Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Hot Pursuit Is a Comedy Clunker

Plus, The D Train is ambitious but uneven, and the latest episode of Orphan Black is sharp and satisfying.

by | May 7, 2015 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got ladies on the run (Hot Pursuit, starring Reese Witherspoon and Sofía Vergara) and reunited high school classmates (The D Train, starring Jack Black and James Marsden). What do the critics have to say?

Hot Pursuit


On paper, Hot Pursuit looks like a can’t-miss proposition: a buddy chase picture staring two capable comedic actresses. Unfortunately, critics say the film misses very badly indeed, stranding the likes of Reese Witherspoon and Sofía Vergara in a plot of startling laziness and predictability. Witherspoon plays Cooper, a straight-laced cop tasked with transporting Daniella Riva (Vergara) across Texas to testify in court against a big-time drug trafficker. Naturally, nothing goes according to plan, and soon the pair are being pursued by would-be assassins and corrupt cops. The critics say Hot Pursuit is a comic dead zone, stuffed with stereotypes and rote situations that fail to conjure much beyond a stray chuckle here and there. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we take count down Witherspoon’s best-reviewed films, and watch our video interview with Witherspoon and Vergara.)

The D Train


Part bromance, part drama, part farce, part cringe comedy, The D Train is nothing if not ambitious. Unfortunately, critics say it’s only partly successful in realizing its various aims, and the result is thought-provoking and well-acted but tonally inconsistent. Jack Black stars as Dan, a perpetual loser who ventures from Pennsylvania to Los Angeles in order to convince Oliver (James Marsden), a former classmate and moderately successful actor, to attend their high school reunion and burnish Dan’s reputation. After a few nights of hard partying, however, Dan discovers he’s gotten more than he bargained for. The pundits say Black and Marsden are both excellent, but the The D Train can’t quite find the perfect balance between moments of darkness and light.

What’s On TV:

“Formalized, Complex, and Costly” (83 percent) offers satisfying action and a good shock, though the season is developing more slowly than some might prefer.

All Happy Families Are Alike” (59 percent) brings season one of Gotham to a somewhat confusing conclusion, but some exciting twists hint at a promising, and hopefully more consistent, season two.

Also opening this week in limited release:

  • I Am Big Bird: The Caroll Spinney Story, a documentary about the man who plays the beloved Sesame Street character, is at 84 percent.
  • 1001 Grams, a comedy about a Norwegian scientist whose love life is in tatters as she journeys to Paris for a conference on the weight of a kilogram, is at 83 percent.
  • The Seven Five, a documentary about a spectacularly corrupt New York City policeman, is at 80 percent.
  • Noble, a based-on-true-events drama about an Irish woman who worked to shelter homeless children in Vietnam, is at 79 percent.
  • The 100-Year-Old Man Who Climbed Out the Window and Disappeared, a comedy about a 100-year-old man who climbs out a window and disappears, is at 66 percent.
  • 5 Flights Up, starring Morgan Freeman and Diane Keaton in a dramedy about an aging couple in the process of selling their apartment, is at 63 percent.
  • Maggie, starring Arnold Schwarzenegger and Abigail Breslin in a thriller about a father attempting to save his daughter from a zombie infection, is at 56 percent.
  • Saint Laurent, a biopic of the famed fashion designer, is at 50 percent.
  • Spike Island, a drama about members of a teenage rock band who attend a Stone Roses gig in order to give the group a demo tape, is at 48 percent.
  • Playing It Cool, starring Chris Evans and Michelle Monaghan in a dramedy about an aging couple in the process of selling their apartment, is at 31 percent.
  • Preggoland, a comedy about a woman who fakes a pregnancy and can’t come clean without ruffling feathers, is at 27 percent.
  • Bravetown, starring Josh Duhamel and Laura Dern in a drama about a New York City teen and aspiring DJ who’s sent to live with his estranged father in a blue collar North Dakota town, is at 25 percent.
  • Skin Trade, starring Dolph Lundgren and Tony Jaa in an action thriller about two guys on the trail of the head of a human trafficking cartel, is at 13 percent.

Tag Cloud

leaderboard japan VICE New York Comic Con IFC sopranos TNT independent Showtime romance ITV Tumblr satire twilight teaser Rock fresh game of thrones Pixar rt labs Food Network National Geographic Paramount Emmy Nominations latino dc spy thriller superhero breaking bad unscripted Thanksgiving target gangster dceu social media Biopics prank The Purge Arrowverse wonder woman 2020 Fox News Superheroes GIFs trophy dreamworks hispanic heritage month PBS Ovation Summer batman versus docuseries Classic Film game show zero dark thirty godzilla venice Sony Pictures theme song OneApp TV One TCA Winter 2020 hist richard e. Grant hidden camera canceled zombie comic book movie christmas movies comedies comics Crackle LGBT TV movies Heroines dramedy crime drama historical drama anthology Tags: Comedy diversity cancelled TV series Fall TV VOD ABC Family Warner Bros. OWN harry potter rotten Fox Searchlight Sundance TV Pride Month comic book movies a nightmare on elm street mutant basketball Character Guide DGA Year in Review Prime Video festival 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards psycho Holiday cars new york Drama Best Picture AMC Plus Starz aliens mob royal family critic resources LGBTQ FXX Watching Series Fargo black Awards Tour quibi japanese scary movies crime summer preview facebook deadpool TV renewals halloween animated cults Mary Poppins Returns Mary poppins toronto TCA 2017 Nominations Christmas Turner Classic Movies broadcast Comic-Con@Home 2021 kaiju Film Festival Creative Arts Emmys posters cancelled television Infographic period drama scorecard golden globe awards CBS All Access President Disney NBC crossover hispanic strong female leads HBO Max lord of the rings Countdown Shondaland revenge Anna Paquin Legendary Disney Channel Marathons blockbuster travel Hear Us Out Masterpiece Best Actress documentary cooking olympics IFC Films women festivals Pet Sematary PlayStation nature Musical Television Academy tv talk Best and Worst new star wars movies BBC Netflix The Witch NBA ABC WGN pirates of the caribbean stoner free movies Focus Features Nat Geo 007 blockbusters Quiz summer TV mockumentary History Academy Awards what to watch Rocketman Premiere Dates Amazon ESPN MGM universal monsters San Diego Comic-Con parents docudrama transformers The Academy classics art house Fantasy Hulu Avengers Travel Channel Lucasfilm indiana jones true crime emmy awards See It Skip It Esquire Nickelodeon MSNBC slasher Sci-Fi comiccon American Society of Cinematographers SDCC 4/20 Valentine's Day TIFF Hallmark Christmas movies dexter boxoffice Teen mission: impossible 1990s CNN Baby Yoda NYCC trailers blaxploitation serial killer doctor who indie SXSW Music golden globes Song of Ice and Fire video on demand finale 20th Century Fox BET Awards 72 Emmy Awards rt labs critics edition Bravo jamie lee curtis Action Kids & Family Holidays E3 Amazon Studios Exclusive Video Funimation ID Emmys legend biopic zombies chucky crime thriller BAFTA comic books A&E Box Office supernatural Oscar Winners cancelled king arthur Disney Plus Image Comics action-comedy documentaries Super Bowl witnail name the review Election Apple TV+ spinoff YA ABC Signature laika nbcuniversal Grammys interviews films medical drama Hallmark The Arrangement RT21 marvel cinematic universe kids genre best The Walt Disney Company canceled TV shows CW Seed kong remakes Marvel Studios child's play FX on Hulu 2016 Apple TV Plus Syfy Binge Guide Trailer Martial Arts Universal Pictures Chernobyl Women's History Month Black Mirror DC Universe Comic Book robots reviews Marvel Television streamig Marvel DC Comics spanish language BET south america book adaptation Hollywood Foreign Press Association razzies scene in color Certified Fresh Comedy Central worst movies aapi Trophy Talk DC streaming service ratings composers high school feel good heist movie Animation space Mindy Kaling politics Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt news spanish Family biography Neflix Trivia South by Southwest Film Festival Winter TV streaming movies book hollywood HBO HBO Go YouTube Premium talk show 99% Podcast live action rotten movies we love TV Land Black History Month BBC America obi wan ghosts streaming 71st Emmy Awards psychological thriller Amazon Prime Video 2017 marvel comics foreign romantic comedy Peacock movie adenture Lifetime Christmas movies Best Director scary concert Cannes Acorn TV Oscars YouTube Paramount Network SXSW 2022 Captain marvel casting Tubi IMDb TV TCM 90s halloween tv technology asian-american Polls and Games Horror Film 21st Century Fox CMT HFPA Superheroe El Rey Crunchyroll vampires MCU Red Carpet die hard science fiction ViacomCBS Discovery Channel RT History sitcom Instagram Live Shudder Spring TV mcc 45 Schedule Pop TV Turner Epix Lionsgate obituary 2019 sports Paramount Pictures based on movie Musicals 93rd Oscars Paramount Plus Star Wars Sundance Now BBC One natural history TruTV E! AMC Mystery Ellie Kemper rom-coms Photos Pacific Islander thriller Tokyo Olympics Stephen King binge football Amazon Prime award winner discovery dragons TLC children's TV Brie Larson video TCA justice league reboot 2015 Logo Elton John miniseries cats screenings Comedy Britbox directors toy story Calendar debate Reality Competition adaptation comic boxing 73rd Emmy Awards vs. Rom-Com Extras Country werewolf MTV FOX slashers Star Trek criterion Mary Tyler Moore Vudu Awards Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Broadway Sneak Peek series young adult Reality TBS GoT Alien sequels PaleyFest nfl international screen actors guild Disney+ Disney Plus 94th Oscars Dark Horse Comics Lifetime war YouTube Red worst Disney streaming service Wes Anderson italian green book WarnerMedia king kong Best Actor The CW black comedy Apple sag awards Freeform summer TV preview 79th Golden Globes Awards DirecTV australia Spectrum Originals SundanceTV CBS Video Games adventure 2021 FX First Reviews spain know your critic USA Network Sundance A24 cops cartoon franchise Universal rt archives james bond french Opinion Tomatazos suspense Ghostbusters APB stand-up comedy Mudbound GLAAD dogs sequel Television Critics Association Endgame new zealand Netflix Christmas movies joker monster movies VH1 The Walking Dead Tarantino Set visit Western renewed TV shows 24 frames superman USA popular Rocky spider-verse dark Pirates live event saw stop motion Interview archives TCA Awards spider-man Pop 2018 all-time political drama First Look Writers Guild of America Adult Swim Comics on TV Cartoon Network jurassic park cancelled TV shows disaster police drama movies Walt Disney Pictures fast and furious Toys anime telelvision singing competition X-Men critics elevated horror Columbia Pictures Spike cinemax Cosplay television TV