Critical Consensus: "Blue" Sinks, "Violence" Kills, "Serenity" Soars

by | September 29, 2005 | Comments

This week at the movies, we have sexy divers ("Into the Blue"), secretive family men ("A History of Violence"), space renegades ("Serenity"), streetwise scamps ("Oliver Twist") and sandtraps ("The Greatest Game Ever Played"). Who will survive the scrutiny of the scribes?

Is "Into the Blue" an action-packed thriller, or an excuse for Jessica Alba and Paul Walker to wear as little clothing as possible? More to the point, is this tale of attractive snorkelers who happen upon some dangerous treasure seaworthy? In a word, no, say the critics. Despite an attractive cast, the critics say this one is submarined by camp and unintentional laughs. At 23 percent on the Tomatometer, the scribes are definitely not "Into" this one.

Why do millions of people pay good money to see violent images on the screen week after week? What evil lurks in the hearts of men? Is it possible that perpetual outsider David Cronenberg has made — gasp! – a mainstream movie? These are some of the questions raised by "A History of Violence," the story of a small-town restaurant owner (Viggo Mortensen) with a secret or two. The critics are raising another question: Is this the best movie of the year so far? At 87 percent on the Tomatometer, it’s one of the best reviewed.

Fangirls and fanboys of the world, rejoice! Your beloved, swiftly cancelled TV series, "Firefly" is on the big screen, and it’s getting really good reviews! A tale of a ragtag bunch of space fugitives, "Serenity" is winning praise for its great ensemble chemistry, genre jumping audacity, and punchy dialogue. At 80 percent on the Tomatometer, Joss Whedon’s space opera will leave its cult following with a feeling of "Serenity."

Roman Polanski is one of those directors whose work is filled with touches so personal that every film is a window to his soul. Polanski has adapted classics before ("Tess," "Macbeth") and brought a heavy dose of autobiography to the table. While the critics aren’t completely opposed to his take on Dickens’ "Oliver Twist," they have collectively questioned why Polanski made such a faithful, surprisingly bloodless version of a story that’s been pretty well covered in cinematic history. At 53 percent on the Tomatometer, the critics are saying let’s not "Twist" again.

Feel-good sports stories never get old. Ever. That’s why so many of them get made. "The Greatest Game Ever Played," Bill Paxton‘s second film in the director’s chair, tells the story of blue collar Francis Ouimet, an amateur golfer who shocked the sports world by defeating British champion Harry Vardon at the 1913 U.S. Open. The critics say the movie is as predictable as they come, but it’s also heartfelt and absorbing. At 65 percent on the Tomatometer, this one’s got "Game."

Most Recent Jessica Alba Movies:
25% — Fantastic Four (2005)
78% — Sin City (2005)
16% — Honey (2003)
17% — Idle Hands (1999)
58% — Never Been Kissed (1999)

Most Recent David Cronenberg Movies:
85% — Spider (2003)
72% — eXistenZ (1999)
63% — Crash (1996)
47% — M Butterfly (1993)
64% — Naked Lunch (1991)

Notable TV Series to Film Adaptations with Principle Cast Members:
70% — X-Files: Fight the Future (1998)
74% — Mystery Science 3000: The Movie (1996)
58% — Twin Peaks: Fire Walk with Me (1992)
92% — The Naked Gun – From the Files of Police Squad (1988)
53% — Star Trek: The Motion Picture (1980)

Tag Cloud

Podcast biography SDCC Paramount Network CBS PaleyFest Universal Rock Pop Comic Book Super Bowl Crackle Winners Showtime Mystery Pixar APB PBS OWN Set visit Schedule Nat Geo President ABC Family TV Video Games war Premiere Dates TNT ABC social media TCA justice league supernatural Star Wars Thanksgiving Britbox Ellie Kemper Food Network dc politics Reality 2015 Toys 2016 Music dceu E! Disney History Lionsgate Sundance Dark Horse Comics Mary Tyler Moore Fall TV Paramount 24 frames BBC Comedy Biopics BBC America NBC USA Network Pirates Syfy Countdown romance 007 MTV 45 Emmys based on movie The CW E3 Ghostbusters Rom-Com USA transformers Writers Guild of America Cartoon Network Marvel travel AMC DC Comics Creative Arts Emmys IFC The Arrangement dramedy YA Amazon Disney Channel DC Universe Lifetime Summer Comedy Central Superheroes Nominations singing competition boxoffice TV Land Tumblr NYCC See It Skip It Election ratings Logo GIFs DirecTV WGN Photos TIFF SundanceTV Year in Review vampires Rocky HBO TruTV TBS Calendar Horror Spring TV First Look MSNBC aliens crime thriller X-Men Martial Arts BET Starz comiccon cinemax Box Office Sci-Fi CBS All Access ESPN GLAAD thriller Sundance Now Sneak Peek Action Awards Red Carpet American Society of Cinematographers adventure crime Masterpiece Hulu Star Trek medical drama TCM Kids & Family police drama Trailer GoT VH1 technology sports Polls and Games Netflix Character Guide zombie FOX cats harry potter binge Fantasy Winter TV spy thriller TCA 2017 Esquire Christmas Spike crime drama LGBTQ cooking composers political drama talk show Tomatazos Western Fox News golden globes El Rey CNN Mindy Kaling science fiction Freeform Trivia sitcom Country ITV RT History FXX Reality Competition Teen Warner Bros. A&E Musicals serial killer CMT Adult Swim TLC VICE historical drama psycho Holidays Drama cops period drama Musical Cosplay Interview Valentine's Day Animation discovery Oscars Nickelodeon Extras Opinion Best and Worst Marathons Acorn TV FX Bravo Certified Fresh Watching Series diversity docudrama 2017 21st Century Fox Grammys Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt what to watch Infographic