Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Noah is a Fresh Take on an Old Tale

Plus, Sabotage is too bloody; Cesar Chavez is too bloodless; Bad Words is vulgar fun; and The Grand Budapest Hotel is Certified Fresh

by | March 27, 2014 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got an Ark builder (Noah, starring Russell Crowe and Jennifer Connelly); an elite DEA agent (Sabotage, starring Arnold Schwarzenegger and Sam Worthington); a labor leader (Cesar Chavez, starring Michael Peña and John Malkovich); a full-service concierge (The Grand Budapest Hotel, starring Ralph Fiennes and Saoirse Ronan); and a grown-up spelling bee champ (Bad Words, starring Jason Bateman and Kathryn Hahn). What do the critics have to say?



If you’re going to retell one of the most epic stories in human history, you’ve got to go big. That’s exactly what director Darren Aronofsky did with Noah, and critics say this ambitious adaptation of one of the Old Testament’s most familiar tales is visually majestic and powerfully acted, though the screen is so stuffed that the main narrative occasionally gets sidetracked. Russell Crowe stars as Noah, a devout man who lives in harmony with nature. When Noah has visions of an apocalyptic flood, he builds an Ark and hits the high seas, encountering some fearsome descendants of Cain along the way. The pundits say that while Noah‘s grasp can sometimes exceed its reach, it’s a robust, inventive re-imagining of a timeless legend. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we run down some of cinema’s most memorable biblical epics.)



Hollywood has turned out plenty of action films about morally ambiguous law enforcement agents, and critics say Sabotage offers little beyond an overabundance of gore to distinguish itself from the pack. After stealing a huge amount of cash during a raid, several members of a DEA unit are mysteriously murdered. It’s up to the team’s leader, John “Breacher” Wharton (Arnold Schwarzenegger), to find out who’s responsible. The pundits say the actors are fine, but Sabotage is predictably plotted and cynically violent. (Check out our video interviews with the cast and crew.)

Cesar Chavez


Even the most extraordinary lives don’t follow a three-act structure, so it’s understandable that filmmakers must cut a few corners when making a biographical film. Unfortunately, critics say Cesar Chavez is an earnest but muted portrait of the influential labor leader that fails to capture its subject’s fire and complexity. The film follows Chavez (Michael Pena) during his extended campaign to secure better earnings and conditions for migrant farm workers in California. The pundits say Cesar Chavez serves as a decent introduction to the man, but mostly it dramatizes his work and achievements without bringing them to vivid life.

The Grand Budapest Hotel


Wes Anderson is undoubtedly one of contemporary cinema’s most distinctive stylists, and critics say he’s got another winner with em>The Grand Budapest Hotel, a madcap, bittersweet period piece with outstanding performances from its illustrious cast. Ralph Fiennes stars as Gustave, a concierge at a swanky European hotel with an eccentric guest list. When Gustave’s rich octogenarian paramour bequeaths him an invaluable painting, he draws the ire of her outraged son; chaotic hilarity ensues. The pundits say the Certified Fresh Grand Budapest Hotel is laugh-out-loud funny, stylistically bold, and poignantly acted — in other words, what we’ve come to expect from Anderson, and more.

Bad Words


Jason Bateman makes his directorial debut with Bad Words, and critics say that while this vulgar black comedy goes a little soft in the final stretch, it’s a fine showcase for the star’s sardonic, misanthropic persona. Bateman stars as Guy Trilby, a 40-something who finds a loophole that allows him to enter a national spelling bee. He proceeds to insult his juvenile competitors and appall their parents, while a reporter tries to discover what’s motivating his ruthless campaign. The pundits say Bad Words is both tasteless and slackly plotted, but it’s irreverent, well-acted, and often outrageously funny. (Check out 24 Frames for a gallery of actors with noteworthy debuts behind the camera.)

Also opening this week in limited release:

Tag Cloud

Nat Geo based on movie Extras crime spinoff cancelled History GoT sitcom strong female leads comic books movie Rock IFC Writers Guild of America indiana jones deadpool Endgame 71st Emmy Awards Drama target YouTube Red discovery sports new star wars movies classics documentary children's TV X-Men Logo teaser high school black international rotten Lucasfilm CBS All Access name the review President latino MCU die hard Tarantino TCM Pop TV DC streaming service festival composers Trivia golden globe awards supernatural Avengers Video Games Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Song of Ice and Fire hispanic toronto doctor who cinemax Watching Series Star Wars criterion free movies mockumentary 2020 Lionsgate USA Film LGBT anime Netflix Christmas movies independent pirates of the caribbean Star Trek unscripted The Walt Disney Company Comedy Central docuseries CNN Discovery Channel nfl PBS spanish language OWN singing competition Valentine's Day Britbox new zealand GLAAD Funimation E3 YA spanish movies Mary Tyler Moore comics television scorecard tv talk cops Marvel Television game show twilight TruTV Lifetime Christmas movies Grammys SDCC PlayStation Walt Disney Pictures satire golden globes king kong boxing Film Festival festivals Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Paramount Network NBC Syfy Countdown spain Amazon Prime Video 2016 Black History Month football Tumblr cancelled TV shows war razzies Oscars Nickelodeon The Walking Dead monster movies biography Lifetime Paramount Plus National Geographic American Society of Cinematographers CMT Rocketman Acorn TV BBC One 2017 APB Paramount godzilla dc Ellie Kemper TIFF blockbuster Travel Channel Alien hidden camera Emmys comiccon TCA 2017 video Image Comics revenge Rocky Television Critics Association Super Bowl Quiz Box Office 21st Century Fox police drama Marvel Studios YouTube Western TV One Disney streaming service game of thrones Winners asian-american batman critics comedies nature VICE TCA Awards animated Black Mirror TBS DC Universe Comedy renewed TV shows HBO Go child's play Year in Review Apple TV Plus Masterpiece ID Sneak Peek australia japanese TV renewals zero dark thirty New York Comic Con Creative Arts Emmys Calendar psychological thriller Television Academy Election Nominations Family Mindy Kaling 24 frames talk show Infographic Shudder heist movie The Academy richard e. Grant Spectrum Originals comic Vudu Marathons facebook 20th Century Fox indie halloween Biopics superhero best SundanceTV Pop ABC Exclusive Video stop motion Cosplay telelvision Hallmark Christmas movies news 4/20 San Diego Comic-Con CW Seed Interview BET Awards El Rey worst movies Captain marvel Set visit The CW Sundance TV Holiday vampires A24 what to watch Disney Channel MSNBC screenings Women's History Month TNT emmy awards french Premiere Dates 93rd Oscars streaming movies DGA Fantasy Reality know your critic VH1 FXX Musicals politics italian mission: impossible Comic Book Anna Paquin DirecTV 007 dogs popular Sundance Now cooking Superheroe Baby Yoda 2019 Food Network Emmy Nominations Sundance WarnerMedia Amazon Studios ABC Signature Toys versus jurassic park foreign diversity Teen BBC America science fiction christmas movies Kids & Family werewolf universal monsters Summer worst rom-coms Hallmark WGN reboot 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards technology Sci-Fi Best and Worst prank Pacific Islander cancelled television natural history AMC VOD HBO Max Disney Plus transformers parents concert historical drama series Stephen King aapi Broadway Music ESPN sequels Country streaming elevated horror YouTube Premium romance CBS Turner Classic Movies a nightmare on elm street 72 Emmy Awards Classic Film Dark Horse Comics Awards Tour The Arrangement Marvel kong Trailer ViacomCBS jamie lee curtis live action Animation cancelled TV series witnail TCA Winter 2020 kids Action sequel Chernobyl Amazon finale franchise PaleyFest FX on Hulu reviews 99% crime thriller Certified Fresh Spring TV First Reviews OneApp Pirates Hear Us Out women Brie Larson harry potter Elton John Universal 45 docudrama quibi space blockbusters fast and furious BAFTA A&E laika Tubi medical drama Legendary crime drama Awards Schedule Columbia Pictures saw miniseries Superheroes rotten movies we love ABC Family blaxploitation Apple justice league The Purge GIFs canceled period drama rt archives Disney+ Disney Plus Horror IFC Films Holidays hollywood archives Reality Competition zombies TCA award winner video on demand ITV chucky nbcuniversal RT History films Character Guide robots trailers stand-up comedy zombie dceu romantic comedy DC Comics spider-man new york Pet Sematary scary movies aliens Cartoon Network cartoon fresh disaster adventure cars BBC cats ratings Sony Pictures Christmas political drama james bond green book 2018 TLC Polls and Games dragons superman LGBTQ Crunchyroll Arrowverse Freeform dramedy book adaptation directors Pride Month breaking bad Rom-Com toy story obituary hist 2015 Turner halloween tv ghosts Thanksgiving Fox News social media Netflix FOX Amazon Prime Trophy Talk Cannes crossover true crime spy thriller remakes south america MTV Epix Esquire SXSW Shondaland Hulu Comics on TV Adult Swim theme song cults scene in color TV Land NYCC kaiju Spike Disney USA Network psycho Showtime The Witch Winter TV Fox Searchlight BET Podcast canceled TV shows Peacock TV mutant thriller venice joker boxoffice adaptation 2021 documentaries Bravo casting Apple TV+ Photos Pixar sag awards slashers all-time See It Skip It lord of the rings Crackle Mudbound stoner Warner Bros. E! TV movies Ovation Red Carpet Binge Guide Academy Awards Mary Poppins Returns Fall TV Musical Opinion travel Martial Arts Ghostbusters FX Starz serial killer First Look book HBO RT21 Mystery marvel cinematic universe dark Tomatazos anthology screen actors guild binge Heroines Mary poppins