Critics Consensus

Critical Consensus: "Descent" and "Talledega" Leave "Listener" and "Barnyard" in the Dust

by | August 3, 2006 | Comments

This week in movies, we’ve got tough chicks fighting for their lives ("The Descent"), a redneck racing saga ("Talladega Nights: The Ballad of Ricky Bobby"), a psychological thriller starring Mork from Ork ("The Night Listener"), and farm animals who just wanna have fun ("Barnyard: The Original Party Animals"). Which flicks will get the critical seal of approval?

"The Descent" — Certified Fresh!

Two constants in Hollywood are that (A) foreign flicks generally don’t have widespread appeal and (B) horror flicks don’t get critical praise, like, ever. "The Descent," about six female spelunkers whose weekend cave-diving adventure turns deadly, has defied these tenets — a low-budget import from Scotland, of all places, this female-driven frightener has critics on the edges of their popcorn-strewn seats. The scribes say that director Neil Marshall ("Dog Soldiers") has masterfully created a claustrophobe’s nightmare, and has added a compelling meditation on morality, vengeance, and the depths to which we might go for human survival. High marks also go to the cast of relatively unknown actresses, who manage to balance sex appeal and strength as believable adventuresses. At 90 percent, this gory thriller has earned RT’s Certified Fresh stamp — and is on track to becoming the best-reviewed horror film of the year!

"Talladega Nights" — sponsored by Wonder Bread and Old Spice

Perennial jester Will Ferrell stars as hard-driven, bumbling NASCAR ace Ricky Bobby in "Talladega Nights: The Ballad of Ricky Bobby," a high-octane comedy set in the all-American world of race car driving. Inescapably drawing comparisons to 2004’s "Anchorman" (which, like "Talladega," starred Ferrell and was co-written by director Adam McKay), there’s no doubt that Ferrell is on his comedic game in this sweet-natured send-up of the NASCAR world. Critics also agree on the strength of Ferrell’s supporting cast (including John C. Reilly as Ricky Bobby’s steadfast racing buddy, and British comedian Sacha Baron Cohen ("Da Ali G Show") as his scene-stealing gay French rival). But is it funny? While the largely-improvised laughs are occasionally uneven, critics say the highs are indeed hilarious and worth the ride. At 73 percent on the Tomatometer, go ahead and buckle up for "Talladega."

Robin Williams in the JT Leroy-ish thriller, "The Night Listener"

"The Night Listener" marks another revisiting of comic genius Robin Williams to that oh-so-foreign milieu — dramatic acting — in a psychological thriller adapted from Armistead Maupin’s story of the same name. Williams plays Gabriel, a lonely nighttime radio host who forges a relationship with a young abuse victim named Pete (Rory Culkin), but begins to question the truth behind Pete’s story; eventually, he wonders if Pete really exists at all. The critics say that, despite a real-life relevancy in light of such fictitious media sensations as J.T. Leroy, any suspensefulness built up by Patrick Stettner‘s creepy, atmospheric direction fizzles out with muddled storytelling; perhaps, too, funnyman Williams has been slightly miscast in a sad-sack role that requires more believable misery. However, many scribes are quick to point out the film’s unusually brief 81-minute runtime, if that gives you any more incentive to buy a ticket, but at 45 percent on the Tomatometer, you probably want to tune out this "Listener."

When the farmer’s asleep, the cows cut loose in "Barnyard"

Are you in the mood for an animated tale of farm animals who party when the humans aren’t looking? How about one with a rebellious boy cow as the hero? "Barnyard" offers up such fare with the story of Otis (voiced by Kevin James), a fun-loving cow who would rather carouse about the farm than protect its denizens from ravenous coyotes, a duty that his father (Sam Elliott) tries in vain to impart to him. With a voice cast that includes Wanda Sykes and Courteney Cox, "Barnyard" aims for comedic targets in the form of anthropomorphized animal laughs, gross humor, and sight gags (courtesy of "Ace Ventura: When Nature Calls" director Steve Oedekirk) — lowbrow humor that, critics moan, appeal only to the senses of children under the age of eight. Unfortunately for the chaperones of the target demographic, aside from some spontaneous musical numbers and a few adult-oriented jokes, there’s not much here to entertain grown-ups. At 33 percent, "Barnyard" is only for parents who love their kids enough to sit through it.

Also opening this week, albeit in limited release: "My Country, My Country," a political documentary about the Iraq 2005 election, is at 100 percent; French romantic thriller "The Bridesmaid" is at 83 percent; the coming-of-age tale (and Sundance fave) "Quinceanera" is at 81 percent; retiree rom-com "The Boynton Beach Club" is at 55 percent; the prison cell drama "Jailbait" is at 14 percent; and gay teen drama "Vacationland" is at — gulp — 0 percent.

Recent Will Ferrell Movies:
Curious George – 69%
Winter Passing – 41%
Melinda & Melinda – 51%
Kicking and Screaming – 43%
Bewitched – 25%

Tag Cloud

zombies The Purge tv talk Comics on TV Summer Western Hallmark Chernobyl Pirates Emmy Nominations mission: impossible Sony Pictures The Walking Dead indie Brie Larson technology Sci-Fi directors 2018 71st Emmy Awards Hulu Cartoon Network Awards Tour GLAAD hispanic foreign romantic comedy screenings crime Spring TV Holidays Teen transformers sequel History series CNN natural history Crunchyroll movies The CW dogs Creative Arts Emmys screen actors guild spanish language talk show Syfy cinemax true crime Turner Classic Movies Avengers Sundance TV Esquire Columbia Pictures Video Games Rom-Com BET Awards breaking bad festivals Discovery Channel Star Trek A&E Nickelodeon indiana jones emmy awards Food Network Valentine's Day Amazon Prime Disney streaming service Oscars Photos blockbuster reboot Logo Classic Film Winter TV Musical robots werewolf Starz USA Network spy thriller anime Universal DC streaming service HBO Go Cannes adventure Arrowverse WGN Acorn TV First Reviews Thanksgiving rotten universal monsters Binge Guide theme song Women's History Month IFC Films documentaries crime drama Premiere Dates Sundance Tarantino political drama cars zero dark thirty DC Comics President Ovation Disney Plus dark cancelled TV shows Paramount Network sag awards RT21 YouTube Premium YouTube TCA Winter 2020 Musicals TCA 2017 reviews all-time quibi television Reality child's play TIFF FOX Drama crossover Bravo HBO Fox News Film Festival Countdown Reality Competition TCA Awards 2015 serial killer Heroines sitcom Nat Geo Dark Horse Comics MSNBC DGA Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Shudder Mudbound VOD scary movies jamie lee curtis FXX Masterpiece Captain marvel mockumentary Lionsgate Spectrum Originals medical drama The Witch ratings CBS satire Writers Guild of America police drama dramedy Comedy finale discovery Pixar New York Comic Con MCU DC Universe Hear Us Out E! Sneak Peek PBS Horror cancelled TV series Biopics independent GIFs superhero 20th Century Fox Spike nature miniseries 45 spinoff Tomatazos Box Office Extras Ellie Kemper twilight composers OWN Certified Fresh kids YA Schedule aliens Year in Review Tubi Amazon TV Land X-Men WarnerMedia Television Academy BBC America comics doctor who unscripted disaster game of thrones Trophy Talk slashers 2019 parents Anna Paquin politics Disney Channel Kids & Family versus Trivia HBO Max travel VICE Peacock Marvel Studios dceu DirecTV stand-up comedy psychological thriller NYCC CBS All Access Ghostbusters Walt Disney Pictures cops classics south america films facebook Travel Channel TCA BBC One Set visit Watching Series ABC rotten movies we love comiccon PaleyFest San Diego Comic-Con Vudu FX on Hulu Country Martial Arts chucky cooking spain golden globes Emmys die hard 24 frames YouTube Red biography Christmas critics stop motion docudrama franchise Endgame Music CMT dc psycho thriller vampires Baby Yoda Grammys Netflix TruTV Podcast Marvel Television BAFTA Apple cancelled spider-man Marathons National Geographic elevated horror video on demand Rocketman Quiz Toys romance VH1 comedies cartoon Film halloween Infographic TCM Pop TV First Look Disney+ Disney Plus science fiction latino green book Netflix Christmas movies Tumblr FX boxoffice batman Disney Holiday Black History Month 007 Election Pop Amazon Prime Video mutant witnail Awards PlayStation See It Skip It worst AMC Adult Swim fast and furious Calendar USA period drama 2016 MTV 2017 Mary poppins Best and Worst Britbox toy story cults SXSW 4/20 El Rey revenge ITV OneApp stoner Mary Poppins Returns Freeform Character Guide Comedy Central 72 Emmy Awards video Showtime Nominations documentary asian-american singing competition Star Wars Rocky christmas movies TV renewals Trailer TNT Amazon Studios APB what to watch ESPN TV ABC Family a nightmare on elm street Super Bowl Animation Fantasy Crackle Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Winners historical drama anthology based on movie ghosts Action obituary hollywood renewed TV shows adaptation war Funimation Interview Paramount cats IFC best Mindy Kaling cancelled television Warner Bros. Polls and Games canceled TV shows hist movie TLC strong female leads crime thriller Apple TV+ diversity richard e. Grant Epix book Rock Shondaland nbcuniversal Pet Sematary Lifetime Christmas movies zombie teaser blaxploitation laika TBS canceled Turner Superheroe Stephen King Mystery Elton John name the review Superheroes 21st Century Fox children's TV casting Marvel Pride Month supernatural game show Cosplay streaming LGBTQ Black Mirror RT History NBC animated news Sundance Now harry potter social media CW Seed E3 Red Carpet Family space LGBT Lucasfilm sports The Arrangement award winner 2020 free movies Television Critics Association joker Comic Book Hallmark Christmas movies binge Opinion GoT A24 comic criterion Apple TV Plus Lifetime Academy Awards BET Song of Ice and Fire concert American Society of Cinematographers Mary Tyler Moore SDCC SundanceTV Fall TV justice league dragons BBC