Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Where the Wild Things Are Is A Wild Rumpus

Plus, Law Abiding Citizen is guilty of contrivance, and guess The Stepfather's Tomatometer!

by | October 15, 2009 | Comments

This week, we’ve got a wild rumpus (Where the Wild Things Are, starring Max Records and Catherine Keener), a legal skirmish (Law Abiding Citizen, starring Jamie Foxx and Gerard Butler), and unconventional parenting (The Stepfather, starring Dylan Walsh and Sela Ward). What do the critics have to say?


Where the Wild Things Are

Maurice Sendak’s Where the Wild Things Are is one of the most beloved classics of modern children’s literature, but the brief text doesn’t necessarily lend itself to feature-length cinematic treatment. Critics have largely praised Spike Jonze for maintaining the spirit of the book while adding some visually daring touches to bring it to life; however, some feel the narrative is a little thin. Max (Max Records) is a troubled youngster who disappears into a fantasy world of his own making, populated by fluffy monsters who symbolize the various facets of his personality. The pundits say Wild Things may be a little too creepy for the wee ones, and it lacks a strong plot. However, the images Jonze crafts are so wondrous that older kids — and adults — will find the film to be a fascinating, poignant dreamscape.


Law Abiding Citizen

Nobody says that a thriller needs to be completely plausible to be watchable. However, staying somewhere within the bounds of believability is generally required, and on this count, and several others, critics say Law Abiding Citizen fails. Gerard Butler stars as a man whose family has been murdered; he becomes enraged when the prosecutor (Jamie Foxx) makes a plea deal with the killer, and goes about exacting revenge. The pundits say Law Abiding Citizen isn’t just outrageously contrived; worse, it lingers a little too long over some gruesome violence under the guise of making a political statement about the judicial system. (Check out our interview with director F. Gary Gray, who shared his Five Favorite Films with RT.).


The Stepfather

It appears the folks behind The Stepfather are being a little too strict with their baby, as it wasn’t screened for critics prior to release. A remake of the 1987 cult classic of the same name, the movie stars Dylan Walsh as a man who’s so perfect for Sela Ward that he must be hiding a dark secret. Kids, guess that Tomatometer!.

Also opening this week in limited release:

Tag Cloud

Photos Reality Sundance Comedy Fox News 2016 Exclusive Video Lionsgate PaleyFest Netflix TIFF VICE Infographic sitcom Character Guide 007 WGN History TCM thriller adventure American Society of Cinematographers Amazon crime drama Box Office Election Fantasy Trivia Reality Competition Extras TCA E! CBS DirecTV Marvel boxoffice Sneak Peek Watching Series Interview CNN Schedule President Red Carpet Ghostbusters OWN 2017 Podcast Opinion Cosplay Polls and Games Summer Freeform GIFs Pirates Country Superheroes CMT IFC Musicals docudrama Masterpiece Action USA Best and Worst Holidays cooking Bravo singing competition Year in Review Showtime Set visit 2015 Tomatazos TruTV politics Emmys Food Network FOX dramedy harry potter GLAAD MSNBC 24 frames Writers Guild of America Cartoon Network Winter TV Drama DC Comics Comedy Central ITV Hulu Fall TV VH1 Star Wars Disney Channel BBC America TNT GoT CBS All Access BET Syfy Oscars Awards Thanksgiving Rocky PBS crime thriller Sci-Fi Tumblr Calendar Animation Valentine's Day The CW Mystery comiccon Kids & Family Esquire sports diversity TBS Nickelodeon AMC NYCC Video Games Martial Arts A&E Adult Swim Premiere Dates Nominations Spring TV Winners Horror Disney Rock LGBTQ El Rey discovery Marathons ABC Family Trailer SDCC Universal travel Toys FXX ABC science fiction HBO period drama SundanceTV Rom-Com Countdown BBC Music Nat Geo serial killer Crackle cinemax Pop FX ESPN social media Lifetime vampires Certified Fresh TCA 2017 Biopics TV Land MTV First Look Starz Logo NBC Grammys