Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Tammy Takes a Wrong Turn

Plus, Earth to Echo echoes too many other movies.

by | July 2, 2014 | Comments

This week at the multiplex, we’ve got a wild road trip with a gal and her grandma (Tammy starring Melissa McCarthy and Susan Sarandon), an alien invasion with a group of young friends (Earth to Echo starring Teo Halm, Brian “Astro” Bradley, and Reese Hartwig), and a series of inexplicable — and possibly demonic — crimes in New York City (Deliver Us from Evil starring Eric Bana and Olivia Munn). What do critics think?



Since her breakthrough performance in Bridesmaids, funny-woman Melissa McCarthy has secured her spot as a leading lady of comedy. In Tammy, which she co-wrote with her husband (and director) Ben Falcone, McCarthy plays a down-on-her-luck woman-child who wrecks her car, loses her job, and discovers her husband is cheating on her — and that’s just in the first 15 minutes. With her profane, beer-swillin’ grandma (Susan Sarandon) in tow, Tammy heads out on a road trip to Niagara Falls, setting the tone for the mishaps to follow by driving south instead of north in Grandma Pearl’s boat-sized Caddy. Critics say that McCarthy’s all-in performance is not enough to elevate what feels like a comedy sketch that accidentally veers into sad territory.

Earth to Echo


If it weren’t for the tireless efforts of kids everywhere, how would aliens ever get back to their home planets? In Earth to Echo, a group of three precocious boys — Alex (Teo Halm), Tuck (Brian “Astro” Bradley), and Munch (Reese Hartwig) — find their smartphones have gone kerflooey and investigate the source of the problem. They discover a small, adorable, owl-like robot from another planet who they nickname “Echo.” Along with their classmate Emma (Ella Linnea Wahlestedt), Alex, Tuck, and Munch embark on a coming-of-age journey which is part trying to return Echo to his home planet, and part trying to save their home, a Nevada town threatened by a sinister construction company. Pundits say Earth to Echo is too derivative of the 1980s films which inspire it to feel fresh, though children will no doubt find Echo and his adventures delightful.

Deliver Us From Evil


In Deliver Us From Evil, the latest film from Scott Derrickson (Sinister, The Exorcism of Emily Rose), Ralph Sarchie (Eric Bana), a tough-as-nails NYPD sergeant, investigates a series of creepy occurrences in the Bronx. In spite of having near-clairvoyant abilities himself, Sarchie is skeptical that the chilling events in New York City’s basements and zoos might have something to do with the supernatural. Still, he joins forces with Joe Mendoza (Edgar Ramírez), an unconventional Catholic priest, who believes that the horrors of Sarchie’s investigations are really the work of the devil. Pundits say that Deliver Us From Evil is too silly to be scary, and too cliched to work as a police drama.

Also opening this week in limited release:

  • Life Itself, a documentary about the life of Roger Ebert, is at 98 percent.
  • Wrinkles, an animated comedy voiced by Martin Sheen and George Coe as residents of a nursing home, is at 100 percent.
  • Gabrielle, a drama about a gifted-yet-disabled musician living in a group home, is at 94 percent.
  • Marius, a French dramedy about a seaside romance, is at 67 percent.

  • Me and You, Bernardo Bertolucci’s drama about a quirky 14-year-old loner, is at 65 percent.

  • Beyond the Edge, a documentary about the first men to summit Mt. Everest, is at 64 percent.
  • Premature, a comedy about a high-school re-living the same day over and over again, is at 60 percent.
  • America, a documentary that imagines if the United States had lost the Revolutionary War, is at 25 percent.

Tag Cloud

Creative Arts Emmys Animation thriller 2018 The Arrangement diversity historical drama dramedy Emmys The CW crossover vampires DC Comics Cannes Apple Cartoon Network BBC casting TV technology BET SDCC golden globes Shondaland Adult Swim talk show CNN crime Showtime Film Festival Pop Ovation Marvel Spike Acorn TV Watching Series romance Lifetime ABC Disney Channel VH1 natural history crime thriller anthology TNT period drama Best and Worst New York Comic Con Sci-Fi ratings teaser spy thriller binge Writers Guild of America politics Brie Larson Spectrum Originals Comedy Central X-Men Shudder comic Winners Comedy zero dark thirty CW Seed Hulu President IFC Music YouTube Premium Quiz Amazon miniseries VICE true crime political drama Tarantino dragons festivals composers Rom-Com Summer E! MTV Election Musical BBC America Thanksgiving crime drama Britbox OWN Women's History Month Action Lucasfilm Sundance Now Holidays TLC adventure Pixar GoT award winner Tumblr TCA FX Musicals 2015 Cosplay Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Superheroe SXSW elevated horror sitcom Podcast Trailer 2017 Sundance sports NBC Bravo Reality social media CBS All Access anime Spring TV USA Network Fantasy Captain marvel Amazon Prime Universal Paramount travel Rocky First Look A&E Set visit Rock spider-man witnail cinemax Food Network boxoffice adaptation Ellie Kemper WGN TV Land PBS Super Bowl Red Carpet DGA Awards Rocketman Dark Horse Comics Interview doctor who ESPN Winter TV ABC Family CMT Netflix Box Office Epix facebook PaleyFest Freeform NYCC cats Martial Arts supernatural Star Trek Starz Trophy Talk Trivia Character Guide medical drama Premiere Dates FOX Mystery Song of Ice and Fire based on movie strong female leads ITV psychological thriller Comics on TV Year in Review robots Columbia Pictures psycho Drama aliens Logo Biopics Toys LGBTQ Disney Warner Bros. SundanceTV cops GLAAD Teen MCU 24 frames Masterpiece cooking TCA 2017 jamie lee curtis Vudu space RT21 unscripted Fox News Oscars GIFs CBS APB Paramount Network Nickelodeon Sony Pictures Pet Sematary finale FXX MSNBC Pirates Ghostbusters Mary poppins blaxploitation Star Wars TCM History Video Games Photos harry potter streaming richard e. Grant Mudbound Countdown television what to watch Nat Geo cults discovery Elton John YouTube Red Syfy zombies National Geographic DC Universe dc 20th Century Fox comiccon transformers TBS Christmas Mindy Kaling police drama mockumentary Extras Western Lionsgate singing competition Country Mary Poppins Returns TruTV Mary Tyler Moore American Society of Cinematographers TIFF Stephen King San Diego Comic-Con 2019 Tomatazos Grammys Schedule Valentine's Day green book mutant AMC 45 E3 Sneak Peek dceu theme song Infographic Calendar USA Opinion Horror 21st Century Fox justice league hist HBO nature Certified Fresh war Fall TV 2016 YA DirecTV Superheroes Crackle Esquire The Witch biography Awards Tour El Rey Comic Book Marathons Reality Competition See It Skip It Heroines Nominations sequel serial killer Polls and Games Walt Disney Pictures DC streaming service Kids & Family zombie RT History Black Mirror Anna Paquin science fiction Chilling Adventures of Sabrina docudrama disaster IFC Films 007