Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Trouble with the Curve Is Solid But Predictable

Plus, Dredd 3D, End of Watch, and The Master are Certified Fresh, and guess House at the End of the Street's Tomatometer.

by | September 20, 2012 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got an aging baseball scout (Trouble with the Curve, starring Clint Eastwood and Amy Adams); a deadly judge (Dredd 3D, starring Karl Urban and Olivia Thirby); cartel-busting cops (End of Watch, starring Jake Gyllenhaal and Michael Pena); a religious leader (The Master, starring Joaquin Phoenix and Philip Seymour Hoffman); and a creepy dwelling (House at the End of the Street, starring Jennifer Lawrence and Elisabeth Shue). What do the critics have to say?

Trouble With the Curve


Nobody plays a grizzled-but-secretly-lovable coot like Clint Eastwood. And critics say he and co-star Amy Adams are in fine form in Trouble with the Curve, even if the movie’s plot is as well-worn as an old catcher’s mitt. Gus Lobel (Eastwood) is an aging scout for the Atlanta Braves who’s losing both his sight and his preternatural gift for judging talent. When the team hopes to secure a hotshot prospect in the draft, Gus’ daughter Mickey (Adams) joins him on a trip to scout the player, mending their frayed relationship in the process. The pundits say Trouble With the Curve may not be a home run, but it’s a solid single: it’s warm, well-acted, and really predictable. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we count down the best movies starring Eastwood.)

Dredd 3D


Judge Dredd, from 1995, has long been a punchline for fans of comic book adaptations. So it’s a small miracle that critics are pretty psyched about the franchise’s reboot — they say Dredd 3D is tense, visceral, and visually dazzling. Karl Urban stars as the title character, a law-enforcement agent that acts as judge, jury, and executioner. Patrolling the streets of a dystopian megalopolis, Dredd battles a vicious drug syndicate that’s taken over a heavily fortified apartment building. The pundits say the Certified Fresh Dredd is ultra-violent (sometimes excessively so), but it’s also deftly paced, action packed, and surprisingly smart.

End of Watch


A buddy-cop movie shot in a found-footage style, End of Watch might initially look like a feature length episode of COPS. However, critics say this is a gritty take on well-trodden turf, and it benefits greatly from the chemistry between leads Jake Gyllenhaal and Michael Pena. They play partners in the LAPD – one of whom is shooting a few days on the beat for a film school project – and what a wild few days they are. Upon making what seems like a routine bust, our heroes become the targets of a ruthless drug cartel. The pundits say the Certified Fresh End of Watch is an immersive experience, putting audiences on a ride-along with two terrifically realized characters.

The Master


Paul Thomas Anderson‘s The Master opens in wide release this weekend, and critics say this tale of a troubled man who falls under the influence of a shadowy religious leader is immersive, expertly crafted, and wonderfully acted. Joaquin Phoenix stars as a navy vet in the midst of personal turmoil who turns to Lancaster Dodd (Philip Seymour Hoffman), the charismatic leader of a group called the Cause; soon, the two men are locked in a test of wills. The pundits say Certified Fresh The Master is a challenging work, but it’s often hypnotic and elusive in the best sense. (Check out RT staffer Jeff Giles’ Paul Thomas Anderson watching series here.)

House at the End of the Street


It appears the folks behind House at the End of the Street were afraid the film wasn’t built on the sturdiest of foundations, since reviews are currently unavailable. Jennifer Lawrence and Elisabeth Shue star as a mother and daughter who move into a new neighborhood, only to learn that the house next door was the site of a gruesome double murder that remains shrouded in mystery. It’s time to guess the Tomatometer! (And check out RT 24 Frames, which delves into Lawrence’s life and career.)

Also opening this week in limited release:

Finally, props to Brian Clarkson and Simon Opitz for coming the closest to guessing Resident Evil: Retribution‘s 29 percent Tomatometer.

Tag Cloud

BET CW Seed Sundance Now American Society of Cinematographers TCA 2017 SDCC Podcast Freeform Oscars APB MSNBC Country Awards The Arrangement Christmas cops CBS All Access TNT LGBTQ 21st Century Fox singing competition political drama PBS cults Opinion romance sitcom BBC Amazon Pixar Star Wars Horror See It Skip It YA CBS Valentine's Day Photos TCA supernatural harry potter boxoffice USA Network politics aliens Bravo TBS MTV Netflix adventure crime thriller President Cartoon Network Biopics docudrama Universal IFC NYCC Disney Channel Rom-Com binge thriller Mary Tyler Moore Year in Review IFC Films Nominations TCM HBO hist YouTube Red 007 zombie 20th Century Fox TLC crossover psycho Lifetime Comedy Central Certified Fresh Rocky AMC Tomatazos Thanksgiving BBC America Comic Book Sony Pictures war Sci-Fi First Look Mystery Lionsgate Reality Food Network Showtime Holidays DC Universe A&E Polls and Games Western TV biography transformers 2016 what to watch Character Guide Mindy Kaling RT History CNN El Rey Action sports Ellie Kemper 45 Winter TV comiccon Dark Horse Comics serial killer dc Syfy Hulu Trivia Spring TV Election Cosplay PaleyFest Superheroe Countdown Nat Geo Spike Emmys Box Office National Geographic technology dceu crime drama Kids & Family ESPN SundanceTV ITV Fall TV vampires WGN cooking Sneak Peek USA Schedule Musical ratings Rock Extras Marvel TIFF Best and Worst FX cinemax dramedy talk show SXSW Music robots TruTV historical drama Watching Series zombies Superheroes travel The CW 2015 Paramount Network Ghostbusters Sundance composers Fantasy GLAAD diversity Britbox Esquire Comedy spy thriller Winners Musicals Super Bowl Premiere Dates Reality Competition Tumblr FOX Creative Arts Emmys ABC Family Marathons medical drama based on movie DC streaming service social media E3 Writers Guild of America Video Games Drama Trailer golden globes Warner Bros. Fox News festivals Lucasfilm TV Land Calendar justice league Nickelodeon Toys Teen Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Grammys science fiction Masterpiece Logo Interview Infographic crime discovery Adult Swim X-Men 24 frames Starz NBC FXX Crackle OWN Acorn TV Star Trek History GoT Martial Arts 2017 DC Comics Paramount Red Carpet ABC Summer police drama GIFs DirecTV Pop Set visit CMT unscripted Shondaland finale Pirates E! Disney Animation VH1 cats VICE period drama