Critics Consensus

Critical Consensus: "Grindhouse" Is Gory Glory; "Done" Needs Fixing; "Firehouse" Is Mangy; "Reaping" Is Plagued

by | April 5, 2007 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got sleaze (Quentin Tarantino and Robert Rodriguez’ "Grindhouse," starring Kurt Russell and Rose McGowan), fixer-uppers ("Are We Done Yet?," starring Ice Cube), plagues ("The Reaping," starring Hilary Swank), and pooches ("Firehouse Dog"). What do the critics have to say?

Quentin Tarantino and Robert Rodriguez have made careers of turning trashy material into cinematic treasure. And just like the good old days of the drive-in double feature, critics say "Grindhouse" is two schlocky treats for the price of one, albeit made with a greater level of skill than the old school-sleazemeisters. Rodriguez’ "Planet Terror," starring Rose McGowan and Freddy Rodriguez, tells the tale of a gas that threatens to turn the world’s population into zombies, and Tarantino’s "Death Proof" stars Kurt Russell as a killer stuntman. The critics say "Grindhouse" delivers an exhilarating platter of exploitation style with wit and panache, and its makers improve upon their source material with their feral intelligence. At 87 percent on the Tomatometer, the Certified Fresh "Grindhouse" is a trashy delight. (For more on the history of exploitation cinema, check out RT’s "Grindhouse A to Z" feature.)

Two of a grind.

Ice Cube once rapped, "I’m scarin ya, wanted by America." If "Are We Done Yet?" is any indication, those days are long gone — and critics say that’s not a good thing. "Are We Done Yet?" is not only a sequel to 2005’s poorly reviewed "Are We There Yet?," it’s also a loose remake of the Cary GrantMyrna Loy comedy "Mr. Blandings Builds His Dream House." The author of "Parental Discretion Iz Advised" plays a family man fixing up a money pit in the suburbs, and his wonderfully expressive scowl is reserved for shoddy construction and an unhinged contractor. The pundits say the film is way too safe, featuring generic slapstick and amiable but uninspired domestic foibles. At 10 percent on the Tomatometer, "Are We Done Yet?" may be aptly titled.

"No more buffets, okay?"

The latest in a storied line of cinematic Fidos, "Firehouse Dog" at least gets points for originality: it features an undercover movie-star pooch that rides skateboards and does laundry. The movie tells the tale of Rexxx, an Irish terrier who’s a hairpiece-wearing, overly pampered canine thespian who accidentally gets dumped in a small town and is adopted by, yep, the local firehouse. The "Doc Hollywood"-esque plot has promise, and some say "Firehouse Dog" is warm enough to please the little ones. But the majority of critics say the movie ruins it with endless fart and poop jokes, and an overlong run time. At 37 percent Tomatometer, this one’s strictly for the dogs.

You’re the man now, dawg!

Why, oh why, ask critics, if the Bible is so loaded with action, suspense, and miracles, have the recent glut of religious-themed dramas been so gosh-darned dull? The latest in Good Book-inspired mediocrity is "The Reaping," starring Hilary Swank as a faithless former missionary who travels the country disproving religious phenomena. But when she comes across a series of plagues in a small Louisiana town, her adherence to science is sorely tested as she tries to save the community. Critics say "The Reaping" is schlocky, spiritually shallow, and wasteful of a grade-A cast that includes David Morrissey, AnnaSophia Robb, Stephen Rea, and Idris Elba (aka Stringer Bell on "The Wire"). At six percent on the Tomatometer, "The Reaping" is an unholy mess.

"So who wants to try my jambalaya?"

Also opening this week in limited release: "The Hoax," starring Richard Gere in the true story of biography-forging Clifford Irving, is at 89 percent on the Tomatometer; "Black Book," Paul Verhoeven’s epic about a beautiful Dutch resistance fighter in WWII, is Certified Fresh at 75 percent; "The TV Set," a satire of prime time television starring David Duchovny and Sigourney Weaver, is at 60 percent; and "Whole New Thing," the story of a teenager and his crush on his English teacher, is at 44 percent.

"How ’bout we just shut down production and throw on a Mama’s Family rerun?"

Quentin Tarantino Films:
85% — Kill Bill Vol. 2 (2004)
84% — Kill Bill Vol. 1 (2003)
84% — Jackie Brown (1998)
96% — Pulp Fiction (1994)
95% — Reservoir Dogs (1992)

Recent Robert Rodriguez Films:
77% — Sin City (2005)
19% — The Adventures of Shark Boy and Lava Girl in 3-D (2005)
45% — Spy Kids 3-D: Game Over (2003)
68% — Once Upon a Time in Mexico (2003)
75% — Spy Kids 2: Island of Lost Dreams (2001)

Tag Cloud

versus Trailer Winners composers anthology New York Comic Con Calendar adaptation President Comic Book Pop Polls and Games MSNBC Animation spider-man cooking Trophy Talk Superheroes Heroines hispanic First Look Vudu OWN Peacock Black Mirror justice league documentary Grammys directors cinemax National Geographic Sundance Now batman comics Trivia Comics on TV DC Comics CBS Rock Teen CMT green book dceu Ellie Kemper aliens Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt dogs Certified Fresh VH1 Disney stand-up comedy book screenings Sony Pictures Mary poppins halloween VICE serial killer period drama Country AMC WarnerMedia E! Marvel Studios joker Logo Discovery Channel cults Paramount dramedy hist Mary Tyler Moore 24 frames Endgame biography science fiction true crime Western 2016 ITV PBS cancelled TV shows Star Wars A24 television Baby Yoda Cannes Film Pet Sematary TCA Musical Apple TV Plus crime drama HBO Winter TV Drama TCA 2017 Holidays SundanceTV USA Network Esquire Podcast cancelled Amazon teaser Reality spanish language south america Set visit APB SXSW Schedule MCU scary movies BBC America RT21 The Arrangement blockbuster DC Universe Mystery Tarantino social media Nickelodeon Captain marvel Tumblr vampires Comedy Central award winner based on movie Mindy Kaling ABC Family 2020 Food Network Kids & Family History Emmy Nominations strong female leads ESPN Pop TV psychological thriller tv talk Amazon Prime PaleyFest Rocketman Biopics YA Brie Larson Epix Acorn TV Film Festival Walt Disney Pictures franchise Amazon Prime Video 2015 Sundance TV USA SDCC Netflix Character Guide TNT theme song YouTube Red latino crime historical drama cancelled television Thanksgiving Action miniseries renewed TV shows 2018 space YouTube Premium IFC Films Shudder natural history canceled TV shows free movies Sci-Fi crossover quibi dc cops screen actors guild Reality Competition Comedy elevated horror Spike Watching Series First Reviews Pixar 2017 Marvel Television comic 007 Fox News Black History Month foreign zero dark thirty Turner Classic Movies diversity Mudbound Superheroe Pirates CBS All Access Emmys series Mary Poppins Returns docudrama Martial Arts police drama TruTV Cosplay Chernobyl GoT Writers Guild of America Classic Film political drama blaxploitation movies Academy Awards thriller dragons Funimation DC streaming service Chilling Adventures of Sabrina FX on Hulu WGN transformers Opinion Nat Geo MTV robots 21st Century Fox movie CW Seed Marathons Red Carpet TBS finale canceled Anna Paquin slashers psycho A&E cartoon disaster DGA reviews travel ABC 20th Century Fox Premiere Dates rotten movies we love GLAAD Year in Review Crackle NBC Stephen King cats Nominations Shondaland spain children's TV FXX Family technology nature Summer talk show video Warner Bros. mockumentary 45 Sneak Peek Arrowverse Photos Freeform Song of Ice and Fire Tubi Disney streaming service Sundance LGBT name the review werewolf medical drama 2019 Super Bowl GIFs politics Box Office Lifetime Christmas movies game show game of thrones Hallmark zombie casting The Witch Women's History Month Infographic christmas movies festivals facebook Spring TV Disney+ Disney Plus independent Fantasy IFC kids Video Games cars singing competition Television Academy Adult Swim E3 Christmas Dark Horse Comics golden globes Crunchyroll Disney Plus The Walking Dead Countdown mutant sitcom YouTube Apple TV+ Ovation spy thriller Star Trek romance supernatural animated richard e. Grant 71st Emmy Awards revenge Travel Channel Syfy sag awards Hallmark Christmas movies Lifetime El Rey Masterpiece Lionsgate Toys OneApp TV Land universal monsters CNN TIFF TCA Winter 2020 Amazon Studios Elton John FOX Turner Marvel TV renewals jamie lee curtis Netflix Christmas movies Awards Tour Awards Quiz cancelled TV series Horror Spectrum Originals BBC romantic comedy Interview Columbia Pictures LGBTQ Showtime San Diego Comic-Con American Society of Cinematographers Starz The CW breaking bad unscripted HBO Max discovery reboot Creative Arts Emmys adventure TCM Bravo Music zombies toy story sequel spinoff Best and Worst binge witnail X-Men Musicals harry potter RT History NYCC Hulu FX Rom-Com BET TV Lucasfilm Cartoon Network Disney Channel Avengers war Britbox Valentine's Day TLC what to watch crime thriller Fall TV Extras Apple See It Skip It DirecTV Rocky sports Holiday ratings Oscars boxoffice Tomatazos Ghostbusters Universal indie comiccon anime streaming The Purge Paramount Network ghosts Election Pride Month doctor who Binge Guide