Critics Consensus

Critical Consensus: "Descent" and "Talledega" Leave "Listener" and "Barnyard" in the Dust

by | August 3, 2006 | Comments

This week in movies, we’ve got tough chicks fighting for their lives ("The Descent"), a redneck racing saga ("Talladega Nights: The Ballad of Ricky Bobby"), a psychological thriller starring Mork from Ork ("The Night Listener"), and farm animals who just wanna have fun ("Barnyard: The Original Party Animals"). Which flicks will get the critical seal of approval?

"The Descent" — Certified Fresh!

Two constants in Hollywood are that (A) foreign flicks generally don’t have widespread appeal and (B) horror flicks don’t get critical praise, like, ever. "The Descent," about six female spelunkers whose weekend cave-diving adventure turns deadly, has defied these tenets — a low-budget import from Scotland, of all places, this female-driven frightener has critics on the edges of their popcorn-strewn seats. The scribes say that director Neil Marshall ("Dog Soldiers") has masterfully created a claustrophobe’s nightmare, and has added a compelling meditation on morality, vengeance, and the depths to which we might go for human survival. High marks also go to the cast of relatively unknown actresses, who manage to balance sex appeal and strength as believable adventuresses. At 90 percent, this gory thriller has earned RT’s Certified Fresh stamp — and is on track to becoming the best-reviewed horror film of the year!

"Talladega Nights" — sponsored by Wonder Bread and Old Spice

Perennial jester Will Ferrell stars as hard-driven, bumbling NASCAR ace Ricky Bobby in "Talladega Nights: The Ballad of Ricky Bobby," a high-octane comedy set in the all-American world of race car driving. Inescapably drawing comparisons to 2004’s "Anchorman" (which, like "Talladega," starred Ferrell and was co-written by director Adam McKay), there’s no doubt that Ferrell is on his comedic game in this sweet-natured send-up of the NASCAR world. Critics also agree on the strength of Ferrell’s supporting cast (including John C. Reilly as Ricky Bobby’s steadfast racing buddy, and British comedian Sacha Baron Cohen ("Da Ali G Show") as his scene-stealing gay French rival). But is it funny? While the largely-improvised laughs are occasionally uneven, critics say the highs are indeed hilarious and worth the ride. At 73 percent on the Tomatometer, go ahead and buckle up for "Talladega."

Robin Williams in the JT Leroy-ish thriller, "The Night Listener"

"The Night Listener" marks another revisiting of comic genius Robin Williams to that oh-so-foreign milieu — dramatic acting — in a psychological thriller adapted from Armistead Maupin’s story of the same name. Williams plays Gabriel, a lonely nighttime radio host who forges a relationship with a young abuse victim named Pete (Rory Culkin), but begins to question the truth behind Pete’s story; eventually, he wonders if Pete really exists at all. The critics say that, despite a real-life relevancy in light of such fictitious media sensations as J.T. Leroy, any suspensefulness built up by Patrick Stettner‘s creepy, atmospheric direction fizzles out with muddled storytelling; perhaps, too, funnyman Williams has been slightly miscast in a sad-sack role that requires more believable misery. However, many scribes are quick to point out the film’s unusually brief 81-minute runtime, if that gives you any more incentive to buy a ticket, but at 45 percent on the Tomatometer, you probably want to tune out this "Listener."

When the farmer’s asleep, the cows cut loose in "Barnyard"

Are you in the mood for an animated tale of farm animals who party when the humans aren’t looking? How about one with a rebellious boy cow as the hero? "Barnyard" offers up such fare with the story of Otis (voiced by Kevin James), a fun-loving cow who would rather carouse about the farm than protect its denizens from ravenous coyotes, a duty that his father (Sam Elliott) tries in vain to impart to him. With a voice cast that includes Wanda Sykes and Courteney Cox, "Barnyard" aims for comedic targets in the form of anthropomorphized animal laughs, gross humor, and sight gags (courtesy of "Ace Ventura: When Nature Calls" director Steve Oedekirk) — lowbrow humor that, critics moan, appeal only to the senses of children under the age of eight. Unfortunately for the chaperones of the target demographic, aside from some spontaneous musical numbers and a few adult-oriented jokes, there’s not much here to entertain grown-ups. At 33 percent, "Barnyard" is only for parents who love their kids enough to sit through it.

Also opening this week, albeit in limited release: "My Country, My Country," a political documentary about the Iraq 2005 election, is at 100 percent; French romantic thriller "The Bridesmaid" is at 83 percent; the coming-of-age tale (and Sundance fave) "Quinceanera" is at 81 percent; retiree rom-com "The Boynton Beach Club" is at 55 percent; the prison cell drama "Jailbait" is at 14 percent; and gay teen drama "Vacationland" is at — gulp — 0 percent.

Recent Will Ferrell Movies:
Curious George – 69%
Winter Passing – 41%
Melinda & Melinda – 51%
Kicking and Screaming – 43%
Bewitched – 25%

Tag Cloud

AMC comic Film E3 Lucasfilm RT History Oscars Columbia Pictures facebook Winners Spectrum Originals Trailer halloween Horror casting Captain marvel dramedy MSNBC Teen Endgame Netflix Acorn TV batman based on movie Western cancelled TV series Comedy cancelled Lifetime Christmas movies Trophy Talk justice league tv talk cars Family Photos Holidays romantic comedy Countdown IFC Films Quiz comics ghosts crime drama crime thriller Cannes MTV science fiction Amazon spider-man GLAAD unscripted Rom-Com comiccon Song of Ice and Fire theme song Awards 2016 VICE HBO toy story Arrowverse Starz Disney Plus TV Land spinoff rotten movies we love American Society of Cinematographers cops San Diego Comic-Con Turner Classic Movies NYCC RT21 canceled TV shows directors First Reviews Best and Worst Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt breaking bad President Spike See It Skip It SXSW 20th Century Fox revenge FXX Animation First Look Classic Film golden globes Television Academy Emmy Nominations 2015 game of thrones christmas movies Mary Poppins Returns Comics on TV Netflix Christmas movies Set visit Star Trek Trivia Marvel Studios zero dark thirty TLC TCA Winter 2020 Walt Disney Pictures social media natural history Universal 71st Emmy Awards Video Games Emmys Holiday Election Calendar Character Guide Reality Competition The Witch Rock Spring TV Paramount Network festivals Pirates Certified Fresh FX Ovation DC streaming service Showtime YouTube ABC Family Superheroes Britbox Superheroe cartoon foreign YouTube Red sports Crunchyroll doctor who Mystery Lifetime Nickelodeon Sneak Peek Premiere Dates Sundance TV Interview Year in Review witnail TCA TNT USA Network IFC adventure cults Ghostbusters binge E! spain Country Polls and Games slashers MCU movies Adult Swim LGBT Amazon Prime period drama Sundance Now CBS All Access composers romance VH1 singing competition APB sequel Discovery Channel Shudder Baby Yoda werewolf Christmas Musical Mudbound Hallmark Christmas movies nature thriller sag awards aliens Box Office free movies reboot 007 Heroines supernatural robots harry potter CBS Hulu Nominations Women's History Month TCA 2017 Mindy Kaling zombie YouTube Premium diversity technology Rocketman Chilling Adventures of Sabrina streaming Elton John Vudu Binge Guide screenings television Avengers WGN A&E Fantasy cats Chernobyl Black Mirror WarnerMedia Amazon Prime Video Comic Book historical drama Infographic Cosplay elevated horror animated political drama disaster Disney+ Disney Plus Disney streaming service The Purge latino Drama Academy Awards vampires ESPN blockbuster 24 frames Tumblr award winner DGA OWN Cartoon Network spy thriller Mary Tyler Moore CMT X-Men versus ITV indie Peacock Awards Tour green book NBC DC Comics HBO Max war Tubi Biopics spanish language book boxoffice 2019 2020 TCM TIFF mockumentary Turner series Esquire DirecTV Logo Disney hispanic Hallmark Crackle medical drama National Geographic Pop screen actors guild A24 name the review USA game show GoT Dark Horse Comics 2018 finale mutant psycho Reality Lionsgate Marvel Television The Walking Dead cinemax BET sitcom Shondaland Kids & Family El Rey PaleyFest PBS Comedy Central Sony Pictures 21st Century Fox police drama jamie lee curtis cancelled TV shows independent Epix Creative Arts Emmys Podcast Apple TV Plus Music quibi true crime canceled anime LGBTQ ratings Brie Larson discovery Masterpiece dc Sundance Disney Channel renewed TV shows Winter TV cancelled television Extras docudrama GIFs Opinion Bravo Super Bowl kids Writers Guild of America Nat Geo Red Carpet crime Marvel dragons Pet Sematary hist FOX DC Universe Marathons Musicals video Freeform Paramount Tarantino 45 Food Network strong female leads TBS BBC stand-up comedy Fall TV The CW cooking Grammys History Tomatazos CNN Valentine's Day biography SDCC adaptation miniseries Syfy 2017 Stephen King Apple TV+ blaxploitation Mary poppins what to watch children's TV Ellie Kemper Star Wars Summer TruTV Fox News OneApp transformers Toys Action politics crossover New York Comic Con Rocky Watching Series richard e. Grant Pride Month BBC America Schedule Anna Paquin Thanksgiving Pixar Film Festival Martial Arts psychological thriller Warner Bros. south america teaser TV renewals YA dceu The Arrangement SundanceTV Apple talk show ABC zombies anthology TV travel space serial killer CW Seed joker Sci-Fi