Critics Consensus

Critical Consensus: Superbad is Certified Fresh; The Invasion Crash-Lands

Last Legion Not Screened; Guess the Tomatometer!

by | August 16, 2007 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got some McLovin
starring Michael
and Jonah
), pod people (The
, starring
Nicole Kidman
and Daniel Craig),
and swordplay (The
Last Legion
, starring
Ben Kingsley
and Colin Firth).
What do the critics have to say?

It’s been a very good year for
Judd Apatow.
After directing Knocked
, he’s the producer on another gross-out comedy with heart,
, and both are big hits with critics. Superbad tells the
story of two geeks (Michael Cera and Jonah Hill) on the cusp of graduation who
really, really want to change their luck with the ladies. The pundits say
is as raunchy and cheerfully vulgar as any comedy you’re likely to
see this summer, but it’s also remarkably wise and poignant regarding the
awkwardness of the high school years. At 92 percent, Superbad surpasses
Knocked Up
‘s Tomatometer score, which means that it’s one of the best
reviewed films of the year. (Check out our interview with the Superbad
gang here.)

“Those RT critics crack me up.”

arrives in theaters with plenty of baggage. The film, helmed
by Oliver
originally wrapped in 2006, but the studio allegedly balked at what they saw,
and it’s rumored that a good portion of the final product is the result of a
retooled script by the
and reshoots by
V for Vendetta
. Such Hollywood intrigue may ultimately prove more interesting than
the film itself, as critics say The Invasion is a pretty tepid,
unsuspenseful remake of an already thrice-adapted story (Invasion
of the Body Snatchers
). After a space shuttle crash, Nicole Kidman and
Daniel Craig discover that an infection is taking over peoples’ bodies in their
sleep, turning them into unemotional quasi-zombies. The pundits say the film is
slick but unfocused, lacking psychological complexity and thrills. At 16 percent
on the Tomatometer, The Invasion sits far below the precedent set by the 1956 and
1978 Body Snatchers, both at 100 percent.

They couldn’t hide their horror upon seeing the Wachowski Bros. re-cut.

It appears the folks behind The Last Legion are afraid the number of
pundits who wouldn’t dig their movie would be, ahem, legion. Perhaps that’s the
reason the film wasn’t screened before hitting theaters. Featuring a pretty
impressive cast that includes Colin Firth, Ben Kingsley, and
Aishwarya Rai,
Last Legion
tells the story of a boy with the responsibility to save the
Roman Empire. Put down your copy of Livy’s From the Founding of the City and
Guess the Tomatometer.

Both sigh as they attempt to guess the Tomatometer.

Also opening this week in limited release:

The King of Kong: A Fistful of Quarters
, a documentary about the
competition between Donkey Kong experts, is at 100 percent on the
Tomatometer; The 11th
, a global warming doc narrated by
, is at 90 percent (check out our review from Cannes
a tale of small-time paparazzi starring
Steve Buscemi
and Michael Pitt,
is at 89 percent (check out our San Francisco International Film Festival review
Manda Bala
, a doc
about class divisions in modern Brazil, is at 89 percent;
Primo Levi’s
, a doc about the great writer’s trek after WWII, is at 75 percent;
Death at a Funeral,
a farce about a funeral interrupted by a dark family secret starring
Peter Dinklage,
is at 71 percent; and Ils,
a tale of a French couple terrorized by a haunted house in Romania, is at 71
percent; Love
for Sale
, a Brazilian import about a woman who leaves Sao Paulo for her
hometown, is at 67 percent;
Takashi Miike‘s
Zebraman, a spoof
of Japanese superheroes, is at 60 percent; and
Zhang Yang‘s
tale of a 30-year relationship starring
Joan Chen, is
at 60 percent.

Attack its weak point for massive damage!

Finally, props to

for correctly guessing
‘ 13
percent Tomatometer. Congrats, BSK. Now you won’t have to write in all caps to
be heard.

Recent Nicole Kidman Movies:
81% — I
Have Never Forgotten You
90% — God Grew
Tired of Us
30% — Fur: An Imaginary Portrait
of Diane Arbus
74% — Happy Feet
25% — Bewitched (2005)

Tag Cloud

Marvel Star Trek Elton John Chilling Adventures of Sabrina GLAAD CMT fast and furious HBO Mystery cops Comic Book Nominations Podcast Writers Guild of America Super Bowl Musical canceled TV shows concert political drama sequel Western Rocky biography Superheroes The Purge 2019 anthology LGBTQ Sundance Arrowverse canceled Polls and Games Television Critics Association transformers mutant elevated horror BET Awards Tour Country TNT Emmys cancelled TV series Amazon Prime Video Brie Larson ABC Family natural history Lifetime Christmas movies witnail 72 Emmy Awards criterion twilight book stoner Kids & Family SundanceTV ESPN E3 dark CBS All Access mission: impossible Opinion vampires TIFF WarnerMedia Hallmark children's TV Sneak Peek 45 sag awards television Netflix Christmas movies golden globes screen actors guild Rom-Com Marvel Studios zero dark thirty Martial Arts ratings USA composers Disney streaming service Trophy Talk 4/20 DC Comics Chernobyl Food Network blaxploitation Summer sitcom Election BBC America hist 71st Emmy Awards FX on Hulu BBC Shudder Tubi RT21 Rock CNN cooking Action FX Pride Month werewolf A&E reboot TCA Awards sports American Society of Cinematographers YouTube APB Captain marvel MCU spider-man Warner Bros. Song of Ice and Fire psycho Awards Lionsgate Schedule romantic comedy Oscars 2018 Hear Us Out Classic Film GIFs rotten movies we love dc directors politics news Tomatazos medical drama Apple TV+ First Reviews Paramount game show Peacock sequels Sony Pictures Discovery Channel obituary Musicals Ovation Best and Worst laika TV renewals Acorn TV hollywood WGN RT History casting Interview The Arrangement NBC free movies PBS FXX MSNBC Spectrum Originals harry potter indiana jones singing competition Anna Paquin die hard The CW revenge Superheroe Reality Competition miniseries Columbia Pictures ABC Mindy Kaling disaster discovery anime mockumentary TCA Winter 2020 game of thrones adventure Fall TV dragons satire AMC Adult Swim Year in Review 20th Century Fox Video Games adaptation X-Men New York Comic Con cancelled television franchise cats crossover VICE IFC USA Network Black History Month DGA YouTube Premium Amazon cars period drama joker dogs spy thriller streaming Cannes latino universal monsters BBC One A24 Fox News Mary Poppins Returns First Look Comics on TV true crime Freeform DC Universe Avengers child's play christmas movies Netflix Creative Arts Emmys name the review Valentine's Day richard e. Grant Teen robots 24 frames Lifetime Countdown cartoon Binge Guide Mudbound zombie Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Shondaland YA remakes Trailer Academy Awards Box Office crime thriller Heroines based on movie Sci-Fi documentaries series tv talk doctor who historical drama CW Seed Crackle OWN Amazon Studios Biopics versus Travel Channel cancelled TV shows YouTube Red Nat Geo independent Animation 007 Calendar The Witch 2020 Cosplay Horror worst movies SXSW Pop TV GoT Universal Logo talk show Ellie Kemper quibi Amazon Prime best DC streaming service finale docudrama 2015 breaking bad psychological thriller Nickelodeon ITV Television Academy Holidays Disney+ Disney Plus Extras Epix comiccon DirecTV chucky Funimation asian-american Music green book worst Photos critics Pirates BET Awards TCA scorecard spinoff Mary poppins justice league emmy awards Syfy romance scary movies aliens south america Trivia theme song President Star Wars Hulu MTV stand-up comedy movie indie OneApp National Geographic nfl a nightmare on elm street halloween technology El Rey HBO Max Grammys venice See It Skip It crime drama Character Guide toy story Quiz blockbuster facebook Red Carpet Premiere Dates space comedies TLC unscripted Holiday ghosts Disney Plus police drama slashers cults nbcuniversal parents movies CBS Cartoon Network IFC Films Pixar Bravo crime supernatural kids Comedy Central Disney Channel Apple TV Plus Tarantino Turner The Walking Dead animated Fantasy rotten Christmas Marathons Toys Showtime travel award winner PlayStation LGBT jamie lee curtis 21st Century Fox video Crunchyroll Britbox science fiction serial killer stop motion SDCC Endgame Disney E! films Winter TV cinemax Turner Classic Movies boxoffice dramedy BAFTA zombies screenings Certified Fresh video on demand Tumblr spain toronto Sundance TV Pop Apple TruTV cancelled Black Mirror nature Women's History Month diversity Set visit hispanic renewed TV shows TCM thriller FOX Hallmark Christmas movies Starz all-time NYCC war reviews superhero Pet Sematary Spring TV football Rocketman Dark Horse Comics 2017 Paramount Network comic what to watch Family Sundance Now Film Festival Mary Tyler Moore binge Film Lucasfilm Thanksgiving Reality festival HBO Go Ghostbusters spanish language History Watching Series VH1 Vudu dceu festivals documentary San Diego Comic-Con Walt Disney Pictures classics Spike Winners social media Infographic Esquire Comedy Marvel Television Baby Yoda foreign Masterpiece 2016 batman TBS TV teaser Emmy Nominations TCA 2017 VOD Stephen King PaleyFest TV Land comics strong female leads Drama