Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Zathura's Got Game, Get Rich Dies Tryin'

by | November 10, 2005 | Comments

This week’s wide releases raise a number of questions. Is “Zathura” a game worth playing? Is 50 Cent‘s movie debut, “Get Rich or Die Tryin’,” the cinematic equivalent of a trip to the candy shop? Is “Derailed” a speedy locomotive, or is it true to its name? What do the critics have to say?

Zathura” is the third story by Rhode Island-based children’s book author Chris Van Allsburg to make the leap from the page to the big screen (the other two were “Jumanji” and last year’s “The Polar Express“). And critics say it’s the best of the bunch. “Zathura” tells the tale of a pair of squabbling brothers who must learn to work together after they are transported into space while playing the titular board game. According to the critics, the movie is solid family entertainment, with a real sense of adventure and wonder, emphasizing characters over the (not at all shabby) special effects. At 71 percent on the Tomatometer, “Zathura”‘s got game. And it beats “The Polar Bear Express,” which scored 56 percent on the Tomatometer, and “Jumanji,” at 48 percent.

Curtis “50 Cent” Jackson has a life story that seems ready-made for cinematic treatment: he was a drug dealer, he survived a shooting, and he eventually became one of America’s biggest musical stars. But the critics say the semi-autobiographical “Get Rich or Die Tryin’,” which features 50 in his acting debut, still feels like the stuff of many other rags-to-riches dramas. The scribes say even veteran director Jim Sheridan can’t make it fresh, despite an excellent supporting cast that includes the always-dependable Terrence Howard. At 16 percent on the Tomatometer, “Get Rich or Die Tryin'” can’t make a dollar out of 50 Cent. And it’s the worst-reviewed film of Sheridan’s career (beating out “The Field,” at 46 percent).

As the old saying goes, what a tangled web we weave, when we make a thriller about adultery and betrayal with lots of plot twists. “Derailed” tells the story of an extramarital affair gone terribly awry, after a very bad guy threatens the two trapped philanderers. The critics say the title is all too apt; the plot twists become more tangled as the film goes along, and Clive Owen and Jennifer Aniston, in spite of their considerable skills, are miscast as, respectively, a schlubby family man and a fundamentally decent femme fatale. At 19 percent on the Tomatometer, the critics say “Derailed” has jumped the tracks.

Movies Starring Musicians Playing Musicians:
5% — Undiscovered (2005) – Starring Ashlee Simpson
81% — Hustle & Flow (2005) – Starring Ludacris
15% — Raise Your Voice (2004) – Starring Hilary Duff
76% — 8 Mile (2002) – Starring Eminem
7% — Glitter (2001) – Starring Mariah Carey
14% — Crossroads (2002) – Starring Britney Spears
24% — Duets (2000) – Starring Huey Lewis
32% — Black and White (1999) – Starring Raekwon
81% — Selena (1997) – Starring Jennifer Lopez
11% — Cool as Ice (1991) – Starring Vanilla Ice
70% — Purple Rain (1984) – Starring Prince

Tag Cloud

mutant unscripted ABC cats Holidays Action Sundance YouTube Red Rock Winners zombies GLAAD thriller robots NYCC Britbox SundanceTV Polls and Games A&E crossover dceu Teen El Rey Awards Comedy TNT AMC History Esquire Hulu political drama Adult Swim Superheroes 2016 politics YouTube Premium Apple Star Wars Rom-Com FXX TCM Sony Pictures harry potter National Geographic Disney Super Bowl Quiz USA Network IFC American Society of Cinematographers Horror Trivia transformers Dark Horse Comics Watching Series ratings crime sports Fantasy E3 Cosplay TruTV Drama Kids & Family Syfy Columbia Pictures Grammys DC Universe WGN Reality Competition Infographic FX San Diego Comic-Con Netflix ABC Family Bravo FOX Winter TV Masterpiece President Countdown TLC talk show 2017 TCA 2017 Premiere Dates Music Pop 24 frames hist DC streaming service Freeform Thanksgiving medical drama HBO social media Walt Disney Pictures Starz Best and Worst Video Games romance Fox News GoT Acorn TV VH1 TBS New York Comic Con comiccon Comedy Central Biopics E! Set visit Tomatazos serial killer First Look comic MSNBC PaleyFest Opinion Western NBC dc period drama Star Trek PBS VICE jamie lee curtis Year in Review supernatural cooking blaxploitation zombie DirecTV Amazon Character Guide Pixar OWN Election Fall TV festivals Certified Fresh Valentine's Day singing competition Lifetime DC Comics Oscars Reality psycho The Arrangement MTV Ovation cinemax YA spy thriller dramedy LGBTQ See It Skip It police drama Podcast crime drama Musical Sundance Now composers biography Trailer SDCC aliens ESPN Crackle historical drama Interview binge X-Men Disney Channel IFC Films Shondaland Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Nominations Food Network Paramount BET based on movie Mindy Kaling Calendar Mystery TV Comics on TV Mary Tyler Moore television Song of Ice and Fire Showtime CNN Trophy Talk Warner Bros. ITV docudrama Emmys Box Office Awards Tour Martial Arts CBS All Access streaming GIFs Pirates boxoffice RT History Ghostbusters Logo Schedule Tumblr Sneak Peek USA Lucasfilm doctor who The CW war Universal CMT Spring TV 21st Century Fox Writers Guild of America TIFF cops Summer discovery Epix BBC Toys Country SXSW justice league 20th Century Fox Shudder Sci-Fi travel TV Land Extras 2015 APB Comic Book sitcom Marvel Animation vampires cults BBC America Christmas science fiction what to watch Lionsgate CW Seed crime thriller Superheroe technology anime golden globes Ellie Kemper Nickelodeon Paramount Network adventure 007 45 diversity TCA Spike Cartoon Network Nat Geo Musicals Photos Red Carpet Rocky CBS Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Creative Arts Emmys finale Marathons