

Available now on: FandangoNOWAmazonGoogle PlayiTunesVudu


Thumbnail image by Columbia Pictures

Tag Cloud

Disney Channel discovery Writers Guild of America crossover Spectrum Originals halloween tv art house Walt Disney Pictures royal family Pixar transformers IFC 2021 twilight RT21 basketball Reality Martial Arts composers docuseries Ovation video canceled TV shows cats Acorn TV VH1 Fargo spider-man marvel cinematic universe what to watch universal monsters Hulu Oscars crime drama Spring TV Best Picture TV Land Apple TV Plus Fox News emmy awards worst movies Tumblr X-Men saw boxing cancelled TV shows TV movies animated adventure MTV E3 television based on movie 79th Golden Globes Awards Apple TV+ Lucasfilm batman Oscar women scary Comedy medical drama ratings zero dark thirty telelvision Star Wars Shudder Nickelodeon Bravo YA Netflix Christmas movies south america crime spanish language canceled A&E king kong Academy Awards Mary Tyler Moore worst social media Classic Film Star Trek VOD Epix Focus Features 73rd Emmy Awards Best Director Marvel Studios Spike Trailer tv talk Binge Guide leaderboard japan Family gangster TV One Comic-Con@Home 2021 HFPA unscripted CBS All Access Thanksgiving natural history Marvel Television genre Disney Plus new star wars movies Prime Video Teen technology summer preview TLC LGBTQ Instagram Live YouTube Premium films DGA jamie lee curtis President ghosts Super Bowl comics 2017 First Look El Rey singing competition strong female leads Image Comics festival Winners MGM The Walt Disney Company Awards Tour stoner vs. CNN Best Actress comedies monster movies Valentine's Day Cannes debate olympics nature Disney streaming service jurassic park james bond Baby Yoda hist PaleyFest Sundance Pride Month Black Mirror action-comedy GIFs GLAAD comic Pop TV Emmy Nominations psychological thriller hispanic cults Arrowverse TV renewals Film Festival movies australia Universal Pictures razzies Brie Larson Podcast laika travel 24 frames legend CBS DC Comics Summer justice league sequels talk show Hallmark Masterpiece renewed TV shows dc serial killer zombies Esquire scary movies AMC Plus Chilling Adventures of Sabrina toy story Mindy Kaling Creative Arts Emmys Nominations Ellie Kemper comiccon Lifetime Lionsgate nbcuniversal Sci-Fi spanish NYCC Extras SundanceTV video on demand Anna Paquin Alien Christmas NBC new york kids The Witch Opinion See It Skip It deadpool Funimation historical drama obi wan SXSW scene in color BET christmas movies cancelled TV series 007 Hear Us Out target The CW stand-up comedy The Walking Dead superman Amazon Prime Video Rock spinoff ESPN Music Hollywood Foreign Press Association 2020 high school Country Musical TV lord of the rings TCA Awards stop motion all-time space marvel comics Sundance Now Britbox dceu comic book movie dexter halloween Cosplay breaking bad rt labs critics edition Endgame know your critic interviews Biopics Dark Horse Comics BBC cartoon FX on Hulu Legendary cinemax Women's History Month thriller period drama 2019 Turner Classic Movies Drama child's play Schedule FXX Food Network CW Seed game of thrones Musicals mob Television Academy series trophy golden globe awards Tags: Comedy Columbia Pictures die hard spy thriller Hallmark Christmas movies psycho Quiz sag awards Winter TV golden globes 2015 HBO Go Logo screen actors guild Television Critics Association YouTube blaxploitation TBS Kids & Family Character Guide king arthur MSNBC Holiday Countdown dark Infographic broadcast criterion FOX aapi romance TCA Winter 2020 Comedy Central Crackle joker Fantasy documentaries rotten boxoffice scorecard TIFF ABC facebook HBO adenture Disney+ Disney Plus New York Comic Con black comedy Polls and Games pirates of the caribbean AMC hidden camera Wes Anderson E! kaiju indie The Purge crime thriller aliens IMDb TV Stephen King free movies Mary poppins Mudbound book critic resources casting PBS streaming movies MCU Tarantino Netflix Tomatazos indiana jones CMT SDCC Grammys Photos foreign Syfy award winner Rocketman Box Office Certified Fresh ABC Signature news politics 72 Emmy Awards Superheroe WGN italian Best and Worst fresh robots live action supernatural Crunchyroll Paramount Pictures book adaptation 4/20 Sundance TV quibi heist movie South by Southwest Film Festival japanese Pet Sematary war football Marvel parents comic book movies ITV Calendar BBC America reviews Captain marvel HBO Max BAFTA TruTV Chernobyl Amazon Pirates prank Set visit best 99% TCA 2017 45 Elton John Horror TNT hollywood Nat Geo 94th Oscars streaming 90s classics Ghostbusters APB docudrama Song of Ice and Fire rt archives mission: impossible DC Universe trailers Broadway Cartoon Network LGBT The Academy romantic comedy VICE Discovery Channel kong blockbusters vampires DC streaming service political drama Awards franchise PlayStation cancelled summer TV preview ViacomCBS Travel Channel First Reviews rotten movies we love police drama spider-verse NBA black Toys Mystery suspense asian-american Peacock Trivia OWN cooking sports Sneak Peek blockbuster Lifetime Christmas movies IFC Films Superheroes dramedy Red Carpet San Diego Comic-Con sopranos witnail diversity fast and furious Comics on TV independent screenings young adult Freeform versus obituary slasher Apple concert Western revenge posters The Arrangement directors slashers game show Vudu chucky Paramount Network finale BBC One Year in Review Reality Competition venice Pop harry potter mutant TCM zombie nfl wonder woman rt labs OneApp science fiction dogs Sony Pictures Interview Mary Poppins Returns Warner Bros. Neflix miniseries Heroines 1990s popular Black History Month Comic Book 2016 movie Showtime BET Awards Marathons international live event superhero green book Shondaland Disney reboot 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards critics A24 summer TV teaser Tokyo Olympics anime name the review binge Paramount Plus Starz mcc werewolf FX Watching Series dragons ABC Family Adult Swim National Geographic biography theme song Amazon Prime Paramount mockumentary hispanic heritage month Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt RT History richard e. Grant satire spain Action disaster latino Film sitcom GoT YouTube Red elevated horror Election 21st Century Fox true crime 2018 adaptation ID french Emmys festivals 71st Emmy Awards Video Games Fox Searchlight Best Actor Rom-Com Rocky WarnerMedia Exclusive Video cancelled television Fall TV Amazon Studios toronto American Society of Cinematographers SXSW 2022 Trophy Talk remakes Animation cops biopic feel good a nightmare on elm street Holidays 20th Century Fox comic books anthology Avengers Turner documentary dreamworks doctor who godzilla archives TCA Universal sequel children's TV Pacific Islander cars DirecTV USA History 93rd Oscars new zealand rom-coms Tubi USA Network Premiere Dates streamig