Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Tomorrowland is Visually Striking But Narratively Uneven

Plus, the Poltergeist reboot fails to live up to live up to the original, and Mad Men ends on a high note.

by | May 21, 2015 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a futuristic realm (Tomorrowland, starring George Clooney and Brittany Robertson) and a possessed property (Poltergeist, starring Sam Rockwell and Rosemarie DeWitt). What do the critics have to say?



Heartfelt, audacious, and visually striking, Tomorrowland is a testament to the power of imagination. Unfortunately, critics say it’s only a half-successful one — while the film is dazzling to the eye, its storytelling is uneven and its overall effect is muted as a result. Brittany Robertson stars as Casey, a smart, idealistic teenager who can’t get the vision of a magical, futuristic realm out of her head. She discovers that Frank (George Clooney), a fallen scientific wunderkind, can help to transport her to the place of her dreams. The pundits say Tomorrowland deserves credit for eschewing predictability and conventionality, but the end result is more admirable than emotionally satisfying. (Check out this week’s Total Recall for our Tomatometer guide to Disneyland, and watch our video interview with Clooney, Robertson, and more.)



Haunted house movies never seem to go out of style, as The Conjuring, Insidious, and Paranormal Activity demonstrate. Now, an update of Poltergeist tries to out-scare the competition, but unfortunately, critics say it’s a professional but lackluster chiller with little to distinguish it beyond its brand name. Strapped for cash, Eric (Sam Rockwell) and Amy (Rosemarie DeWitt) move their family into a suburban fixer-upper. Soon, however, their three children are bedeviled by mysterious supernatural entities, while Eric and Amy discover what happened to the house’s previous occupants. The pundits say Poltergeist offers up a few decent scares, but it’s a far cry from the inventive, iconic 1982 original. (Check out this week’s 24 Frames for a gallery of famous movie clowns.)

What’s On TV:

Person to Person” (92 percent) shoulders the burden of concluding a masterpiece by avoiding predictability while still offering a sweet sendoff for most of Mad Men‘s main characters.

Unbalanced storytelling and unnecessary, excessive brutality add up to disturbing viewing, although “Unbowed, Unbent, Unbroken” (59 percent) still includes enough plot revelations to offer hope for future episodes.

Creepy and strange in the best way possible, Wayward Pines (Certified Fresh at 85 percent) is a welcome return to form for M. Night Shamalyan.

Also opening this week in limited release:

Tag Cloud

toy story cars Amazon USA Country free movies nfl Mindy Kaling rom-coms animated Acorn TV Bravo werewolf stoner teaser Emmys 2016 Biopics comedies Starz golden globes Broadway Amazon Prime Video Pet Sematary IFC Films Freeform travel Lifetime Christmas movies binge 4/20 E3 japanese dramedy universal monsters First Reviews twilight Travel Channel YA Musical rt archives singing competition anthology high school transformers canceled game show cats DirecTV ratings Lucasfilm 1990s LGBT sports WGN 21st Century Fox Year in Review Awards Tour Fox News feel good lord of the rings adventure die hard mission: impossible Vudu know your critic cartoon dogs Comedy Central Academy Awards Ovation TV renewed TV shows President international Song of Ice and Fire historical drama Amazon Studios hidden camera streaming movies screen actors guild hist prank razzies Nickelodeon Holidays TV Land YouTube Premium VH1 GIFs hollywood CMT Image Comics festivals 2017 adenture women Red Carpet TIFF deadpool Shudder parents technology superhero PaleyFest Turner suspense Ghostbusters RT History finale hispanic 71st Emmy Awards cops comic book movie Paramount Plus Logo cults olympics Film 007 boxoffice BET Awards Countdown Teen italian FOX tv talk TBS Classic Film crossover indie jurassic park NYCC new york AMC Superheroes OneApp child's play Lionsgate comiccon cancelled television Food Network period drama Nominations criterion OWN adaptation Quiz 2015 halloween japan SXSW Christmas Netflix Christmas movies Infographic See It Skip It Action worst movies Lifetime rt labs critics edition vampires BBC One fast and furious Tokyo Olympics History blaxploitation dceu TCM asian-american Mary Tyler Moore scary movies true crime mutant APB composers Film Festival crime drama A24 mcc Extras Box Office Funimation docuseries Pirates 72 Emmy Awards Warner Bros. 73rd Emmy Awards gangster classics Rock Turner Classic Movies Disney streaming service Sundance Calendar spain Epix MTV Britbox satire Disney Channel television Certified Fresh The Walt Disney Company talk show Baby Yoda Peacock 2021 New York Comic Con Rom-Com CBS All Access The Arrangement emmy awards posters Reality Competition book adaptation slasher SDCC award winner psycho The Academy war strong female leads A&E unscripted ID Superheroe toronto BET indiana jones 93rd Oscars marvel cinematic universe streaming The Walking Dead National Geographic Television Critics Association Winners crime thriller Nat Geo green book heist movie documentary blockbuster golden globe awards trailers based on movie disaster remakes independent Crackle festival critic resources slashers Endgame Trailer Anna Paquin Pixar quibi spanish language franchise romantic comedy 2020 spider-man superman archives black Paramount french witnail nature El Rey TLC Pop TV mockumentary boxing elevated horror debate ViacomCBS ABC Signature aliens scene in color 90s Stephen King Exclusive Video comic Set visit Star Trek a nightmare on elm street MCU nbcuniversal BBC Reality HBO best TNT rt labs FX critics Summer Paramount Network batman Women's History Month Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt TCA Awards worst saw Rocketman cancelled TV series cancelled TV shows Holiday YouTube Premiere Dates Cartoon Network Comic-Con@Home 2021 Sundance TV ABC Marvel Studios TV movies Martial Arts 99% target natural history Sneak Peek basketball politics versus 20th Century Fox LGBTQ dc Mary Poppins Returns Wes Anderson FX on Hulu Heroines Sony Pictures NBA Arrowverse zombie stand-up comedy psychological thriller Legendary romance screenings australia IFC 45 Hallmark Christmas movies CW Seed facebook Animation 2019 Tumblr MSNBC FXX Avengers Hear Us Out Adult Swim comics PlayStation PBS 2018 RT21 Spectrum Originals Creative Arts Emmys Alien what to watch DC Comics space X-Men Chernobyl documentaries BAFTA sequel Amazon Prime Captain marvel halloween tv Ellie Kemper Grammys DC Universe Dark Horse Comics Podcast Schedule TCA 2017 Star Wars reboot supernatural TruTV VOD Discovery Channel Fall TV concert Walt Disney Pictures Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Mary poppins aapi doctor who latino Hallmark zombies stop motion Apple TV Plus young adult comic books kids venice NBC Marvel Television VICE godzilla name the review Apple TV+ Best and Worst E! christmas movies The Witch marvel comics serial killer anime sag awards discovery Comedy harry potter Cosplay Syfy telelvision cancelled medical drama royal family robots spinoff hispanic heritage month rotten james bond Polls and Games Television Academy game of thrones series CNN sitcom dragons HBO Go justice league ABC Family crime joker new zealand Binge Guide Masterpiece Emmy Nominations Tubi obituary docudrama First Look police drama San Diego Comic-Con Brie Larson biopic Black Mirror Showtime Super Bowl Rocky video DGA Trivia rotten movies we love Pop Marathons scorecard HBO Max Pacific Islander theme song science fiction Esquire ITV Interview Video Games Spring TV Family Crunchyroll Character Guide live action Oscars biography king kong USA Network spy thriller Fox Searchlight Tomatazos Watching Series south america Spike Hulu social media Apple Disney kong chucky Awards Tarantino The CW children's TV Fantasy Writers Guild of America book laika fresh miniseries political drama Western Shondaland CBS revenge king arthur cinemax ESPN Kids & Family Music Black History Month movie 24 frames The Purge Trophy Talk Marvel new star wars movies Cannes Horror all-time Disney+ Disney Plus Elton John cooking news GLAAD WarnerMedia Drama GoT Election Musicals American Society of Cinematographers breaking bad TV renewals pirates of the caribbean dark reviews Universal football Winter TV Toys films sequels popular Comics on TV Columbia Pictures canceled TV shows movies Thanksgiving SundanceTV Photos diversity Comic Book Mystery DC streaming service thriller Pride Month comic book movies TV One Sundance Now BBC America YouTube Red Sci-Fi jamie lee curtis TCA Winter 2020 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards video on demand casting Netflix Mudbound foreign directors richard e. Grant zero dark thirty wonder woman TCA kaiju Opinion dexter Disney Plus Valentine's Day monster movies legend spanish action-comedy ghosts blockbusters