Did David Lynch Win New Fans With His Twin Peaks Revival?

Our writer, new to the series, seeks out other Lynch newbies to find out if the legend lives up to the hype.

by | May 22, 2017 | Comments

The revival of Twin Peaks, the ’90s cultural phenomenon created by David Lynch, was announced years ago. There was plenty of time for anyone who missed the show’s original two seasons and movie, Twin Peaks: Fire Walk With Me, to catch up. But life gets busy and Netflix drops a new season of some show every week —Master of None and Kimmy Schmidt aren’t going to watch themselves! — so viewers who never found the time to catch up on Twin Peaks probably aren’t alone.

There were plenty of fans on Twitter sharing theories to help fill in the gaps — or not.

A Twin Peaks newb wasn’t that far behind the fanboys when Showtime aired the first two hours of Twin Peaks: The Return on Sunday. Episodes 3 and 4 went up on Showtime Anytime right after, but the first two already provide a lot to unpack, so let’s start there.

Anyone alive in the ‘90s already knows the basics even if they never watched it: Agent Cooper (Kyle MacLachlan) went to Twin Peaks to solve the murder of Laura Palmer (Sheryl Lee). The kooky town had a Log Lady (Catherine E. Coulson), who shares messages from her log; owls; a pale horse; and some damn fine coffee and cherry pie.


Double the Cooper With Double the Hair

After 25 years, Lynch and co-creator Mark Frost upended even the few basic things Twin Peaks thought they could count on. The Agent Cooper we first meet (after a brief intro in the Black Lodge, that weird red-curtained place with stripey floors), now has hair like Nicolas Cage in Con Air — and a temper like Nicolas Cage in everything else!

It soon became clear that this had something to do with BOB, an evil spirit from the Black Lodge who possessed Leland Palmer (Ray Wise) in the original series. By the end of part 2, long-haired Cooper was refusing to go back to the Black Lodge, where mysterious callers were trying to get back to BOB. Some fans were onto BOB much earlier.

Fortunately, good old clean-cut Cooper was still there in the Black Lodge. That doesn’t look like a fun place to spend 25 years. Somebody get that man some coffee and pie!

At least he got to see Laura Palmer again.

So in the Black Lodge, a dead person can age 25 years. Or at least some bright white light can wear a Laura Palmer face!

The horse appears briefly too.

And a talking tree. So this gets complicated. The tree says he is the arm. The arm was played by Michael J. Anderson in the original series. You know what they say: When Michael J. Anderson isn’t available, get a tree.

So yes, for double Kyle MacLachlan, and just to see how these trippy visuals develop, whether they’re explained or not, keep watching Twin Peaks.

The Log Lady And Other Friendly Neighbors

I totally know the log lady! It’s still Catherine E. Coulson, who passed away in 2015, so she must have filmed scenes before she died. She’s got breathing tubes in her nose, which could have been her reality near the end of life, but it was very touching that Lynch was able to include her.

Hawk (Michael Horse) was still there to follow the Log’s guidance.

There were plenty of other Twin Peaks regulars a newcomer would be excited to meet for the first time. Lucy (Kimmy Robertson) is still the sheriff’s receptionist, and she filled everyone in that Cooper’s been missing for at least 24 years.

It wasn’t until the last scene in The Bang Bang Bar that Shelly (Madchen Amick) shows up. She’s out with her girlfriends and notices James (James Marshall) eyeing one of her friends.

James, I had to look up, but he was on the original show too. Shelly says he had a motorcycle accident so he’s quiet now, but if the fans are happy to see him again, so am I.

Jerry (David Patrick Kelly) is clearly a fan favorite, so can’t wait to see more of him.

Leland Palmer and Phillip Michael Gerard (Al Strobel) are also in the Black Lodge with Cooper. The Giant (Carel Struycken) is now officially credited as “???????,” so people we thought we knew are getting more vague!

The Glass Box of Doom

Of course there are totally new characters and bizarre scenarios, so everyone is in the same boat watching the new storylines unfold. That science experiment in New York City where a college student (Ben Rosenfield) is watching a glass box to see if anything appears becomes the second most graphic scene in the show when a figure appears in the box, then busts out and kills both the college student and the flirtatious Tracy (Madeline Zima).

By the end of the second hour, Cooper has appeared in the glass box, but it was while the observer was out in the hall with Tracy. So did Cooper come back and kill them, or was that BOB? Or something else? Definitely going to have to watch the series to find out.

Who Killed Ruth Davenport?

We met a lot of new characters, some briefly like Beverly (Ashley Judd) and Chantal Hutchens (Jennifer Jason Leigh). It looks like Bill Hastings (Mathew Lillard) is the main suspect in a new murder. A body was found in an apartment in Buckhorn, South Dakota, in what was the most graphic scene.

Since she was missing an eye, some fans thought she was someone familiar, but they were wrong.

The body was Ruth Davenport, a librarian. Bill’s fingerprints are all over her apartment and his only alibi is an affair he was having. But his wife Phyllis (Cornelia Guest) is cheating on him too. Phyllis is letting Bill go down for this, but Evil Cooper kills her before we got much of a chance to know her.

And then, two cells over from Bill, a black figure dematerializes from the cell. If Lillard’s unhinged performance and the murder mystery werent’ enough (they were), you’ve got to keep watching to find out what that was.This sure ain’t Law & Order.

Mr. Lynch, You Have Our Attention

Low-fi visual effects punctuate the twisted nature of the Twin Peaks story, and there are trails of breadcrumbs dropped that we’ll also have to follow, like Evil Cooper’s Ace of Not Quite Spades. What’s that about?

And there are plenty of cast members who have not yet appeared. So we can look forward to finding out who Robert Knepper, Jim Belushi, David Koechner, Trent Reznor, and Amanda Seyfried are going to play. One guess is that Seyfried’s character is Shelly’s daughter.

So yes, here’s one viewer who got sucked into David Lynch’s trippy world tonight and who’s going to watch to the end, and maybe even go back and catch up on the original finally.

Twin Peaks airs Sunday nights at 9 p.m. on Showtime.


Tag Cloud

anthology Heroines war MSNBC franchise Amazon Prime Video Classic Film Spectrum Originals Lionsgate WarnerMedia news composers finale Awards Spring TV facebook Winter TV cults Spike Country Amazon Studios discovery Mystery Ghostbusters ITV Sundance TV festivals all-time Superheroes USA Disney streaming service social media WGN 2018 Pop TV IFC Films slashers series dceu cats breaking bad diversity child's play TV renewals comedies quibi Calendar NYCC CBS Turner Classic Movies Rom-Com Shudder PBS VICE 2019 rotten movies we love universal monsters nature Mary Poppins Returns Toys VOD CMT Schedule stoner Martial Arts Apple TV Plus Film Festival comics American Society of Cinematographers VH1 Extras Pride Month IFC batman Walt Disney Pictures witnail Marathons BAFTA revenge binge 2016 The Purge Hear Us Out Star Wars spinoff Elton John independent theme song a nightmare on elm street Amazon Nickelodeon children's TV Stephen King Emmy Nominations Peacock mission: impossible cartoon AMC romance south america Netflix Christmas movies A24 Writers Guild of America elevated horror Tarantino Chernobyl Pop E3 cancelled TV shows Fox News indiana jones Apple psycho spy thriller comiccon what to watch streaming ABC politics Adult Swim Hallmark Christmas movies Super Bowl directors Britbox hist YouTube Red documentaries Marvel Studios natural history spider-man BET Awards historical drama justice league period drama Masterpiece Shondaland Ovation Captain marvel hispanic Paramount Network GLAAD CNN Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Rock singing competition Television Academy Summer FXX Christmas DGA parents dark Logo screenings TV Polls and Games TCA 2017 Fall TV OWN Action ESPN Pixar GoT crime drama dogs renewed TV shows Lucasfilm unscripted Black Mirror cooking Election kids Disney Red Carpet Bravo Universal PlayStation teaser Cannes HBO Max disaster Song of Ice and Fire 2015 SDCC Grammys screen actors guild Dark Horse Comics HBO robots based on movie The Witch Disney+ Disney Plus Mary Tyler Moore boxoffice Epix LGBTQ sag awards TIFF sports zombie CBS All Access video Endgame Syfy die hard RT History tv talk OneApp cops Holidays Set visit political drama Awards Tour cancelled Women's History Month spanish language harry potter critics Tomatazos First Reviews X-Men Turner supernatural adventure game show dramedy ABC Family Comic Book Countdown Pirates Marvel Television Drama YouTube APB The Walking Dead Holiday chucky transformers Certified Fresh Freeform ghosts See It Skip It The Arrangement History DC Universe RT21 Crackle television Opinion Sundance TLC DC streaming service President medical drama Crunchyroll Thanksgiving Year in Review twilight documentary BBC One casting Ellie Kemper 2020 Comics on TV DirecTV Avengers NBC Acorn TV Discovery Channel HBO Go Binge Guide biography Anna Paquin Disney Plus 4/20 science fiction New York Comic Con movies Family game of thrones Box Office spain Photos TCA Winter 2020 Hallmark Rocketman free movies award winner Sneak Peek Baby Yoda GIFs Emmys Funimation Hulu MCU vampires Musical TBS YouTube Premium Mindy Kaling National Geographic A&E Amazon Prime cancelled television Video Games San Diego Comic-Con El Rey cancelled TV series Western Premiere Dates true crime crime thriller halloween space versus Winners Kids & Family Biopics Superheroe Nat Geo Pet Sematary technology Esquire Lifetime blockbuster canceled comic talk show films Tubi romantic comedy 71st Emmy Awards Marvel Tumblr Arrowverse golden globes name the review Mary poppins Academy Awards Star Trek canceled TV shows travel Best and Worst sitcom christmas movies Creative Arts Emmys zero dark thirty werewolf BBC America 24 frames miniseries Podcast asian-american Oscars Trailer CW Seed cars jamie lee curtis book Netflix 2017 Comedy DC Comics police drama joker 20th Century Fox Travel Channel sequel Nominations TruTV Reality richard e. Grant BBC dc Mudbound Reality Competition Infographic indie movie SXSW 21st Century Fox Cosplay Comedy Central Trophy Talk Black History Month video on demand TCM animated dragons thriller psychological thriller First Look LGBT Teen serial killer Watching Series Character Guide Disney Channel cinemax PaleyFest TNT The CW reviews Interview adaptation Cartoon Network concert ratings docudrama Columbia Pictures foreign 45 Trivia FOX FX BET Warner Bros. crime mockumentary YA satire latino blaxploitation USA Network crossover SundanceTV Lifetime Christmas movies toy story E! TCA mutant Horror Sundance Now TV Land MTV Quiz Music Starz Film Showtime Apple TV+ best reboot Animation doctor who aliens green book Sci-Fi criterion Brie Larson anime Sony Pictures stand-up comedy scary movies Musicals Food Network Fantasy Rocky strong female leads zombies Vudu FX on Hulu Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Paramount Valentine's Day 007