Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Battle: Los Angeles Loses The Fight

Plus, Mars Needs Moms is so-so, but Red Riding Hood misses the mark.

by | March 11, 2011 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a war of the worlds (Battle: Los Angeles, starring Aaron Eckhart and Ramon Rodriguez); an interplanetary quest (Mars Needs Moms, starring Seth Green and Joan Cusack); and a lupine love story (Red Riding Hood, starring Amanda Seyfried and Gary Oldman). What do the critics have to say?

Battle: Los Angeles


The extraterrestrial invasion movie never seems to go out of style. Still, it helps if we have heroes we can root for and a strong storyline, two things that critics say are generally lacking in Battle: Los Angeles. Aaron Eckhart stars as a marine who must lead his charges into battle to protect Santa Monica after hostile outer space visitors have attacked many of the world’s major cities. The pundits say Battle: Los Angeles has a few kinetic action sequences, but those can’t make up for a lack of three-dimensional characters, an overabundance of shaky cam, and a feeling that we’ve seen this kind of thing before. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we run down some noteworthy cinematic alien invasions.)

Mars Needs Moms


There’s nothing wrong with a kids’ film espousing the timeless message that your parents love you. It’s too bad, critics say, that beyond that handy reminder, Mars Needs Moms is something of a mixed bag; its technology is sometimes impressive, but the script isn’t particularly original. Seth Green stars as a nine-year-old who has an argument with his mom, but realizes the error of his ways when he sees her being abducted by a UFO. Our pint-sized hero stows away on the craft in an effort to extricate his mother from the Martians’ clutches. The pundits say Mars Needs Moms has some decent laughs and a good message, but they’re mixed on the animation and largely find the story lacking.

Red Riding Hood


The tale of Little Red Riding Hood is loaded with potential for an irreverent retelling, one that expands on the dark implications lurking on the edges of this most famous of stories. However, Twilight is popular these days, and critics say what we end up getting with Red Riding Hood is a badly executed drama featuring a love triangle and werewolves. Amanda Seyfried stars as a young woman in an arranged betrothal to a boring guy; soon, she falls in love with the village bad boy, while a series of mysterious wolf attacks create suspicion among the townsfolk. The pundits say Red Riding Hood amounts to a strange miscalculation: the clothes may be from days of yore, but the dialogue is oddly contemporary, and the plot seems like little more than an attempt to cash in on conventions that theoretically make teenage girls swoon.

Also opening this week in limited release:

  • The Desert Of Forbidden Art, a documentary about a man who rescued priceless works of art by hiding them in the Uzbek desert, is at 100 percent.
  • I Will Follow, an indie drama about a successful woman at life’s crossroads, is at 100 percent.
  • Jane Eyre, starring Mia Wasikowska and Michael Fassbender in a new adaptation of Charlotte Bronte’s classic novel, is at 90 percent.
  • Certified Copy, starring Juliette Binoche as a woman who pretends to be married to a man she just met while on a tour of rural Italy, is at 86 percent.
  • Black Death, about a medieval knight who embarks on a journey to save his village from the plague, is at 79 percent.
  • 3 Backyards, starring Edie Falco in a drama of three stories that occur on the same day in a suburban neighborhood, is at 71 percent.
  • Kill the Irishman, starring Ray Stevenson and Val Kilmer in the based-on-true-events tale of a notorious Cleveland mobster, is at 70 percent.
  • Elektra Luxx, starring Carla Gugino and Timothy Olyphant in a comedy about a retired porn star in a new phase of her life, is at 31 percent.
  • Monogamy, an indie drama about a wedding photographer who’s hired to take more voyeuristic pictures, is at 20 percent.

Tag Cloud

Red Carpet Tumblr Marathons Quiz spy thriller The Witch Reality Competition Shondaland Mary Tyler Moore talk show medical drama GIFs Crackle teaser Toys Film Festival 2019 sports OWN Britbox Freeform 007 Podcast dc The CW CW Seed singing competition Song of Ice and Fire Horror 2016 anthology hist elevated horror Countdown Western dceu Country Infographic crime TV E3 24 frames DC Universe Disney Channel boxoffice CBS All Access Mary poppins Masterpiece sitcom mutant NBC HBO Max Adult Swim CBS miniseries crossover Disney FXX Walt Disney Pictures witnail comiccon GoT FX Spring TV YouTube Premium Superheroes doctor who mockumentary Vudu binge animated National Geographic Election Rocky adventure MCU Epix transformers award winner Polls and Games President Ovation disaster Cannes Lionsgate thriller Valentine's Day television historical drama TNT VICE Marvel WGN Rock Emmys Rom-Com Musicals adaptation anime USA ESPN BBC nature true crime blaxploitation Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Video Games History Amazon Prime Biopics festivals robots theme song RT21 zombie The Arrangement 21st Century Fox Fox News Pop Anna Paquin Star Trek Christmas serial killer Animation Fall TV facebook DC streaming service justice league Stephen King green book Character Guide 2018 ABC Family YA Fantasy Brie Larson Esquire A&E SDCC Lifetime dramedy Pixar 20th Century Fox RT History 2017 technology YouTube Red Comics on TV Ellie Kemper spider-man cults X-Men Calendar MTV Pride Month San Diego Comic-Con Paramount Network LGBTQ spinoff Year in Review Amazon Reality political drama Tomatazos politics Apple Watching Series Certified Fresh Heroines jamie lee curtis DirecTV Trophy Talk period drama toy story what to watch Mudbound Holidays sequel Thanksgiving NYCC psychological thriller Best and Worst space dragons Mary Poppins Returns composers science fiction cops Nat Geo Drama VH1 Oscars Lucasfilm Sundance 2015 cooking travel Trailer TCA WarnerMedia Spectrum Originals Martial Arts Ghostbusters casting Women's History Month Comedy Central Star Wars BET DGA Opinion Paramount Teen Food Network TLC Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Premiere Dates discovery natural history Pirates GLAAD strong female leads romance Super Bowl Mystery Kids & Family USA Network Nickelodeon Cosplay Awards Tour TruTV vampires BBC America biography crime drama El Rey PaleyFest Tarantino Musical See It Skip It Logo PBS war harry potter Comedy Acorn TV unscripted Columbia Pictures Trivia Sundance Now Shudder Winners CNN Syfy Netflix Showtime ABC Black Mirror police drama HBO IFC Photos Creative Arts Emmys cats Comic Book TIFF game show AMC Sneak Peek Elton John finale LGBT zero dark thirty DC Comics aliens Set visit ratings Interview FOX Dark Horse Comics Rocketman TCA 2017 psycho Grammys Hulu Pet Sematary E! Awards Mindy Kaling 45 Sony Pictures Warner Bros. Captain marvel SXSW New York Comic Con ITV TCM MSNBC comic First Look Action American Society of Cinematographers TV Land Emmy Nominations social media CMT Winter TV Schedule TBS Extras Spike Summer crime thriller cinemax based on movie Box Office Starz zombies SundanceTV golden globes Nominations docudrama Universal Chernobyl Sci-Fi Cartoon Network APB streaming Bravo Music Superheroe supernatural Writers Guild of America richard e. Grant IFC Films diversity