Critics Consensus

American Ultra is Half-Baked

Plus, Hitman: Agent 47 and Sinister 2 both misfire badly, and Show Me a Hero is Certified Fresh.

by | August 20, 2015 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a reluctant assassin (American Ultra, starring Jesse Eisenberg and Kristen Stewart), a remorseless assassin (Hitman: Agent 47, starring Rupert Friend and Zachary Quinto), and remorseless revenant (Sinister 2, starring James Ransone and Shannyn Sossamon). What do the critics have to say?

American Ultra (2015) 43%

American Ultra has a pretty ingenious premise: what if a perpetually stoned slacker was a brainwashed killing machine? Unfortunately, critics say this would-be mashup of The Manchurian Candidate and Pineapple Express is undone by an inconsistent tone, veering wildly between laughs and ultraviolence — though stars Jesse Eisenberg and Kristen Stewart make a charming pair. Eisenberg plays Mike, a small-town layabout who lives blissfully unaware that he was once trained as a CIA super soldier. When the agency decides to eliminate him, his dormant powers are activated and chaos ensues. The pundits say American Ultra is quite sweet and charming in spots, but it devolves into the kind of mediocre shoot-em-up it seemed to parody in the first place.

Hitman: Agent 47 (2015) 8%

Hitman: Agent 47 is a sequel/reboot to a video game adaptation that wasn’t particularly loved to begin with. So it shouldn’t come as much of a surprise that critics say it’s a bland, shallow action flick that heaps more loving care on its shootouts than its characters. Rupert Friend stars as the titular assassin, who acquired his murderous talents as part of a secret government experiment. He’s tasked with tracking down a woman who knows secrets about the program’s origins. The pundits say Hitman: Agent 47 is thoroughly generic stuff, and its occasional flashes of craft do little to elevate its hollow emotional core.

Sinister 2 (2015) 15%

In Sinister, a writer moved into a house that was bedeviled by a ghoul that lurked within the frames of old Super 8 films. Critics say Sinister 2 is haunted as well — by a dull script and a decided lack of scares. Shannyn Sossamon stars as a woman who moves into an isolated farmhouse with her sons to escape her abusive husband. Soon, however, the malevolent spirit Bughuul turns up with his box of haunted Super 8 reels. Critics say Sinister 2 substitutes jump scares for real tension, and it’s only on the strength of the acting that the film sustains any interest.

 What’s Hot on TV


Show Me a Hero: Season 1 (2015) 96%

Show Me a Hero is an impressively crafted period drama whose timely themes prove as absorbing as its engaging, compassionately drawn characters.

Fear the Walking Dead: Season 1 (2015) 76%

Fear the Walking Dead recycles elements of its predecessor, but it’s still moody and engrossing enough to compete with the original.

Kevin From Work: Season 1 (2015) 55%

Kevin From Work relies on raunchy jokes delivered by unsavory characters, but the show’s gags hit their targets often enough to elevate a rather routine premise.

Also Opening This Week In Limited Release


  • Being Evel (2015) , a documentary portrait of legendary motorcycle daredevil Evel Knievel, is at 100 percent.
  • Blood Cells (2015) , a drama about a transient laborer haunted by family secrets, is at 100 percent.
  • Station To Station (2015) , which documents a cross-country train trip and features short works by a wide range of artists, is at 90 percent.
  • Grandma (2015) , starring Lily Tomlin in a comedy about a woman who visits a bunch of old friends iin order to borrow money to help her granddaughter out of a jam, is at 88 percent.
  • The Iron Ministry (2015) , a semi-experimental documentary about China’s railway system and its passengers, is at 86 percent.
  • Guidance (2015) , a comedy about a former child star who fakes his way into a gig as a high school guidance counselor, is at 80 percent.
  • The Mend (2015) , starring Josh Lucas in a comedy about a man who stirs up dysfunction when he crashes on his brother’s couch, is at 75 percent.
  • Digging For Fire (2015) , starring Jake Johnson and Rosemarie DeWitt in a comedy about the marital tension that arises when a man makes a strange discovery at a rented house, is at 70 percent.
  • Learning To Drive (2015) , starring Patricia Clarkson and Ben Kingsley in a romantic drama about a lovelorn woman who bonds with a cabbie while receiving driving lessons, is at 45 percent.
  • After Words (2015) , starring Marcia Gay Harden in a drama about a woman in the midst of a personal crisis who meets a younger man while on vacation, is at 40 percent.
  • 6 Years (2015) , starring Taissa Farmiga and Ben Rosenfield in a drama about the ups and downs in a young couple’s relationship, is at 40 percent.
  • Peter Bogdanovich‘s  She's Funny That Way (2015) , starring Owen Wilson and Imogen Poots in a screwball farce about a theater director who casts his wife and her ex  alongside his mistress in a new play, is at 38 percent.
  • The Curse of Downers Grove (2015) , a horror film about a hex that claims the life of a high school senior each year, is at 20 percent.
  • Some Kind of Beautiful (2015) , starring Pierce Brosnan and Salma Hayek in a comedy about a rakish professor in love with his girlfriend’s sister, is at zero percent.
  • Tenshi Ippikiookami

    well, skipping the weekend. I may see American ultra at home, in the future, some day…

    • April Bianca

      No, no, no! American Ultra is so good. Really funny. And everyone in the theater was laughing. It was fun to see it with a crowd. I don’t usually care about that, but this time it’s really true. The critics are often wrong when they dis a movie. This is a classic example of that. The violence is graphic, but it is a part of the story. Go to the theater with your friends and you will have a lot of fun!

      • Tenshi Ippikiookami

        I had the feeling American Ultra could be one of those movies. I may check it then 😉

        • April Bianca


          • Tenshi Ippikiookami

            thanks 😉

      • The critics didn’t get the irony of this movie.Because they are stupid, that’s why. They don’t get paid much so they don’t try much.

  • Robert O’Dell

    American Ultra is a blast. Ignore the meter and see it. You will laugh alot!

  • Gary the Dairy Fairy

    Sometimes critics miss the mark. I get the feeling that American Ultra is better than the tomato-meter suggests. Looking forward to seeing it.

    • Robert O’Dell

      You won’t be let down.

    • April Bianca

      You’re right. It is so good. Really funny! Enjoy!!

  • Júlio de Oliveira

    Oh Fear the Walking dead starts this weekend!

  • Robert O’Dell

    Can’t abide by the meter this weekend. American Ultra is hilarious and Hitman: Agent 47 is a first rate action film. Both enjoyable popcorn flicks.

  • Anna

    I learned long time ago not to care what critics have to say about a movie. American Ultra was a great movie. I was very impressed with Jesse Eisenberg’s fight scenes. I really didn’t think he had it him. He was kicking ass and taking names.

  • American Ultra is a great serious spoof on the dum ol Hollywood’s tired cliches of plot and characters. Eisenberg and Stewart show just how great actors can turn in a tool kit performance in a fug you to Hollywood’s genre films.

  • Lola

    Reminds me of a Classic !!! Funny !!!

Tag Cloud

game show football know your critic Comic-Con@Home 2021 social media Disney YouTube Red marvel cinematic universe Walt Disney Pictures 99% Mary poppins RT21 Ellie Kemper Endgame discovery based on movie critics period drama Tumblr stoner mutant halloween tv Amazon Studios New York Comic Con satire Lucasfilm FOX Nominations Star Wars science fiction rotten telelvision TV renewals TCM San Diego Comic-Con saw ABC Family south america FX BET Awards TCA Winter 2020 FX on Hulu monster movies halloween Family OneApp scene in color christmas movies Arrowverse X-Men CBS All Access series NBA TLC The Arrangement 1990s richard e. Grant stop motion medical drama Watching Series rotten movies we love Quiz movies MCU teaser Pixar Countdown El Rey serial killer crime 93rd Oscars kids video obituary ITV TV Land Shudder Universal slashers Writers Guild of America Netflix Christmas movies Year in Review DC Comics Rom-Com ratings Musical hist GoT BBC America NBC hispanic new star wars movies Chilling Adventures of Sabrina MSNBC rom-coms Sneak Peek Hallmark Christmas movies Spike Classic Film GLAAD Acorn TV festival superman BBC 2015 2019 Best and Worst suspense biography Paramount Plus cancelled TV One blockbuster YA Broadway OWN harry potter Discovery Channel Sundance Now comic books concert japan emmy awards twilight APB quibi Alien NYCC unscripted international ESPN cars cancelled TV shows facebook comedies razzies Cosplay Travel Channel spanish 2016 The Walt Disney Company italian Holidays WGN Paramount Network HBO binge 2018 dceu The Academy political drama WarnerMedia HBO Go documentary supernatural Marvel Television Martial Arts Podcast 24 frames stand-up comedy venice space TCA Film psycho historical drama E! Schedule independent Tokyo Olympics Star Trek A24 BAFTA sequel Syfy Amazon E3 Action dramedy mission: impossible Marvel miniseries Drama reviews YouTube Premium nbcuniversal Sony Pictures Mindy Kaling crossover anthology Freeform Rocketman cancelled TV series french parents DC Universe BBC One die hard batman child's play Hulu Apple TV+ live action a nightmare on elm street The CW spanish language AMC Thanksgiving trailers RT History USA Network Paramount cinemax Pop transformers what to watch DGA docuseries spider-man Adult Swim foreign blockbusters Photos toy story Reality Competition Peacock MTV Red Carpet vampires hidden camera worst movies all-time Awards Tour Avengers jurassic park Vudu Sundance TV talk show Esquire Funimation dc finale superhero romantic comedy Bravo fast and furious Kids & Family Turner Classic Movies cartoon theme song Shondaland TV Fantasy PaleyFest 71st Emmy Awards Hallmark boxing television Reality Legendary crime drama 72 Emmy Awards Food Network Lifetime Christmas movies streaming police drama 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards History Elton John boxoffice Comedy Central ABC Signature Pacific Islander latino Television Critics Association Cannes 2020 VICE dark Television Academy Awards cops indiana jones Mary Tyler Moore joker green book legend video on demand kong sitcom Amazon Prime Academy Awards golden globe awards Trivia Spectrum Originals The Purge Rocky travel classics President Disney streaming service documentaries PlayStation hollywood wonder woman archives Comedy Creative Arts Emmys Emmy Nominations 21st Century Fox rt archives animated ViacomCBS TBS australia Teen strong female leads Apple TV Plus The Walking Dead breaking bad singing competition films Lifetime reboot USA prank free movies comiccon news renewed TV shows DirecTV Captain marvel 45 4/20 HBO Max scorecard Exclusive Video Chernobyl universal monsters Warner Bros. Britbox spy thriller Stephen King toronto FXX versus adenture spain DC streaming service fresh screen actors guild canceled TV shows black Black Mirror Pop TV CNN 2017 name the review Rock Winners nfl Nat Geo Horror deadpool 20th Century Fox Superheroes nature aapi Comics on TV TIFF Western war A&E canceled Baby Yoda SDCC sequels Turner Women's History Month CW Seed remakes indie Film Festival Interview First Look Winter TV basketball comic Music Musicals Election blaxploitation CMT Netflix IFC Films Disney Plus Mary Poppins Returns Premiere Dates laika scary movies movie dogs best natural history thriller asian-american Tarantino Fox News YouTube Animation criterion VOD Fox Searchlight Epix golden globes Disney Channel book Country ABC Oscars LGBT The Witch anime See It Skip It zombie game of thrones Anna Paquin new york romance Crunchyroll popular SundanceTV women Tomatazos GIFs elevated horror king arthur Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt chucky sports Binge Guide First Reviews disaster VH1 Summer directors Toys doctor who LGBTQ Song of Ice and Fire godzilla aliens zero dark thirty comics new zealand 2021 Columbia Pictures Lionsgate Showtime jamie lee curtis pirates of the caribbean IFC Image Comics Biopics kaiju Pride Month Sundance Fall TV revenge TCA 2017 psychological thriller Wes Anderson technology cooking composers Calendar Cartoon Network sag awards Spring TV spinoff Amazon Prime Video Christmas TV movies heist movie Valentine's Day book adaptation justice league Box Office Holiday 90s casting award winner Dark Horse Comics Brie Larson ID Heroines PBS Apple Black History Month SXSW politics BET tv talk TCA Awards james bond target Trailer olympics Extras CBS National Geographic Set visit cults true crime screenings dragons zombies Certified Fresh Logo Video Games Marvel Studios Masterpiece Ovation crime thriller japanese Infographic diversity king kong Disney+ Disney Plus witnail Super Bowl franchise Character Guide cancelled television streaming movies robots Starz Comic Book Crackle 007 Emmys Hear Us Out festivals Ghostbusters Polls and Games Mudbound worst Sci-Fi Tubi Pirates Trophy Talk American Society of Cinematographers werewolf ghosts Opinion Nickelodeon adaptation cats Superheroe Grammys TruTV high school docudrama adventure children's TV lord of the rings TNT Pet Sematary Marathons Mystery mockumentary