Critics Consensus

Arrival is Certified Fresh

Plus, Almost Christmas is overstuffed, and guess Shut In's Tomatometer.

by | November 10, 2016 | Comments

This weekend at the movies, we have aliens among us (Arrival, starring Amy Adams and Jeremy Renner), a housebound mother’s worst nightmare (Shut In, starring Naomi Watts and Jacob Tremblay), and the first holiday dramedy of the season (Almost Christmas, starring Danny Glover and Kimberly Elise). What do the critics have to say?

Arrival (2016) 94%

Hollywood has imagined mankind meeting alien life countless times, making it fairly difficult to grab a film fan’s attention with yet another entry in the genre. Difficult, but not impossible: with this weekend’s Arrival, director Denis Villeneuve delivers a refreshingly thoughtful take on first contact that’s also already one of the year’s most widely acclaimed releases. Starring Amy Adams as a linguist called upon to decipher our visitors’ communication before the planet tilts into war, this Venice Film Festival favorite has critics spewing the kinds of superlatives that don’t ordinarily come attached to movies featuring aliens and spaceships. As we settle into prestige season at the cineplex, this looks like one release capable of bridging the gap between popcorn entertainment and pundits’ praise.

Almost Christmas (2016) 51%

It wouldn’t be the holidays at the movies without at least one warmhearted ensemble dramedy about a squabbling family solving its differences in time to bond over carols under the tree. It isn’t even Thanksgiving yet, but at the theaters this weekend, it’s Almost Christmas, the latest from writer-director David E. Talbert (Baggage Claim, First Sunday). Starring a crowded cast that includes Danny Glover, Kimberly Elise, Omar Epps, Mo’Nique, and J.B. Smoove, Christmas brings several generations together under one roof for the holidays, and if you’ve gotten this far, you pretty much know the drill — just as it most likely won’t surprise you that critics aren’t overly impressed with the end result, which has been accused of stuffing an overload of clichés into an already unnecessarily crowded plot. Unless you’re in a rush to watch a holiday movie in theaters this weekend, it looks like you can safely skip Almost Christmas.

Shut In (2016) 9%

The old trapped-in-a-house gambit is a pretty dependable horror setup, and we know Naomi Watts is pretty darn talented. Unfortunately, we can’t tell you much more about Shut In, in which Watts stars as a grieving mom caring for her paralyzed son during a major storm while growing increasingly convinced there’s an intruder in her home, because it wasn’t screened in advance for critics. Guess that Tomatometer!

Also Opening This Week In Limited Release

Tag Cloud

Mindy Kaling USA Network Sci-Fi period drama Sneak Peek Tarantino YouTube Premium Peacock ghosts OWN Song of Ice and Fire mutant TCA 2017 children's TV crime Epix National Geographic Arrowverse Spike TIFF Comedy latino GIFs mockumentary FOX docudrama transformers based on movie doctor who WGN Thanksgiving spider-man Year in Review HBO ESPN Star Wars Binge Guide First Reviews The Witch GLAAD Holidays finale tv talk Lionsgate sequel Musical Black Mirror Vudu Winners Character Guide Action cults DC Universe Comedy Central Best and Worst Adult Swim X-Men Showtime Awards Tour DC streaming service adaptation Countdown hist WarnerMedia casting science fiction romance A&E cops Chernobyl LGBT Horror Quiz Cartoon Network witnail Box Office Masterpiece Election 2019 Starz true crime hispanic Polls and Games PaleyFest disaster Pet Sematary 2015 The CW book Disney streaming service Cosplay Photos 24 frames Captain marvel singing competition spinoff Christmas Amazon Prime CMT Film Festival 2017 unscripted spain 20th Century Fox TruTV Bravo APB movies Trivia Lucasfilm TNT Pop Mary poppins serial killer Fantasy sitcom aliens biography RT History IFC Films Sundance Now SDCC Film crossover Winter TV cooking Star Trek kids Rock CBS All Access Trailer FXX Premiere Dates Ghostbusters Rocky 007 Tomatazos adventure Writers Guild of America TV Land Nickelodeon Crackle MSNBC harry potter composers cinemax psycho Pride Month Sony Pictures Rocketman Country Syfy vampires Television Academy Oscars revenge VH1 71st Emmy Awards game of thrones DirecTV Acorn TV Teen dramedy crime drama Schedule Shudder historical drama Spectrum Originals Kids & Family ABC DGA nature Heroines streaming TBS ABC Family First Look Amazon spy thriller Comics on TV Hulu President zero dark thirty Netflix ITV justice league 2016 anthology NBC RT21 war Creative Arts Emmys psychological thriller comic Esquire Anna Paquin 45 Rom-Com Grammys Biopics Nominations quibi richard e. Grant BBC Podcast IFC Emmys stand-up comedy jamie lee curtis YA zombie Fall TV festivals facebook Amazon Prime Video See It Skip It Tumblr FX CNN HBO Max 21st Century Fox crime thriller social media Super Bowl E! Dark Horse Comics Universal TCM animated what to watch Interview Walt Disney Pictures AMC TCA golden globes New York Comic Con Reality Competition Sundance Chilling Adventures of Sabrina police drama USA Western Summer Paramount Network Shondaland political drama Superheroes Warner Bros. Emmy Nominations PBS LGBTQ Brie Larson Trophy Talk zombies elevated horror Valentine's Day Spring TV SundanceTV travel diversity Pixar Logo medical drama NYCC natural history Awards Opinion Nat Geo dragons Reality Martial Arts Stephen King spanish language Cannes politics Set visit Marathons E3 Columbia Pictures Drama TLC south america Elton John game show Certified Fresh technology 2018 foreign ratings Britbox sports Superheroe toy story Mudbound BET dc award winner MTV Red Carpet cars MCU video Comic Book series History miniseries Video Games robots DC Comics VICE Pirates Mary Poppins Returns Animation thriller dceu Ellie Kemper El Rey anime Mary Tyler Moore green book blaxploitation boxoffice Apple Family TV Toys television cats CBS GoT Women's History Month discovery Infographic comiccon space CW Seed The Arrangement Calendar Food Network Music SXSW Watching Series Mystery supernatural Marvel Fox News strong female leads talk show Ovation Musicals Lifetime Disney YouTube Red Freeform San Diego Comic-Con BBC America Extras Paramount binge American Society of Cinematographers Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Disney Channel theme song teaser