Don't Sleep on these 14 Award-Worthy Performances From Earlier In the Year

For Your Consideration: Standout showings that voters shouldn't forget as awards season ramps up.

by | September 28, 2018 | Comments

(Photo by © Marvel / © Walt Disney Studios Motion Pictures, © A24, © Sony Pictures Classics)

We’re just days into awards season, and already each new weekend is bringing movie fans the kind of noteworthy titles and buzzy performances that get voters and prognosticators talking. This weekend, Robert Redford returns to theaters – apparently for the last time before going into retirement – with his disarming and hilarious turn as an aging bank robber in The Old Man and the Gun; next week, the crowd-pleasing A Star is Born is primed to dazzle audiences in the same way it’s already captivated critics (it’s currently Certified Fresh at 94% on the Tomatometer).

The onslaught of big awards aspirants at this time of year is, of course, no accident. Studios postpone the release of movies they deem awards contenders to couple with ‘For Your Consideration’ campaigns and to ensure voters have the films and the performances in them top of mind when it’s close to voting time. It’s a strategy that works. Of the last three year’s Best Picture nominees at the Academy Awards, only one film each year was released before September: Genre favorites Mad Max: Fury Road, Hell or High Water, and Get Out were the precious few that managed to remain in the conversation months after their release. Similarly, the acting categories are typically dominated by showings in later-in-the-year releases.

Here, we’re making a case for some actors who staked a claim for gold many months ago, some as far back as February. These are the impressive early-year performances that critics singled out, and we hope Oscar voters haven’t forgotten.


Toni Collette | Alex Wolff | Emily Blunt | Joe Cole | Helena Howard

We’re seeing more and more genre films land nominations – and wins – in major categories. Last year, Get Out and eventual Best Picture winner The Shape of Water topped various Oscar categories, while in other recent years, Mad Max: Fury Road, Gravity, and Arrival have taken home golden statuettes. Still, the Oscar spotlight rarely shines on performances in genre films, particularly multiple genre performances in the same year. This year could be different. For Hereditary, released in June, Toni Collette managed to be both convincingly terrified and terrifying in a performance that’s unquestionably deserving of voters’ attention – critic Christy Lemire called it an “all-time great Toni Collette performance.” (And, on the subject of fierce horror performances, don’t dismiss Emily Blunt in A Quiet Place.) Hereditary costar Alex Wolff also has a chance to join Collette for his unsettling and eerie turn as teenage Peter in the supporting categories. But don’t overlook some of the less prominent indie genre darlings, too. Joe Cole, in a primarily non-verbal role, transformed into a gut-wrenching bare-knuckle boxer in A Prayer Before Dawn. Hard to watch but impossible to shake, Cole – who many may remember from Black Mirror‘s “Hang the DJ” episode – gives an astounding and, according to critic Stephanie Watts, “brilliantly physical performance.” Like Cole, newcomer Helena Howard wowed critics as the titular character in Madeline’s MadelineMinneapolis Star Tribune critic Colin Covert called her a “once-in-a-generation talent” in his review of the film.


Lupita Nyong’o | Danai Gurira | Michael B. Jordan

Black Panther will likely land several Oscar nominations. Below-the-line contributions from costume designer Ruth E. Carter, production designer Hannah Beachler, and cinematographer Rachel Morrison will probably receive their due, but there are a handful of onscreen efforts that we should keep in mind six months after the film stormed into theaters, particularly the work of Lupita Nyong’o and Danai Gurira. As Nakia, Nyong’o preached the virtues of Killmonger’s message without adopting his ‘by any means necessary’ militant approach, while Gurira balanced ferocity and grace for a surprisingly emotional portrayal of the Dora Milaje general, Okoye – her tearful threat to her husband Wakabi, played by Daniel Kaluuya, still delivers the chills. “Men quail before her,” Vulture’s David Edelstein wrote of Gurira’s Okoye in his review. “Black Panther gives her a wide berth. Everything in her affect says ‘uncontainable’.” Letitia Wright as Shuri is a fan favorite but unlikely to get any traction with voters – though stranger things have happened. Of the men, while Winston Duke impressed as M’Baku, Michael B. Jordan‘s Killmonger might be one of the strongest supporting performances of early 2018. Uncompromising and charismatic, Jordan was the ultimate antagonist, delivering biting one-liners laced with social commentary and shaping what many have called the most complex and interesting villain in the MCU.

The Quiet Ones

Charlie Plummer | Brady Jandreau | Elsie Fisher | Rachel McAdams | Ben Foster | Ethan Hawke

Understated, early-in-the-year performances tend to be subsumed by the showier stuff that hits screens during awards season, but this year we could be different. Pay particular attention to Charlie Plummer in Lean On Pete and Brady Jandreau in The Rider. Plummer disarmed critics as an unassuming runaway, journeying to find a home for himself and his aging racehorse Pete, and the role cemented the All the Money in the World co-star as a young actor to watch. Meanwhile, Jandreau’s performance in The Rider is so subtle that its brilliance takes a minute to creep up on you – AARP‘s Tim Appelo writes that Jandreau has “the presence of a screen veteran” in his debut. The same could be said for Elsie Fisher as Kayla in Bo Burnham’s authentically awkward and heartrending Eighth Grade. Ben Foster earned praise for Leave No Trace (Certified Fresh at 100%), as did Rachel McAdams in Disobedience; whether they can compete with the likes of Bradley Cooper and Lady Gaga come ballot-time, though, remains to be seen. Among the set of quieter performances that earned acclaim early in the year, Ethan Hawke’s as an equal-parts nihilistic and hopeful priest in First Reformed seems the surest bet to be in the awards conversation. Questioning his faith and ultimately his existence, Hawke is unyielding and devastating in a performance that multiple critics have called a “career best.”

Tag Cloud

2020 binge Black Mirror robots X-Men Extras mutant facebook Marathons war Amazon Studios Musical Box Office animated strong female leads VICE Superheroe Turner Classic Movies stand-up comedy Certified Fresh SDCC Hallmark Christmas movies singing competition New York Comic Con ABC Family Ovation Anna Paquin Acorn TV disaster werewolf Photos TNT Disney Channel Avengers crime drama Awards Martial Arts TCA 2017 finale cooking comics Mary Poppins Returns slashers Lifetime IFC streaming Brie Larson CBS casting Set visit serial killer 71st Emmy Awards cartoon Nominations Apple TV+ historical drama Mary Tyler Moore Marvel CMT Countdown GoT Horror First Reviews Shudder transformers cancelled TV shows Syfy Spectrum Originals jamie lee curtis Sundance TV Columbia Pictures Rock revenge Spike Super Bowl Amazon Prime Video Comics on TV sitcom 20th Century Fox AMC Disney+ Disney Plus Fox News DC streaming service latino Amazon Amazon Prime USA Network toy story Apple TV Plus Food Network 2017 A24 45 blockbuster Chernobyl screenings psycho RT History Nat Geo Mystery movie The Purge Star Wars anime MTV theme song Sundance Now sports Valentine's Day Hulu NYCC Toys christmas movies golden globes Lucasfilm Writers Guild of America The Walking Dead supernatural BBC medical drama elevated horror Thanksgiving BET Netflix Christmas movies Lifetime Christmas movies Dark Horse Comics National Geographic Academy Awards Emmy Nominations psychological thriller renewed TV shows spanish language Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Shondaland children's TV Mindy Kaling ratings Polls and Games TV 2019 E3 dc canceled DC Comics Heroines cops crime thriller Television Academy WarnerMedia Grammys thriller Cosplay dramedy Lionsgate Warner Bros. Star Trek Nickelodeon SXSW zombies 2016 TV Land zombie Apple Black History Month Pop Showtime Best and Worst The Witch TCA romantic comedy LGBTQ FX adaptation quibi spider-man DC Universe Winter TV composers Sneak Peek Mudbound tv talk doctor who Animation rotten movies we love vampires sequel CNN Interview YouTube Premium science fiction indie TBS police drama HBO Ellie Kemper award winner cults TCA Winter 2020 Rom-Com zero dark thirty E! San Diego Comic-Con Oscars Discovery Channel Trivia MSNBC discovery Hallmark Tubi VH1 TruTV hist Action Holidays Rocketman based on movie Sci-Fi ITV Women's History Month anthology Paramount Infographic romance Arrowverse nature spinoff Disney Plus name the review documentary space The CW richard e. Grant cats Fantasy Captain marvel HBO Max independent witnail 24 frames dragons Cartoon Network biography book hispanic Freeform Baby Yoda Film video adventure PBS Pirates Film Festival talk show Teen what to watch Premiere Dates joker true crime Christmas President spain Tomatazos Logo USA Turner comic Fall TV cancelled Year in Review cars LGBT Biopics Summer El Rey Emmys Creative Arts Emmys south america cinemax CBS All Access screen actors guild foreign television teaser Esquire TCM Family crossover Watching Series 21st Century Fox Universal dogs series Mary poppins blaxploitation Comedy batman Pixar halloween docudrama movies Schedule social media Masterpiece Tarantino YA Country Music YouTube Red IFC Films mockumentary miniseries Song of Ice and Fire period drama Video Games First Look crime Disney MCU FOX TLC Awards Tour canceled TV shows game of thrones kids Election spy thriller Chilling Adventures of Sabrina comiccon technology Drama Bravo Pet Sematary Crackle politics Cannes Sundance Endgame Adult Swim unscripted Trailer Ghostbusters APB Musicals Peacock FXX TIFF Kids & Family Reality Comic Book Walt Disney Pictures Pride Month natural history game show Trophy Talk dceu 2018 A&E harry potter TV renewals American Society of Cinematographers Vudu Rocky cancelled television diversity Marvel Studios YouTube Character Guide DGA Tumblr History Britbox Red Carpet Classic Film political drama Comedy Central breaking bad OWN Epix SundanceTV Western Podcast Sony Pictures green book 2015 Starz Marvel Television Crunchyroll Disney streaming service CW Seed free movies 007 RT21 OneApp DirecTV Opinion sag awards Elton John Paramount Network BBC America festivals The Arrangement reboot Holiday boxoffice See It Skip It GLAAD travel ESPN Winners aliens cancelled TV series Quiz PaleyFest Reality Competition ghosts versus Superheroes Netflix WGN NBC Stephen King justice league Spring TV GIFs Calendar ABC Binge Guide directors