Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Hot Pursuit Is a Comedy Clunker

Plus, The D Train is ambitious but uneven, and the latest episode of Orphan Black is sharp and satisfying.

by | May 7, 2015 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got ladies on the run (Hot Pursuit, starring Reese Witherspoon and Sofía Vergara) and reunited high school classmates (The D Train, starring Jack Black and James Marsden). What do the critics have to say?

Hot Pursuit


On paper, Hot Pursuit looks like a can’t-miss proposition: a buddy chase picture staring two capable comedic actresses. Unfortunately, critics say the film misses very badly indeed, stranding the likes of Reese Witherspoon and Sofía Vergara in a plot of startling laziness and predictability. Witherspoon plays Cooper, a straight-laced cop tasked with transporting Daniella Riva (Vergara) across Texas to testify in court against a big-time drug trafficker. Naturally, nothing goes according to plan, and soon the pair are being pursued by would-be assassins and corrupt cops. The critics say Hot Pursuit is a comic dead zone, stuffed with stereotypes and rote situations that fail to conjure much beyond a stray chuckle here and there. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we take count down Witherspoon’s best-reviewed films, and watch our video interview with Witherspoon and Vergara.)

The D Train


Part bromance, part drama, part farce, part cringe comedy, The D Train is nothing if not ambitious. Unfortunately, critics say it’s only partly successful in realizing its various aims, and the result is thought-provoking and well-acted but tonally inconsistent. Jack Black stars as Dan, a perpetual loser who ventures from Pennsylvania to Los Angeles in order to convince Oliver (James Marsden), a former classmate and moderately successful actor, to attend their high school reunion and burnish Dan’s reputation. After a few nights of hard partying, however, Dan discovers he’s gotten more than he bargained for. The pundits say Black and Marsden are both excellent, but the The D Train can’t quite find the perfect balance between moments of darkness and light.

What’s On TV:

“Formalized, Complex, and Costly” (83 percent) offers satisfying action and a good shock, though the season is developing more slowly than some might prefer.

All Happy Families Are Alike” (59 percent) brings season one of Gotham to a somewhat confusing conclusion, but some exciting twists hint at a promising, and hopefully more consistent, season two.

Also opening this week in limited release:

  • I Am Big Bird: The Caroll Spinney Story, a documentary about the man who plays the beloved Sesame Street character, is at 84 percent.
  • 1001 Grams, a comedy about a Norwegian scientist whose love life is in tatters as she journeys to Paris for a conference on the weight of a kilogram, is at 83 percent.
  • The Seven Five, a documentary about a spectacularly corrupt New York City policeman, is at 80 percent.
  • Noble, a based-on-true-events drama about an Irish woman who worked to shelter homeless children in Vietnam, is at 79 percent.
  • The 100-Year-Old Man Who Climbed Out the Window and Disappeared, a comedy about a 100-year-old man who climbs out a window and disappears, is at 66 percent.
  • 5 Flights Up, starring Morgan Freeman and Diane Keaton in a dramedy about an aging couple in the process of selling their apartment, is at 63 percent.
  • Maggie, starring Arnold Schwarzenegger and Abigail Breslin in a thriller about a father attempting to save his daughter from a zombie infection, is at 56 percent.
  • Saint Laurent, a biopic of the famed fashion designer, is at 50 percent.
  • Spike Island, a drama about members of a teenage rock band who attend a Stone Roses gig in order to give the group a demo tape, is at 48 percent.
  • Playing It Cool, starring Chris Evans and Michelle Monaghan in a dramedy about an aging couple in the process of selling their apartment, is at 31 percent.
  • Preggoland, a comedy about a woman who fakes a pregnancy and can’t come clean without ruffling feathers, is at 27 percent.
  • Bravetown, starring Josh Duhamel and Laura Dern in a drama about a New York City teen and aspiring DJ who’s sent to live with his estranged father in a blue collar North Dakota town, is at 25 percent.
  • Skin Trade, starring Dolph Lundgren and Tony Jaa in an action thriller about two guys on the trail of the head of a human trafficking cartel, is at 13 percent.

Tag Cloud

The Walt Disney Company Mudbound italian WarnerMedia witnail Syfy SXSW composers Pet Sematary OneApp GoT OWN Star Wars BAFTA serial killer zero dark thirty superhero worst movies First Look APB concert chucky A&E Hulu Film Festival sequel Winners The Academy Awards Tour MTV book adaptation Broadway disaster Universal rom-coms Starz festival Dark Horse Comics Schedule new zealand MSNBC halloween YA IFC Films 45 independent Sundance TV Spectrum Originals obituary boxing trailers Bravo USA cooking Tomatazos Heroines video Pixar crime popular SDCC nfl Country supernatural Arrowverse Nickelodeon President directors VH1 Marvel Studios Film comics Grammys Horror crime drama mutant History halloween tv Television Critics Association TCM Epix The Purge asian-american USA Network screenings 2017 LGBT aliens Netflix target 2018 Rocketman high school movie Thanksgiving Esquire streaming The Walking Dead cars TLC politics zombies IFC deadpool unscripted Classic Film Superheroe cats Nat Geo ABC Family documentaries Shudder james bond Paramount Network PlayStation romance Comedy Central medical drama festivals Anna Paquin Image Comics Toys Pride Month TCA docuseries Set visit TV Land renewed TV shows reviews Awards blockbusters hidden camera historical drama Sundance Now Western 72 Emmy Awards National Geographic CBS All Access binge TIFF Amazon CW Seed south america classics Apple TV+ know your critic ViacomCBS joker science fiction breaking bad Certified Fresh Trailer CNN HBO Max crime thriller superman elevated horror Ovation Disney Plus FOX jurassic park BET Comics on TV screen actors guild Avengers mockumentary Cartoon Network live action 93rd Oscars E3 spinoff Sneak Peek RT History green book Stephen King quibi foreign new york parents Ghostbusters 2021 Martial Arts tv talk movies game of thrones FXX Oscars golden globe awards Trivia Sundance Fox News documentary technology cinemax Disney+ Disney Plus what to watch comic books Video Games hispanic spanish language Mindy Kaling Black Mirror The CW Apple HBO Go space Podcast Paramount Plus worst Valentine's Day criterion FX on Hulu Turner Masterpiece Extras streaming movies natural history Family Hallmark Warner Bros. ITV Walt Disney Pictures Hear Us Out PBS women singing competition remakes richard e. Grant Academy Awards YouTube AMC sag awards Disney streaming service Lifetime Christmas movies saw Britbox Creative Arts Emmys toronto Countdown satire TNT versus football war Shondaland a nightmare on elm street Crackle Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt prank robots dark thriller Mystery Reality Competition Comedy Paramount BET Awards Exclusive Video Brie Larson scorecard king kong GIFs Nominations monster movies 007 Emmy Nominations HBO anthology E! Cosplay child's play Reality free movies spy thriller Watching Series Best and Worst Animation First Reviews Mary poppins award winner Chilling Adventures of Sabrina VOD Pop TV cults TCA Awards Captain marvel period drama Showtime TruTV rt archives Crunchyroll Superheroes name the review Trophy Talk australia Fantasy twilight films DC Universe television See It Skip It comiccon Alien DGA romantic comedy crossover TV renewals Peacock aapi strong female leads Teen japanese theme song Hallmark Christmas movies GLAAD 2020 mission: impossible Spring TV book The Arrangement cops spain MCU animated batman cancelled TV series police drama Spike Netflix Christmas movies hollywood Rock universal monsters rotten movies we love BBC CBS all-time doctor who Emmys Cannes X-Men El Rey harry potter Rocky Marathons critics rotten Disney kids canceled DirecTV YouTube Red Lifetime 20th Century Fox based on movie Binge Guide toy story CMT docudrama Lionsgate ESPN diversity adventure franchise finale canceled TV shows french Apple TV Plus emmy awards biography news Fox Searchlight Discovery Channel children's TV Sony Pictures indiana jones sequels FX Funimation Writers Guild of America hist black Adult Swim 4/20 ABC Signature jamie lee curtis dc 2016 DC Comics justice league sports cancelled television TV One Character Guide Election stop motion Tubi venice Box Office latino ratings kong Opinion kaiju Vudu razzies casting dceu Star Trek nbcuniversal A24 social media stoner adaptation 71st Emmy Awards PaleyFest Elton John werewolf Infographic Amazon Prime Video YouTube Premium New York Comic Con Mary Poppins Returns Pirates psychological thriller Quiz vampires cancelled TV shows 2019 Pacific Islander comedies 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Women's History Month Acorn TV Premiere Dates international blockbuster facebook 21st Century Fox Marvel Television Drama The Witch golden globes Marvel comic Travel Channel Columbia Pictures psycho spider-man Action Interview blaxploitation 99% Red Carpet Sci-Fi Baby Yoda teaser talk show Christmas sitcom TCA Winter 2020 Photos TBS political drama Summer Food Network die hard NBC miniseries fast and furious Musical TV Ellie Kemper Tumblr ABC spanish best VICE discovery dragons BBC America Comic Book new star wars movies video on demand Polls and Games Year in Review scary movies Super Bowl SundanceTV christmas movies 24 frames cartoon nature Disney Channel cancelled Music indie series RT21 Black History Month lord of the rings Endgame Legendary WGN Chernobyl Winter TV Amazon Studios revenge Logo LGBTQ travel telelvision pirates of the caribbean transformers boxoffice ghosts Amazon Prime Musicals Kids & Family BBC One heist movie Television Academy reboot Tarantino Fall TV Calendar Biopics Mary Tyler Moore Holiday Turner Classic Movies Lucasfilm NYCC dogs Song of Ice and Fire laika ID true crime Freeform 2015 fresh godzilla zombie slashers Holidays scene in color marvel cinematic universe Pop DC streaming service San Diego Comic-Con stand-up comedy game show anime dramedy archives TV movies Rom-Com American Society of Cinematographers TCA 2017