Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Paul Blart: Mall Cop Isn't Arresting

Plus, My Bloody Valentine 3D is a gory glory; Notorious isn't juicy enough, and Hotel is for the dogs.

by | January 15, 2009 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a guard with insecurity (Paul Blart: Mall Cop, starring Kevin James); pampered pooches (Hotel for Dogs, starring Emma Roberts and Jake T. Austin); a crazed killer (My Bloody Valentine 3D, starring Jensen Ackles and Jaime King); Brooklyn’s finest (Notorious, starring Jamal Woolard and Angela Bassett); and wartime heroics (Defiance, starring Daniel Craig and Liev Schreiber). What do the critics have to say?

Everybody loves a good dumb comedy — as long as it provides ample laughs. However, the critics say Paul Blart: Mall Cop is good for a couple of lowbrow yucks, but it isn’t exactly a model of disciplined storytelling. Kevin James likeably plays the title character, a portly, self-important (and sidearm-free) crime fighter in a suburban New Jersey mall who must utilize every shred of his training when a hostage situation arises. The pundits say Paul Blart contains some funny slapstick pratfalls, but its thin premise doesn’t generate a headlong comic intensity, and a number of gags simply fall flat. At 29 percent on the Tomatometer, you may want to go shopping somewhere else.

Kevin James, in a dramatic moment from Chopping Mall 2.

Marley and Me, Bolt, Wendy and Lucy, Beverly Hills Chihuahua… dog people must feel like they’re in cinematic heaven these days. Hotel for Dogs is the latest pooch-centric flick to hit multiplexes, but critics say its appeal will be limited to little kids and die-hard canine lovers. The film stars Emma Roberts and Jake T. Austin as a pair of orphans who are so in love with man’s best friends that they convert an abandoned hotel into a four-star doggie resort, providing posh accommodations for as many strays as they can find. Look, few will go to Hotel for Dogs expecting hyper-realism, but the pundits say this occasionally funny slice of whimsy is predictable and contrived, and the four-legged heroes repeatedly outshine their human counterparts. At 48 percent on the Tomatometer, Hotel for Dogs may not be worth a stay.

“This is one more reason why we need a bailout.”

If you’re the type of filmgoer that really, really enjoys blood and guts, My Bloody Valentine 3D is here to overload your senses. Critics say this extremely grisly slasher flick, which with a sick sense of humor and three-dimensions-worth of wild kills, might just be a gorehound’s nirvana. A loose remake of the 1981 title of the same name, Valentine stars Jensen Ackles as Tom, a coal miner whose mistake costs the lives of some co-workers; now, a decade later, someone donning a miner’s mask and wielding a pickaxe is running amok in town, and Tom looks to be a target. The pundits say this is an expertly crafted, pretension-free genre piece that’s technologically advanced and features plenty of wicked scares. At 83 percent on the Tomatometer, this is one Bloody good time.

“I can’t believe it! That guy didn’t even signal!”

The Notorious B.I.G. was one of rap’s most compelling figures, with the remarkable ability to spin tales of his wayward past with devastating emotional vulnerability and insight. However, the critics say Notorious, George Tillman Jr.’s biopic of the late hip hop great, succumbs to the kind of clichés that Biggie studiously avoided on his records. First-timer Jamal Woolard stars as the man who would be B.I.G., a small-time Brooklyn hustler who became a huge star before his death in a shooting before his 25th birthday. The critics say Woolard is excellent, capturing the nuances of the character with assurance, but the rest of the film isn’t up to its central performance, clicking off the details of Biggie’s life without the complexity or depth of his rhymes. At 57 percent on the Tomatometer, Notorious isn’t quite “Juicy” enough.

“What a drag… Oh well, let’s see if Pizza Hut is open.”

Defiance recounts an undeniably important historical tale: that of a group of Eastern European Jews who fought the Nazis in World War II. And although the critics say the film is well-crafted, they also find it lacking in emotional impact. Daniel Craig, Liev Schreiber, and Jamie Bell star as brothers who, on the run from the Germans, establish a community of refugees deep in the Belarusian forest; as food becomes scarce and disease runs rampant, the brothers decide to mount an offensive against the Nazis. The pundits say this is a respectful telling of a fascinating story, but the trouble is, it’s overly solemn and clichéd. Defiance currently stands at 54 percent on the Tomatometer. (Check out our interview with director Ed Zwick here)

“So anyway, my agent told me to hold out for $20 million before agreeing to Billy Elliot 2: Feet Afire.”

Also opening this week in limited release:

  • The German import Cherry Blossoms, the story of an elderly couple making a final journey to Japan, is at 100 percent.

  • The Pervert’s Guide to Cinema, a documentary in which famed philosopher Slavoj Zizek pontificates on the appeal of the movies, is at 100 percent.

  • Chandni Chowk to China, a Bollywood martial arts musical comedy, is at 10 percent.

Recent Daniel Craig Movies:

Tag Cloud

criterion name the review Television Academy halloween robots BBC casting Marathons Alien Amazon Studios Lifetime Christmas movies stoner remakes Bravo disaster Family slasher SXSW TCM zombie FOX Emmy Nominations Rocketman werewolf Writers Guild of America spider-man slashers debate Premiere Dates RT History VH1 Britbox international Infographic Film superman DC streaming service Spike USA canceled TV shows blockbuster hollywood Netflix romance zombies psychological thriller new york indie Reality Trivia tv talk based on movie The CW canceled TNT streaming adaptation Marvel Studios all-time game of thrones critic resources Song of Ice and Fire Disney Plus comics a nightmare on elm street SundanceTV italian Sundance TV olympics scene in color Esquire franchise crime drama 1990s child's play space Winter TV ratings Disney Channel archives comic book movies Academy Awards PlayStation Valentine's Day Pride Month medical drama crime dragons Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt discovery 71st Emmy Awards Disney streaming service Pacific Islander theme song Pop TV dceu Sony Pictures marvel cinematic universe superhero monster movies 2016 Certified Fresh black Comedy news Awards Tour Spectrum Originals Super Bowl live action aliens DirecTV 4/20 movies Trophy Talk Calendar Shondaland TCA Awards Nickelodeon young adult indiana jones mutant police drama godzilla hispanic Opinion Tumblr E! Kids & Family serial killer Cannes Amazon Western book batman Character Guide Travel Channel blaxploitation Netflix Christmas movies japanese festivals dexter Cosplay hist biopic BET james bond independent Tokyo Olympics New York Comic Con Musicals Black Mirror films 21st Century Fox GIFs 24 frames PBS saw A&E comic venice video History vampires Martial Arts Rom-Com USA Network FXX Horror Film Festival crossover 2019 know your critic kaiju Biopics spain twilight Ellie Kemper AMC 90s target MTV Amazon Prime Pop Vudu true crime singing competition Comic Book TCA 2017 universal monsters TV movies TIFF HBO teaser Pet Sematary Freeform technology Paramount Plus HBO Go sequel parents TCA Masterpiece PaleyFest Ghostbusters Thanksgiving Election hispanic heritage month harry potter justice league Fox Searchlight CMT witnail Funimation television ghosts Oscars Mudbound APB dark australia VICE cops Mindy Kaling Pixar CBS doctor who what to watch Lifetime Apple TV+ Turner WGN boxing Emmys screen actors guild The Arrangement cartoon Heroines Tarantino X-Men richard e. Grant Ovation period drama 2018 BBC One laika Tomatazos TLC posters wonder woman IFC Fantasy Nat Geo sitcom YA classics latino OneApp Box Office Food Network razzies Apple TV Plus romantic comedy OWN Tubi women Country fast and furious thriller See It Skip It cars stand-up comedy Sundance Now mockumentary anthology gangster docuseries 73rd Emmy Awards GoT CW Seed directors rotten spanish Grammys Quiz Mary Tyler Moore war Shudder king arthur basketball Year in Review Superheroe breaking bad sequels jamie lee curtis strong female leads DGA Cartoon Network green book Elton John cancelled TV series rt archives anime nbcuniversal ABC Family El Rey adenture Christmas feel good golden globe awards best transformers Hear Us Out children's TV high school WarnerMedia Hallmark Christmas movies french Chernobyl VOD Video Games 20th Century Fox nature binge Baby Yoda golden globes Crackle 72 Emmy Awards Comic-Con@Home 2021 President San Diego Comic-Con LGBTQ new zealand ITV ID spy thriller comedies Teen First Look fresh Disney prank kids cooking reviews south america Summer Star Wars spanish language kong dramedy 2020 finale Black History Month BAFTA Discovery Channel 99% comic book movie japan Paramount Network political drama action-comedy Lucasfilm Musical Pirates cults ESPN A24 versus The Witch heist movie Comics on TV Stephen King 007 quibi christmas movies cats foreign Disney+ Disney Plus Television Critics Association NBA Adult Swim Walt Disney Pictures chucky comic books royal family Countdown Exclusive Video stop motion cancelled TV shows Mary poppins Brie Larson YouTube Red TV Land YouTube Premium marvel comics king kong adventure Watching Series Polls and Games dc Columbia Pictures biography free movies asian-american diversity ABC Signature unscripted Logo Sneak Peek The Walt Disney Company Hulu renewed TV shows Acorn TV legend nfl Drama Spring TV Syfy scary movies game show lord of the rings new star wars movies travel book adaptation die hard Hallmark blockbusters docudrama Photos toy story Schedule rt labs critics edition Holiday Anna Paquin reboot crime thriller Classic Film supernatural Toys Marvel Fox News Warner Bros. First Reviews obituary sports rt labs Marvel Television DC Comics screenings Music Arrowverse streaming movies social media MCU American Society of Cinematographers BBC America talk show psycho TV renewals Extras telelvision Rock Crunchyroll Reality Competition TBS rom-coms halloween tv elevated horror Lionsgate Fall TV worst Captain marvel football FX Star Trek Turner Classic Movies Binge Guide popular Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Comedy Central movie sag awards Legendary Awards critics Superheroes video on demand historical drama dogs Creative Arts Emmys trailers 93rd Oscars emmy awards cinemax TCA Winter 2020 mcc Broadway composers cancelled television Apple Action The Academy MSNBC concert suspense Showtime mission: impossible HBO Max 2017 TV NBC Best and Worst ABC Epix cancelled Podcast Holidays Amazon Prime Video NYCC comiccon rotten movies we love TruTV deadpool boxoffice Peacock documentaries DC Universe Universal Mary Poppins Returns FX on Hulu GLAAD National Geographic aapi spinoff Wes Anderson satire Image Comics pirates of the caribbean Winners Animation revenge Endgame series natural history zero dark thirty toronto joker hidden camera Women's History Month Red Carpet Sci-Fi YouTube documentary RT21 festival worst movies Rocky TV One Avengers BET Awards 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards SDCC award winner Interview Dark Horse Comics CBS All Access The Walking Dead 45 ViacomCBS Set visit scorecard Trailer jurassic park E3 2015 Nominations LGBT Paramount facebook animated 2021 Mystery IFC Films CNN Starz The Purge politics Sundance miniseries science fiction