Critic Resources

Editors' Awards Season Advice for Freelancers

IndieWire, AwardsWatch, AwardsCircuit, and Rotten Tomatoes editors offer advice on covering the year's most coveted films and series.

by | November 22, 2019 | Comments

Regina King

(Photo by John Rasimus / Barcroft Media via Getty Images)

Covering the year’s buzziest movies, series, and chatter during the feverish time period known as “Awards Season” presents unique challenges. Screenings and screeners can be hard to come by, advanced access is limited, and everyone’s trying to articulate increasingly edgier takes about properties that everyone else is writing about, too. But there are ways to cut through. Ahead of the Golden Globes, Guild awards, and Oscars, Rotten Tomatoes asked editors and awards experts what tips they have for freelancers covering the contenders.

Eric Kohn, Executive Editor and Chief Critic, IndieWire

“Read as much as you can from the established pundits who cover awards season and pay attention to the calendar of awards events throughout the year — from the Gothams to the SAG Awards — so you can deepen your understanding of the awards season ecosystem. Your take on the race will have more authority if you make the effort to see how each piece fits into the larger whole.”

Erik Anderson, Founder and Owner, AwardsWatch

“For me, breaking into awards coverage was a 20-year game. I started out in forums, talking about movies, and then building my way up in the ranks, and then ultimately creating my own outlet. That might not be for everyone, but if I had to give any advice to people who want to break in, it would be to say ‘yes’ to everything at first. Publicists will grab onto to you and the reciprocal relationship will hopefully then bring you bigger and better things. I try and answer every email back, even if it’s with a ‘no.’ Be as persistent as they are. It’s respectful and it garners respect. Something else I will tell anyone, freelancer or entrepreneur, know your worth. It took me a long time to get to that, to even knowing what it was. But it made all the difference in the world.”

Clayton Davis, Editor-in-Chief and Owner,

“After removing the ‘glitz’ and ‘glam’ or just merely watching films and meeting stars for a living, you have to ask yourself, why do you WANT to write? If passion is the foundation for your pitches, then the next course of action is to show how your voice is unique in an industry that has so many perspectives and feels oversaturated. Be persistent, but not rude or overbearing when you receive a ‘no’ or a non-response. Get your foot in the door, no matter how trivial, and show what you’re worth when you’re finally inside.”

Rubin Safaya, Executive Editor, AwardsWatch & Cinemalogue

“The most consistent factor impacting a journalist’s visibility is speed. International festival coverage – Cannes, Venice, Toronto, etc. – is early in the cycle. From these reviews, studios pull quotes for FYC campaigns, trailers, one-sheets. In addition to notoriety as one of the first 15 to 20 critics on the Rotten Tomatoes listing for a feature, festivals provide resourceful journalists a feel for the rhythm and flow of the entire cycle: what films are being tapped by distributors for their awards potential, how public and press/industry screenings are shaping the distributors public and trade (FYC) marketing campaigns, and which films public sentiment and critical consensus are likely to coalesce around.”

Jacqueline Coley, Editor, Rotten Tomatoes

“One of the best assets for a freelancer is cultivating positive relationships with editors. Editors get hundreds of pitches a week. Having familiarity with them is always going to fare better than cold calls. So, make the rounds and say hello at screenings, events, or whenever possible. Get contact information and make sure to follow up. The next most important thing for pitches is uniqueness. If a site has four reporters on staff, then don’t pitch an article they could easily staff out. Give perspective or an outlook they would not normally contemplate. Make sure your pitch is tailored to you and make sure to explain why you’ll be the best person for the job. You can do this in the thoughtfulness of the pitch or with the subject matter. Either way – and forgive the quote, but – ‘Make them a pitch they can’t refuse.’ Best of luck, and pitch away.”

Check out more resources for critics from Rotten Tomatoes

Tag Cloud

Netflix Musicals Toys cats Horror reboot First Reviews Quiz classics jamie lee curtis Disney Channel History 20th Century Fox Classic Film VICE DC Universe revenge Apple TV Plus BET Awards Photos batman Christmas Film Festival CBS social media superhero video on demand diversity Ovation Box Office sequels 24 frames Apple TV+ witnail President National Geographic RT History MTV stand-up comedy Starz Watching Series Thanksgiving rotten movies we love TCA Awards critics USA Network transformers comedies PBS FX vampires laika toronto game of thrones Polls and Games ITV Paramount Network nbcuniversal strong female leads scorecard comics Esquire name the review Stephen King HBO technology Fox News discovery elevated horror mission: impossible RT21 SundanceTV christmas movies scary movies Oscars Drama USA Character Guide X-Men zero dark thirty Pixar Masterpiece WarnerMedia YouTube Set visit ratings toy story reviews composers Disney+ Disney Plus cancelled See It Skip It E3 Reality Competition asian-american Kids & Family Action Marvel Studios aliens tv talk Netflix Christmas movies sitcom TV Nominations Awards dceu television spider-man Ellie Kemper ghosts robots PaleyFest all-time Animation Pop TV Awards Tour 007 TCM CW Seed Sundance Now foreign Rom-Com Bravo spinoff Valentine's Day Winter TV Emmys war Television Critics Association Sci-Fi Martial Arts Hear Us Out best Trophy Talk films 2015 Logo Premiere Dates Comic Book HBO Go HBO Max WGN Superheroe Endgame 2018 festival Binge Guide 72 Emmy Awards Paramount adventure Mystery Interview Family Lionsgate Black History Month comic Marvel Trailer The Purge Syfy Podcast Rock free movies police drama Best and Worst blaxploitation versus Nat Geo renewed TV shows Comedy Central football Emmy Nominations documentaries Travel Channel Columbia Pictures Country TLC crime SXSW sequel stoner FXX CBS All Access Lucasfilm streaming Rocky spy thriller slashers franchise GIFs psycho Trivia travel dragons Marathons NYCC golden globes Turner Classic Movies Pet Sematary cartoon Musical romantic comedy Film Black Mirror finale GLAAD boxoffice cancelled TV series space supernatural facebook concert Walt Disney Pictures 2017 natural history Red Carpet psychological thriller screen actors guild BBC adaptation universal monsters Showtime crossover ABC Family YA Amazon Prime Video Super Bowl screenings Pirates casting Winners Britbox die hard richard e. Grant 2016 LGBT serial killer venice mockumentary hollywood thriller 4/20 talk show FOX Shudder Spring TV PlayStation cancelled TV shows Arrowverse Turner Heroines Tarantino anime hispanic Holidays Sundance VH1 Infographic dogs Election Tubi Hulu Anna Paquin Women's History Month American Society of Cinematographers Lifetime Christmas movies Marvel Television Fall TV IFC award winner parents Freeform game show APB DirecTV medical drama nfl Mary poppins Hallmark anthology satire werewolf Sundance TV romance book Tumblr TV renewals Biopics docudrama FX on Hulu indiana jones CMT Food Network crime drama true crime spain Schedule halloween Crackle Hallmark Christmas movies Chernobyl MCU Cosplay obituary chucky Brie Larson cults Disney cinemax green book BBC One video Amazon Prime zombies CNN rotten Nickelodeon worst IFC Films Amazon children's TV theme song zombie spanish language Funimation Amazon Studios based on movie Cartoon Network Creative Arts Emmys TNT Academy Awards hist The Witch ABC movies biography LGBTQ The Walking Dead Music Television Academy Sneak Peek Extras YouTube Premium period drama MSNBC canceled TV shows AMC Teen festivals Captain marvel Western teaser Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Fantasy political drama Grammys Discovery Channel OneApp Mary Tyler Moore independent The Arrangement movie Mary Poppins Returns San Diego Comic-Con Apple Lifetime quibi Warner Bros. doctor who mutant DC streaming service cooking dark indie dc Pop blockbuster Ghostbusters joker Certified Fresh singing competition nature series Spectrum Originals emmy awards miniseries Vudu Tomatazos TIFF Cannes directors crime thriller TCA 2017 sag awards justice league Video Games Peacock A24 2020 Adult Swim Comics on TV Baby Yoda documentary Universal Avengers TCA Winter 2020 Acorn TV criterion GoT cars DGA Elton John stop motion worst movies Summer ESPN OWN TBS BBC America Pride Month 45 BAFTA YouTube Red Rocketman SDCC comiccon what to watch TCA TV Land remakes dramedy Mudbound DC Comics Disney Plus fast and furious Calendar Comedy Song of Ice and Fire child's play twilight Shondaland cancelled television E! 21st Century Fox Dark Horse Comics NBC Crunchyroll El Rey Disney streaming service binge First Look TruTV BET Reality Year in Review historical drama 2019 Opinion kids Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt south america breaking bad Superheroes Spike science fiction VOD harry potter Epix Star Trek Countdown cops Star Wars The CW animated Holiday politics Mindy Kaling 71st Emmy Awards disaster Writers Guild of America Sony Pictures A&E news sports New York Comic Con canceled a nightmare on elm street latino unscripted