Critics Consensus

Critical Consensus: Life Has Its Ups And Downs, Darjeeling Is Transporting

Plus: Guess the Saw IV Tomatometer!

by | October 25, 2007 | Comments

This week at the movies we have a lovelorn single dad (Dan
in Real Life
, starring
Steve Carell and
Juliette Binoche),
brothers on a train (The Darjeeling Limited,
Owen Wilson and
Jason Schwartzman,
and the return of Jigsaw (Saw IV,
starring Tobin
Scott Patterson
). What do the critics have to say?

The perpetually awesome
Steve Carell and
Juliette Binoche team up for
in Real Life
, a rom-com about an advice columnist who falls for his
brother’s significant other. It sounds good on paper: who wouldn’t be intrigued
by the pairing of the brilliantly guileless Carell with Binoche, an actress of
uncommon range and depth? Though Life suffers from an uneasy mix of sitcom wackiness and sentimentality, director Peter Hedges has a clear love for the film’s characters, with most critics agreeing Carell and company overcome the weak script. At 60 percent, Dan looks to survive his mid (Tomatometer) Life crisis.

"Want to join my Lynne Cheney book discussion group?"

Wes Anderson‘s back, and with him comes the visual splendor and melancholy humor
for which he’s known. In
The Darjeeling Limited
Adrien Brody joins
Anderson regulars Owen Wilson and
Jason Schwartzman in the story three brothers
trekking across the Subcontinent in search of spiritual truth. The critics
aren’t all on board with Darjeeling; some find Anderson’s quirks
overwhelming and impersonal. But the majority says it’s engaging and funny in
that deadpan Wes Anderson way, with loads of quirky visual touches. At 66
percent on the Tomatometer, The Darjeeling Limited may be worth the trip.
(Check out our Wes Anderson Total Recall feature

“I’m telling you, Wes Anderson has never seen Harold and Maude!”

For those of you who yearn for even more insight into the twisted mind of
Jigsaw, you’re in luck: Saw IV hits theaters Friday. However, if you’re a
movie critic, you won’t be able to see it before the rest of us civilians, since
it wasn’t screened before release. Whoever correctly guesses the Tomatometer
will be the sharpest tool in the RT shed.

Scott Patterson wishing he were back in Stars Hollow.

Also opening this week in limited release:
Pete Seeger: The Power of Song
a doc about the venerable folksinger/lefty activist, is at 92 percent on the
The Living and the Dead
, a psychological
horror film about
an unbalanced man caring for his sick mother, is at 89 percent;
Jimmy Carter
Man From Plains
Jonathan Demme‘s doc about the 39th president, is at 81
Sidney Lumet‘s

Before the Devil Knows You’re Dead
, a family drama starring
Philip Seymour
, Marisa Tomei, and
Ethan Hawke, is at 79 percent;
The Island, a
Russian import about a soldier who takes refuge in a monastery, is at 71
Mr. Untouchable
, a doc about the rise and fall of drug kingpin
Nicky Barnes, is at 63 percent;
, an examination of the man behind
, is at 63 percent;
Black Irish
, a coming-of-age dysfunctional
family drama, is at 50 percent;
Lagerfeld Confidential
, a doc about the
fashion icon, is at 45 percent;
Music Within
, a drama about a Vietnam Vet
who fought for the rights of the disabled, is at 38 percent;
O Jerusalem
a dramatization of the establishment of Israel, is at 33 percent;
written and directed by Anthony Hopkins, is at 30 percent;
, about
an unconventional love story in New York City, is at 30 percent; and
Rails &
, a drama about a family struggling with illness starring
Kevin Bacon
and Marcia Gay Harden, is at 23 percent.

Seeger, with some random groupie.

Finally, props to
m_ioannidis for coming the closest to guessing
10 percent Tomatometer. And semi-props to
SplendidIsolation and
BlueStar 50 for coming the closest to guessing
Sarah Landon and the
Paranormal Hour
‘s zero percent score.

Recent Steve Carell Movies:
24% — Evan Almighty (2007)
74% — Over the Hedge (2006)
92% — Little Miss Sunshine (2006)
83% — The 40-Year-Old Virgin (2005)
51% — Melinda and Melinda (2005)

27% — Saw III (2006)
35% — Saw II (2005)
46% — Saw (2004)

Tag Cloud

tv talk Hulu richard e. Grant prank nature Spectrum Originals Pop TV rt labs critics edition television Countdown Rocky Nickelodeon independent Comics on TV cartoon scorecard animated Mary Tyler Moore child's play Black Mirror new zealand comic black GoT TCM hollywood Creative Arts Emmys jamie lee curtis Anna Paquin versus monster movies breaking bad Apple TV Plus Academy Awards AMC Plus reviews Polls and Games canceled Women's History Month scary movies Trivia TCA Awards Pacific Islander Acorn TV Lifetime Christmas movies die hard IFC Films YouTube Premium biography WarnerMedia joker HBO Go facebook Turner Classic Movies true crime hidden camera National Geographic sitcom Spike BBC ID legend Oscars 72 Emmy Awards Family LGBT Summer Pirates rotten movies we love cinemax Freeform award winner mission: impossible comics Superheroe YouTube young adult french unscripted Chernobyl Ghostbusters stop motion Premiere Dates sports Marvel Studios 007 Sneak Peek FX Country TCA 2017 new star wars movies asian-american all-time game show HFPA zombie Cannes President Winter TV black comedy thriller justice league TLC 2015 PaleyFest The CW FOX pirates of the caribbean transformers movie Disney Plus vs. Star Trek theme song Legendary werewolf TV One halloween Image Comics Action kong trophy live action Pet Sematary Instagram Live children's TV marvel cinematic universe IMDb TV BBC One SDCC Music royal family spanish language films sag awards scary WGN Sundance Elton John romance comedies comic books japanese Disney Cartoon Network batman book adaptation basketball CW Seed Tumblr 21st Century Fox E! DirecTV ABC Family VH1 news Hollywood Foreign Press Association Teen festival History police drama SundanceTV Opinion PlayStation documentaries Bravo YA mob Martial Arts medical drama documentary natural history posters leaderboard crime Comedy Central Brie Larson Shudder Lucasfilm supernatural nbcuniversal Schedule Avengers TV Land Rom-Com Emmy Nominations Marathons NYCC streaming LGBTQ indiana jones 24 frames superhero Masterpiece stoner christmas movies Crunchyroll telelvision criterion Neflix Sci-Fi Mindy Kaling SXSW mcc archives directors Nominations Musical 73rd Emmy Awards james bond rom-coms singing competition TV renewals Pixar cancelled TV series Comic-Con@Home 2021 Lionsgate Comedy sequels 99% Broadway HBO harry potter sopranos movies Tokyo Olympics CNN Ellie Kemper travel 2017 Binge Guide BBC America spinoff Star Wars PBS Mudbound ViacomCBS RT21 Logo 20th Century Fox HBO Max Columbia Pictures Tomatazos foreign Dark Horse Comics nfl Sony Pictures AMC biopic anthology ESPN king arthur anime ABC target superman GIFs El Rey blaxploitation OneApp Song of Ice and Fire First Look NBC 1990s deadpool MSNBC popular Heroines football Horror scene in color Spring TV international FXX TNT CBS video GLAAD teaser worst movies Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Sundance TV 2016 strong female leads what to watch women BET Awards Crackle screenings Pop The Walking Dead Musicals cooking Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt laika 2020 Food Network 93rd Oscars finale Best and Worst venice chucky know your critic Holiday TIFF zombies saw Amazon Prime spain 4/20 Interview Universal Pictures DC Comics razzies hispanic heritage month Red Carpet Infographic Awards Tour composers Starz Rock video on demand twilight TruTV Disney+ Disney Plus rt archives Mary Poppins Returns cars Fantasy indie Peacock Baby Yoda 2021 TCA Winter 2020 wonder woman APB New York Comic Con cancelled TV shows japan politics Year in Review social media critics dragons critic resources adventure screen actors guild reboot Winners Netflix 2018 technology streaming movies witnail San Diego Comic-Con remakes Discovery Channel Nat Geo discovery crime thriller Animation universal monsters renewed TV shows Superheroes OWN franchise canceled TV shows ITV USA Network Hallmark emmy awards DC Universe Tarantino Paramount Plus RT History Prime Video latino Valentine's Day Adult Swim ratings Rocketman zero dark thirty 2019 romantic comedy Mystery Apple TV+ disaster boxoffice Classic Film Trophy Talk genre Endgame suspense classics Thanksgiving 90s slashers Western high school olympics Netflix Christmas movies art house Hear Us Out dramedy trailers jurassic park Fargo Drama gangster space toronto CMT godzilla king kong best docudrama dark X-Men worst serial killer Exclusive Video Ovation marvel comics A24 vampires name the review Certified Fresh Lifetime Captain marvel Disney Channel halloween tv Character Guide casting TBS stand-up comedy Sundance Now MTV fresh lord of the rings Television Academy revenge parents Vudu Black History Month Kids & Family E3 festivals VICE dceu docuseries TCA IFC 45 action-comedy new york dogs CBS All Access USA mutant doctor who Film Festival YouTube Red Alien hist Holidays mockumentary satire Television Critics Association Calendar Wes Anderson golden globe awards Shondaland crossover miniseries Grammys 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards aliens 79th Golden Globes Awards cats NBA Travel Channel blockbusters spanish Esquire adenture Mary poppins Disney streaming service game of thrones Tags: Comedy series dc Biopics Arrowverse political drama hispanic science fiction Fall TV kids cancelled television Reality Universal Writers Guild of America Marvel Television Trailer Emmys Video Games Election comiccon elevated horror Syfy Set visit italian cops Extras spider-man talk show A&E rt labs Walt Disney Pictures 71st Emmy Awards psycho cults Paramount Network Stephen King The Arrangement The Purge Britbox Toys concert golden globes Fox Searchlight adaptation Hallmark Christmas movies aapi The Witch Turner Photos Amazon Studios Watching Series period drama DC streaming service feel good Tubi Paramount Awards The Academy australia boxing robots south america Amazon Prime Video obituary Funimation Warner Bros. free movies Apple slasher MCU based on movie Podcast toy story TV dreamworks psychological thriller crime drama quibi book Fox News Film historical drama Cosplay Reality Competition kaiju Quiz spy thriller diversity binge a nightmare on elm street Super Bowl comic book movies Amazon See It Skip It live event Comic Book BET rotten comic book movie DGA green book debate Box Office FX on Hulu Pride Month blockbuster heist movie ghosts cancelled Christmas spider-verse VOD American Society of Cinematographers Marvel BAFTA fast and furious sequel ABC Signature The Walt Disney Company war First Reviews dexter TV movies Epix Showtime