Critics Consensus

Arrival is Certified Fresh

Plus, Almost Christmas is overstuffed, and guess Shut In's Tomatometer.

by | November 10, 2016 | Comments

This weekend at the movies, we have aliens among us (Arrival, starring Amy Adams and Jeremy Renner), a housebound mother’s worst nightmare (Shut In, starring Naomi Watts and Jacob Tremblay), and the first holiday dramedy of the season (Almost Christmas, starring Danny Glover and Kimberly Elise). What do the critics have to say?


Arrival (2016) 94%

Hollywood has imagined mankind meeting alien life countless times, making it fairly difficult to grab a film fan’s attention with yet another entry in the genre. Difficult, but not impossible: with this weekend’s Arrival, director Denis Villeneuve delivers a refreshingly thoughtful take on first contact that’s also already one of the year’s most widely acclaimed releases. Starring Amy Adams as a linguist called upon to decipher our visitors’ communication before the planet tilts into war, this Venice Film Festival favorite has critics spewing the kinds of superlatives that don’t ordinarily come attached to movies featuring aliens and spaceships. As we settle into prestige season at the cineplex, this looks like one release capable of bridging the gap between popcorn entertainment and pundits’ praise.


Almost Christmas (2016) 49%

It wouldn’t be the holidays at the movies without at least one warmhearted ensemble dramedy about a squabbling family solving its differences in time to bond over carols under the tree. It isn’t even Thanksgiving yet, but at the theaters this weekend, it’s Almost Christmas, the latest from writer-director David E. Talbert (Baggage Claim, First Sunday). Starring a crowded cast that includes Danny Glover, Kimberly Elise, Omar Epps, Mo’Nique, and J.B. Smoove, Christmas brings several generations together under one roof for the holidays, and if you’ve gotten this far, you pretty much know the drill — just as it most likely won’t surprise you that critics aren’t overly impressed with the end result, which has been accused of stuffing an overload of clichés into an already unnecessarily crowded plot. Unless you’re in a rush to watch a holiday movie in theaters this weekend, it looks like you can safely skip Almost Christmas.


Shut In (2016) 5%

The old trapped-in-a-house gambit is a pretty dependable horror setup, and we know Naomi Watts is pretty darn talented. Unfortunately, we can’t tell you much more about Shut In, in which Watts stars as a grieving mom caring for her paralyzed son during a major storm while growing increasingly convinced there’s an intruder in her home, because it wasn’t screened in advance for critics. Guess that Tomatometer!


Also Opening This Week In Limited Release

  • My Life as a Zucchini (2016) , the stop-motion story of an orphan’s efforts to build a new family, is at 100 percent.
  • National Bird (2016) , a documentary look at military whistleblowers’ efforts to unmask the downside of drone warfare, is at 100 percent.
  • Kiki, Love to Love (2016) , a five-chapter look at sex, love, and romance from director Paco León, is at 100 percent.
  • The Love Witch (2016) , about a witch on a magically sexy quest to land the man of her dreams, is at 97 percent.
  • Elle (2016) , a Paul Verhoeven drama about the aftermath of a woman’s (Isabelle Huppert) assault, is Certified Fresh at 93 percent.
  • The Monster (2016) , about a mother and daughter stranded in potentially lethal woods after a car accident, is at 79 percent.
  • Uncle Kent 2 (2015) , a meta-sequel of sorts to Joe Swanberg‘s 2011 feature, is at 63 percent.
  • Billy Lynn's Long Halftime Walk (2016) , Ang Lee‘s technologically innovative look at a war veteran’s experiences in combat and at home, is at 47 percent.
  • Dreamland (2016) , about a layabout musician’s increasingly fraught efforts to open his own piano bar, is at 43 percent.
  • USS Indianapolis: Men of Courage (2016) , a World War II drama starring Nicolas Cage, is at 11 percent.

Tag Cloud

new star wars movies rt archives AMC documentary Mudbound spider-verse Paramount Pictures 2017 Crackle NBA Sneak Peek 2016 Nat Geo fast and furious spanish language composers nbcuniversal Netflix Christmas movies Lifetime Hallmark Christmas movies critic resources war canceled comic Chernobyl golden globes slasher HBO Go Warner Bros. vampires San Diego Comic-Con based on movie Pixar Best Actor 007 ESPN movies The Walking Dead Stephen King what to watch comic book movie comic book movies cancelled television dreamworks screen actors guild Musical USA reboot stop motion FXX Fargo Crunchyroll prank South by Southwest Film Festival international heist movie New York Comic Con TBS Election 90s sports binge joker theme song romantic comedy football venice elevated horror Hollywood Foreign Press Association ID Travel Channel GoT 99% Superheroes Cartoon Network casting cancelled TV series APB leaderboard Brie Larson biopic blaxploitation supernatural kaiju Endgame jurassic park ViacomCBS Film Festival IMDb TV TV Tubi live event Red Carpet cancelled TV shows PaleyFest Marvel Television quibi classics Turner USA Network Schedule BAFTA dexter hidden camera french die hard SXSW 2022 CMT Rock Instagram Live Freeform Grammys Year in Review Amazon El Rey zero dark thirty Character Guide Awards Tour hispanic heritage month Fantasy action-comedy cults archives mob mockumentary Pop TV streaming movies See It Skip It franchise Country Food Network Wes Anderson Interview 79th Golden Globes Awards black summer preview news trailers satire Ovation Amazon Studios Funimation green book travel marvel cinematic universe cartoon thriller aliens japan PBS rotten movies we love OneApp all-time high school harry potter AMC Plus Trailer nfl 2020 obituary discovery MGM scary new york Opinion concert First Look Pride Month fresh Tumblr ITV Drama hispanic Star Trek Mary Poppins Returns Academy Awards Emmys Oscars Paramount Plus Certified Fresh Reality A24 south america Oscar Black Mirror Lionsgate breaking bad Horror 73rd Emmy Awards boxing TCA 2017 target docuseries crime thriller adventure Exclusive Video singing competition Polls and Games Hear Us Out YouTube Premium Toys criterion BBC One live action worst The Arrangement medical drama Elton John IFC Prime Video trophy 1990s comic books festivals ratings Rom-Com australia Emmy Nominations Star Wars halloween Columbia Pictures Turner Classic Movies TCA OWN Disney+ Disney Plus Netflix royal family psycho Premiere Dates Marathons 94th Oscars stoner Arrowverse comics 2019 crime drama Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt DirecTV worst movies Neflix Sony Pictures BBC 45 young adult Heroines art house First Reviews technology asian-american italian police drama independent movie American Society of Cinematographers Epix Action Britbox biography natural history dramedy TLC tv talk Creative Arts Emmys crime game of thrones social media transformers Apple TV+ Comedy Central Martial Arts MCU dc popular video LGBT YouTube Red Captain marvel Mystery monster movies dark Super Bowl name the review TIFF spanish Masterpiece Sci-Fi basketball The CW chucky SXSW true crime BET Awards TV movies streaming historical drama Ellie Kemper black comedy Comedy Holidays Syfy TCA Awards rt labs critics edition psychological thriller DGA ABC Family NBC scorecard wonder woman aapi Teen Esquire YA adaptation 24 frames Podcast christmas movies space remakes Fox News Fall TV political drama Apple TV Plus child's play Women's History Month laika documentaries 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards HBO Max Spike lord of the rings Best Director LGBTQ doctor who Legendary Universal Television Critics Association 20th Century Fox Mary Tyler Moore talk show sequels Superheroe Photos FOX Valentine's Day Dark Horse Comics Amazon Prime Amazon Prime Video sitcom Calendar batman Watching Series Disney streaming service cars dogs godzilla Thanksgiving BBC America Broadway halloween tv versus television scary movies Fox Searchlight RT21 werewolf saw Cannes deadpool SDCC book Kids & Family Quiz strong female leads Cosplay game show Rocky rotten MTV mission: impossible CBS Family NYCC award winner Box Office witnail scene in color latino TCA Winter 2020 Best Picture animated Christmas Paramount Network Sundance Now 72 Emmy Awards Logo romance marvel comics Tomatazos streamig Animation robots Disney Channel suspense DC Universe vs. Lifetime Christmas movies Awards toy story Television Academy Sundance TV reviews Marvel VICE diversity DC Comics 2018 king arthur YouTube GLAAD X-Men 71st Emmy Awards crossover gangster Walt Disney Pictures blockbusters Rocketman slashers boxoffice indie Lucasfilm Countdown Pet Sematary HBO feel good 4/20 Paramount twilight obi wan BET Bravo justice league serial killer E3 FX on Hulu period drama films National Geographic directors ABC Signature Best Actress ghosts Nickelodeon politics festival razzies Image Comics IFC Films TCM Reality Competition TNT Anna Paquin facebook kong indiana jones sequel Pirates zombies summer TV mutant Discovery Channel anime olympics renewed TV shows Vudu Apple miniseries dragons WarnerMedia revenge know your critic video on demand Trivia sag awards Infographic Shudder stand-up comedy summer TV preview VH1 hollywood Peacock cinemax Trophy Talk RT History spy thriller zombie E! The Walt Disney Company dceu richard e. Grant Acorn TV cops series cats Alien The Purge jamie lee curtis Hallmark Baby Yoda a nightmare on elm street genre Hulu hist anthology Starz james bond Showtime Focus Features WGN Video Games A&E History superman Comics on TV TV Land superhero Extras GIFs The Academy Western Pop spinoff Sundance mcc Disney Spring TV Tokyo Olympics ABC Binge Guide unscripted universal monsters President posters VOD parents Song of Ice and Fire Musicals CBS All Access Avengers MSNBC The Witch spider-man spain Comic Book screenings PlayStation Music Pacific Islander Tags: Comedy adenture CNN book adaptation Holiday CW Seed HFPA Mary poppins Adult Swim pirates of the caribbean Black History Month disaster Marvel Studios debate Winners TV renewals Classic Film japanese comedies Tarantino Universal Pictures FX nature best cancelled rom-coms finale cooking Chilling Adventures of Sabrina rt labs 2015 telelvision teaser new zealand Winter TV Film Summer Nominations toronto TV One 2021 docudrama 93rd Oscars Biopics canceled TV shows children's TV blockbuster legend sopranos Comic-Con@Home 2021 Shondaland comiccon TruTV golden globe awards SundanceTV Mindy Kaling critics free movies Spectrum Originals women king kong Set visit kids emmy awards 21st Century Fox foreign Writers Guild of America Disney Plus DC streaming service Best and Worst Ghostbusters science fiction