Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Noah is a Fresh Take on an Old Tale

Plus, Sabotage is too bloody; Cesar Chavez is too bloodless; Bad Words is vulgar fun; and The Grand Budapest Hotel is Certified Fresh

by | March 27, 2014 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got an Ark builder (Noah, starring Russell Crowe and Jennifer Connelly); an elite DEA agent (Sabotage, starring Arnold Schwarzenegger and Sam Worthington); a labor leader (Cesar Chavez, starring Michael Peña and John Malkovich); a full-service concierge (The Grand Budapest Hotel, starring Ralph Fiennes and Saoirse Ronan); and a grown-up spelling bee champ (Bad Words, starring Jason Bateman and Kathryn Hahn). What do the critics have to say?



If you’re going to retell one of the most epic stories in human history, you’ve got to go big. That’s exactly what director Darren Aronofsky did with Noah, and critics say this ambitious adaptation of one of the Old Testament’s most familiar tales is visually majestic and powerfully acted, though the screen is so stuffed that the main narrative occasionally gets sidetracked. Russell Crowe stars as Noah, a devout man who lives in harmony with nature. When Noah has visions of an apocalyptic flood, he builds an Ark and hits the high seas, encountering some fearsome descendants of Cain along the way. The pundits say that while Noah‘s grasp can sometimes exceed its reach, it’s a robust, inventive re-imagining of a timeless legend. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we run down some of cinema’s most memorable biblical epics.)



Hollywood has turned out plenty of action films about morally ambiguous law enforcement agents, and critics say Sabotage offers little beyond an overabundance of gore to distinguish itself from the pack. After stealing a huge amount of cash during a raid, several members of a DEA unit are mysteriously murdered. It’s up to the team’s leader, John “Breacher” Wharton (Arnold Schwarzenegger), to find out who’s responsible. The pundits say the actors are fine, but Sabotage is predictably plotted and cynically violent. (Check out our video interviews with the cast and crew.)

Cesar Chavez


Even the most extraordinary lives don’t follow a three-act structure, so it’s understandable that filmmakers must cut a few corners when making a biographical film. Unfortunately, critics say Cesar Chavez is an earnest but muted portrait of the influential labor leader that fails to capture its subject’s fire and complexity. The film follows Chavez (Michael Pena) during his extended campaign to secure better earnings and conditions for migrant farm workers in California. The pundits say Cesar Chavez serves as a decent introduction to the man, but mostly it dramatizes his work and achievements without bringing them to vivid life.

The Grand Budapest Hotel


Wes Anderson is undoubtedly one of contemporary cinema’s most distinctive stylists, and critics say he’s got another winner with em>The Grand Budapest Hotel, a madcap, bittersweet period piece with outstanding performances from its illustrious cast. Ralph Fiennes stars as Gustave, a concierge at a swanky European hotel with an eccentric guest list. When Gustave’s rich octogenarian paramour bequeaths him an invaluable painting, he draws the ire of her outraged son; chaotic hilarity ensues. The pundits say the Certified Fresh Grand Budapest Hotel is laugh-out-loud funny, stylistically bold, and poignantly acted — in other words, what we’ve come to expect from Anderson, and more.

Bad Words


Jason Bateman makes his directorial debut with Bad Words, and critics say that while this vulgar black comedy goes a little soft in the final stretch, it’s a fine showcase for the star’s sardonic, misanthropic persona. Bateman stars as Guy Trilby, a 40-something who finds a loophole that allows him to enter a national spelling bee. He proceeds to insult his juvenile competitors and appall their parents, while a reporter tries to discover what’s motivating his ruthless campaign. The pundits say Bad Words is both tasteless and slackly plotted, but it’s irreverent, well-acted, and often outrageously funny. (Check out 24 Frames for a gallery of actors with noteworthy debuts behind the camera.)

Also opening this week in limited release:

Tag Cloud

witnail Warner Bros. VH1 Star Trek IFC natural history Musical serial killer Pop psychological thriller comiccon cops Crackle MTV Rock dramedy game show foreign TV Emmy Nominations cults Peacock RT21 Watching Series BBC A&E adaptation Arrowverse The Arrangement robots PaleyFest CBS All Access GoT ratings President Amazon Prime zero dark thirty Tumblr Sony Pictures Comedy Quiz 2017 mockumentary USA science fiction Marathons NYCC Showtime political drama The CW Universal Logo CW Seed ESPN Walt Disney Pictures Biopics Extras Mindy Kaling teaser 007 stand-up comedy The Witch 2019 Comedy Central Sci-Fi Lionsgate TIFF mutant Mary Poppins Returns Infographic Drama TBS Sundance Now latino Oscars Film Festival Kids & Family crime thriller Reality Mudbound facebook Vudu discovery medical drama GIFs CMT SundanceTV American Society of Cinematographers OWN disaster YA hispanic crime drama Winter TV 21st Century Fox dc sequel Masterpiece Film thriller Writers Guild of America binge National Geographic Tomatazos toy story RT History 20th Century Fox dragons true crime USA Network Cannes hist sports doctor who Thanksgiving crossover streaming BET cars Summer FXX E! Opinion kids travel Teen television quibi what to watch Grammys GLAAD 2015 Countdown movies Comics on TV technology DGA Song of Ice and Fire WarnerMedia Anna Paquin supernatural Marvel Schedule Chilling Adventures of Sabrina docudrama Shudder nature Musicals Lifetime Calendar Shondaland south america singing competition Red Carpet BBC America Ellie Kemper Pride Month Black Mirror blaxploitation Family Trailer Freeform spy thriller Pixar Action Podcast period drama New York Comic Con E3 jamie lee curtis Photos Premiere Dates Set visit See It Skip It Pet Sematary Horror NBC 24 frames Animation Tarantino TruTV Star Wars WGN Hulu Winners Spike Box Office Amazon X-Men Elton John Super Bowl casting CBS Britbox composers strong female leads zombie talk show Reality Competition game of thrones comic Cosplay Disney streaming service Year in Review TCA 2017 LGBTQ Amazon Prime Video Lucasfilm cinemax Paramount revenge 2018 ABC series Captain marvel Awards PBS aliens Women's History Month finale DC Universe adventure TCA cats miniseries Interview Toys TV Land boxoffice vampires unscripted First Reviews police drama Trivia Sundance Pirates festivals ABC Family Superheroes Awards Tour Chernobyl Disney Channel Fox News Columbia Pictures Spectrum Originals social media Food Network Emmys Epix richard e. Grant Christmas Rocketman space Fantasy historical drama theme song book Sneak Peek HBO Max Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Dark Horse Comics ITV Video Games MCU animated award winner harry potter HBO diversity spain politics anthology Certified Fresh Character Guide TLC Valentine's Day Mystery spanish language Paramount Network Nickelodeon 2016 transformers Apple Ovation romance Stephen King Heroines Rocky DC Comics anime CNN children's TV sitcom First Look psycho Rom-Com Comic Book TNT golden globes Ghostbusters Martial Arts war DirecTV MSNBC Syfy Fall TV VICE AMC El Rey 45 ghosts Adult Swim APB Best and Worst Mary Tyler Moore Binge Guide elevated horror Cartoon Network IFC Films Superheroe dceu History Netflix FX Bravo SDCC FOX Music Brie Larson Nat Geo based on movie SXSW spinoff Spring TV Esquire Starz Country Trophy Talk Polls and Games green book cooking justice league YouTube Premium Mary poppins San Diego Comic-Con crime YouTube Red Disney tv talk biography spider-man zombies Election DC streaming service Creative Arts Emmys Holidays TCM Acorn TV LGBT Nominations Western