Total Recall

Total Recall: American Gangster's Paradise

Re-discovering the cinema of organized crime.

by | October 31, 2007 | Comments

This week,
Ridley Scott‘s
American Gangster
Russell Crowe and
Denzel Washington hits theaters. With its story of a drug
kingpin and the cop who’s trying to take him down, we at Rotten Tomatoes thought
it would be a good time to delve into some flicks about organized crime you may
have missed.

Organized crime figures have long been some of cinema’s
greatest antiheros. Since the earliest days of sound, gangsters have appealed to
the dark side of audiences, especially since the bad guys are more colorful,
witty, and beholden to codes of honor than the milquetoast “good guys.” Some
films (most notably The Godfather, 100 percent on the Tomatometer) have
had a profound influence on the public’s ideas of the mafia (and mobsters

From the 1910s to the 1920s, "swiped from the
headlines" crime dramas were huge. Scandalous to audiences and censors, these
salacious two and three reel films exposed the plight of pushers, bootleggers
and sex slaves without the banner of the "newsreel" to redeem them. By the sound
era, crime dramas didn’t rely as extensively on the framework of "true stories"
but did sometimes justify their graphic content with socially cautious
introductions. William Wellman’s 1931 masterpiece
The Public Enemy

(100 percent)
introduces its story with outright public service. How better to validate the
sex, bootlegging and gun fighting than to root it in immigration stress and
social woe and then ask the audience, "What will you do about it?"

The Public Enemy balances indignities (remember the
famous grapefruit smashing?) with the ‘business’ of tommy gun stand offs and
even sprinkles the occasional bit of humor into the violence to muddy the moral
waters (amidst gunfire: "I can’t hear you, can you speak-a up?"). Wellman’s
creative use of sound heightens the effects of off-screen sex and violence
(listen for the giggling in the bedroom when Tom Powers [James Cagney] tells his
live-in girlfriend "I wish you was a wishing well ") and the use of screams and
gunfire in Power’s famous retribution scene. The Public Enemy is one of
the best displays of heartbreaking violence you’ll find, so much so that the
censors were stoking coals when this film came out. Though it made overtures
toward a socially redeeming message, the graphic brutality and overt sexual
charge of The Public Enemy would be one of many factors in the
establishment of the1934 Production Code. "James Cagney’s portrayal of a
bootlegging runt is truly electrifying, and Jean Harlow makes the tartiest tart
imaginable," wrote Dave Kehr of the Chicago Reader.

As the decades progressed, the French also carved out their niche in the genre. Director
Jules Dassin was one of the hundreds of named
names during the Hollywood blacklist. Dassin — who had directed classic noirs
like The Naked City
(92 percent) and Brute Force
(80 percent) by time he was routed — was only briefly a
member of the Communist Party, but enough to send him into French exile. But you
know how international directors usually do their worst work when they start working in Hollywood?  Reversing the formula also seems to work: like
Woody Allen, Dassin’s permanent foreign vacation got him to produce one of his best features.
1955’s Rififi
(92 percent), about a newly released jailbird who re-enters the crime world to
pull of a jewel heist, is a crackerjack thriller. Elegantly shot in black
and white and with compelling performances, Kenneth Turan of the Los Angeles
calls Rififi, "[o]ne of the great crime thrillers, the benchmark all
succeeding heist films have been measured against."

And now, a moment of silence. Or several hundred moments of
silence. The legendary centerpiece of Rififi is the jewel heist segment, a completely
wordless, music-free caper that ingeniously turns ordinary objects into tools of
the criminal trade. It’s one of the most nail-biting 30 minutes captured on film.
With action segments now largely driven by stylish edits and speaker-blowing
sound effects and music, Rififi‘s intensely intimate silence speaks

As the times change, so do crime movies. It’s now
commonplace to find crime dramas with hip hop soundtracks, but when
New Jack
(79 percent) was first released in 1991, such cross-promotion was
nothing short of revelatory. It didn’t hurt that the movie itself was a sharp
neo-noir packed with grit and electricity. In his feature directorial debut,
Mario Van Peebles simultaneously borrowed from such gangster touchstones as Scarface
and The Godfather while updating the streetwise blaxploitation classics
of the 1970s (Shaft,
, his father’s
Sweet Sweetback
and adding a dash of quasi-history to the mix as well. Drug lord Nino Brown
(Wesley Snipes) is loosely based upon Nicky Barnes (the subject of the recent
doc Mr. Untouchable, 63 percent); he runs New York’s most dominant drug
organization, converting an apartment complex into a thriving crackhouse. The
police make it a priority to infiltrate Nino’s organization, with an undercover
cop (Ice-T) and a reformed drug addict (Chris Rock) enlisted for the task.

New Jack City has a few problems, most notably its
ludicrous ending. But the film boasts a number of excellent performances: Snipes
is malevolently effective as the brilliant but amoral Nino;
Ice-T and
smartly transcend cliché as cops who don’t like each other but share a
level of mutual respect; and Rock, in a rare dramatic role, is spellbinding as a
recovering crackhead, full of desperate energy and gallows humor. “The
performances are stoked with hyperbolic verve,” wrote Hal Hinson in the Washington
. “The actors all seem to have hooked into the pure, concentrated heart
of their characters, and while their emotions are big, there’s no empty
strutting in them — they’re street-operatic.”

There are a multitude of cinematic roads to Gangland; films
as varied as Little Caesar (84 percent),
Bob Le Flambeur
percent), Deep Cover (84 percent),
Donnie Brasco
(85 percent), and
City of God (92 percent) have allowed audience to infiltrate organized
crime, and reap illicit thrills in the process.

Authors: Sara Schieron, Alex Vo, and Tim Ryan.

Tag Cloud

Super Bowl Pixar FOX Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Opinion The Arrangement what to watch diversity Sundance Warner Bros. X-Men ratings ITV San Diego Comic-Con TLC spider-man mutant natural history Polls and Games talk show Nickelodeon TIFF YouTube Premium Box Office IFC Films miniseries Crackle Superheroe medical drama YouTube Red crime thriller festivals Amazon Mary Poppins Returns HBO Anna Paquin Pet Sematary teaser YA Disney 2015 Columbia Pictures Grammys Horror Teen technology Holidays police drama E3 finale Awards Tour Ovation History Netflix science fiction The CW Valentine's Day Tumblr crime Paramount El Rey dragons Trivia comiccon cooking hist ESPN Logo NBC DC Comics Marathons Mindy Kaling MTV Photos Star Wars Animation Toys MCU Universal crime drama APB war SXSW TruTV TCM Mary poppins Acorn TV OWN Drama nature Reality Spring TV Christmas ABC TCA 2017 Adult Swim 2018 Britbox Superheroes Marvel Showtime National Geographic doctor who Character Guide Women's History Month 21st Century Fox zero dark thirty spy thriller supernatural Stephen King Nominations ABC Family aliens TNT dc comic AMC politics Comic Book Cartoon Network Creative Arts Emmys cats Black Mirror facebook Comedy Central casting Pop Mudbound harry potter GoT Fall TV Thanksgiving Set visit true crime FXX transformers Disney Channel Song of Ice and Fire Spike USA TBS BET adventure Calendar crossover 20th Century Fox Lucasfilm Music A&E elevated horror PaleyFest richard e. Grant anime CBS Sci-Fi Certified Fresh Ellie Kemper social media 007 biography award winner IFC E! WGN GIFs Trailer Action serial killer SDCC MSNBC Countdown Musicals Freeform Tomatazos binge sitcom LGBTQ Biopics Infographic Comics on TV Esquire Amazon Prime Awards political drama Epix Interview Nat Geo Extras Musical romance 24 frames travel cults sequel Fox News RT21 NYCC Rom-Com Quiz Oscars based on movie CBS All Access cops Year in Review Video Games Sneak Peek Sundance Now Trophy Talk See It Skip It GLAAD TCA Apple BBC unscripted Premiere Dates Winter TV Food Network Shudder Reality Competition Mary Tyler Moore VICE Western Sony Pictures Lionsgate Ghostbusters psycho docudrama green book Starz Country American Society of Cinematographers DGA Kids & Family Podcast First Look mockumentary Dark Horse Comics Spectrum Originals discovery CW Seed DC streaming service USA Network dramedy dceu Syfy Cosplay theme song anthology historical drama television boxoffice 2019 justice league CMT Winners Shondaland Emmys Lifetime psychological thriller FX PBS composers robots Comedy Masterpiece BBC America President Captain marvel Martial Arts blaxploitation zombies Summer SundanceTV New York Comic Con adaptation 2016 Red Carpet sports TV streaming Paramount Network Rocky Hulu VH1 Bravo Brie Larson TV Land 2017 Fantasy cinemax Rock Best and Worst golden globes thriller Election RT History vampires singing competition Pirates Star Trek Mystery CNN jamie lee curtis Schedule Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Watching Series Writers Guild of America 45 witnail DirecTV zombie DC Universe Walt Disney Pictures period drama