Critical Consensus: "Gardener" Reaps Praise

by | September 1, 2005 | Comments

This week we have a movie about international intrigue ("The Constant Gardener"), a mercenary ("The Transporter 2"), the problems of time travel ("A Sound of Thunder"), and a cop who goes back to school "Underclassman").Which one will get the best marks from the critics?

Director Fernando Meirelles‘ first film, "City of God," was a marvel, as it examined the lives of the poor in Rio de Janeiro while simultaneously being exhilarating entertainment. So what does he do for an encore? "The Constant Gardener," a film that critics say manages to be both exiting and a thoughtful, angry diatribe against neo-colonialism in Africa. The film, starring Ralph Fiennes and Rachel Weisz, tells the story of a mild-mannered British diplomat who finds himself in the midst of an international conspiracy. If, at 79 percent on the Tomatometer, it falls a tad below "City of God" (93 percent), the scribes still think it’s one of the smartest films of the summer.

Jason Statham is back in his signature role, as "The Transporter 2" continues the story of the ex-special-forces-agent-turned-mercenary, and the critics are as divided on the sequel as they were on the original. While some say the latest installment is absurd and riddled with plot holes, others say it’s got enough excitement to keep action fans satisfied. It’s currently at 50 percent on the Tomatometer; the original was a shade better, at 51 percent.

The sound you hear may be thunder, or it may be the pounding of critics’ keyboards to pan "A Sound of Thunder," a new science fiction film based on a short story by Ray Bradbury. Starring Edward Burns and Ben Kingsley, the movie examines the potentially devastating effects of time travel on the course of history. The critics say the film has all the negative trappings of 1950s B-movies; with cheesy dialogue and way more fi than sci, "A Sound of Thunder" is at nine percent on the Tomatometer.

What was high school like for you? At my school, there was a car theft ring, and all of a sudden there was this new, popular guy at my school, who I was stunned to find out later was an undercover cop. As you may have guessed, "Underclassman," starring the very likable Nick Cannon, is not the height of realism, critics say. But, even worse, it is not original at all, copping riffs from "Beverly Hills Cop" and "21 Jump Street." The critics are giving this one a flunking grade; at zero on the Tomatometer, "Underclassman" won’t make it out of summer school.

Recent Luc Besson Productions:
66% — Unleashed (2005)
42% — High Tension (2005)
10% — Taxi (2004)
51% — The Transporter (2002)
46% — Wasabi (2002)
48% — Kiss of the Dragon (2001)

Tag Cloud

APB TCA 2017 American Society of Cinematographers RT21 Amazon Studios classics batman politics Arrowverse legend Quiz CBS crime thriller Film based on movie Action TV One concert criterion thriller canceled Reality Competition james bond screenings robots Countdown mutant live action Nat Geo Showtime comiccon blaxploitation Funimation PlayStation Tarantino TLC olympics series disaster Crunchyroll spanish fast and furious laika dogs Pixar A&E Western worst IFC Films natural history basketball Rock Marvel Television lord of the rings Apple TV Plus science fiction asian-american adventure Nominations Certified Fresh Watching Series Toys NBA Emmys children's TV political drama Photos serial killer Rocky The Academy Hallmark rt labs Shudder singing competition comic YA Spectrum Originals Captain marvel reviews E3 Mary Poppins Returns ESPN spy thriller 2017 VH1 YouTube WarnerMedia dark pirates of the caribbean See It Skip It Peacock TNT rotten foreign SXSW 93rd Oscars renewed TV shows cartoon spinoff SDCC revenge Box Office Awards Musicals marvel cinematic universe richard e. Grant new zealand Discovery Channel Star Wars ABC Family Masterpiece FXX TruTV DGA godzilla Paramount Network green book Baby Yoda royal family Fantasy CMT Hulu kong zero dark thirty dragons 2020 cancelled Rocketman Music Apple police drama Calendar Paramount Plus Pop TV kids australia japan south america anthology sitcom Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Election streaming movies TV target fresh Schedule Valentine's Day X-Men The CW blockbuster ratings GoT romance Women's History Month video travel Comic Book Tubi Winter TV Star Trek Disney+ Disney Plus boxoffice slashers Heroines book adaptation free movies strong female leads TCM VOD Mystery new york Warner Bros. Apple TV+ adaptation latino rt archives zombies 71st Emmy Awards elevated horror El Rey HBO BBC America TBS PaleyFest docuseries Video Games Logo GIFs 2018 Martial Arts Writers Guild of America Marathons streaming Teen unscripted 4/20 miniseries sequels Lionsgate rom-coms docudrama Ovation FOX werewolf ID San Diego Comic-Con Sundance Now suspense sequel Reality chucky AMC Creative Arts Emmys Year in Review blockbusters saw independent OneApp Fox Searchlight Vudu Acorn TV Chernobyl MTV 72 Emmy Awards VICE facebook hidden camera HBO Go deadpool theme song Mindy Kaling Disney Channel Universal king kong psychological thriller MSNBC Grammys a nightmare on elm street Television Critics Association First Reviews DirecTV Bravo Comedy Central marvel comics heist movie Disney Plus Film Festival MCU wonder woman game show video on demand stoner quibi breaking bad BBC One DC Universe Comedy The Walking Dead Netflix jurassic park WGN PBS award winner Superheroe italian dexter period drama films President Hallmark Christmas movies Summer IFC First Look dceu Avengers movie news joker CBS All Access Exclusive Video razzies TV Land aapi documentary TV movies 2019 USA documentaries romantic comedy Sony Pictures Epix comic book movie young adult Character Guide rt labs critics edition zombie LGBT Oscars book CNN Pop ABC Signature sports hispanic heritage month Disney Lifetime Christmas movies Thanksgiving Amazon Prime Video Hear Us Out kaiju festival Super Bowl Song of Ice and Fire christmas movies FX on Hulu TIFF FX comic books Fox News NBC new star wars movies BAFTA Ghostbusters Pacific Islander Christmas spain mockumentary Pirates monster movies YouTube Premium stop motion Opinion Pride Month 1990s Pet Sematary The Arrangement golden globe awards finale Cartoon Network witnail historical drama superman Tumblr comedies cults hist NYCC Horror Binge Guide crossover Food Network halloween aliens Turner nfl biography biopic DC Comics TCA obituary french 2015 name the review Anna Paquin Winners casting war Brie Larson all-time gangster E! Mary Tyler Moore game of thrones mission: impossible slasher critics DC streaming service best technology women SundanceTV true crime teaser History 20th Century Fox Country Emmy Nominations medical drama 99% Cosplay 2021 Columbia Pictures vampires Cannes 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Walt Disney Pictures 90s Legendary hispanic animated boxing posters cancelled TV shows Esquire high school 2016 king arthur Trophy Talk Podcast discovery The Walt Disney Company Musical action-comedy scene in color spanish language justice league indie ITV trailers Spring TV Marvel Studios toy story YouTube Red Family Red Carpet Interview Broadway Academy Awards CW Seed nature festivals versus telelvision franchise harry potter Sundance composers comics Fall TV Television Academy Paramount Superheroes cars Mudbound 007 worst movies binge mcc Infographic National Geographic psycho TV renewals USA Network emmy awards talk show 45 cinemax Travel Channel japanese BET Awards twilight Kids & Family child's play dramedy die hard Holidays crime drama Starz Britbox Syfy GLAAD toronto canceled TV shows jamie lee curtis universal monsters Disney streaming service halloween tv cancelled TV series OWN TCA Awards Amazon Prime Stephen King Lifetime Premiere Dates The Witch debate Marvel popular HBO Max crime Holiday Animation cats cooking Elton John space Black Mirror Best and Worst rotten movies we love adenture Crackle TCA Winter 2020 Freeform Lucasfilm prank football ABC Amazon comic book movies feel good Dark Horse Comics Tomatazos superhero Extras Classic Film Shondaland Tokyo Olympics RT History Image Comics television cops remakes know your critic movies supernatural scary movies ViacomCBS Netflix Christmas movies Mary poppins Black History Month Ellie Kemper Trivia spider-man what to watch nbcuniversal diversity dc golden globes Nickelodeon Turner Classic Movies stand-up comedy BBC transformers archives satire doctor who Sundance TV cancelled television Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Sci-Fi BET parents screen actors guild tv talk Trailer indiana jones The Purge black Sneak Peek 24 frames Awards Tour 21st Century Fox Comics on TV anime Polls and Games Biopics ghosts Set visit A24 international venice LGBTQ Comic-Con@Home 2021 scorecard Endgame hollywood Wes Anderson Spike Rom-Com Adult Swim sag awards critic resources reboot social media 73rd Emmy Awards Alien Drama New York Comic Con directors