Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Spy is Certified Fresh

Plus, Entourage underwhelms, and Hannibal is delightfully demented.

by | June 4, 2015 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got an unlikely undercover agent (Spy, starring Melissa McCarthy and Jason Statham), a quartet of Hollywood bros (Entourage, starring Jeremy Piven and Adrian Grenier), and a haunted family (Insidious: Chapter 3, starring Dermot Mulroney and Stefanie Scott). What do the critics have to say?



Melissa McCarthy made her bones as a scene-stealing supporting player, but her starring vehicles have only occasionally made the most of her comic gifts. Until now, that is: critics say Spy is an inspired, uproarious spoof of espionage thrillers loaded with self-effacing performances and sharp jabs at workplace sexism. When an arms dealer identifies several of the CIA’s top field agents, desk-bound analyst Susan Cooper (McCarthy) gets her chance to go undercover in Paris. But during the course of her mission, Cooper must endure a string of indignities, from an unflattering cover story to a borderline-psychotic fellow agent (Jason Statham) who questions her competence at every turn. The pundits say the Certified Fresh Spy boasts sharp dialogue, solid action sequences, and, most of all, a terrific showcase for McCarthy’s talents. (Check out this week’s 24 Frames for a gallery of silly spies from TV and the movies, and watch our video interview with the cast and crew.)



Over the course of its eight season run on HBO, Entourage entertained as both a bro wish-fulfillment fantasy and as a gentle satire of Hollywood. Entourage the movie offers up more of the same, and critics say that’s a problem — this is a low-stakes, nearly conflict-free affair that feels more like an extended TV episode than a cinematic experience. Hunky movie star Vincent Chase (Adrian Grenier) is directing his first film — an adaptation of Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde — and live-wire agent-cum-studio head Ari Gold (Jeremy Piven) is freaking out about budget overruns and Vincent’s lack of filmmaking experience. Meanwhile, the rest of the gang is busy partying, carousing, and bumping into celebrities. The pundits say that Entourage may please hardcore fans, but aside from Piven’s crass, coarse performance, it’s too bland and self-satisfied to appeal to non-diehards. (Check out this week’s Total Recall for a list of essential movies about movies, and watch our video interview with the stars.)

Insidious: Chapter 3


Plenty of horror movie part threes exist primarily to wring a few extra box office bucks out of a brand name franchise. However, while critics say that Insidious: Chapter 3 is a bit too reliant on empty jump scares, it’s smarter and more character-driven than many others of its ilk, and does a decent job of staking out new territory within the Insidious universe. Still grieving from the death of her mother, high school senior Quinn (Stefanie Scott) asks a psychic to make contact with her mother’s spirit and unwittingly draws the attention of a malevolent supernatural force in the process. The pundits say Insidious Chapter 3 can’t match the efficient terror of the original, but it’s a better-than-average fright-fest that builds considerable tension throughout. (Check out our video interview with the stars of Chapter 3.)

What’s On TV:

Following several episodes of setup, “Hardhome” (100 percent) blends a sharp script with spectacular blockbuster action to offer viewers a powerful, game-changing payoff.

Bryan Fuller serves up another delightfully demented season of Hannibal (100 percent) featuring a hearty helping of gorgeous gore, paired with a sweet side of twisted humor (read our Q&A with Fuller here).

UnReal (Certified Fresh at 95 percent) uses reality TV as a suitably soapy springboard for absorbing drama.

Also opening this week in limited release:

Tag Cloud

MCU TIFF diversity E3 casting revenge theme song Countdown adaptation Chernobyl romance BBC America Song of Ice and Fire Superheroe First Look Lionsgate politics Nickelodeon TruTV Grammys Masterpiece Quiz doctor who Best and Worst CNN unscripted mutant Comics on TV ghosts Sundance comic spanish language Esquire Pet Sematary children's TV Spectrum Originals latino DC streaming service space period drama First Reviews Warner Bros. Sneak Peek Film Festival OWN Film binge NYCC American Society of Cinematographers true crime cops Amazon Prime crime Starz travel kids Musicals Lifetime animated Amazon Prime Video crime thriller Tomatazos Pride Month anime The CW YouTube Red Mystery Cannes transformers BET Ovation crossover Amazon Trophy Talk Certified Fresh Disney Video Games Winners Reality Spike YouTube Premium Oscars Watching Series boxoffice Emmy Nominations Comic Book hispanic Netflix Chilling Adventures of Sabrina teaser cooking DGA harry potter New York Comic Con RT History Infographic elevated horror game of thrones X-Men Reality Competition thriller quibi ESPN GLAAD supernatural DirecTV Rocky Schedule Marvel TLC festivals Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt science fiction technology series Writers Guild of America USA Network toy story TV Pop Mary Poppins Returns historical drama Shondaland Brie Larson Drama Election Opinion Apple justice league Universal The Witch Fantasy Fall TV Family 24 frames WarnerMedia Star Trek based on movie Awards Tour tv talk sitcom nature TV Land jamie lee curtis See It Skip It Paramount Binge Guide Acorn TV SDCC BBC Photos south america aliens dragons facebook stand-up comedy Red Carpet Animation Trailer Disney Channel Polls and Games singing competition robots strong female leads Teen Stephen King Musical PaleyFest Walt Disney Pictures Elton John crime drama Hulu Tarantino Heroines GIFs Sundance Now Showtime IFC Films Premiere Dates Pixar witnail RT21 VICE Ellie Kemper Music biography The Arrangement CMT Bravo political drama game show Mary poppins DC Comics Freeform dramedy Black Mirror Superheroes Winter TV psycho Mary Tyler Moore E! miniseries vampires Nat Geo Action San Diego Comic-Con blaxploitation zero dark thirty History Food Network 20th Century Fox Britbox what to watch SundanceTV Podcast Sci-Fi dc Lucasfilm Set visit Logo PBS Super Bowl TNT 2016 Adult Swim Women's History Month cats National Geographic MSNBC Extras 2015 spider-man 2018 natural history Vudu social media richard e. Grant APB war Calendar SXSW comiccon Rocketman zombies ABC discovery Captain marvel 45 TCA 2017 Rom-Com CBS Mindy Kaling sports Year in Review Sony Pictures spy thriller docudrama serial killer Nominations FXX Fox News ABC Family Tumblr Comedy IFC streaming FX AMC HBO YA President LGBTQ El Rey CW Seed Character Guide hist 2019 TBS FOX Dark Horse Comics Marathons psychological thriller 2017 foreign 007 Awards Creative Arts Emmys composers NBC Martial Arts mockumentary award winner golden globes Summer Horror zombie Mudbound spain Disney streaming service Pirates spinoff adventure Columbia Pictures Toys Crackle dceu Country finale Emmys A&E talk show Valentine's Day cars Interview Comedy Central VH1 ITV book Syfy cults Thanksgiving LGBT TCM television USA Holidays Kids & Family HBO Max ratings movies police drama Biopics DC Universe 21st Century Fox Rock sequel Cartoon Network Shudder MTV disaster Trivia Epix Box Office Spring TV TCA green book WGN medical drama cinemax Western Ghostbusters anthology GoT Cosplay Anna Paquin Christmas Paramount Network CBS All Access Star Wars