Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: On Stranger Tides is Out to Sea

Plus, Woody Allen's Midnight in Paris is a charmer.

by | May 20, 2011 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got the hotly-anticipated fourth journey of Capt. Jack Sparrow — Pirates of the Caribbean: On Stranger Tides, starring Johnny Depp and Penelope Cruz. What do the critics have to say?

Pirates of the Caribbean: On Stranger Tides


When Pirates of the Caribbean: The Curse of the Black Pearl hit theaters in 2003, it was a delightful surprise — Johnny Depp charmed nearly everyone with his Keith Richards-meets-Buster Keaton performance as the lovable, roguish Capt. Jack Sparrow, and the whole enterprise was much smarter — and more exciting – than any movie based upon an amusement park ride had a right to be. What was once fresh, however, has now become pretty stale; critics say the third Pirates sequel, On Stranger Tides, has moments of inspiration, but mostly it just feels mechanical, overdosing on big effects without generating much excitement in the process. This time out, Sparrow is in search of the mythical Fountain of Youth. He commandeers the ship of the legendary Blackbeard (Ian McShane) and joins forces with the mysterious, possibly villainous Angelica (Penélope Cruz). The pundits say that while On Stranger Tides is well-acted and shows flashes of the vaudevillian swashbuckling that made the franchise a pop-culture staple, it mostly does exactly what you expect, but without the brisk pacing and panache of yore. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we count down producer Jerry Bruckheimer’s best-reviewed movies.)

Also opening this week in limited release:

  • Louder Than A Bomb, a documentary about a group of high school students competing in a poetry slam competition, is at 100 percent.
  • Life 2.0, a doc about the strange lives of Second Life players, is at 100 percent.
  • Woody Allen‘s Midnight in Paris, starring Owen Wilson and Rachel McAdams in a comedy/fantasy about a writer who finds himself transported to Jazz Age Paris, is at 87 percent.
  • Cost of a Soul, a drama about an Iraq war vet who returns home to a dangerous neighborhood, is at 33 percent.

Tag Cloud

Pirates Spring TV Pixar 24 frames jamie lee curtis Television Critics Association TCA 2017 E3 justice league ABC TV Land spain Elton John crime stoner cinemax BAFTA Crunchyroll Holidays Red Carpet Opinion Mary Poppins Returns PaleyFest Teen Baby Yoda Paramount Disney+ Disney Plus Paramount Network sequels reboot Turner Classic Movies mission: impossible VH1 X-Men Heroines politics dragons worst CW Seed rotten social media IFC Films Pop period drama VOD technology Holiday aliens TCA Adult Swim golden globes 2019 Avengers First Look hist Comic Book die hard comedies Lifetime Christmas movies romantic comedy USA VICE HBO Max 71st Emmy Awards Amazon Studios Anna Paquin Chernobyl USA Network Music Sundance 72 Emmy Awards composers ratings Video Games spider-man Pride Month TLC Comedy DC Comics First Reviews game of thrones Year in Review The Arrangement Disney streaming service Awards Tour The CW news screen actors guild sports south america police drama Winter TV Mary Tyler Moore Vudu children's TV YA PBS crime thriller concert films halloween directors Cannes psycho Reality LGBT Superheroes adventure Musical Character Guide richard e. Grant DGA BET Awards true crime ABC Family 2018 Fantasy spinoff A&E docudrama Britbox Hulu Musicals Reality Competition joker independent canceled TV shows Pet Sematary crime drama 4/20 historical drama Lucasfilm cancelled SDCC blaxploitation revenge Grammys Quiz Valentine's Day TIFF President Captain marvel strong female leads psychological thriller based on movie PlayStation all-time NBC ESPN OneApp Showtime Schedule zombie talk show Thanksgiving Election HBO comiccon dc binge Comedy Central renewed TV shows 45 DC streaming service finale spy thriller Netflix Christmas movies versus Sneak Peek canceled ghosts political drama toy story The Witch vampires 2020 Marvel Studios slashers Martial Arts asian-american Tomatazos cars Apple Nominations breaking bad hollywood twilight romance Fall TV Family series History APB Cosplay TNT disaster Star Wars Classic Film Rom-Com 007 Acorn TV Toys thriller Premiere Dates OWN Walt Disney Pictures Trailer Polls and Games Peacock singing competition Ovation Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Tumblr game show See It Skip It Apple TV Plus obituary Christmas 2015 Women's History Month cancelled television dogs Esquire Black History Month Oscars supernatural comic laika Animation cancelled TV series cooking Logo latino AMC diversity Columbia Pictures DirecTV Freeform satire sequel reviews superhero YouTube Premium Funimation Black Mirror TCA Winter 2020 harry potter Shondaland Writers Guild of America Action Rock BET Crackle WGN ITV cartoon Photos Apple TV+ CNN Amazon Prime Video Star Trek parents Podcast book Film sag awards YouTube unscripted space comics television Drama Emmy Nominations RT21 Spike Sci-Fi TruTV Mystery Song of Ice and Fire Sundance Now Mary poppins Trophy Talk Winners Brie Larson screenings Universal christmas movies CBS All Access GLAAD dramedy travel Food Network Academy Awards green book Starz Marathons Disney Rocketman cops Amazon Turner Awards Tarantino RT History 2017 Bravo Emmys Horror serial killer Summer kids quibi criterion San Diego Comic-Con nbcuniversal medical drama boxoffice science fiction Set visit Creative Arts Emmys TCM video on demand Ghostbusters Marvel DC Universe HBO Go Binge Guide witnail Arrowverse theme song Hallmark Best and Worst Infographic Box Office FX on Hulu Amazon Prime Fox News WarnerMedia dceu cats Biopics tv talk NYCC fast and furious classics MSNBC Calendar Netflix El Rey Shudder Travel Channel biography award winner LGBTQ Tubi Disney Plus cults Warner Bros. New York Comic Con documentary Sundance TV teaser Disney Channel scary movies hispanic Trivia TV renewals war TBS FXX indie CMT indiana jones GIFs crossover Dark Horse Comics sitcom Ellie Kemper Cartoon Network adaptation Hear Us Out Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Interview natural history Stephen King Epix chucky robots zombies BBC Syfy a nightmare on elm street Endgame A24 doctor who Pop TV miniseries Marvel Television American Society of Cinematographers blockbuster Television Academy emmy awards mockumentary 20th Century Fox anime transformers Lionsgate critics werewolf SXSW Nickelodeon best Hallmark Christmas movies Rocky zero dark thirty facebook dark FX what to watch stand-up comedy stop motion Masterpiece cancelled TV shows BBC America Spectrum Originals MCU BBC One TV The Purge GoT casting animated movies Superheroe streaming video Sony Pictures TCA Awards Discovery Channel E! free movies YouTube Red nature FOX CBS child's play name the review Lifetime foreign mutant Certified Fresh batman SundanceTV universal monsters IFC 2016 movie anthology franchise Western elevated horror 21st Century Fox MTV discovery Watching Series festivals Extras Kids & Family spanish language documentaries Super Bowl Mindy Kaling National Geographic Country Nat Geo Mudbound Film Festival The Walking Dead Comics on TV Countdown rotten movies we love