Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Tomorrowland is Visually Striking But Narratively Uneven

Plus, the Poltergeist reboot fails to live up to live up to the original, and Mad Men ends on a high note.

by | May 21, 2015 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a futuristic realm (Tomorrowland, starring George Clooney and Brittany Robertson) and a possessed property (Poltergeist, starring Sam Rockwell and Rosemarie DeWitt). What do the critics have to say?



Heartfelt, audacious, and visually striking, Tomorrowland is a testament to the power of imagination. Unfortunately, critics say it’s only a half-successful one — while the film is dazzling to the eye, its storytelling is uneven and its overall effect is muted as a result. Brittany Robertson stars as Casey, a smart, idealistic teenager who can’t get the vision of a magical, futuristic realm out of her head. She discovers that Frank (George Clooney), a fallen scientific wunderkind, can help to transport her to the place of her dreams. The pundits say Tomorrowland deserves credit for eschewing predictability and conventionality, but the end result is more admirable than emotionally satisfying. (Check out this week’s Total Recall for our Tomatometer guide to Disneyland, and watch our video interview with Clooney, Robertson, and more.)



Haunted house movies never seem to go out of style, as The Conjuring, Insidious, and Paranormal Activity demonstrate. Now, an update of Poltergeist tries to out-scare the competition, but unfortunately, critics say it’s a professional but lackluster chiller with little to distinguish it beyond its brand name. Strapped for cash, Eric (Sam Rockwell) and Amy (Rosemarie DeWitt) move their family into a suburban fixer-upper. Soon, however, their three children are bedeviled by mysterious supernatural entities, while Eric and Amy discover what happened to the house’s previous occupants. The pundits say Poltergeist offers up a few decent scares, but it’s a far cry from the inventive, iconic 1982 original. (Check out this week’s 24 Frames for a gallery of famous movie clowns.)

What’s On TV:

Person to Person” (92 percent) shoulders the burden of concluding a masterpiece by avoiding predictability while still offering a sweet sendoff for most of Mad Men‘s main characters.

Unbalanced storytelling and unnecessary, excessive brutality add up to disturbing viewing, although “Unbowed, Unbent, Unbroken” (59 percent) still includes enough plot revelations to offer hope for future episodes.

Creepy and strange in the best way possible, Wayward Pines (Certified Fresh at 85 percent) is a welcome return to form for M. Night Shamalyan.

Also opening this week in limited release:

Tag Cloud

docuseries new zealand Women's History Month video sitcom NYCC DGA Amazon Prime Video travel TNT BET Rocketman critics international Comedy revenge TCM stop motion Hallmark Christmas movies christmas movies thriller Shondaland Black History Month television docudrama Trivia australia Binge Guide children's TV Arrowverse doctor who Toys concert NBC documentary X-Men Pet Sematary 20th Century Fox SundanceTV mockumentary toy story Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Pacific Islander DC Universe Sundance TV Watching Series archives VOD Amazon Studios 2016 adventure Superheroes comiccon based on movie Kids & Family BBC One Tarantino Box Office Elton John ABC Family Film Festival cancelled TV shows book franchise discovery Polls and Games kaiju SDCC Disney Plus indie crossover lord of the rings rom-coms cancelled miniseries dogs Super Bowl American Society of Cinematographers kong festivals anthology Emmys TV One 21st Century Fox E3 ghosts Lionsgate blockbuster satire criterion Fall TV science fiction Country ratings LGBTQ crime thriller Shudder ABC Signature Tumblr HBO Max TCA Winter 2020 worst movies VICE spy thriller Grammys a nightmare on elm street batman Rock YouTube Premium Hear Us Out Disney Channel The Walking Dead golden globe awards natural history Awards DirecTV animated CMT Song of Ice and Fire monster movies scary movies 99% Pixar blockbusters Character Guide heist movie universal monsters twilight king kong 2019 aapi target elevated horror french nfl DC streaming service Interview jurassic park ESPN jamie lee curtis sports Premiere Dates Drama saw live action binge war Horror Music Funimation TCA crime drama mutant adaptation The Walt Disney Company FOX spanish slashers 2021 talk show Broadway remakes historical drama golden globes psychological thriller PaleyFest RT History President Masterpiece richard e. Grant YouTube sag awards Academy Awards reboot rotten Warner Bros. spanish language Superheroe TCA Awards Television Academy Marathons ITV Paramount Plus romantic comedy canceled TV shows comic books mission: impossible Disney+ Disney Plus cancelled television scene in color political drama Photos ID Apple TV Plus Creative Arts Emmys true crime medical drama streaming movies scorecard Adult Swim Ellie Kemper streaming crime Television Critics Association football cancelled TV series movie E! Sundance First Reviews festival what to watch 45 Classic Film Holidays 2018 Starz superman CW Seed italian video on demand child's play MSNBC OneApp LGBT MTV cooking The Academy disaster dc Mudbound Pop TV Fox News spinoff Bravo The Purge Winter TV Sundance Now teaser Mindy Kaling reviews PlayStation free movies National Geographic FX on Hulu Western renewed TV shows YA Lucasfilm Logo Spring TV films green book TV Land japanese Musicals APB Endgame A24 TIFF rt archives Ghostbusters Summer trailers Marvel Television Dark Horse Comics james bond comics news Disney Peacock WarnerMedia Video Games ABC Winners Tomatazos Mary Tyler Moore BBC America casting TLC razzies The Witch period drama Best and Worst asian-american El Rey WGN GoT zombies Mystery Sneak Peek boxing Nickelodeon Spike Chernobyl Freeform robots Sci-Fi Amazon Prime police drama best TBS Oscars stoner Animation joker theme song Quiz Comics on TV nature diversity CNN kids 71st Emmy Awards Anna Paquin Crunchyroll Trailer 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards nbcuniversal BBC know your critic cops Brie Larson USA Network GLAAD Netflix Ovation Captain marvel Musical 93rd Oscars Pride Month aliens game show 2020 TruTV romance Paramount CBS unscripted Christmas GIFs zero dark thirty venice Vudu new star wars movies BAFTA movies quibi comedies singing competition Lifetime Christmas movies godzilla TV transformers parents FXX 72 Emmy Awards Epix 2015 hidden camera HBO Go Emmy Nominations Black Mirror social media spider-man YouTube Red sequels Crackle worst HBO Comedy Central chucky cats justice league Podcast Food Network superhero halloween hispanic Certified Fresh Avengers cults halloween tv Holiday telelvision comic classics 007 composers boxoffice deadpool fast and furious Pop San Diego Comic-Con series blaxploitation Spectrum Originals all-time Film prank Sony Pictures game of thrones The Arrangement book adaptation women Alien directors IFC hollywood laika biography latino Walt Disney Pictures Schedule Red Carpet Turner spain RT21 Election obituary independent Infographic Reality Competition zombie Opinion Turner Classic Movies AMC new york emmy awards Esquire BET Awards witnail Set visit MCU Discovery Channel Apple FX Action Cosplay fresh Baby Yoda Universal cartoon Tubi Britbox dceu Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt serial killer Biopics 24 frames sequel dark Marvel Studios Cartoon Network die hard PBS Year in Review Fantasy stand-up comedy Acorn TV screen actors guild anime Paramount Network Netflix Christmas movies Nominations Stephen King Apple TV+ Star Wars Travel Channel CBS All Access south america ViacomCBS name the review politics harry potter technology werewolf dramedy Countdown Family screenings Reality USA History TCA 2017 Showtime Exclusive Video toronto Rom-Com versus supernatural OWN Pirates Hulu dragons popular Hallmark Comic Book IFC Films pirates of the caribbean Calendar black New York Comic Con psycho Heroines 4/20 Rocky foreign Columbia Pictures Marvel cinemax Mary Poppins Returns SXSW DC Comics finale indiana jones Mary poppins TV movies See It Skip It tv talk facebook VH1 cars award winner documentaries First Look Disney streaming service TV renewals breaking bad Thanksgiving Star Trek space Awards Tour Trophy Talk The CW Extras Fox Searchlight rotten movies we love Martial Arts Syfy marvel cinematic universe 2017 strong female leads Legendary Valentine's Day Image Comics Lifetime canceled Amazon vampires Nat Geo Cannes hist Teen A&E high school Writers Guild of America