Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Hot Pursuit Is a Comedy Clunker

Plus, The D Train is ambitious but uneven, and the latest episode of Orphan Black is sharp and satisfying.

by | May 7, 2015 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got ladies on the run (Hot Pursuit, starring Reese Witherspoon and Sofía Vergara) and reunited high school classmates (The D Train, starring Jack Black and James Marsden). What do the critics have to say?

Hot Pursuit


On paper, Hot Pursuit looks like a can’t-miss proposition: a buddy chase picture staring two capable comedic actresses. Unfortunately, critics say the film misses very badly indeed, stranding the likes of Reese Witherspoon and Sofía Vergara in a plot of startling laziness and predictability. Witherspoon plays Cooper, a straight-laced cop tasked with transporting Daniella Riva (Vergara) across Texas to testify in court against a big-time drug trafficker. Naturally, nothing goes according to plan, and soon the pair are being pursued by would-be assassins and corrupt cops. The critics say Hot Pursuit is a comic dead zone, stuffed with stereotypes and rote situations that fail to conjure much beyond a stray chuckle here and there. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we take count down Witherspoon’s best-reviewed films, and watch our video interview with Witherspoon and Vergara.)

The D Train


Part bromance, part drama, part farce, part cringe comedy, The D Train is nothing if not ambitious. Unfortunately, critics say it’s only partly successful in realizing its various aims, and the result is thought-provoking and well-acted but tonally inconsistent. Jack Black stars as Dan, a perpetual loser who ventures from Pennsylvania to Los Angeles in order to convince Oliver (James Marsden), a former classmate and moderately successful actor, to attend their high school reunion and burnish Dan’s reputation. After a few nights of hard partying, however, Dan discovers he’s gotten more than he bargained for. The pundits say Black and Marsden are both excellent, but the The D Train can’t quite find the perfect balance between moments of darkness and light.

What’s On TV:

“Formalized, Complex, and Costly” (83 percent) offers satisfying action and a good shock, though the season is developing more slowly than some might prefer.

All Happy Families Are Alike” (59 percent) brings season one of Gotham to a somewhat confusing conclusion, but some exciting twists hint at a promising, and hopefully more consistent, season two.

Also opening this week in limited release:

  • I Am Big Bird: The Caroll Spinney Story, a documentary about the man who plays the beloved Sesame Street character, is at 84 percent.
  • 1001 Grams, a comedy about a Norwegian scientist whose love life is in tatters as she journeys to Paris for a conference on the weight of a kilogram, is at 83 percent.
  • The Seven Five, a documentary about a spectacularly corrupt New York City policeman, is at 80 percent.
  • Noble, a based-on-true-events drama about an Irish woman who worked to shelter homeless children in Vietnam, is at 79 percent.
  • The 100-Year-Old Man Who Climbed Out the Window and Disappeared, a comedy about a 100-year-old man who climbs out a window and disappears, is at 66 percent.
  • 5 Flights Up, starring Morgan Freeman and Diane Keaton in a dramedy about an aging couple in the process of selling their apartment, is at 63 percent.
  • Maggie, starring Arnold Schwarzenegger and Abigail Breslin in a thriller about a father attempting to save his daughter from a zombie infection, is at 56 percent.
  • Saint Laurent, a biopic of the famed fashion designer, is at 50 percent.
  • Spike Island, a drama about members of a teenage rock band who attend a Stone Roses gig in order to give the group a demo tape, is at 48 percent.
  • Playing It Cool, starring Chris Evans and Michelle Monaghan in a dramedy about an aging couple in the process of selling their apartment, is at 31 percent.
  • Preggoland, a comedy about a woman who fakes a pregnancy and can’t come clean without ruffling feathers, is at 27 percent.
  • Bravetown, starring Josh Duhamel and Laura Dern in a drama about a New York City teen and aspiring DJ who’s sent to live with his estranged father in a blue collar North Dakota town, is at 25 percent.
  • Skin Trade, starring Dolph Lundgren and Tony Jaa in an action thriller about two guys on the trail of the head of a human trafficking cartel, is at 13 percent.

Tag Cloud

Comedy Central FX cancelled television award winner venice Paramount Network Biopics psychological thriller critic resources comic book movies concert mcc Countdown breaking bad Legendary cooking Comedy ghosts blockbusters YouTube singing competition Fantasy what to watch book adaptation disaster pirates of the caribbean christmas movies dceu sports new star wars movies Disney Channel Showtime The Walking Dead crime twilight spider-man Disney streaming service 4/20 Brie Larson dc aliens Ghostbusters 99% Animation A24 71st Emmy Awards Martial Arts diversity cars indiana jones Pixar stand-up comedy canceled TV shows boxing docuseries Turner Classic Movies Pacific Islander ABC E! Action GIFs vampires Film Festival Opinion superhero slasher Binge Guide godzilla slashers 20th Century Fox HBO Max adventure television Set visit Holidays anime Sneak Peek SXSW social media VH1 hispanic TV renewals rt labs critics edition BBC Star Wars fresh Extras MCU Wes Anderson jamie lee curtis independent franchise Tokyo Olympics doctor who CBS All Access fast and furious spanish language halloween Sundance screen actors guild Turner Infographic heist movie comic books Hallmark Christmas movies documentary Crackle GoT discovery Hallmark Mystery TCA Awards book 2017 james bond Schedule X-Men Creative Arts Emmys GLAAD Marvel Marvel Television Starz crime drama child's play suspense Reality latino revenge TBS Amazon Studios Freeform supernatural Lucasfilm Winners reviews Arrowverse Crunchyroll MTV romantic comedy Image Comics Musical classics mutant SundanceTV basketball Christmas Broadway movies kaiju LGBT Premiere Dates Columbia Pictures Marvel Studios American Society of Cinematographers remakes international FOX Black Mirror TCA Rock Song of Ice and Fire Universal women VOD YouTube Premium Box Office laika The Academy spain historical drama Paramount wonder woman marvel cinematic universe Family Comic Book video archives Oscars series IFC cancelled TV shows Travel Channel satire cartoon OWN free movies TV Land rotten movies we love Polls and Games Avengers nbcuniversal blockbuster docudrama Chernobyl Winter TV Tumblr dragons Mary Poppins Returns CMT 45 Netflix Christmas movies game show Best and Worst Cosplay Grammys Chilling Adventures of Sabrina HBO Tomatazos Lifetime Election zombie BET thriller rt archives live action Musicals Disney The Arrangement Anna Paquin National Geographic trailers universal monsters Shudder TIFF worst psycho Kids & Family theme song CBS name the review Sundance TV PBS zombies 2016 DGA ABC Signature VICE Comics on TV indie 1990s comics worst movies movie Country Cartoon Network critics Pop high school witnail Awards Tour Peacock technology posters TNT DC Comics space green book sequels Logo japan films toronto dexter USA deadpool Teen kong cinemax Western Calendar ESPN elevated horror festivals finale Apple TV Plus Trailer serial killer Adult Swim Superheroe comedies olympics TV movies comic book movie Black History Month reboot Sony Pictures 2015 rom-coms CNN hist versus dreamworks TCA 2017 quibi Funimation Reality Competition The Purge ABC Family parents Emmys Mary poppins Discovery Channel PaleyFest royal family comic Superheroes jurassic park golden globes unscripted Nat Geo The CW Interview Quiz Pop TV science fiction APB NYCC Elton John El Rey Sci-Fi DC streaming service joker FX on Hulu Horror superman TCA Winter 2020 Fox Searchlight SDCC stop motion The Walt Disney Company police drama Shondaland kids Podcast justice league dark BAFTA razzies rt labs canceled Character Guide Academy Awards strong female leads natural history 90s Pirates screenings Photos Ovation king arthur 72 Emmy Awards debate Disney Plus lord of the rings die hard tv talk legend ratings king kong black DC Universe australia rotten political drama Nickelodeon richard e. Grant harry potter Sundance Now golden globe awards biopic 2020 Tubi Stephen King emmy awards Television Academy Britbox travel 24 frames Watching Series Hulu crime thriller See It Skip It dramedy Alien NBC casting Women's History Month Film comiccon Year in Review Mary Tyler Moore IFC Films Music President Thanksgiving TCM BET Awards war talk show Toys TLC south america batman Cannes japanese Paramount Plus biography young adult feel good Classic Film Exclusive Video scary movies Acorn TV robots dogs RT21 Drama scene in color WGN cancelled boxoffice mission: impossible A&E First Reviews BBC One adenture scorecard Hear Us Out telelvision San Diego Comic-Con Trophy Talk french Holiday nfl E3 Dark Horse Comics new york football YouTube Red History festival stoner Walt Disney Pictures Pride Month DirecTV mockumentary nature Amazon Prime Trivia Nominations criterion Tarantino hollywood Mudbound Emmy Nominations Lifetime Christmas movies Apple asian-american Rocketman Mindy Kaling New York Comic Con target YA Comic-Con@Home 2021 hidden camera spinoff OneApp cancelled TV series WarnerMedia ITV ViacomCBS prank Rom-Com romance Apple TV+ Valentine's Day Amazon Prime Video know your critic directors Pet Sematary cops 93rd Oscars Rocky 21st Century Fox Netflix game of thrones zero dark thirty obituary popular ID CW Seed Vudu children's TV Masterpiece RT History Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt TV politics italian Baby Yoda Bravo saw action-comedy toy story FXX 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards video on demand 73rd Emmy Awards Television Critics Association adaptation renewed TV shows Video Games TV One Marathons Endgame Spring TV 2021 BBC America Ellie Kemper Spectrum Originals 2019 best Disney+ Disney Plus Writers Guild of America monster movies 007 cults Red Carpet facebook news USA Network Lionsgate werewolf binge animated MSNBC anthology Star Trek aapi Spike Fox News halloween tv LGBTQ marvel comics Awards blaxploitation miniseries sequel sitcom foreign Certified Fresh a nightmare on elm street streaming cats Esquire based on movie Summer chucky new zealand TruTV medical drama Syfy spy thriller The Witch Super Bowl NBA gangster Heroines hispanic heritage month spanish First Look PlayStation all-time documentaries period drama Warner Bros. 2018 AMC streaming movies sag awards HBO Go Amazon Fall TV Food Network Captain marvel teaser transformers composers true crime crossover Epix