Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: I Love You, Man Is A Fine Bromance

Plus, Knowing flunks, and Duplicity is brainy -- if too twisty.

by | March 19, 2009 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a bromantic comedy (I Love You, Man, starring Paul Rudd and Jason Segel), ominous numerology (Knowing, starring Nicolas Cage and Rose Byrne), and corporate mischief (Duplicity, starring Julia Roberts and Clive Owen). What do the critics have to say?


I Love You, Man

The term “bromance” has reached a near-saturation point in the movie lexicon, and not a moment too soon. Critics say I Love You, Man is a warm, very funny example of the burgeoning subgenre, featuring some of the best comedic chemistry between two leads since Jack Lemmon and Walter Matthau. Paul Rudd stars as Peter, a recently engaged guy who realizes that he has no one to be the best man at his wedding. After a series of man-dates, he finds himself (platonically, of course) bonding with Sydney (Jason Segel), a slovenly hipster with plenty of sound advice. The pundits say I Love You, Man is a perfect example of how old formulas can feel new again: with hearty laughs, nuance, and razor-sharp performances. I Love You, Man is Certified Fresh.



Alex Proyas has established himself as one of the more interesting sci-fi directors in Hollywood, but critics say his latest, Knowing, crosses the line that separates profundity and preposterousness. The movie stars Nicolas Cage as an MIT professor who discovers that a random string of numbers on a piece of paper from a recently unearthed time capsule successfully predicted numerous disasters over the last 50 years. As he unlocks the secrets of this strange document, he discovers that the numbers predict future calamities as well. The pundits say Knowing has some interesting ideas and a couple good scenes, but it’s weighted down by its absurd plot and over-seriousness. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we count down Cage’s best reviewed films. Also, find out what Proyas’ five favorite films are, and don’t forget to play our “Name Nic’s Movie ‘Do” game.)



Tony Gilroy (Michael Clayton) is certainly a smart guy, but critics say his latest, Duplicity, may be just a little too brainy for its own good. The film stars Julia Roberts and Clive Owen as an on-again, off-again couple of spies turned corporate fixers that get involved in an elaborate con game between two multinational companies; as a result, our heroes become increasingly concerned that they can’t trust each other. The pundits say Roberts and Owen exude plenty of chemistry and star power, and Duplicity is nothing if not well-crafted. However, they also feel the film is more cerebral than visceral, and it gets bogged down in a densely complex plot and too many twists and turns.

Also opening this week in limited release:

Tag Cloud

witnail Discovery Channel zero dark thirty cancelled television based on movie Mary Tyler Moore IFC Films Horror LGBTQ Comedy Central IFC Amazon Star Wars Lionsgate binge canceled Sneak Peek RT21 political drama ghosts Podcast SDCC Apple TV Plus 2015 dceu ABC Family Hallmark 2020 kids name the review Food Network richard e. Grant FX Interview Sci-Fi miniseries Emmy Nominations batman crime disaster Elton John Disney Heroines CBS YA Extras strong female leads WarnerMedia CBS All Access Showtime crossover USA Network Sundance TV A&E green book SXSW dc spinoff Endgame Best and Worst cancelled TV shows book MSNBC Ellie Kemper Pop TV revenge Rocky 4/20 Musical Sony Pictures tv talk 20th Century Fox Hallmark Christmas movies elevated horror ITV halloween finale what to watch travel animated First Look TruTV CNN Trivia Mindy Kaling natural history Vudu Disney Plus south america ESPN 45 Countdown rotten movies we love E3 Rom-Com FXX television TV Land Hear Us Out Reality YouTube Premium Funimation a nightmare on elm street Arrowverse Valentine's Day Schedule Acorn TV Ovation The Walking Dead PaleyFest Paramount news jamie lee curtis war festivals Certified Fresh The CW Turner Classic Movies YouTube Red Trailer game of thrones Country independent Black History Month chucky scary movies cartoon Martial Arts Fantasy Oscars documentaries Red Carpet mutant politics Mary Poppins Returns NYCC period drama Year in Review sitcom BBC America award winner Amazon Prime Video historical drama Toys Summer boxoffice Fox News spanish language Adult Swim Ghostbusters HBO Max comedies Crackle video on demand crime drama joker Trophy Talk Tarantino Rock screenings Chernobyl cats series TBS Quiz BET Classic Film technology Black Mirror breaking bad Set visit Logo Pride Month HBO Go hist facebook streaming Teen Video Games casting Superheroes Pirates PlayStation unscripted serial killer 21st Century Fox VICE E! hispanic Awards Watching Series children's TV mission: impossible doctor who Thanksgiving critics reboot Chilling Adventures of Sabrina See It Skip It Amazon Prime renewed TV shows Animation blaxploitation diversity social media robots Baby Yoda Holidays Marvel Studios American Society of Cinematographers science fiction 2018 parents video Cannes Crunchyroll Photos dark comic Brie Larson Awards Tour Warner Bros. medical drama A24 Nat Geo concert Walt Disney Pictures Academy Awards space Tumblr police drama Election Sundance Now Esquire spider-man Marathons comics Paramount Network Columbia Pictures Action Spectrum Originals documentary discovery adventure Sundance The Purge best Apple TV+ 71st Emmy Awards SundanceTV BBC Stephen King Television Academy all-time YouTube MTV The Arrangement franchise Comics on TV Avengers satire GLAAD films Nominations OneApp biography Song of Ice and Fire Disney+ Disney Plus cancelled TV series Pop crime thriller indiana jones Netflix Christmas movies VH1 Polls and Games Box Office TNT stoner quibi Winter TV true crime Lucasfilm OWN sports mockumentary cars Starz teaser reviews TCA Writers Guild of America Calendar transformers romantic comedy DirecTV Captain marvel BET Awards 24 frames HBO 007 nature Epix Tubi Film zombie 2019 Premiere Dates cancelled DC Comics foreign TV renewals cooking child's play Lifetime Christmas movies Musicals Freeform Family cops Superheroe Pet Sematary Nickelodeon aliens AMC die hard RT History golden globes BAFTA National Geographic Lifetime Marvel Television Universal indie Marvel USA stand-up comedy WGN toy story Bravo free movies screen actors guild Mudbound X-Men ratings Cosplay werewolf versus Dark Horse Comics Music Binge Guide Masterpiece Reality Competition singing competition 2017 criterion Disney streaming service dragons PBS sequel BBC One VOD sag awards movie cults anthology slashers DGA zombies Women's History Month Opinion talk show GIFs vampires romance President docudrama Infographic Winners Spring TV twilight Amazon Studios El Rey Grammys psycho TV Character Guide Biopics Fall TV FX on Hulu Hulu Super Bowl justice league Comedy dramedy TCA Winter 2020 Kids & Family Turner CW Seed TCM Spike NBC GoT adaptation canceled TV shows TCA 2017 TIFF LGBT Tomatazos thriller ABC supernatural Western Pixar FOX Shondaland asian-american Comic Book harry potter spy thriller directors Drama APB DC streaming service Travel Channel composers Apple game show christmas movies Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt comiccon cinemax The Witch theme song Cartoon Network Film Festival psychological thriller spain Disney Channel Peacock Rocketman Mary poppins Star Trek DC Universe Christmas movies MCU Creative Arts Emmys Mystery Shudder New York Comic Con 2016 blockbuster Emmys dogs Britbox San Diego Comic-Con Anna Paquin universal monsters History anime CMT latino TLC Holiday Syfy Netflix First Reviews