Critics Consensus

Critical Consensus: "Departed" Is Best Reviewed Wide Release of 2006

by | October 5, 2006 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got cops and robbers in Boston ("The Departed," starring Jack Nicholson, Leonardo DiCaprio, and Matt Damon), chainsaw massacres in Texas ("The Texas Chainsaw Massacre: The Beginning," starring Jordana Brewster), and retail employees in New Mexico ("Employee of the Month," starring Jessica Simpson and Dane Cook). What do the critics have to say?

Is Martin Scorsese America’s greatest living filmmaker? He’s certainly bolstering his case with "The Departed." The film, which is a loose remake of the Hong Kong thriller "Infernal Affairs," tells the story of two moles, one of whom (DiCaprio) a cop undercover within a Boston crime family led by Jack Nicholson, and the other (Damon) a hood who has infiltrated the police department. Critics say Scorsese has created a crime drama with the gritty authenticity and soupy morality that infused such past triumphs as "GoodFellas," with outstanding work from an excellent cast. At 96 percent on the Tomatometer, "The Departed" may signify a new arrival for the master director; Scorsese’s best reviewed wide release since "GoodFellas." And it’s not only Certified Fresh, but it’s also the best reviewed wide release of the year.

"Wait a minute… you’re telling me I ripped that ‘how do you like them apples’ line off from you?"

The lives of wage slaves are often grist for the cinema’s mill, whether comic ("Clerks"), dramatic ("One Hour Photo") or both ("The Good Girl"). Now comes "Employee of the Month," starring Cook as a slacker at a Costco-like box store who whips himself into shape when attractive new hire (Simpson) comes on board. Critics say the movie has a few good laughs, but Cook and Simpson lack chemistry, and the film doesn’t do much beyond showing employee antics. At 25 percent on the Tomatometer, audiences may want to hire a different "Employee."

"And these are called ‘numbers.’ I know, it’s confusing."

For horror fans who are interested in the origin of Leatherface, "The Texas Chainsaw Massacre: The Beginning" provides some back story on the Lone Star State’s scariest resident. It also provides oodles of gore, and a style reminiscent of the original. Unfortunately, the critics say it doesn’t provide enough scares to make the experience worthwhile. The plot involves a group of young adults headed to Mexico for a good time before two brothers go to fight in Vietnam; naturally, Leatherface curtails their enjoyment in a hurry. The scribes say the film is a little too rote, and at 14 percent on the Tomatometer, this "Chainsaw" doesn’t cut very deep. (Read RT’s interview with director Jonathan Liebesman here.)

"The unsuspecting teenagers wail/ along the trail/ deep in the heart of Texas"

Also opening this week in limited release: "Blood Tea and Red String," a handmade stop-motion fairy tale 13 years in the making, is at 100 percent on the Tomatometer; "So Goes the Nation," a documentary about the 2004 election season in Ohio, is at 100 percent; "49 Up," the latest in Michael Apted‘s remarkable documentary series about growing and changing in England, is at 94 percent; "Black Gold," a documentary about the global effects of the coffee trade, is at 88 percent; "Little Children," a tale of suburban angst starring Kate Winslet, Patrick Wilson and Jennifer Connelly, is at 79 percent; "Shortbus," John Cameron Mitchell‘s warmhearted exploration of unconventional sexuality, is at 68 percent; and "Wrestling with Angels: Playwright Tony Kushner," a documentary about the eponymous Pulitzer Prize and Tony Award winning scribe, is at 55 percent. And "The Queen," which is expanding this week, is at 98 percent, making it the third best reviewed limited release of the year.

"Blood Tea and Red String":"The King of Cartoons!"

Recent Martin Scorsese Movies:
92% — No Direction Home: Bob Dylan (2005)
89% — The Aviator (2004)
77% — Gangs of New York (2002)
100% — My Voyage to Italy (2001)
72% — Bringing Out the Dead (1999)

Texas Chainsaw Massacres:
86% — The Texas Chain Saw Massacre (1974)
50% — The Texas Chainsaw Massacre 2 (1986)
23% — Leatherface: The Texas Chainsaw Massacre 3 (1989)
16% — The Texas Chainsaw Massacre: The Next Generation (1994)
37% — The Texas Chainsaw Massacre (2003)

Best Reviewed Wide Releases Of 2006
(Releases with at least 40 reviews)
96% — The Departed
93% — Dave Chappelle’s Block Party
93% — Little Miss Sunshine
90% — United 93
88% — Inside Man
84% — Akeelah and the Bee
83% — Slither
83% — The Descent
80% — A Prairie Home Companion
78% — The Devil Wears Prada

Best Reviewed Limited Releases Of 2006
(Releases with at least 40 reviews)
98% — Kekexeli: Mountain Patrol
98% — The War Tapes
98% — The Queen
96% — Army of Shadows
95% — Wordplay
93% — Fateless
93% — Little Miss Sunshine
92% — The Death of Mr. Lazarescu
92% — An Inconvenient Truth
92% — Lassie

Tag Cloud

historical drama NBA ghosts Spectrum Originals Tomatazos Trivia Amazon Studios Song of Ice and Fire Musical anthology technology Lucasfilm sports Summer Star Wars The Walt Disney Company Paramount Plus Television Critics Association GIFs Hallmark Christmas movies Country crime El Rey Thanksgiving GoT talk show The Walking Dead American Society of Cinematographers miniseries 79th Golden Globes Awards slasher FX Fall TV disaster best robots Marvel Television black comedy anime TruTV cops San Diego Comic-Con Apple godzilla olympics 45 emmy awards classics live event docuseries dreamworks Winter TV Vudu Extras BBC One thriller nature Legendary Columbia Pictures FXX TV streaming movies Emmy Nominations ITV football Podcast 007 Showtime police drama comics Rock festival critics scorecard mcc genre 99% dramedy MCU boxoffice Anna Paquin IFC fast and furious discovery Rom-Com Pirates BET Academy Awards nbcuniversal Turner The Arrangement Lionsgate Musicals Pet Sematary YouTube Red Black Mirror TBS christmas movies Teen a nightmare on elm street Syfy CW Seed Opinion game of thrones TCA 2017 aliens SundanceTV elevated horror The CW debate art house transformers USA based on movie indiana jones renewed TV shows A&E VH1 casting Avengers natural history Elton John know your critic new york scary ABC Signature Masterpiece Paramount Network Oscars Toys 2016 Black History Month HBO E! pirates of the caribbean james bond parents dexter Character Guide suspense CBS All Access unscripted Crunchyroll telelvision Shudder french Awards The Witch 93rd Oscars saw fresh Trailer PlayStation dc quibi TIFF Fox Searchlight Funimation FX on Hulu festivals Nominations mission: impossible Paramount Western hispanic heritage month cinemax TCA Awards 2015 binge films Britbox Apple TV Plus asian-american space new zealand dark finale period drama 21st Century Fox cancelled TV shows canceled TV shows ESPN Sundance golden globe awards Fargo PaleyFest children's TV Animation legend TNT adaptation Martial Arts 20th Century Fox richard e. Grant joker true crime President Horror Rocky cooking latino worst movies book adaptation SXSW Holidays ABC Family black Nat Geo Star Trek crime drama Stephen King Mary Poppins Returns serial killer spinoff Crackle Disney Women's History Month Christmas critic resources spanish language marvel comics witnail Esquire Amazon Prime Video Fox News satire Nickelodeon 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards cancelled Acorn TV lord of the rings Family documentaries Sneak Peek venice LGBT Year in Review APB directors reviews animated romance Amazon Prime Comedy Central Mystery women MTV war versus biopic SDCC Sundance TV cars toronto Chilling Adventures of Sabrina deadpool Alien dceu Tumblr trophy Pride Month Schedule Certified Fresh sopranos AMC IMDb TV remakes First Look popular DGA RT21 dogs gangster TCM politics The Purge travel supernatural Marvel Studios reboot Quiz adenture 2021 scary movies 72 Emmy Awards BBC America breaking bad Superheroe slashers Rocketman indie young adult psychological thriller Adult Swim Election Amazon The Academy spider-man Superheroes superhero japanese mob science fiction National Geographic Pacific Islander green book Universal rom-coms Kids & Family rt labs romantic comedy Video Games posters kaiju sequel spy thriller Tarantino Polls and Games A24 TV Land docudrama Instagram Live 24 frames aapi ViacomCBS Peacock YA stand-up comedy Reality Cartoon Network Prime Video Music singing competition CBS DC Comics Starz toy story Super Bowl BBC Interview worst stoner Box Office diversity First Reviews comic book movies Set visit jurassic park 73rd Emmy Awards spanish justice league Captain marvel Chernobyl cancelled television TV One Netflix Christmas movies Tokyo Olympics video on demand crime thriller rt archives twilight 2017 Drama comic book movie cults HBO Go king kong YouTube Premium mutant Sci-Fi south america WGN 2019 Reality Competition TV movies Lifetime Christmas movies Film Festival Image Comics AMC Plus biography Universal Pictures hist psycho Spring TV dragons Ellie Kemper Watching Series TCA ABC blaxploitation king arthur Pixar marvel cinematic universe doctor who book child's play target television action-comedy Comedy cancelled TV series ratings HFPA sitcom hollywood royal family all-time TCA Winter 2020 documentary batman comiccon CMT golden globes criterion wonder woman Writers Guild of America Comic Book New York Comic Con PBS 1990s Freeform sag awards vs. Food Network Hollywood Foreign Press Association name the review laika Ghostbusters DirecTV Best and Worst halloween Fantasy Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt heist movie Emmys live action Spike series Netflix kids HBO Max Premiere Dates Tags: Comedy 71st Emmy Awards franchise Mary poppins game show Arrowverse Disney Plus video Bravo See It Skip It NYCC Comics on TV hispanic canceled Sony Pictures rotten movies we love Pop TV VICE superman Baby Yoda stop motion GLAAD kong LGBTQ what to watch DC Universe scene in color cats Valentine's Day australia TV renewals Marvel tv talk RT History DC streaming service USA Network rotten Action Disney streaming service Infographic Creative Arts Emmys ID spider-verse Disney+ Disney Plus halloween tv Exclusive Video Shondaland Hear Us Out vampires free movies Biopics screenings Television Academy Comic-Con@Home 2021 X-Men Logo jamie lee curtis 4/20 History harry potter Film revenge Classic Film sequels TLC Calendar mockumentary Dark Horse Comics italian Mary Tyler Moore foreign crossover teaser Cosplay Ovation Binge Guide leaderboard CNN news Apple TV+ comic Mudbound medical drama Awards Tour comedies streaming archives strong female leads E3 nfl Red Carpet Wes Anderson OneApp universal monsters zombie 2018 NBC OWN adventure Turner Classic Movies Tubi comic books Walt Disney Pictures VOD Discovery Channel werewolf WarnerMedia monster movies Cannes Photos screen actors guild facebook Lifetime 2020 movie movies Disney Channel independent feel good Winners award winner japan Sundance Now social media Mindy Kaling chucky razzies basketball Heroines Grammys MSNBC Broadway Trophy Talk Countdown Hulu theme song Hallmark rt labs critics edition boxing BET Awards zero dark thirty 90s blockbuster new star wars movies Holiday Neflix spain Pop concert Brie Larson cartoon hidden camera BAFTA YouTube high school Marathons obituary composers trailers die hard FOX Endgame Warner Bros. political drama Travel Channel Epix prank international zombies IFC Films blockbusters