Critics Consensus

Arrival is Certified Fresh

Plus, Almost Christmas is overstuffed, and guess Shut In's Tomatometer.

by | November 10, 2016 | Comments

This weekend at the movies, we have aliens among us (Arrival, starring Amy Adams and Jeremy Renner), a housebound mother’s worst nightmare (Shut In, starring Naomi Watts and Jacob Tremblay), and the first holiday dramedy of the season (Almost Christmas, starring Danny Glover and Kimberly Elise). What do the critics have to say?


Arrival (2016) 94%

Hollywood has imagined mankind meeting alien life countless times, making it fairly difficult to grab a film fan’s attention with yet another entry in the genre. Difficult, but not impossible: with this weekend’s Arrival, director Denis Villeneuve delivers a refreshingly thoughtful take on first contact that’s also already one of the year’s most widely acclaimed releases. Starring Amy Adams as a linguist called upon to decipher our visitors’ communication before the planet tilts into war, this Venice Film Festival favorite has critics spewing the kinds of superlatives that don’t ordinarily come attached to movies featuring aliens and spaceships. As we settle into prestige season at the cineplex, this looks like one release capable of bridging the gap between popcorn entertainment and pundits’ praise.


Almost Christmas (2016) 49%

It wouldn’t be the holidays at the movies without at least one warmhearted ensemble dramedy about a squabbling family solving its differences in time to bond over carols under the tree. It isn’t even Thanksgiving yet, but at the theaters this weekend, it’s Almost Christmas, the latest from writer-director David E. Talbert (Baggage Claim, First Sunday). Starring a crowded cast that includes Danny Glover, Kimberly Elise, Omar Epps, Mo’Nique, and J.B. Smoove, Christmas brings several generations together under one roof for the holidays, and if you’ve gotten this far, you pretty much know the drill — just as it most likely won’t surprise you that critics aren’t overly impressed with the end result, which has been accused of stuffing an overload of clichés into an already unnecessarily crowded plot. Unless you’re in a rush to watch a holiday movie in theaters this weekend, it looks like you can safely skip Almost Christmas.


Shut In (2016) 9%

The old trapped-in-a-house gambit is a pretty dependable horror setup, and we know Naomi Watts is pretty darn talented. Unfortunately, we can’t tell you much more about Shut In, in which Watts stars as a grieving mom caring for her paralyzed son during a major storm while growing increasingly convinced there’s an intruder in her home, because it wasn’t screened in advance for critics. Guess that Tomatometer!


Also Opening This Week In Limited Release

Tag Cloud

71st Emmy Awards Anna Paquin critics Video Games Syfy cults serial killer Acorn TV comic Holiday TV TV Land Ellie Kemper YouTube OWN Lucasfilm Pirates Interview NBC slashers franchise DGA tv talk cats green book Amazon Prime Video richard e. Grant Reality Competition crossover canceled Lionsgate Trivia Year in Review MCU travel south america romantic comedy screenings psycho WGN Masterpiece Epix Tomatazos werewolf Set visit crime thriller GLAAD Baby Yoda Amazon Comics on TV war Nickelodeon reviews documentary Martial Arts Thanksgiving The CW Marvel stoner Holidays Trailer Pixar National Geographic harry potter Lifetime Christmas movies zero dark thirty halloween Hulu BBC TLC Amazon Studios Superheroe Heroines independent dogs CBS All Access Western Summer Countdown Awards Tour Star Trek joker strong female leads cancelled television Oscars VH1 Opinion VICE Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt First Look sag awards biography Star Wars crime drama Universal Paramount Network Netflix Nat Geo San Diego Comic-Con 2017 AMC LGBTQ Awards Red Carpet Tubi 45 E3 TCA 2017 Disney+ Disney Plus ratings DC Universe child's play game of thrones Mudbound Comedy ESPN dark Television Academy children's TV The Walking Dead diversity cancelled blaxploitation First Reviews period drama rotten movies we love reboot witnail Photos American Society of Cinematographers dragons Disney streaming service jamie lee curtis scary movies Film Festival Emmy Nominations Avengers Best and Worst MSNBC Crunchyroll Music USA Network all-time movies Ghostbusters concert boxoffice kids festivals cops book FX Super Bowl CW Seed BET TCM renewed TV shows blockbuster what to watch USA Superheroes sports Kids & Family technology chucky based on movie President discovery MTV crime 20th Century Fox Dark Horse Comics Sci-Fi Warner Bros. versus Tumblr DC Comics Chilling Adventures of Sabrina sequel mission: impossible Reality police drama die hard Creative Arts Emmys ABC Family Britbox Comedy Central politics toy story Apple historical drama Disney Plus aliens best comics disaster indie justice league Box Office Writers Guild of America Shudder psychological thriller Premiere Dates FXX Logo romance Pet Sematary Sundance Discovery Channel series streaming TV renewals dc Marvel Studios comedies Turner Classic Movies YouTube Red Walt Disney Pictures Song of Ice and Fire Binge Guide quibi batman dramedy Shondaland medical drama Classic Film teaser APB Rock composers Amazon Prime casting HBO 2019 CBS Freeform Mystery parents Crackle social media Schedule BBC America El Rey Chernobyl New York Comic Con Tarantino stand-up comedy Infographic golden globes Animation canceled TV shows GoT A&E game show IFC Films Drama TruTV GIFs Action Apple TV+ asian-american hist animated award winner IFC Christmas breaking bad miniseries Fantasy zombie Apple TV Plus natural history 007 ITV anime movie 2015 mutant video A24 Captain marvel binge cancelled TV series OneApp Spring TV 2016 NYCC LGBT Fall TV Vudu name the review Toys Rocketman Hallmark ghosts Stephen King robots spy thriller TBS The Witch Horror Certified Fresh YA vampires anthology spinoff nature cars unscripted Rom-Com theme song Brie Larson Pride Month Netflix Christmas movies Disney Channel cancelled TV shows Comic Book space Bravo Spectrum Originals Winners political drama Arrowverse Valentine's Day facebook latino revenge HBO Max true crime Cartoon Network Paramount TCA Winter 2020 History CMT Ovation Mary Tyler Moore Pop SDCC DC streaming service TIFF Elton John spanish language Sundance TV criterion talk show 21st Century Fox X-Men DirecTV Funimation Extras Columbia Pictures See It Skip It Country Film TCA ABC Sony Pictures The Purge Marvel Television 24 frames Starz Fox News screen actors guild Mindy Kaling Teen TNT Sundance Now 2020 SXSW sitcom Calendar Quiz Peacock Hear Us Out transformers cooking Food Network finale Turner Disney spider-man directors Biopics Endgame Family cinemax SundanceTV Grammys hispanic television Travel Channel Lifetime spain Women's History Month Academy Awards Pop TV christmas movies Winter TV mockumentary science fiction Esquire PBS Adult Swim Musicals Cosplay Spike free movies Mary poppins singing competition RT21 2018 Cannes Watching Series YouTube Premium CNN a nightmare on elm street comiccon Black Mirror E! doctor who 4/20 Mary Poppins Returns cartoon The Arrangement Musical Emmys Showtime thriller supernatural elevated horror docudrama foreign WarnerMedia Character Guide FX on Hulu Sneak Peek zombies Black History Month dceu Trophy Talk universal monsters Polls and Games Hallmark Christmas movies Podcast Nominations adventure Election PaleyFest RT History Marathons Rocky FOX adaptation