Critics Consensus

Critical Consensus: Game Plan Fumbles, Kingdom is Overthrown, Feast Is Semi-Appetizing, Elah Worth a Visit

What the critics are saying about this week's crop of movies.

by | September 27, 2007 | Comments

This week at the movies we have parenting quarterbacks (The
Game Plan
, starring
The Rock),
FBI agents (The
Kingdom
, starring
Jamie Foxx and
Jennifer
Garner
), lonely citizens (Feast
of Love
, starring
Greg Kinnear
and Radha
Mitchell
), and one angry father (In
the Valley of Elah
, starring
Tommy Lee
Jones
and
Charlize Theron
).  What speaketh the critics?

After generating middling box office returns for films like
Doom,
Walking Tall
,
and The Rundown,
Dwayne "The Rock" Johnson takes a career readjustment into comedy.  In
The Game Plan
,
Johnson plays a high-flying quarterback whose bachelor lifestyle is interrupted
when he’s suddenly confronted with a 7-year-old daughter he never knew he had
from a prior relationship. While some critics are impressed with The Rock’s
charismatic performance, most are exasperated by the movie’s excessively
saccharine tone and formulaic plot that’s stretched to a nearly two hour
runtime. With 33 percent on the Tomatometer, critics are sending The Game
Plan
back to the drawing board. (Check out our Total Recall Game Plan
feature
here
.)
 




The Rock practices Vulcan mind-melding.


From documentaries like
No End in Sight

and Fahrenheit 9/11
to narrative pieces like
The Situation

and Rendition,
no conflict has gotten as immediate a cinematic response as the one we’re
currently embroiled in.  The latest movie to join the fray:
The Kingdom
,
starring Jamie Foxx and Jennifer Garner about FBI operatives trying to locate
terrorists in the Middle East.  While The Kingdom wants to do good by
exploring the topic of international politics and subterfuge, critics claim that
the drama is manipulative and the film quickly descends into war genre
trappings, treating enemies as generic moving targets.  The Kingdom fails
to accomplish its mission at 46 percent on the Tomatometer.
 




“And
here’s what would happen if Saudi Arabia doesn’t get enough Nintendo Wiis."


With
Everything
is Illuminated
a few years behind us and
Watchmen
coming up,
the idea of some novels being too complex to be adapted suddenly seems passé. 
Feast of Love,
based on a novel by

Charles Baxter
about a community of people looking for emotional
connections, could also have been deemed too sprawling and multi-faceted to
adapt convincingly.  So while they haven’t found any weak links in the fine
ensemble cast, critics call Feast of Love a hodgepodge of sentimentality
that’s ambitious but fails to go in-depth with its characters. And the film’s
congenial manner, coupled with its total lack of cynicism on love and human
relationships, makes for a pleasant time at the movies, if not a riveting one.
At 56 percent, Feast of Love is for those willing to gorge on romance at
the multiplex.



“Would you believe I have some advice on this matter?”


Ever since being catapulted to the limelight with his
much-discussed Best Picture Oscar win for the racial melodrama
Crash
,
Paul Haggis
has been a divisive figure in the film community.  And his latest directorial
effort,
In the Valley of Elah
, doesn’t look to buck the trend. Elah stars
Tommy Lee
Jones
as a gravel transporter trying to uncover the mystery the death of his
son, a Marine recently returned from Iraq. Critics say that while some of
Haggis’s themes and symbolic images are heavy-handed, In the Valley of Elah
is an otherwise engrossing murder mystery and profound antiwar statement,
featuring a mesmerizing performance from Jones. With 69 percent on the
Tomatometer, Elah showcases some peak performances. (Check out our review

here
.)




“Okay,
in this scene, you’re outraged about something. Really outraged. Go with it."


Also opening in limited release:
The Price of
Sugar
, a documentary about the Dominican Republic’s corrupt sugar
production, is at 86 percent;
Outsourced
, a
comedy about an office drone teaching his replacement in India, is at 85
percent; Lust,
Caution
,
Ang Lee
‘s controversial erotic thriller, is at 79 percent (check out our
review

here
);
The Darjeeling Limited
,
Wes Anderson‘s
new comedy/drama about three soul-searching brothers, is at 65 percent;
The Man of My Life
,
a French import about the sexual politics between three neighbors, is at 53
percent; Trade,
a high-minded thriller about the sex trade and human trafficking, is at 20
percent.




"Ooo, a MacGuffin."

And, finally, it’s game over for last week’s round of Guess the Tomatometer. m_ioannidis hit it on the nose on guessing Resident Evil: Extinction‘s 26 percent Tomatometer.

Recent Jamie Foxx Movies:
——————————————
47% — Miami Vice (2006)
78% — Dreamgirls
(2006)
13% — Stealth (2005)
61% — Jarhead (2005)
71% — Shade (2004)

Wes Anderson Movies:
——————————————
56% — The
Life Aquatic with Steve Zissou
(2004)
79% — The Royal
Tenenbaums

(2001)
86% — Rushmore (1998)
77% — Bottle Rocket (1996)

Tag Cloud

CBS BET Pirates YA doctor who Character Guide SundanceTV diversity Oscars First Look VICE ESPN thriller Comic Book Ellie Kemper Summer cinemax 2019 LGBTQ Schedule DC Comics 24 frames Winter TV Film Festival Drama NBC HBO GoT award winner DC streaming service Opinion FX Logo Reality Pop social media Toys talk show facebook anime ABC Family spinoff finale medical drama disaster harry potter The Arrangement TCM richard e. Grant CW Seed Pixar VH1 Spike sequel DC Universe MSNBC Freeform Star Trek Pride Month true crime serial killer GIFs Calendar Disney Channel WarnerMedia The CW TLC Paramount Network TV Land New York Comic Con Super Bowl Syfy Elton John Disney Video Games cops Trophy Talk Sundance Now YouTube Red theme song vampires biography justice league Rocky Quiz Animation ABC USA Network Fox News PaleyFest TIFF psychological thriller Columbia Pictures Countdown Apple crime IFC Comics on TV Cartoon Network Mary Tyler Moore psycho Masterpiece dceu RT History streaming adventure docudrama IFC Films NYCC Musical police drama Amazon Prime Emmy Nominations composers MTV spy thriller cats Adult Swim Dark Horse Comics what to watch teaser Sci-Fi See It Skip It Chernobyl Trivia San Diego Comic-Con AMC romance LGBT Thanksgiving TBS Grammys Writers Guild of America Mindy Kaling Martial Arts sports Premiere Dates witnail Ovation binge miniseries Crackle Horror Song of Ice and Fire SDCC Certified Fresh Podcast period drama zero dark thirty technology science fiction cults Lionsgate nature Music Stephen King Bravo Heroines Comedy APB political drama Red Carpet robots Nominations Valentine's Day toy story BBC politics Esquire 20th Century Fox Acorn TV casting crime thriller TruTV Spectrum Originals Marathons space crossover dragons OWN Brie Larson The Witch Rock Infographic cooking hist TNT ITV Trailer Tarantino MCU transformers Ghostbusters green book Emmys Sundance E3 supernatural Mary poppins Showtime Black Mirror Biopics anthology zombie Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Extras Marvel spider-man discovery Interview Election sitcom television 2015 zombies History natural history ratings Teen Polls and Games USA aliens Country Netflix Nat Geo adaptation Tumblr Food Network TCA 2017 E! SXSW Awards Tour Spring TV Warner Bros. WGN animated Hulu CNN Women's History Month Shondaland 007 Comedy Central BBC America CMT A&E Starz Epix blaxploitation Captain marvel strong female leads 2018 Watching Series Year in Review President YouTube Premium Star Wars Photos 2017 festivals dc Superheroe 45 dramedy Tomatazos historical drama Rom-Com Paramount comiccon elevated horror Kids & Family Cannes based on movie game show Best and Worst CBS All Access Reality Competition unscripted FOX Walt Disney Pictures Superheroes Holidays RT21 Lucasfilm Lifetime Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Musicals 21st Century Fox singing competition GLAAD Fall TV crime drama Amazon Vudu travel mutant comic Anna Paquin PBS Western Action Creative Arts Emmys Christmas X-Men Sony Pictures DGA Box Office Awards HBO Max Mary Poppins Returns Mystery El Rey Winners American Society of Cinematographers DirecTV Shudder National Geographic Fantasy Cosplay TV Set visit 2016 Universal Mudbound war jamie lee curtis Rocketman Nickelodeon Britbox boxoffice FXX Pet Sematary mockumentary golden globes TCA Sneak Peek