Winter/Spring TV Scorecard 2016

With more and more shows being released jockeying for your attention, Rotten Tomatoes offers up our Winter/Spring 2016 TV Scorecard where we rank new and returning shows by Tomatometer. We’re updating this countdown every Monday with new scores and critics responses, so say goodbye to being stuck with bad binges this season!


Critics Consensus: The visibly low-budget Hunters unsuccessfully searches for a well-executed plot in a forest of common tropes and cheap clichés.
Synopsis: Inspired by author Whitley Strieber's novel "Alien Hunter," Season 1 of "Hunters" follows Baltimore FBI agent and former soldier Flynn... [More]

Rosewood: Season 1 (2015)

Adjusted Score: 10.87%
Critics Consensus: Rosewood comes up anything but roses with a poorly written, ill-paced, and overall insubstantial entry in the crowded procedural genre.
Synopsis: When the Miami Police Department struggles with solving the murder of a young woman, they seek the help of private... [More]

Heartbeat: Season 1 (2015)

Adjusted Score: 20.56%
Critics Consensus: Heartbeat is a Frankensteined drama made up of hospital genre cliches and unlikable characters, though the cases-of-the-week are sporadically interesting.
Synopsis: Melissa George stars in the one-season-and-done medical drama as heart-transplant surgeon Alex Panttiere, who bucks convention on the job at... [More]

Adjusted Score: 25.093%
Critics Consensus: Beyond Borders relies on the same characters and storylines the franchise has used for years, with an extra undertow of xenophobic paranoia.
Synopsis: The International Division of the FBI investigates cases involving Americans in abroad.... [More]

Adjusted Score: 30.845%
Critics Consensus: Second Chance boasts a few interesting ideas and Robert Kazinsky's game performance, but there aren't enough functioning parts in what's ultimately yet another mediocre take on the Frankenstein myth.
Synopsis: A disgraced former police officer gets a chance at redemption after he's resurrected by a billionaire and his bioengineer twin... [More]

Crowded: Season 1 (2015)

Adjusted Score: 32.185%
Critics Consensus: A talented cast is left with no room to flourish in Crowded, a misfire whose dated feel is compounded by a pronounced lack of laughs.
Synopsis: Empty nesters see their plans change when their grown daughters move back home and his folks decide to stick around... [More]
Directed By: James Burrows

Adjusted Score: 38.416%
Critics Consensus: After the initial dose of nostalgia, Fuller House has little to offer to anyone except the original series' most diehard fans.
Synopsis: The Fuller house fills up fast in season one, with DJ, Stephanie, Kimmy, and the kids tackling everything from room... [More]

Adjusted Score: 13.528%
Synopsis: Sketch comedy series featuring comedy shorts and in-studio segments filmed in front of a live audience at the Alexandria Hotel... [More]

Dice: Season 1 (2016)

Adjusted Score: 43.435%
Critics Consensus: The Dice man is back with a few surprisingly funny guest stars, but they're not enough to salvage a series of unfunny storylines.
Synopsis: This semi-autobiographical comedy series follows the life of renowned comedian Andrew Dice Clay, portraying himself. The series chronicles the stops... [More]
Directed By: Scot Armstrong

Adjusted Score: 39.23%
Critics Consensus: Bordertown's controversy-rich premise is an idea disappointingly ill-served by its execution, which repeatedly mistakes crass, desperate gags for topical humor.
Synopsis: Animated misadventures of two culturally and ethnically different families who live next door to each other in a southwest desert... [More]

Adjusted Score: 25.248%
Critics Consensus: Of Kings and Prophets tries to add a Game of Thrones-inspired spin to the Old Testament, but ends up an aimless muddle.
Synopsis: A Biblical saga that chronicles the fall from grace of Saul, the first king of Israel, and the rise of... [More]

Flaked: Season 1 (2016)

Adjusted Score: 36.118%
Critics Consensus: Dull and pointless, Flaked makes it uncomfortably clear that the man-child persona is no longer compelling.
Synopsis: A self-appointed ''guru'' named Chip falls for the object of his best friend's desire.... [More]

Adjusted Score: 27.055%
Critics Consensus: Those Who Can't is sporadically funny, but its attempts at light-hearted comedy are undone by derivative writing and a crude, somewhat depressing tone.
Synopsis: Three thirtysomething high-school teachers struggle to motivate their students as well as themselves.... [More]

Rebellion: Season 1 (2016)

Adjusted Score: 13.664%
Synopsis: A period drama that chronicles life in post-World War I Ireland as seen through the eyes of three young women,... [More]
Starring: Ruth Bradley

Adjusted Score: 42.186%
Critics Consensus: Banish thee from the airwaves, oh Angel from Hell, for sins of commonplace sitcom triteness and obnoxious use of an iconic comedic lead.
Synopsis: An oddball guardian angel offers guidance to a high-strung New York doctor.... [More]

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 Next

  • Troy Kleasner

    Why is number 5 only 77% surrounded by 100% on both sides?

  • simon

    To each, I guess.

  • Ragnar Lodbrok

    For every negative review this season I simply shouted “SHIELD WALL”

  • Felipe G

    Why is Vikings on top if it has less reviews and a lower average rating?

  • BPods

    I give this list an Incomplete.

  • Pinkk

    When you see the 100% have a total of 8 reviews compared to those with lower scores, not to sure on this list :p

  • TomNewYorker

    My 10 Favorite New Shows of 2016, so far, are

    1-Fuller House
    3-Legends of Tomorrow
    4-The Real O’Neals
    5-The People Vs. O.J. Simpson
    6-Recovery Road
    8-School of Rock

    My 10 Favorite Returning Shows of 2016, so far, are
    2-Family Guy
    4-The Goldbergs
    5-The Flash
    8-The Carmichael Show
    9-American Crime

    • stellabystarlite

      I have the whole season Baskets on my DVR since I haven’t had time to watch it yet…looking forward to binge-watching the whole thing when I have more free time after the college semester ends. I have all of OJ too, but I’m on the fence about if I want to see that. I’ve heard a lot of mixed reactions to that one.

      • Poncho-Da-God

        You’ll be disappointed

  • d12

    I am early i got a joke


  • Dennis Bowers

    What is the basis for this list? No Flash, no Supergirl, but Legends of Tomorrow is listed?

    • Catalyst

      Shows that started their runs in the spring. Flash and Supergirl started their runs in fall and are continuing. Granted, WD is also on the list. On second thought, no idea.

  • dfsfdv

    Isn’t fair because OB’s only had one episode… but so far so amazing

  • Poncho-Da-God

    Dice is pretty good. The second episode is classic. Game Of Thrones should be #1 on the list.

  • JFH

    The Americans is great! It proves that you don’t need superheroes, monsters, magic, CGI, blood, and endless action to create an amazing show. Whatever happened to storytelling.

  • J_S_Mastropiero

    Gotham 90% Flash 100% Agents of shield 100% Supergirl 90% Agent Carter 80%…..Daredevil 75% Something is fundamentally broken with Rotten Tomatoes…or critics

  • Doofy69

    This list is poopy.

Tag Cloud

CBS Opinion Anna Paquin Heroines Endgame directors nbcuniversal Country basketball DC Universe Schedule critics miniseries marvel cinematic universe VOD Image Comics video on demand Sundance Now ViacomCBS 45 remakes psychological thriller HBO Fantasy teaser Nominations Paramount Pop foreign See It Skip It spanish WGN reboot japanese Disney Channel joker Columbia Pictures Trivia latino crime drama werewolf women A24 Hallmark Christmas movies cancelled TV shows animated RT21 The Witch TBS Marvel Studios IFC cartoon GIFs The Walt Disney Company X-Men comic books AMC Apple TV+ Countdown based on movie RT History Wes Anderson Avengers die hard comiccon BAFTA live action fast and furious The Purge Netflix Christmas movies Holidays Spring TV crossover hist rotten movies we love 007 2018 Chernobyl Ghostbusters harry potter kids streaming movies NBA a nightmare on elm street Trailer Reality Competition VH1 jurassic park know your critic crime thriller Amazon Prime Fox Searchlight high school Infographic MTV diversity new star wars movies docuseries stand-up comedy TV Land Showtime Holiday Binge Guide travel cooking television San Diego Comic-Con best Spectrum Originals FX Writers Guild of America batman Amazon Prime Video LGBTQ crime golden globes Nickelodeon suspense Rocky heist movie legend Sony Pictures OWN canceled NBC 21st Century Fox The CW canceled TV shows Comic Book psycho Chilling Adventures of Sabrina international Lifetime award winner superman Alien TIFF Rock hispanic PaleyFest Women's History Month First Reviews Tumblr new zealand Toys Disney streaming service nfl space Hear Us Out cops MCU Family FXX screen actors guild 24 frames Pirates Mudbound CW Seed BBC One Esquire 20th Century Fox historical drama singing competition classics Fox News satire Interview target IFC Films Shondaland 2017 DGA scary movies facebook child's play Crunchyroll Black Mirror Thanksgiving spinoff laika ratings YouTube italian TCA Winter 2020 Baby Yoda zombies TV trailers Starz ABC Family Winners BBC America Cosplay Red Carpet HBO Go Adult Swim Oscars comedies period drama richard e. Grant 93rd Oscars Star Trek Cartoon Network Legendary Funimation Spike Travel Channel dragons Podcast dc natural history Horror FX on Hulu cancelled Rocketman Ovation 90s Turner Disney halloween tv twilight japan rom-coms Lionsgate Box Office Sundance Biopics venice Comic-Con@Home 2021 Amazon Studios concert Western worst movies deadpool 72 Emmy Awards Photos Marvel Mindy Kaling anime Epix what to watch ghosts Amazon talk show zombie mutant romantic comedy YA ID adaptation sports Video Games Paramount Plus war 1990s theme song christmas movies Best and Worst Quiz spy thriller Super Bowl Action The Arrangement green book DC Comics witnail History Paramount Network SundanceTV australia south america slashers Television Critics Association universal monsters TCA 2017 adenture documentary Reality sequels series french scene in color Grammys ABC Character Guide Dark Horse Comics saw films ABC Signature Comedy The Academy Polls and Games jamie lee curtis Shudder Creative Arts Emmys indiana jones Song of Ice and Fire 2020 Sneak Peek technology news DC streaming service comics biography worst criterion emmy awards docudrama Broadway Disney+ Disney Plus Watching Series Musical parents blockbusters LGBT video Black History Month American Society of Cinematographers Comics on TV 2021 Captain marvel Drama wonder woman Emmy Nominations toy story scorecard festival finale movies hollywood Crackle TLC Pacific Islander Pride Month APB razzies Apple fresh Food Network Nat Geo chucky golden globe awards name the review nature 71st Emmy Awards cults 99% unscripted blaxploitation TCA cars binge Extras Trophy Talk new york anthology movie Awards Tour USA monster movies aapi ESPN CBS All Access Sundance TV YouTube Red Turner Classic Movies cinemax Marathons Awards obituary NYCC TV One political drama Mary Poppins Returns zero dark thirty CMT Logo Tomatazos disaster pirates of the caribbean TruTV Tarantino Martial Arts true crime documentaries spanish language Lifetime Christmas movies YouTube Premium TCA Awards romance composers rotten lord of the rings Mystery boxoffice Teen hidden camera festivals Pop TV versus popular Animation indie Fall TV President book adaptation CNN USA Network 4/20 PlayStation toronto comic Comedy Central Hallmark aliens Apple TV Plus robots Marvel Television doctor who GoT Pet Sematary Star Wars thriller game of thrones spain National Geographic Hulu justice league kong E! football Vudu stop motion BET Awards vampires Tubi free movies spider-man telelvision social media streaming kaiju Classic Film VICE Academy Awards Peacock halloween science fiction elevated horror ITV Summer screenings discovery stoner medical drama Bravo Disney Plus breaking bad dceu reviews Film Festival SDCC Calendar Syfy WarnerMedia strong female leads Cannes OneApp Universal 2016 blockbuster Certified Fresh FOX Emmys TCM TNT mockumentary 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Television Academy Mary Tyler Moore king kong Arrowverse renewed TV shows TV renewals Acorn TV boxing Stephen King rt archives Masterpiece children's TV PBS Elton John Election BBC olympics DirecTV New York Comic Con sitcom Exclusive Video quibi HBO Max Music Discovery Channel game show Christmas Freeform Premiere Dates prank Netflix dogs superhero cancelled TV series Year in Review all-time First Look tv talk transformers police drama Kids & Family Musicals GLAAD TV movies serial killer sag awards Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt El Rey godzilla Set visit Pixar dramedy Superheroe adventure mission: impossible supernatural Britbox Rom-Com Walt Disney Pictures Superheroes Brie Larson Valentine's Day BET casting Warner Bros. 2019 politics dark cancelled television independent Tokyo Olympics book Lucasfilm archives revenge 2015 cats franchise Sci-Fi Ellie Kemper A&E Film Mary poppins king arthur The Walking Dead E3 Winter TV black asian-american james bond SXSW MSNBC sequel