Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Fighting Is Down For The Count

Also, The Soloist Falls Flat, but Earth Is Impressive

by | April 23, 2009 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got bare-knuckle bouts (Fighting, starring Channing Tatum and Terrence Howard), the wonders of nature (Earth, narrated by James Earl Jones), a musical friendship (The Soloist, starring Robert Downey Jr. and Jamie Foxx), and some office intrigue (Obsessed, starring Idris Elba and Beyonce Knowles). What do the critics have to say?



Look, you pretty much know what you’re getting into with a movie called Fighting: lots of tough-as-nails dudes beating the stuffing out of each other. And the pundits say that while director Dito Montiel does his best to infuse interesting characterization and a sense of place, Fighting is still a shopworn underdog sports movie. Channing Tatum stars as a kid who’s just arrived in New York City from Alabama; after attempting to make a living on the streets, he falls in with a sketchy character (Terrence Howard) who realizes he may be a natural fit for the world of underground bare-knuckle brawls. The pundits say Fighting is a bit better than its setup would suggest, with a good deal of energy and a dash of gritty authenticity. However, others say the performances are a mixed bag and the script is ultimately weighted down by clichés. (Check out Terrence Howard’s Five Favorite Films.)



The popular award-winning BBC series Planet Earth offered some staggeringly beautiful images of life around the globe. If the small screen version was too limited to contain such visual majesty, now comes its multiplex companion: Earth, which critics say is a remarkable document with a timely message. Narrated by (who else?) James Earl Jones, Earth focuses on three mother/child relationships in the animal kingdom, following the exploits of polar bears, humpback whales, and African elephants. The pundits say Earth doesn’t offer a ton of insight, but the images on display are so gorgeous that viewers are unlikely to quibble too much. Plus, it invites audiences to reflect upon our place in the larger ecosystem. Earth is Certified Fresh.


The Soloist

The Soloist tells an inspiring true story, and its stars and director are Oscar nominees. But distinguished pedigree does not a movie make, and critics say The Soloist is too uneven to fully resonate. Robert Downey Jr. stars as Steve Lopez, an LA Times reporter who befriends, and writes movingly about, a homeless, profoundly mentally ill man named Nathaniel Ayers, who was once a virtuoso cellist. The pundits say all the elements are here for a moving tale, and Downey and Foxx give it everything they’ve got; unfortunately, that’s not enough to overcome the film’s lack of focus and maudlin stretches. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we count down Downey’s best-reviewed films, and find out director Joe Wright’s Five Favorite Films).



It appears the folks behind Obsessed were dubious that critics would be, ahem, obsessed with their film. Hence, it wasn’t screened prior to its release. The movie stars Idris Elba as a successful asset manager who’s happily married — to Beyonce, no less — before an attractive, brazen office temp (Ali Larter) threatens to bring his world crashing down. Kids, it’s time to guess that Tomatometer!

Also opening this week in limited release:

Finally, props to Brendan C. for correctly guessing Crank High Voltage‘s 63 percent Tomatometer.

Tag Cloud

Countdown anthology Video Games hist Podcast Fall TV Opinion binge Creative Arts Emmys Heroines Cosplay Reality Competition Nat Geo Logo Spring TV strong female leads Tumblr Epix historical drama robots FOX USA Red Carpet ratings Character Guide Comics on TV Lionsgate Black Mirror Rocketman crime thriller Pet Sematary Sony Pictures Fantasy Warner Bros. DC Comics mockumentary Calendar Brie Larson diversity Nickelodeon Thanksgiving Comic Book comic Rocky HBO Cannes Martial Arts San Diego Comic-Con comiccon Mindy Kaling Mary Poppins Returns discovery Watching Series Ghostbusters aliens First Look FXX theme song LGBTQ GoT TBS TLC transformers Action Amazon Esquire crime X-Men what to watch Adult Swim medical drama 007 Certified Fresh Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Film Festival Starz Sundance Tarantino TruTV television Horror Acorn TV psychological thriller E! Disney cats ABC Hulu APB Year in Review Freeform harry potter Bravo dceu Nominations CMT spy thriller vampires Britbox Cartoon Network TV PBS crime drama VICE NYCC zombies OWN zero dark thirty Pirates Pixar Infographic FX SundanceTV sitcom Fox News Comedy Extras cops E3 Western Best and Worst green book Tomatazos Comedy Central ESPN A&E miniseries Walt Disney Pictures sports cults RT History The Witch Teen Star Trek justice league Rom-Com Awards Awards Tour TNT supernatural See It Skip It Crackle natural history cooking Reality witnail Anna Paquin Christmas American Society of Cinematographers sequel war true crime Winter TV psycho Ovation TV Land Trivia Sundance Now SDCC facebook IFC Films science fiction Valentine's Day Superheroes Toys CNN Musicals Animation Netflix singing competition travel 21st Century Fox Rock Kids & Family TCM YouTube Premium Quiz finale The Arrangement Pop NBC Paramount Network DC Universe Showtime blaxploitation award winner Columbia Pictures Universal MSNBC golden globes ITV jamie lee curtis teaser YouTube Red Superheroe Super Bowl adaptation TIFF Stephen King composers Marathons RT21 Masterpiece Set visit social media cinemax Apple AMC CW Seed talk show Interview serial killer Sci-Fi technology boxoffice festivals Song of Ice and Fire ABC Family crossover Mary poppins Oscars Premiere Dates Trailer Election disaster romance Shondaland 2018 DC streaming service Spike casting Disney Channel 20th Century Fox Summer Music GIFs 2019 Photos DGA Mudbound Trophy Talk Country spider-man based on movie GLAAD Drama elevated horror Lucasfilm politics President 2015 24 frames nature El Rey Emmys WGN Ellie Kemper anime MTV Elton John 2017 CBS political drama Grammys Box Office Musical docudrama IFC Winners thriller New York Comic Con mutant 2016 Star Wars Biopics Mystery adventure Spectrum Originals streaming richard e. Grant dragons BBC America Vudu Lifetime DirecTV Amazon Prime dramedy biography YA zombie The CW National Geographic Paramount Captain marvel USA Network Writers Guild of America VH1 space dc Shudder Polls and Games unscripted 45 PaleyFest police drama Marvel period drama Food Network Sneak Peek History BBC Women's History Month SXSW doctor who MCU Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt TCA 2017 Mary Tyler Moore Dark Horse Comics Schedule Holidays TCA CBS All Access Syfy BET